Ambiguous cells: The emergence of the stem cell concept in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries

Notes and Records of the Royal Society

Volumn 65, Issue 4, 2011, Pages 359-378

  Maehle, Andreas Holger ^a  

^a DURHAM UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Embryology; Haematopoiesis; Stem cells; Teratoma; Tumours

Indexed keywords

EID: 82455219454     PISSN: 00359149     EISSN: 17430178     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1098/rsnr.2011.0023     Document Type: Article

References (132)

1. L. Bums, '"You are our only hope": trading metaphorical "magic bullets" for stem cell "superheroes"', Theor. Med. Bioethics 30, 427-442 (2009).
2. A. Musolff, '"Progressive" evolution and "totipotent" stem cells: metaphors in British and German debates about the "life sciences'", IBERICA 17, 45-59 (2009).
3. M. B. Fagan, 'The search for the hematopoietic stem cell: social interaction and epistemic success in immunology', Stud. Hist. Phil. Biol. Biomed. Sci. 38, 217-237 (2007);
4. M. B. Fagan, 'Stems and standards: social interaction in the search for blood stem cells', J. Hist. Biol. 43, 67-109 (2010);
5. A. Kraft, 'Manhattan transfer: lethal radiation, bone marrow transplantation, and the birth of stem cell biology, ca. 1942-1961', Hist. Stud. Nat. Sci. 39, 171-218 (2009)
6. A. Kraft, 'Converging histories, reconsidered potentialities: the stem cell and cancer', BioSocieties 6, 195-216 (2011). For historical accounts of embryonic stem cell research see note 91 below.
7. M. Ramalho-Santos and H. Willenbring, 'On the origin of the term "stem cell'", Cell Stem Cell 1, 35-38 (2007).
8. R. J. Richards, The tragic sense of life: Ernst Haeckel and the struggle over evolutionary thought (University of Chicago Press, 2008).
9. E. Haeckel, Naturliche Schbpfungsgeschichte (Georg Reimer, Berlin, 1868), 15th lecture.
10. Richards, op. cit. (note 5), pp. 148-156
11. N. Hopwood, 'Embryology', in The Cambridge history of science, vol. 6 {The modern biological and earth sciences) (ed. P. J. Bowler and J. V. Pickstone), pp. 285-315 (Cambridge University Press, 2009).
12. E. Haeckel, Anthropogenic oder Entwickelungsgeschichte des Menschen, 3rd edn (Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig, 1877), p. 144 [my translation].
13. P. J. Weindling, Darwinism and Social Darwinism in Imperial Germany: the contribution of the cell biologist Oscar Hertwig (1849-1922) (Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart, 1991), pp. 63-72.
14. Haeckel, op. cit. (note 8), Darwinism and Social Darwinism in Imperial Germany: the contribution of the cell biologist Oscar Hertwig 1849-1922 (1991) p. 149 [my translation].
15. E. Johach, Krebszelle und Zellenstaat. Zur medizinischen und politischen Metaphorik in Rudolf Virchows Zellularpathologie (Rombach Verlag, Freiburg i. Br., 2008)
16. A. Reynolds, 'The theory of the cell state and the question of cell autonomy in nineteenth and early twentieth-century biology', Sci. Context 20, 71-95 (2007)
17. D. J. Nicholson, 'Biological atomism and cell theory', Stud. Hist. Phil. Biol. Biomed. Sci. 41, 202-211 (2010).
18. R. Virchow, Die Cellularpathologie in ihrer Begrundung auf physiologische und pathologische Gewebelehre, 4th edn (August Hirschwald, Berlin, 1871), p. 17 [my translation; emphasis in the original].
19. E. Haeckel, 'Zellseelen und Seelenzellen' (1878), in Vortrage und Abhandlungen (ed. H. Schmidt-Jena) (Alfred Kroner, Leipzig, 1924), pp. 162-195
20. A. Reynolds, 'Ernst Haeckel and the theory of the cell state: remarks on the history of a bio-political metaphor', Hist. Sci. 46, 123-152 (2008)
21. Weindling, op. cit. (note 9) 'Ernst Haeckel and the theory of the cell state: remarks on the history of a bio-political metaphor', Hist. Sci. 46, pp. 258-261.
