Not a surgical vaccine: There is no case for boosting infant male circumcision to combat heterosexual transmission of HIV in Australia

Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health

Volumn 35, Issue 5, 2011, Pages 459-465

  Darby, Robert ^a   Van Howe, Robert ^b  

^a Michigan State University ^*  (Australia)

^b MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Australia; Children; Circumcision; HIV; Human rights; Medical ethics; Random clinical trials; STIs; Sub Saharan Africa

Indexed keywords

AUSTRALIA; CIRCUMCISION; DISEASE TRANSMISSION; EVIDENCE BASED MEDICINE; HETEROSEXUALITY; HUMAN; HUMAN IMMUNODEFICIENCY VIRUS INFECTION; MALE; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); REVIEW; SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED DISEASE;

AUSTRALIA; CIRCUMCISION, MALE; EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE; HETEROSEXUALITY; HIV INFECTIONS; HUMANS; MALE; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC; SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED DISEASES;

EID: 83155192367     PISSN: 13260200     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1753-6405.2011.00761.x     Document Type: Article

References (87)

1. Belmaine S P. Circumcision. Med J Aust. 1971;1:1148.
2. Circumcision Information and Resource Pages. Circumcision: Medical Organization Official Policy Statements [Internet]. CIRP [place and date unknown]. [cited 2011 Jan 16]. Available from: http://www.cirp.org/library/ statements
3. Siegfried N, Muller M, Deeks JJ, Volmink J. Male circumcision for prevention of heterosexual acquisition of HIV in men (Cochrane Review). In: The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews; Issue 2; 2009 Apr. 15. Chichester (UK): John Wiley; 2009.
4. Morris BJ. In Favour of Circumcision. Sydney (AUST): University of New South Wales Press; 1999;
5. Morris BJ, Bailis SA, Castellsague X, Wiswell TE, Halperin DT. RACP's policy statement on infant male circumcision is ill-conceived. Aust N Z J Public Health. 2006;30(1):16-22. (Pubitemid 43280039)
6. Cooper DA, Wodak AD, Morris BJ. The case for boosting infant male circumcision in the face of rising heterosexual transmission of HIV [editorial]. Med J Aust. 2010;193:318-19.
7. Forbes DA. "The case for boosting infant male circumcision in the face of rising heterosexual transmission of HIV"... and now the case against. Med J Aust. 2011;194(1) 97-101.
8. Auvert B, Taljaard D, Lagarde E, Sobngwi-Tambekou J, Sitta R, et al. Randomized, controlled intervention trial of male Circumcision for reduction of HIV infection risk: The ANRS 1265 Trial. PLoS Med. 2005;2(11):298.
9. Bailey RC, Moses S, Parker CB, Agot K, Maclean I, et al. Male circumcision for HIV prevention in young men in Kisumu, Kenya: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 2007;369:643-56. (Pubitemid 46281312)
10. Gray RH, Kigozi G, Serwadda D, Makumbi F, Watya S, et al. Male circumcision for HIV prevention in men in Rakai, Uganda: a randomised trial. Lancet. 2007;369:657-66.
11. Green LW, McAlister RG, Peterson K W, Travis J W. Male circumcision is not the surgical vaccine we have been waiting for! Future HIV Therapy. 2008;2(3):193-9.
12. Myers A, Myers JE. Editorial: Rolling out male circumcision as a mass HIV/AIDS intervention seems neither justified nor practicable. S Afr Med J. 2008;98(10):781-2.
13. Van Howe RS, Svoboda JS. Neonatal circumcision is neither medically necessary nor ethically permissible: A response to Clark et al. Med Sci Monit. 2008;14(8): LE7-13.
14. Dowsett GW, Couch M. Male circumcision and HIV prevention: is there really enough of the right kind of evidence? Reprod Health Matters. 2007;15(29):33-44. (Pubitemid 46734686)
15. Van Howe RS, Storms MR. How the circumcision solution in Africa will increase HIV infections. Journal of Public Health in Africa. 2011;2(1):4.
16. Bassler D, Briel M, Montori VM, Lane M, et al. Stopping Randomized Trials Early for Benefit and Estimation of Treatment Effects Systematic Review and Meta-regression Analysis. JAMA. 2010;303(12):1180-7.
17. Auvert B, Taljaard D, Lagarde E, Sobngwi-Tambekou J, Sitta R, Puren A. Randomized, controlled intervention trial of male circumcision for reduction of HIV infection risk: The ANRS 1265 Trial. PLoS Med. 2005;2(11):298.
