Hospital standardized mortality ratios: Sensitivity analyses on the impact of coding

Health Services Research

Volumn 46, Issue 6 PART 1, 2011, Pages 1741-1761

  Bottle, Alex ^a   Jarman, Brian ^a   Aylin, Paul ^a  

^a IMPERIAL COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Administrative data; hospitals; mortality; quality of care

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CODING; COMORBIDITY; CONTROLLED STUDY; DATA BASE; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; HOSPITAL; HUMAN; MORTALITY; PALLIATIVE THERAPY; SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS;

AGE FACTORS; CLINICAL CODING; COMORBIDITY; HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATION; HOSPITAL MORTALITY; HUMANS; MORTALITY; PALLIATIVE CARE; QUALITY INDICATORS, HEALTH CARE; RISK ADJUSTMENT;

EID: 81755179401     PISSN: 00179124     EISSN: 14756773     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1475-6773.2011.01295.x     Document Type: Article

References (22)

1. Audit Commission. 2009. "PbR Data Assurance Framework 2008/09. Key Messages from Year 2 of the National Clinical Coding Audit Programme" [accessed August 31, 2010]. Available at.
2. Black, N., 2010. " Assessing the Quality of Hospitals: Hospital Standardised Mortality Ratios Should be Abandoned. British Medical Journal 340: 933-4.
3. Bottle, A., and, P. Aylin,. 2008. " Intelligent Information: A National System for Monitoring Clinical Performance. Health Services Research 43: 10-31.
4. Bottle, A., B. Jarman, and, P. Aylin,. 2011. " Hospital Standardised Mortality Ratios: Strengths and Weaknesses. British Medical Journal 342: c7116.
5. Carstairs, V., and, R. Morris,. 1989. " Deprivation: Explaining Differences in Mortality between Scotland and England and Wales. British Medical Journal 299 (6704): 886-9.
6. Department of Health. 2010. "Equity and Excellence: Liberating the NHS" [accessed August 31, 2010]. Available at
7. Downar, J., R. Sibbald, and, N. M. Lazar,. 2010. " Ethical Considerations for Classifying Patients as 'Palliative' When Calculating Hospital Standardised Mortality Ratios. Journal of Medical Ethics 36 (7): 387-90.
8. Harrell, F., 2001. Regression Modelling Strategies. New York: Springer.
9. Jarman, B., S. Gault, B. Alves, A. Hider, S. Dolan, A. Cook, B. Hurwitz, and, L. I. Iezzoni,. 1999. " Explaining Differences in English Hospital Death Rates Using Routinely Collected Data. British Medical Journal 318: 1515-20. (Pubitemid 29255794)
10. Krumholz, H. M., Y. Wang, J. A. Mattera, Y. Wang, L. F. Han, M. J. Ingber, S. Roman, and, S.-L. T. Normand,. 2006. " An Administrative Claims Model Suitable for Profiling Hospital Performance Based on 30-Day Mortality Rates among Patients with an Acute Myocardial Infarction. Circulation 113: 1683-1692.
11. Lilford, R., and, P. Pronovost,. 2010. " Using Hospital Mortality Rates to Judge Hospital Performance: A Bad Idea That Just Won't Go Away. British Medical Journal 340: 955-7.
12. Marshall, E. C., and, D. J. Spiegelhalter,. 1998. " Reliability of League Tables of In Vitro Fertilisation Clinics: Retrospective Analysis of Live Birth Rates. British Medical Journal 316: 1701-5.
13. Mohammed, M. A., J. J. Deeks, A. Girling, G. Rudge, M. Carmalt, A. J. Stevens, and, R. J. Lilford,. 2009. " Evidence of Methodological Bias in Hospital Standardised Mortality Ratios: Retrospective Database Study of English Hospitals. British Medical Journal 338: b780.
14. ™. 2003 Measuring, Evaluating, and Reducing Hospital Mortality Rates (Part 1). IHI Innovation Series White Paper. Boston: Institute for Healthcare Improvement [accessed on June 28, 2011]. Available at
15. NHS Classifications Service. 2010a. Coding of Comorbidities. Coding Clinic, Volume 6, Issue 6, March.
16. NHS Classifications Service. 2010b. Palliative and End of Life Care. Coding Clinic, Volume 7, Issue 4, June.
17. Nicholl, J., 2007. " Case-Mix Adjustment in Non-Randomised Observational Evaluations: The Constant Risk Fallacy. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 61: 1010-3. (Pubitemid 350032599)
18. Normand, S.-L. T., L. Iezzoni, R. Wolf, D. Shahian, and, L. Kirle,. 2010. A Comprehensive Comparison of Whole System Hospital Mortality Measures. A Report to the Massachusetts Division of Health Care Finance and Policy, December.
19. Pitches, D. W., M. A. Mohammed, and, R. J. Lilford,. 2007. " What Is the Empirical Evidence That Hospitals with Higher-Risk Adjusted Mortality Rates Provide Poorer Quality Care? A Systematic Review of the Literature. BMC Health Services Research 7: 91-8.
20. Seagroatt, V., and, M. J. Goldacre,. 2004. " Hospital Mortality League Tables: Influence of Place of Death. British Medical Journal 328: 1235-6.
21. Shahian, D. M., R. E. Wolf, L. I. Iezzoni, L. Kirle, and, S.-L. T. Normand,. 2010. " Variability in the Measurement of Hospital-Wide Mortality Rates. New England Journal of Medicine 363: 2530-9.
22. Sundararajan, V., T. Henderson, C. Perry, A. Muggivan, H. Quan, and, W. A. Ghali,. 2004. " New ICD-10 Version of the Charlson Comorbidity Index Predicted In-Hospital Mortality. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 57: 1288-94. (Pubitemid 40023149)