22. E. B. Wilson, The cell in development and heredity, 3rd edn (Macmillan, New York, 1925), pp. 101-102
23. A. Weismann, Die Continuitdt des Keimplasma's als Grundlage einer Theorie der Vererbung (Gustav Fischer, Jena, 1885), pp. 5-21.
24. V. Haecker, 'Die Kerntheilungsvorgange bei der Mesoderm- und Entodermbildung von Cyclops', Arch. Mikrosk. Anat. 39, 556-581 (1892).
25. T. Boveri, 'Ueber die Entstehung des Gegensatzes zwischen den Geschlechtszellen und den somatischen Zellen bei Ascaris megalocephala, nebst Bemerkungen zur Entwicklungsgeschichte der Nematoden', Sitzungsber. Ges. Morphol. Physiol. Munchen 8, 114-125 (1892).
26. H. Satzinger, Differenz und Vererbung. Geschlechterordnungen in der Genetik und Hormonforschung 1890-1950 (Bohlau Verlag, Cologne, 2009), pp. 85-97
27. F. Baltzer, Theodor Boveri: life and work of a great biologist 1862-1915 (University of California Press, Berkeley, 1967)
28. K. B. Moritz, Theodor Boveri (1862-1915), Pionier der modernen Zell- und Entwicklungsbiologie (Gustav Fischer, Jena, 1993)
29. H. A. Neumann, Vom Ascaris zum Tumor. Leben und Werk des Biologen Theodor Boveri (1862-1915) (Blackwell, Berlin, 1998).
30. J. Harwood, Styles of scientific thought. The German genetics community 1900-1933 (University of Chicago Press, 1993), pp. 52-55
31. R. Haecker, 'Das Leben von Valentin Haecker', Zool. Anz. 174, 1-22 (1965).
32. V. Haecker, Uber Geddchtnis, Vererbung und Pluripotenz (Gustav Fischer, Jena, 1914), pp. 63 and 85.
33. For example, T. Boveri, 'Die Entwickelung von Ascaris megalocephala mit besonderer Riicksicht auf die Kernverhaltnisse', in Festschrift zum siebenzigsten Geburtstag von Carl von Kupffer, pp. 383-430 (Gustav Fischer, Jena, 1899)
34. T. Boveri, 'Die Potenzen der Ascaris- Blastomeren bei abgeanderter Furchung. Zugleich ein Beitrag zur Frage qualitativ-ungleicher Chromosomen-Teilung', in Festschrift zum sechzigsten Geburtstag Richard Hertwigs (Munchen), pp. 133-214 (Gustav Fischer, Jena, 1910).
35. On Wilson's book, see J. Maienschein, 'From presentation to representation in E. B. Wilson's The Cell', Biol. Phil. 6, 227-254 (1991).
36. R. W. Hegner, The germ-cell cycle in animals (Macmillan, New York, 1914), pp. 174-179.
37. R. Weissenberg, 'Zeugung und Sexualitat in ihren anatomischen und biologischen Grundlagen', in Handbuch der Sexualwissenschaften, 3rd edn (2 volumes) (ed. A. Moll), vol. 1, pp. 1-232 (F. C. W. Vogel, Leipzig, 1926).
38. Boveri's work on Ascaris and stem cells was also reviewed in Wilhelm Waldeyer's contribution on 'Die Geschlechtszellen' in Handbuch der vergleichenden und experimentellen Entwickelungslehre der Wirbeltiere (ed. Oskar Hertwig), vol. 1, part 1, pp. 86-476 (Gustav Fischer, Jena, 1906), at pp. 222-223.
39. Weissenberg (note 25), pp. 19-20.
40. A. Pappenheim, 'Ueber Entwickelung und Ausbildung der Erythroblasten', Virchows Arch. Pathol. Anat. 145, 587-643 (1896).
