Attention to painful cutaneous laser stimuli evokes directed functional interactions between human sensory and modulatory pain-related cortical areas

Pain

Volumn 152, Issue 12, 2011, Pages 2781-2791

  Liu, Chang Chia ^a   Ohara, Shinji ^a   Franaszczuk, Piotr J ^b   Crone, Nathan E ^b   Lenz, Frederick A ^a  

^a JOHNS HOPKINS HOSPITAL   (United States)

^b JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

Attention; Causality; Cortex; Event related; Human; Network; Pain

Indexed keywords

ADULT; ARTICLE; ATTENTION; BRAIN CORTEX; CASE REPORT; DISTRACTIBILITY; ELECTRODE; EPILEPSY; FEMALE; HUMAN; LASER; MALE; PAIN; PRIORITY JOURNAL; STIMULATION; STIMULUS; VISUAL ANALOG SCALE;

ADULT; ATTENTION; CEREBRAL CORTEX; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; NERVE NET; PAIN; PAIN PERCEPTION; PAIN THRESHOLD; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 81055157590     PISSN: 03043959     EISSN: 18726623     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.pain.2011.09.002     Document Type: Article

References (89)

1. H. Akaike New look at statistical-model identification IEEE Trans Autom Control AC19 1974 716 723
2. A.V. Apkarian, M.C. Bushnell, R.-D. Treede, and J.K. Zubieta Human brain mechanisms of pain perception and regulation in health and disease Eur J Pain 9 2005 463 484 (Pubitemid 40836040)
3. S.J. Bantick, R.G. Wise, A. Ploghaus, S. Clare, S.M. Smith, and I. Tracey Imaging how attention modulates pain in humans using functional MRI Brain 125 2002 310 319 (Pubitemid 34127433)
4. U. Baumgartner, H. Vogel, S. Ohara, R.D. Treede, and F.A. Lenz Dipole source analyses of laser evoked potentials (LEP) obtained from subdural grid recordings from primary somatic sensory cortex J Neurophysiol 106 2011 722 730
5. J.S. Bendat, and A.G. Piersol Random data 1976 Wiley New York, NY
6. D. Boatman, C. Hall, M.H. Goldstein, R.H. Lesser, and B. Gordon Neuroperceptual differences in consonant and vowel discrimination as revealed by direct cortical electrical interference Cortex 33 1997 83 89
7. M. Boly, E. Balteau, C. Schnakers, C. Degueldre, G. Moonen, A. Luxen, C. Phillips, P. Peigneux, P. Maquet, and S. Laureys Baseline brain activity fluctuations predict somatosensory perception in humans PNAS 104 2007 12187 12192 (Pubitemid 47185651)
8. J.J. Borckardt, S.T. Reeves, M. Weinstein, A.R. Smith, N. Shelley, F.A. Kozel, Z. Nahas, K.T. Byrne, K. Morgan, and M.S. George Significant analgesic effects of one session of postoperative left prefrontal cortex repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation: a replication study Brain Stimulat 1 2008 122 127 (Pubitemid 351689972)
9. H. Burton Second somatosensory cortex and related areas E.G. Jones, A. Peters, Cerebral cortex, vol. 5: sensory-motor areas and aspects of cortical connectivity 1986 Plenum Press New York, NY 31 98
10. H. Burton, M. Fabri, and K. Alloway Cortical areas within the lateral sulcus connected to cutaneous representations in areas 3b and 1: a revised interpretation of the second somatosensory area in macaque monkeys J Comp Neurol 355 1995 539 562
11. K.L. Casey, and M.C. Bushnell Pain imaging 2001 IASP Press Seattle, WA
12. A.C.N. Chen, and B. Bromm Pain-related generators of laser-evoked brain potentials: brain mapping and dipole modeling B. Bromm, J.E. Desmedt, Pain and the brain: from nociception to cognition 1995 Raven Press New York, NY 245 266
13. N.E. Crone, D.L. Miglioretti, B. Gordon, and R.P. Lesser Functional mapping of human sensorimotor cortex with electrocorticographic spectral analysis. II. Event-related synchronization in the gamma band Brain 121 1998 2301 2315 (Pubitemid 28552467)