18. Green LW, Travis JW, McAllister RG, Peterson K W, et al. Male Circumcision and HIV Prevention: Insufficient Evidence and Neglected External Validity. Am J Prev Med. 2010;39(5) 479-82.
19. Garenne M. Long-term population effect of male circumcision in generalised HIV epidemics in sub-Saharan Africa. African Journal of AIDS Research. 2008;7(1):1-8. (Pubitemid 351769430)
20. Connolly C, Simbayi LC, Shanmugam R, Nqeketo A. Male circumcision and its relationship to HIV infection in South Africa: Results of a national survey in 2002. S Afr Med J. 2008;98(10):789-94.
21. Garenne M. Mass campaigns of male circumcision for HIV control in Africa: Clinical efficacy, population effectiveness, political issues. In: Denniston GC, Hodges FM, Milos M F, editors. Genital Autonomy: Protecting Personal Choice. Dordrecht (NLD): Springer; 2010. p. 50.
22. National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical Research. HIV/AIDS, Viral Hepatitis and Sexually Transmissible Infections in Australia, Annual Surveillance Report. Sydney (AUST): National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical Research, University of New South Wales; 2010. Figure. 7, p. 12.
23. Xu F, Markowitz LE, Sternberg MR, Aral SO. Prevalence of circumcision and herpes simplex type 2 infection in men in the United States: the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), 1999-2004. Sex Transm Dis. 2007;34:479-84. (Pubitemid 46987955)
24. US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Racial/ethnic disparities in diagnoses of HIV/AIDS - 33 states, 2001-2005. MMWR Morb Mort Wkly Rep. 2007;56:189-93.
25. Musa Simelane, More circumcised men are HIV positive. Times of Swaziland. 2010 September 19 [cited 2010 Dec. 1]. Available from: http://www.times.co.sz/ index.php?news=20909
26. Dinh MH, Fahrbach KM, Hope TJ. The role of the foreskin in male circumcision: an evidence-based review. Am J Reprod Immunol. 2010 Nov. 28. PubMed PMID: 21114567
27. Ganor Y, Bomsel M. HIV-1 transmission in the male genital tract. Am J Reprod Immunol. 2011;65:284-291.
28. Dinh MH, McRaven MD, Kelley Z, Penugonda S, Hope TJ. Keratinization of the adult male foreskin and implications for male circumcision. AIDS. 2010;24:899-906.
29. Chin J. The AIDS Pandemic: The Collision of Epidemiology with Political Correctness. Oxford (UK): Radcliffe Publishing; 2007.
30. de Witte L, Nabatov A, Pion M, Fluitsma D, de Jong M A W P, de Gruijl T, et al. Langerin as a natural barrier to HIV-1 transmission by Langerhans cells. Nat Med. 2007;13:367-71. (Pubitemid 46376681)
31. Ferris JA, Richters J, Pitts MK, Shelley JM, et al. Circumcision in Australia: Further evidence on its effects on sexual health and wellbeing. Aust N Z J Public Health. 2010;34(2):160-4.
32. Weiss GN. Prophylactic neonatal surgery and infectious diseases. Pediatr Infect Dis J. 1997;16:727-34. (Pubitemid 27364783)
33. Weiss HA, Thomas SL, Munabi SK, Hayes RJ. Male circumcision and risk of syphilis, chancroid, and genital herpes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sex Transm Infect. 2006;82:101-10.
34. Van Howe RS. Human papillomavirus and circumcision: A meta-analysis. J Infect. 2007;54:490-6. (Pubitemid 46567503)
35. Gisselquist D. Points to Consider: Responses to HIV/AIDS in Africa, Asia, and the Caribbean. London (UK): Adonis and Abbey; 2008.
36. National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical Research. HIV/AIDS, Viral Hepatitis and Sexually Transmissible Infections in Australia, Annual Surveillance Report. Sydney (AUST): National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical Research, University of New South Wales; 2010.
37. As reported in Bay Area Reporter (San Francisco), 24 November 1999; cited in Pittas-Giroux JA. Male circumcision and HIV infection. Lancet. 2000;355:926.
38. Xiao Xu, Patel AD, Vanessa KD, Pearlman MD, Johnson T R B. Can Routine Neonatal Circumcision Help Prevent Human Immunodeficiency Virus Transmission in the United States? Am J Men Health. 2009;3; 79-84.