41. Ibid., pp. 600-601 and 635-636.
42. Ibid., p. 640.
43. See also Ramalho-Santos and Willenbring, op. cit. (note 4), p. 37. On the further development of research on haematopoietic stem cells, see L. G. Lajtha, 'The common ancestral cell', in Blood, pure and eloquent. A story of discovery, of people, and of ideas (ed. M. M. Wintrobe), pp. 81-95 (McGraw-Hill, New York, 1980)
44. E. A. McCulloch, The Ontario Cancer Institute: successes and reverses at Sherbourne Street (McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal, 2003), pp. 46-60
45. N. Brown, A. Kraft and P. Martin, 'The promissory pasts of blood stem cells', BioSocieties 1, 329-348 (2006)
46. A. Kraft, 'Atomic medicine: the cold war origins of biological research', Hist. Today 59 (11), 26-33 (2009)
47. A. Kraft, 'Manhattan transfer', op. cit. (note 3)
48. A. Pappenheim, 'Zwei Falle akuter grosslymphozytarer Leukamie', Fol. Haematol. 4, 301-308 (1907).
49. On Pappenheim and his haematological work, see Ricarda Dinser, 'Der Beitrag Artur Pappenheims zur Hamatologie um die Jahrhundertwende', MD thesis, Ruhr-Universitat Bochum (2001).
50. W. Dantschakoff, 'Untersuchungen iiber die Entwickelung des Blutes und Bindegewebes bei den Vogeln', Anat. Hefte 37, 471 -589 (1908). On Dantschakoff's international career, see Satzinger, op. cit. (note 19), pp. 231-232 and 394-396.
51. A. Maximow, 'Der Lymphozyt als gemeinsame Stammzelle der verschiedenen Blutelemente in der embryonalen Entwicklung und im postfetalen Leben der Saugetiere', Fol. Haematol. 8, 125-134 (1909)
52. I. E. Konstantinov, 'In search of Alexander A. Maximow: the man behind the unitarian theory of hematopoiesis', Perspect. Biol. Med. 43, 269-276 (2000).
53. E. Neumann, 'Ueber die Bedeutung des Knochenmarkes fur die Blutbildung, Vorlaufige Mittheilung', CentBlatt Med. Wiss. 6, no. 44 (1868)
54. E. Neumann-Redlin v. Meding, Der Pathologe Ernst Neumann (1834-1918) und sein Beitrag zur Begrundung der Hdmatologie im 19. Jahrhundert (Demeter Verlag, Munich, 1987), pp. 30-33.
55. E. Neumann, 'Hamatologische Studien I. -III.', Virchows Arch. Pathol. Anat. 143, 225-277 (1896);
56. E. Neumann, 'Hamatologische Studien I. -III.', Virchows Arch. Pathol. Anat. 174, 41-78 (1903);
57. E. Neumann, 'Hamatologische Studien I. -III.', Virchows Arch. Pathol. Anat. 207, 379-412 (1912);
58. P. Ehrlich and A. Lazarus, Histology of the blood: normal and pathological (Cambridge University Press, 1900), pp. 81-120;
59. E. Neumann, 'Hamatologische Studien. III. Leukocyten ynd Leukamie', Virchows Arch. Pathol. Anat. 207, 379-412 (1912), at p. 382.
60. J. Maienschein, 'Regenerative medicine in historical context', Med. Stud. 1, 33-40 (2009).
61. R. G. Harrison, 'Observations on the living developing nerve fiber', Anat. Rec. 1, 116-118 (1907)
62. R. G. Harrison, 'The outgrowth of the nerve fiber as a mode of protoplasmic movement', J. Exp. Zool. 9, 787-846 (1910).
63. H. Landecker, Culturing life. How cells became technologies (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 2007)
64. D. H. Stapleton, 'Tissue culture and tissue culture technologies at the Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research: roots of regenerative medicine, 1910-1950', Med. Stud. 1, 77-81 (2009).
65. O. Hertwig, Der Stoat als Organismus. Gedanken zur Entwicklung der Menschheit (Gustav Fischer, Jena, 1922), p. 65 [my translation].
66. Hertwig here quoted himself from the second edition of his work Zur Abwehr des ethischen, des sozialen und politischen Darwinismus (Gustav Fischer, Jena, 1921). For a detailed discussion of O. Hertwig's ideas on the state as an organism, see Weindling (note 9), pp. 262-303.
67. E. Haeckel, Naturliche Schbpfungs-Geschichte. Gemeinverstdndliche wissenschaftliche Vortrdge iiber die Entwickelungslehre, Volksausgabe (Walter de Gruyter, Berlin, 1926), p. 226 [my translation].