14. K.D. Davis Studies of pain using functional magnetic resonance imaging K.L. Casey, M.C. Bushnell, Pain imaging vol. 18 2000 IASP Press Seattle, WA 195 210
15. K.D. Davis, S.J. Taylor, A.P. Crawley, M.L. Wood, and D.J. Mikulis Functional MRI of pain- and attention related activation in the human cingulate cortex J Neurophysiol 77 1997 3370 3380 (Pubitemid 27290900)
16. L.M. De, G.J. Parker, K. Embleton, J.M. Newton, and V. Walsh Diffusion tensor MRI-based estimation of the influence of brain tissue anisotropy on the effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation Neuroimage 36 2007 1159 1170 (Pubitemid 47001727)
17. S.W.G. Derbyshire, B.A. Vogt, and A.K.P. Jones Pain and stroop interference tasks activate separate processing modules in anterior cingulate cortex Exp Brain Res 118 1998 52 60 (Pubitemid 28052677)
18. M. Desmurget, K.T. Reilly, N. Richard, A. Szathmari, C. Mottolese, and A. Sirigu Movement intention after parietal cortex stimulation in humans Science 324 2009 811 813
19. M. Ding, S.L. Bressler, W. Yang, and H. Liang Short-window spectral analysis of cortical event-related potentials by adaptive multivariate autoregressive modeling: data preprocessing, model validation, and variability assessment Biol Cybern 83 2000 35 45
20. J. Downar, A.P. Crawley, D.J. Mikulis, and K.D. Davis A cortical network sensitive to stimulus salience in a neutral behavioral context across multiple sensory modalities J Neurophysiol 87 2002 615 620 (Pubitemid 34669975)
21. J. Downar, D.J. Mikulis, and K.D. Davis Neural correlates of the prolonged salience of painful stimulation Neuroimage 20 2003 1540 1551 (Pubitemid 37468262)
22. P. Dunckley, Q. Aziz, R.G. Wise, J. Brooks, I. Tracey, and L. Chang Attentional modulation of visceral and somatic pain Neurogastroenterol Motil 19 2007 569 577 (Pubitemid 46985591)
23. H.M. Duvernoy, E.A. Cabanis, M.T. Iba-Zizen, J. Tamraz, and J. Guyot The human brain: surface, three-dimensional sectional anatomy and MRI 1991 Springer-Verlag New York, NY
24. A.K. Engel, and W. Singer Temporal binding and the neural correlates of sensory awareness Trends Cogn Sci 5 2001 16 25 (Pubitemid 32063335)
25. P.J. Franaszczuk, and G.K. Bergey An autoregressive method for the measurement of synchronization of interictal and ictal EEG signals Biol Cybern 81 1999 3 9 (Pubitemid 129543163)
26. U.N. Frankenstein, W. Richter, M.C. McIntyre, and F. Remy Distraction modulates anterior cingulate gyrus activations during the cold pressor test Neuroimage 14 2001 827 836 (Pubitemid 32929883)
27. J. Ginter Jr., K.J. Blinowska, M. Kaminski, and P.J. Durka Phase and amplitude analysis in time-frequency space - application to voluntary finger movement J Neurosci Methods 110 2001 113 124 (Pubitemid 32846545)
28. J. Ginter Jr., K.J. Blinowska, M. Kaminski, P.J. Durka, G. Pfurtscheller, and C. Neuper Propagation of EEG activity in the beta and gamma band during movement imagery in humans Methods Inf Med 44 2005 106 113 (Pubitemid 40461339)
29. C.W. Granger Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross spectral methods Econometrics 37 1969 424 438
30. J.D. Greenspan, R.C. Coghill, I. Gilron, E. Sarlani, D. Veldhuijzen, and F.A. Lenz Quantitative somatic sensory testing and functional imaging of the response to painful stimuli before and after cingulotomy for obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) Eur J Pain 12 2008 990 999
31. J.D. Greenspan, R.R. Lee, and F.A. Lenz Pain sensitivity alterations as a function of lesion location in the parasylvian cortex Pain 81 1999 273 282 (Pubitemid 29257897)
32. T. Herbsman, L. Forster, C. Molnar, R. Dougherty, D. Christie, J. Koola, D. Ramsey, P.S. Morgan, D.E. Bohning, M.S. George, and Z. Nahas Motor threshold in transcranial magnetic stimulation: the impact of white matter fiber orientation and skull-to-cortex distance Hum Brain Mapp 30 2009 2044 2055