39. Jozkowski K, Rosenberger JG, Schick V, Herbenick D, et al. Relations Between Circumcision Status, Sexually Transmitted Infection History, and HIV Serostatus Among a National Sample of Men Who Have Sex with Men in the United States. AIDS Patient Care STDs. 2010;24(8):465-70.
40. Gust DA, Wiegand RE, Kretsinger K, Sansom S, et al. Circumcision status and HIV infection among MSM: reanalysis of a Phase III HIV vaccine clinical trial. AIDS. 2010;24(8):1135-43.
41. Millett GA, Flores SA, Marks G, Reed JB, Herbst JH. Circumcision status and risk of HIV and sexually transmitted infections among men who have sex with men. JAMA. 2008;300:1674-84.
42. Errata JAMA. 2009;301:1126-9.
43. Reid D, Weatherburn P, Hickson F, Stephens M. Know the Score: Findings from the National Gay Men's Sex Survey 2001. London (UK): Sigma Research, Faculty of Humanities & Social Sciences, University of Portsmouth; 2002.
44. National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical Research. HIV/AIDS, Viral Hepatitis and Sexually Transmissible Infections in Australia, Annual Surveillance Report 2010. Sydney (AUST): National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical Research, University of New South Wales; 2010. p. 7.
45. National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical Research. National HIV Registry: Table 1.1.1. In: HIV, Viral Hepatitis and Sexually Transmissible Infections in Australia Annual Surveillance Report 2010. Sydney (AUST): National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical Research, University of New South Wales; 2010. p. 35.
46. National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical Research. Main Findings: Figure 5 - HIV diagnoses, 2005-2009, by HIV exposure category. In: HIV, Viral Hepatitis and Sexually Transmissible Infections in Australia Annual Surveillance Report 2010. Sydney (AUST): National Centre in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical Research, University of New South Wales; 2010. p. 11
47. Richters J, Smith A M A, de Visser RO, et al. Circumcision in Australia: prevalence and effects on sexual health. Int J STD AIDS. 2006;17:547-54. (Pubitemid 44285730)
48. Ferris JA, Richters J, Pitts MK, Shelley JM, et al. Circumcision in Australia: Further evidence on its effects on sexual health and wellbeing. Aust N Z J Public Health. 2010;34(2):160-4.
49. Simonsen JN, Cameron DW, Gakinya MN, Ndinya Achola JO, D'Costa LJ, Karasira P, et al. Human immunodeficiency virus infection among men with sexually transmitted diseases. Experience from a center in Africa. N Engl J Med. 1988;319:274-8.
50. Perera CL, Bridgewater F H G, Thavaneswaran P, Maddern GJ. Safety and efficacy of nontherapeutic male circumcision: A systematic review. Ann Fam Med. 2010;8(1):64-72.
51. McDaid LM, Weiss HA, Hart GJ. Circumcision among men who have sex with men in Scotland: limited potential for HIV prevention. Sex Transm Infect. 2010;86:404-6.
52. Wei C, Raymond H, McFarland W, Buchbinder S, Fuchs J. What is the potential impact of adult male circumcision on the HIV epidemic among men who have sex with men (MSM) in San Francisco? Sex Transm Dis. 2010;37:1-3.
53. Royal Dutch Medical Association. Non-therapeutic Circumcision of Male Minors [Internet]. Utrecht (NLD): KNMG; 2010 [cited 2010 Oct. 26]. p. 6. Available from: http://knmg.artsennet.nl/Diensten/knmgpublicaties/ KNMGpublicatie/Nontherapeutic-circumcision-of-male-minors-2010.htm
54. Royal Australasian College of Physicians. Circumcision - RACP Position Statement. Sydney (AUST): RACP; 2010 September. p. 13.
55. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. A Picture of Australia's Children 2005. Canberra (AUST): AGPS; 2005.
56. Cold CJ, Taylor JR. The prepuce. BJU Int. 1999;83 Suppl 1:34-44. (Pubitemid 29150290)
57. Fink KS, Carson CC, De Vellis RF. Adult circumcision outcomes study: effect on erectile function, penile sensitivity, sexual activity and satisfaction. J Urol. 2002;167:2113-16. (Pubitemid 34309677)
58. Kim DS, Pang M-G. The effect of male circumcision on sexuality. BJU Int. 2007;99:619-22. (Pubitemid 46238838)
59. Payne K, Thaler L, Kukkonen T, Carrier S, Binik Y. Sensation and sexual arousal in circumcised and uncircumcised men. J Sex Med. 2007;4:667-74. (Pubitemid 46779302)