68. F. Kahn, Das Leben des Menschen. Eine volkstumliche Anatomie, Biologie, Physiologie und Entwicklungsgeschichte des Menschen (5 volumes) (Kosmos, Stuttgart, 1922-31), vol. 1, plate XVII opp. p. 240. On Kahn and his use of visual representations in the popularization of biological and medical information
69. C. Borck, 'Der industrialisierte Mensch: Fritz Kahns Visualisierungen des Korpers als Interferenzzone von Medizin, Technik und Kultur', WerkstattGeschichte 47, 7-22 (2008).
70. J. Cohnheim, Vorlesungen iiber allgemeine Pathologic Ein Handbuchfur Aerzte und Studirende (2 volumes) (August Hirschwald, Berlin, 1877-80), vol. 1, pp. 634-650 and 655-656.
71. On Cohnheim's theory, see also L. J. Rather, The genesis of cancer. A study in the history of ideas (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD, 1978), pp. 169-174
72. M. Cooper, 'Regenerative pathologies: stem cells, teratomas and theories of cancer', Med. Stud. 1, 55-66 (2009).
73. H. Ribbert, Ueber Ruckbildung an Zellen und Geweben und iiber die Entstehung der Geschwulste (Erwin Nagele, Stuttgart, 1897), pp. 41-42
74. H. Ribbert, Beitrdge zur Entstehung der Geschwulste (Friedrich Cohen, Bonn, 1906), pp. 6-13
75. M. Borst, Die Lehre von den Geschwulsten (2 volumes) (J. F. Bergmann, Wiesbaden, 1902), vol. 1, p. 39a
76. M. Borst, Die Lehre von den Geschwulsten vol. 2, pp. 817-818
77. E. Schwalbe, Allgemeine Missbildungslehre (Teratologic). Eine Einfuhrung in das Studium der Abnormen Entwicklung (Gustav Fischer, Jena, 1906), pp. 155-158;
78. L. Aschoff, E. Kiister and W. J. Schmidt, Hundert Jahre Zellforschung (Gebriider Borntraeger, Berlin, 1938), pp. 250-258.
79. A. Birch-Hirschfeld and S. Garten, 'Ueber das Verhalten implantirter embryonaler Zellen im erwachsenen Thierkorper', Beitr. Pathol. Anat. Allg. Pathol. 26, 132-172 (1899)
80. C. Fere and A. Lutier, 'Nouvelles observations sur les teratomes experimentaux', Arch. Anat. Microsc. 3, 337-368 (1900)
81. R. Traina, 'Ueber Transplantationen von Embryonalgeweben ins Ovarium und die Bildung von Ovarialcysten', Centralblatt Allg. Pathol. Pathol. Anat. 13, 49-56 (1902)
82. M. Wilms, 'Wachstum embryonaler Implantation und Geschwulstbildung', Verh. Dt. Pathol. Ges., year 1904, 79-80 (1905)
83. R. Rossle, 'Ueber die Einverleibung von Embryonalzellen', Munch. Med. WochSchr. 53, 143-144 (1906)
84. M. Borst, 'Die Teratome und ihre Stellung zu anderen Geschwiilsten', Verh. Dt. Pathol. Ges., year 1907, 83-104 (1908)
85. Eugen Korschelt, Regeneration und Transplantation (2 volumes) (Gebriider Borntraeger, Berlin, 1927-31), vol. 2, pp. 1205-1208.
86. M. Askanazy, 'Die Teratome nach ihrem Bau, ihrem Verlauf, ihrer Genese und im Vergleich zum experimentellen Teratoid', Verh. Dt. Pathol. Ges., year 1907, 39-82 (1908).
87. Significantly, numerous experiments on the transplantation of tumours in mice were performed in the institutes of Paul Ehrlich in Frankfurt am Main and Oscar Hertwig in Berlin during the same period. See P. Ehrlich, 'Experimentelle Studien an Mausetumoren', Z. Krebsforsch. 5, 59-81 (1907)
88. O. Hertwig and H. Poll, Zur Biologie der Mausetumoren. Experimentelle Untersuchungen (Konigliche Akademie der Wissenschaften, Berlin, 1907).