33. H.G. Hoffman, T.L. Richards, B. Coda, A.R. Bills, D. Blough, A.L. Richards, and S.R. Sharar Modulation of thermal pain-related brain activity with virtual reality: evidence from fMRI Neuroreport 15 2004 1245 1248 (Pubitemid 38757257)
34. M. Kaminski, M. Ding, W.A. Truccolo, and S.L. Bressler Evaluating causal relations in neural systems: Granger causality, directed transfer function and statistical assessment of significance Biol Cybern 85 2001 145 157 (Pubitemid 33605209)
35. H.O. Karnath, S. Borchers, and M. Himmelbach Comment on "Movement intention after parietal cortex stimulation in humans" Science 327 2010 1200
36. Y. Kitamura, R. Kakigi, M. Hoshiyama, S. Koyama, M. Shimojo, and S. Watanabe Pain-related somatosensory evoked magnetic fields Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 95 1995 463 474 (Pubitemid 26020895)
37. J. Kong, M.L. Loggia, C. Zyloney, P. Tu, P. Laviolette, and R.L. Gollub Exploring the brain in pain: activations, deactivations and their relation Pain 148 2010 257 267
38. J. Kong, N.S. White, K.K. Kwong, M.G. Vangel, I.S. Rosman, R.H. Gracely, and R.L. Gollub Using fMRI to dissociate sensory encoding from cognitive evaluation of heat pain intensity Hum Brain Mapp 27 2006 715 721 (Pubitemid 44412047)
39. A. Korzeniewska, C.M. Crainiceanu, R. Kus, P.J. Franaszczuk, and N.E. Crone Dynamics of event-related causality in brain electrical activity Hum Brain Mapp 29 2008 1170 1192
40. A. Korzeniewska, M. Manczak, M. Kaminski, K.J. Blinowska, and S. Kasicki Determination of information flow direction among brain structures by a modified directed transfer function (dDTF) method J Neurosci Methods 125 2003 195 207 (Pubitemid 36579348)
41. J.P. Lefaucher TMS and pain E.M. Wassermann, C.M. Epstein, U. Ziemann, V. Walsh, T. Paus, S.H. Lisanby, Handbook of transcranial stimulation 2008 Oxford University Press New York, NY p. 717-36
42. V. Legrain, R. Bruyer, J.M. Guerit, and L. Plaghki Involuntary orientation of attention to unattended deviant nociceptive stimuli is modulated by concomitant visual task difficulty. Evidence from laser evoked potentials Clin Neurophysiol 116 2005 2165 2174 (Pubitemid 41262208)
43. F.A. Lenz, K.L. Casey, E.G. Jones, and W.D. Willis Jr. The human pain system: experimental and clinical perspectives 2010 Cambridge University Press New York, NY
44. F.A. Lenz, M. Rios, D. Chau, G.L. Krauss, T.A. Zirh, and R.P. Lesser Painful stimuli evoke potentials recorded from the parasylvian cortex in humans J Neurophysiol 80 1998 2077 2088 (Pubitemid 28489134)
45. F.A. Lenz, M. Rios, A. Zirh, D. Chau, G. Krauss, and R.P. Lesser Painful stimuli evoke potentials recorded over the human anterior cingulate gyrus J Neurophysiol 79 1998 2231 2234
46. F.A. Lenz, M. Seike, R.T. Richardson, Y.C. Lin, F.H. Baker, I. Khoja, C.J. Jaeger, and R.H. Gracely Thermal and pain sensations evoked by microstimulation in the area of human ventrocaudal nucleus J Neurophysiol 70 1993 200 212
47. R.P. Lesser, B. Gordon, J.M. Fox, J. Hart, and S. Uematsu Subdural grid electrodes in surgery of epilepsy H.O. Luders, Epilepsy surgery 1992 Raven Press New York, NY 399 408
48. N. Levit-Binnun, N.Z. Handzy, E. Moses, I. Modai, and A. Peled Transcranial magnetic stimulation at M1 disrupts cognitive networks in schizophrenia Schizophr Res 93 2007 334 344 (Pubitemid 46817928)
49. R.H. Levy, R.H. Mattson, W. Melega, and E. Perucca Antiepileptic drugs 2002 Lippincott, Williams and Wilkins
50. C.C. Liu, N.E. Crone, P.J. Franaszczuk, D. Cheng, D.S. Schretlen, and F.A. Lenz Fear conditioning is associated with dynamic directed functional interactions between and within the human amygdala, hippocampus, and frontal lobe Neuroscience 189 2011 359 369