60. Sorrells ML, Snyder JL, Reiss MD, Eden C, Milos MF, Wilcox N, et al. Finetouch pressure thresholds in the adult penis. BJU Int. 2007;99:864-9. (Pubitemid 46439566)
61. Darby R, Cox L. Objections of a sentimental character: The subjective dimension of foreskin loss. In: Zabus C, editor. Fearful Symmetries: Essays and Testimonies around Excision and Circumcision. Amsterdam (NLD): Rodopi; 2009. p. 251-98.
62. Schoen EJ, Colby CJ, To TT. Cost analysis of neonatal circumcision in a large health maintenance organization. J Urol. 2006;175:1111-15. (Pubitemid 43200107)
63. Van Howe R. A cost-utility analysis of neonatal circumcision. Med Decis Making. 2004;24:584-601. (Pubitemid 39525178)
64. Royal Australasian College of Physicians. Circumcision - RACP Position Statement. Sydney (AUST): RACP; 2002.
65. Sutherland JM, Glueck HI, Gleser G. Hemorrhagic disease of the newborn: breast feeding as a necessary factor in the pathogenesis. American Journal of Diseases of Children. 1967;113:524-33.
66. O'Brien TR, Calle EE, Poole WK. Incidence of neonatal circumcision in Atlanta, 1985-1986. South Med J. 1995;88:411-15.
67. Moreno CA, Realini J P. Infant circumcision in an outpatient setting. Tex Med. 1989;85:37-40.
68. Van Howe RS. Incidence of meatal stenosis following neonatal circumcision in a primary care setting. Clin Pediatr (Phila). 2006;45; 49-54. (Pubitemid 43362658)
69. Joudi M, Fathi M, Hiradfar M. Incidence of asymptomatic meatal stenosis in children following neonatal circumcision. J Pediatr Urol [Internet]. 2010. PubMed PMID: 20851685
70. Peterson S. Assaulted and mutilated: A personal account of circumcision trauma. In: Denniston GC, Hodges FM, Milos MF, editors. Understanding Circumcision: A Multi-disciplinary Approach to a Multi-dimensional Problem. New York (NY): Kluwer Academic; 2001. p. 271-90.
71. Ly L, Sankaran K. Acute venous stasis and swelling of the abdomen after circumcision. Canadian Medical Association Journal. 2003;169(3):216-17.
72. Paediatric Death Review Committee: Office of the Chief Coroner of Ontario. Circumcision: a minor procedure? Paediatrics & Child Health. 2007;12(4):311-2.
73. Doctor barred but still at work. Herald-Sun. 2010; November 11. [Internet] Circumcision Information Australia. [cited 2010 Dec. 2]. Available from: http://www.circinfo.org/news-upto2010.html#jabbar
74. Machmouchi M, Alkhotani A. Is Neonatal Circumcision Judicious? Eur J Pediatr Surg. 2007;17:266-9. (Pubitemid 47472091)
75. Leitch I O W. Circumcision: A continuing enigma. Australian Paediatric Journal. 1970;6:60.
76. Clements A. Letter. Med J Aust. 1972; April 29:946.
77. Darby R. Svoboda JS. A Rose by any other Name: Rethinking the similarities and differences between male and female genital cutting. Med Anthropol Q. 2007;21:301-23.
78. Beauchamp TL, Childress JF. Principles of Biomedical Ethics - Part II. 6th ed. New York (NY): Oxford University Press; 2009.
79. Fox M, Thomson M. Short Changed? The Law and Ethics of Male Circumcision. International Journal of Children's Rights 2005;13:161-81. (Pubitemid 41093368)
80. Svoboda JS, Van Howe RS, Dwyer JG. Informed consent for neonatal circumcision: An ethical and legal conundrum. J Contemp Health Law Policy. 2000;17:61-133.
81. Tasmania Law Reform Institute. Non-therapeutic Male Circumcision: Issues Paper No. 14. Hobart (AUST): University of Tasmania; 2009 June 2.
82. Lenganji Sikapizye. Boys see circumcision as a licence for unprotected sex. Saturday Post Online (Zambia) [Internet]. 2010; November 13 [cited 2010 Nov. 19]. Available from: http://www.postzambia.com/post-read-article.php? articleId=15572
83. Hodges FM, Svoboda JS, Van Howe RS. Prophylactic interventions on children: balancing human rights with public health. J Med Ethics. 2002;28(1):10-16. (Pubitemid 34162891)
84. Sawers L, Stillwaggon E. Concurrent sexual partnerships do not explain the HIV epidemics in Africa: a systematic review of the evidence. J Int AIDS Soc. 2010;13:34.
85. Gisselquist D. Points to Consider: Responses to HIV/AIDS in Africa, Asia, and the Caribbean. London (UK): Adonis and Abbey; 2008.
86. Setel P. A Plague of Paradoxes: AIDS, Culture and Demography in Northern Tanzania. Chicago (IL): Chicago University Press; 1999.
87. Bowtell WD. World AIDS day. Med J Aust. 2010;193(11/12): 653-4.