89. For a discussion of Ehrlich's cancer research, see A. C. Hiintelmann, Paul Ehrlich: Leben, Forschung, Okonomien, Netzwerke (Wallstein Verlag, Gottingen, 2011), pp. 174-176.
90. F. Marchand, Die Missbildungen, 3rd edn (Gistel, Vienna, 1898), pp. 75-79
91. R. Bonnet, 'Zur Aetiologie der Embryome', Monatsschr. Geburtshulfe Gynaekol. 13, 149-176 (1901).
92. See also M. Askanazy, Die Dermoidcysten des Eierstocks: ihre Geschichte, ihr Bau und ihre Entstehung sowie ihre Beziehung zu verwandten pathologischen Bildungen (Erwin Nagele, Stuttgart, 1905), pp. 16-18
93. Marchand, 'MiBbildungen', in Real-Encyclopddie der gesamten Heilkunde, 4th edn (ed. A. Eulenburg), vol. 9, pp. 722-853 (Urban & Schwarzenberg, Berlin, 1910), at pp. 778-779.
94. M. Wilms, Die Mischgeschwulste, IE. (Schluss-) Heft (Arthur Georgi, Berlin, 1902), pp. 227-252.
95. Ribbert, Ruckbildung, op. cit. (note 51), pp. 42-43
96. Ribbert, Beitrdge, op. cit. (note 51), pp. 8-13.
97. T. Boveri, Zur Frage der Entstehung maligner Tumoren (Gustav Fischer, Jena, 1914), p. 2.
98. T. Boveri, Concerning the origin of malignant tumours (transl. and annot. H. Harris) (Company of Biologists Limited and Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Woodbury, NY, 2008), preface (by Harris), p. v.
99. A. Musolff, Metaphor, nation and the Holocaust: the concept of the body politic (Routledge, New York, 2010), pp. 1-8.
100. O. Lubarsch, Ein bewegtes Gelehrtenleben (Springer, Berlin, 1931), pp. 591-592
101. cited in Johach (note 11), p. 267. On Lubarsch's nationalist views and his directorship of the Pathological Institute in Berlin from 1917 to 1928, see C.-R. Priill, Medizin am Toten oder am Lebenden? Pathologie in Berlin und in London, 1900-1945 (Schwabe, Basel, 2003), pp. 85-88 and 358-367.
102. G. W. de P. Nicholson, 'The histogeny of teratomata', J. Pathol. Bacterial. 32, 365-386 (1929).
103. Similar points on the 'non-foetiformity of teratomas' were later made by R. A. Willis, Pathology of tumours (Butterworth, London, 1953), pp. 976-978.
104. E. Witschi, 'Migration of the germ cells of human embryos from the yolk sac to the primitive gonadal folds', Contrib. Embryol. 32, 67-80 (1948).
105. See also J. E. Wheeler, 'History of teratomas', in The human teratomas: experimental and clinical biology (ed. I. Damjanov, B. B. Knowles and D. Solter), pp. 1-22 (Humana, Clifton, NJ, 1983).
106. F. J. Dixon and R. A. Moore, 'Testicular tumors: a clinicopathological study', Cancer 6, 427- 454 (1953).
107. See also R. H. Young, 'A brief history of the pathology of the gonads', Mod. Pathol. 18, S3-S17 (2005). (Pubitemid 40188614)
108. K. Rader, Making mice: standardizing animals for biomedical research 1900-1955 (Princeton University Press, 2004).
109. Leroy C. Stevens, 'Spontaneous and experimentally induced testicular teratomas in mice', Cell Differ. 15, 69-74 (1984)
110. R. A. Lewis, Discovery: windows on the life sciences (Blackwell, Maiden, MA, 2001), p. 132.
111. L. C. Stevens and C. C. Little, 'Spontaneous testicular teratomas in an inbred strain of mice', Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 40, 1080-1087 (1954).
112. L. C. Stevens, 'Embryology of testicular teratomas in strain 129 mice', J. Natl Cancer Inst. 23, 1249-1295 (1959)
113. L. C. Stevens, 'Embryonic potency of embryoid bodies derived from transplantable testicular teratoma of the mouse', Dev. Biol. 2, 285-297 (1960).