51. C.C. Liu, S. Ohara, P.J. Franaszczuk, and F.A. Lenz Attention to painful cutaneous laser stimuli evokes directed functional connectivity between activity recorded directly from human pain-related cortical structures Pain 152 2011 664 675
52. C.C. Liu, S. Ohara, P.J. Franaszczuk, N. Zagzoog, M. Gallagher, and F.A. Lenz Painful stimuli evoke potentials recorded from the medial temporal lobe in humans Neuroscience 165 2010 1402 1411
53. C.C. Liu, C.Q. Shi, P.J. Franaszczuk, N.E. Crone, D. Schretlen, S. Ohara, and F.A. Lenz Painful laser stimuli induce directed functional interactions within and between the human amygdala and hippocampus Neuroscience 178 2011 208 217
54. J. Lorenz, and L. Garcia-Larrea Contribution of attentional and cognitive factors to laser evoked brain potentials Neurophysiol Clin 33 2003 293 301 (Pubitemid 38044022)
55. C. Montes, P. Mertens, P. Convers, R. Peyron, M. Sindou, B. Laurent, F. Mauguiere, and L. Garcia-Larrea Cognitive effects of precentral cortical stimulation for pain control: an ERP study Neurophysiol Clin 32 2002 313 325 (Pubitemid 36014755)
56. A. Mouraux, J.M. Guerit, and L. Plaghki Refractoriness cannot explain why C-fiber laser-evoked brain potentials are recorded only if concomitant Adelta-fiber activation is avoided Pain 112 2004 16 26 (Pubitemid 39371016)
57. A. Mouraux, and G.D. Iannetti Nociceptive laser-evoked brain potentials do not reflect nociceptive-specific neural activity J Neurophysiol 101 2009 3258 3269
58. T.P. Naidich MR imaging of the brain surface anatomy Neuroradiology 33 1991 S95 S99
59. S. Ohara, N.E. Crone, N. Weiss, J.H. Kim, and F.A. Lenz Analysis of synchrony demonstrates that the presence of "pain networks" prior to a noxious stimulus can enable the perception of pain in response to that stimulus Exp Brain Res 185 2008 353 358
60. S. Ohara, N.E. Crone, N. Weiss, and F.A. Lenz Attention to a painful cutaneous laser stimulus modulates electrocorticographic event-related desynchronization in humans Clin Neurophysiol 115 2004 1641 1652 (Pubitemid 38760310)
61. S. Ohara, N.E. Crone, N. Weiss, and F.A. Lenz Analysis of synchrony demonstrates 'pain networks' defined by rapidly switching, task-specific, functional connectivity between pain-related cortical structures Pain 123 2006 244 253
62. S. Ohara, N.E. Crone, N. Weiss, R.D. Treede, and F.A. Lenz Cutaneous painful laser stimuli evoke responses recorded directly from primary somatosensory cortex in awake humans J Neurophysiol 91 2004 2734 2746 (Pubitemid 38649779)
63. S. Ohara, N.E. Crone, N. Weiss, H. Vogel, R.D. Treede, and F.A. Lenz Attention to pain is processed at multiple cortical sites in man Exp Brain Res 156 2004 513 517 (Pubitemid 38822619)
64. A.V. Oppenheim, and R.W. Schafer Digital signal processing 1975 Prentice-Hall Englewood Heights, NJ
65. A.G. Osborn Diagnostic neuroradiology 2007 Mosby New York, NY
66. P. Petrovic, K.M. Petersson, P.H. Ghatan, S. Stone-Elander, and M. Ingvar Pain-related cerebral activation is altered by a distracting cognitive task Pain 85 2000 19 30 (Pubitemid 30110740)
67. R. Peyron, I. Faillenot, P. Mertens, B. Laurent, and L. Garcia-Larrea Motor cortex stimulation in neuropathic pain. Correlations between analgesic effect and hemodynamic changes in the brain. A PET study Neuroimage 34 2007 310 321 (Pubitemid 44765250)
68. R. Peyron, B. Laurent, and L. Garcia-Larrea Functional imaging of brain responses to pain. A review and meta-analysis Neurophysiol Clin 30 2000 263 288
69. A. Ploghaus, I. Tracey, J.S. Gati, S. Clare, R.S. Menon, P.M. Matthews, and J.N. Rawlins Dissociating pain from its anticipation in the human brain Science 284 1999 1979 1981 (Pubitemid 29309443)
70. M. Ploner, J.M. Schoffelen, A. Schnitzler, and J. Gross Functional integration within the human pain system as revealed by Granger causality Hum Brain Mapp 30 2009 4025 4032
71. D.D. Price Psychological and neural mechanisms of the affective dimension of pain Science 288 2000 1769 1772 (Pubitemid 30399009)
72. P. Rainville, M.C. Bushnell, and G.H. Duncan PET studies of the subjective experience of pain K.L. Casey, M.C. Bushnell, Pain imaging vol. 18 2000 IASP Press Seattle, WA 123 156
73. M. Rios, R. Treede, J. Lee, and F.A. Lenz Direct evidence of nociceptive input to human anterior cingulate gyrus and parasylvian cortex Curr Rev Pain 3 1999 256 264
74. K.A. Ruppert, M.P. Wand, and J.R. Carroll Semiparametric regression 2003 Cambridge University Press Cambridge, UK
75. P.M. Shajahan, M.F. Glabus, J.D. Steele, A.B. Doris, K. Anderson, J.A. Jenkins, P.A. Gooding, and K.P. Ebmeier Left dorso-lateral repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation affects cortical excitability and functional connectivity, but does not impair cognition in major depression Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry 26 2002 945 954 (Pubitemid 35245564)
76. H. Shibata, and M. Yukie Thalamocingulate interactions in the monkey B.A. Vogt, Cingulate neurobiology and disease 2009 Oxford University Press New York, NY 95 112
77. A. Sirigu, C. Mottolese, and M. Desmurget Response to comment on "Movement intention after parietal cortex stimulation in humans" Science 327 2010 1200-d
78. C.J. Starr, L. Sawaki, G.F. Wittenberg, J.H. Burdette, Y. Oshiro, A.S. Quevedo, and R.C. Coghill Roles of the insular cortex in the modulation of pain: insights from brain lesions J Neurosci 29 2009 2684 2694
79. P.N. Steinmetz, A. Roy, P.J. Fitzgerald, S.S. Hsiao, K.O. Johnson, and E. Niebur Attention modulates synchronized neuronal firing in primate somatosensory cortex Nature 404 2000 187 190 (Pubitemid 30154486)
80. 2 laser J Clin Neurophysiol 10 1993 513 519 (Pubitemid 23360787)
81. A. Truini, P. Rossi, F. Galeotti, A. Romaniello, M. Virtuoso, L.C. De, M. Leandri, and G. Cruccu Excitability of the Adelta nociceptive pathways as assessed by the recovery cycle of laser evoked potentials in humans Exp Brain Res 155 2004 120 123 (Pubitemid 38315321)
82. 2 laser stimulation of the hand EEG Clin Neurophysiol 100 1996 343 353
83. M. Valet, T. Sprenger, H. Boecker, F. Willoch, E. Rummeny, B. Conrad, P. Erhard, and T.R. Tolle Distraction modulates connectivity of the cingulo-frontal cortex and the midbrain during pain - an fMRI analysis Pain 109 2004 399 408 (Pubitemid 38638717)
84. G.W. Van Hoesen, R.J. Morecraft, and B.A. Vogt Connections of the monkey cingulate cortex B.A. Vogt, M. Gabriel, Neurobiology of cingulate cortex and limbic thalamus: a comprehensive handbook 1993 Birkhäuser Boston, MA 249 284
85. H. Vogel, J.D. Port, F.A. Lenz, M. Solaiyappan, G. Krauss, and R.D. Treede Dipole source analysis of laser-evoked subdural potentials recorded from parasylvian cortex in humans J Neurophysiol 89 2003 3051 3060 (Pubitemid 36682657)
86. B.A. Vogt Pain and emotion interactions in subregions of the cingulate gyrus Nat Rev Neurosci 6 2005 533 544 (Pubitemid 40942820)
87. N. Wiener The theory of prediction E. Bechenbach, Modern mathematics for engineers 1956 McGraw-Hill New York, NY
88. H. Yamasaki, R. Kakigi, S. Watanabe, and D. Naka Effects of distraction on pain perception: magneto- and electro-encephalographic studies Brain Res Cogn Brain Res 8 1999 73 76 (Pubitemid 29202238)
89. R. Zaslansky, E. Sprecher, C.E. Tenke, J.A. Hemli, and D. Yarnitsky The P300 in pain evoked potentials Pain 66 1995 39 49 (Pubitemid 26247023)