114. L. C. Stevens, 'Experimental production of testicular teratomas in mice', Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 52, 654-661 (1964)
115. L. C. Stevens, 'The development of teratomas from intratesticular grafts of tubal mouse eggs', J. Embryol. Exp. Morphol. 20, 329-341 (1968)
116. L. C. Stevens, 'The development of transplantable teratocarcinomas from intratesticular grafts of pre- and postimplantation mouse embryos', Dev. Biol. 21, 364-382 (1970).
117. L. J. Kleinsmith and G. B. Pierce Jr, 'Multipotentiality of single embryonal carcinoma cells', Cancer Res. 24, 1544-1551 (1964).
118. Ibid, p. 1544, making reference to Askanazy, op. cit. (note 53). Askanazy's paper was also cited, in the same context, in G. B. Pierce, 'Teratocarcinoma: model developmental concept of cancer', Curr. Top. Dev. Biol. 2, 223-246 (1967), at p. 224.
119. B. Mintz and K. Illmensee, 'Normal genetically mosaic mice produced from malignant teratocarcinoma cells', Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 72, 3585-3589 (1975).
120. See also the similar results by R. L. Brinster, 'The effect of cells transferred into the mouse blastocyst on subsequent development', J. Exp. Med. 140, 1049-1056 (1974).
121. M. J. Evans and M. H. Kaufman, 'Establishment in culture of pluripotential cells from mouse embryos', Nature 292, 154-156 (1981) (Pubitemid 11050741)
122. G. R. Martin, 'Isolation of a pluripotent cell line from early mouse embryos cultured in medium conditioned by teratocarcinoma stem cells', Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 78, 7634-7638 (1981). (Pubitemid 12186197)
123. P. W. Andrews, 'From teratocarcinomas to embryonic stem cells', Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B 357, 405-417 (2002) (Pubitemid 34489857)
124. D. Solter, 'From teratocarcinomas to embryonic stem cells and beyond: a history of embryonic stem cell research', Nature Rev. Genet. 7, 319-327 (2006);
125. M. Morange, 'What history tells us. VII. Twenty-five years ago: the production of mouse embryonic stem cells', J. Biosci. 31, 537-541 (2006) (Pubitemid 46021157)
126. M. J. Shamblott, J. Axelman, S. Wang, E. M. Bugg, J. W. Littlefield, P. J. Donovan, P. D. Blumenthal, G. R. Huggins and J. D. Gearhart, 'Derivation of pluripotent stem cells from cultured human primordial germ cells', Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 95, 13726-13731 (1998) (Pubitemid 28523040)
127. J. A. Thomson, J. Itskovitz-Eldor, S. S. Shapiro, M. A. Waknitz, J. J. Swiergiel, V. S. Marshall and J. M. Jones, 'Embryonic stem cell lines derived from human blastocysts', Science 282, 1145-1147 (1998). (Pubitemid 28516247)
128. J. E. Till and E. A. McCulloch, 'A direct measurement of the radiation sensitivity of normal mouse bone marrow cells', Radiat. Res. 14, 213-222 (1961)
129. A. J. Becker, E. A. McCulloch and J. E. Till, 'Cytological demonstration of the clonal nature of spleen colonies derived from transplanted mouse marrow cells', Nature 197, 452-454 (1963)
130. Z. Master, M. McLeod and I. Mendez, 'Benefits, risks and ethical considerations in translation of stem cell research to clinical applications in Parkinson's disease', J. Med. Ethics 33, 169-173 (2007)
131. N. Amariglio, A. Hirschberg, B. W. Scheithauer, Y. Cohen, R. Loewenthal, L. Trakhtenbrot, N. Paz, M. Koren-Michowitz, D. Waldman, L. Leider-Trejo, A. Toren, S. Constantini and G. Rechavi, 'Donor-derived brain tumor following neural stem cell transplantation in an ataxia teleangiectasia patient', PLoS Med. 6 (2), el000029 (doi:10.1371/ journal.pmed.1000029).
132. From A. Pappenheim, Atlas der menschlichen Blutzellen (Gustav Fischer, Jena, 1905-12), vol. 1, opp. p. 347.