Percutaneous versus surgical closure of secundum atrial septal defects: A systematic review and meta-analysis of currently available clinical evidence

EuroIntervention

Volumn 7, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 377-385

  Butera, Gianfranco ^a   Biondi Zoccai, Giuseppe ^b   Sangiorgi, Giuseppe ^c   Abella, Raul ^a   Giamberti, Alessandro ^a   Bussadori, Claudio ^a   Sheiban, Imad ^b   Saliba, Zackhia ^d   Santoro, Tiberio ^e   Pelissero, Gabriele ^a   Carminati, Mario ^a   Frigiola, Alessandro ^a  

^a IRCCS POLICLINICO SAN DONATO   (Italy)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MODENA AND REGGIO EMILIA   (Italy)

^c UNIVERSITY OF TURIN   (Italy)

^d SAINT JOSEPH UNIVERSITY   (Lebanon)

^e CASA SOLLIEVO DELLA SOFFERENZA HOSPITAL   (Italy)

Author keywords

Atrial septal defect; Meta analysis; Surgery; Systematic review; Transcatheter; Treatment

Indexed keywords

ANTITHROMBOCYTIC AGENT;

ANTICOAGULATION; CARDIOVERSION; COHORT ANALYSIS; FLUOROSCOPY; HEART ATRIUM SEPTUM DEFECT; HEART HEMODYNAMICS; HOSPITALIZATION; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; LENGTH OF STAY; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PERCUTANEOUS CLOSURE; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATION; QUALITY CONTROL; REVIEW; STERNOTOMY; SURGICAL APPROACH; SURGICAL CLOSURE; SURGICAL TECHNIQUE; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW;

ANGIOPLASTY; CARDIOVASCULAR SURGICAL PROCEDURES; ENDPOINT DETERMINATION; HEART SEPTAL DEFECTS, ATRIAL; HUMANS; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATIONS; PREVALENCE; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 80355137326     PISSN: 1774024X     EISSN: 19696213     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.4244/EIJV7I3A63     Document Type: Review

References (32)

1. Dickinson DF, Arnold R, Wilkinson JL. Congenital heart disease among 160,480 liveborn children in Liverpool 1960 to 1969: implications of surgical treatment. Br Heart J 1981;46:55-62. (Pubitemid 11018962)
2. Lewis FJ, Roufle M. Closure of atrial septal defects with aid of hypothermia: experimental accomplishments and the report of one successful case. Surgery 1953;33:52-9.
3. Horvath KA, Burke RP, Collins JJ Jr, Cohn LM. Surgical treatment of atrial septal defect: early and long term results. J Am Coll Cardiol 1992; 20:1156-9.
4. Murphy JG, Gersh BJ, Mc Goon MD, Mair DD, Porter CJ, Ilstrup DM, McGoon DC, Puga FJ, Kirklin JW, Danielson GK. Long term outcome after surgical repair of isolated atrial septal defect: follow-up at 27 to 32 years. N Engl J Med 1990;323: 1645-50.
5. Galal MD, Wobst A, Halees Z, Hatle L, Scmaltz AA, Khougeer F, De Vol E, Fawzy ME, Abbag F, Fadley F. Peri-operative complications following surgical closure of atrial septal defect type II in 232 patients - a baseline study. Eur Heart J 1994;15:1381-4. (Pubitemid 24326060)
6. Meijboom F, Hess J, Szatmari A, Utens EM, McGhie J, Deckers JW, Roelandt JR, Bos E. Long term follow-up (9 to 20 years) after surgical closure of atrial septal defect at a young age. Am J Cardiol 1993;72:1431-4. (Pubitemid 24005674)
7. Konstantidines S, Geibel A, Olschewski M, Gornandt L, Roskamm H, Spillner G, Just H, Kasper W. A comparison of surgical and medical therapy for atrial septal defect in adults. N Engl J Med 1995;333:469-73.
8. King TD, Thompson SL, Steiner L, Mills NL. Secundum atrial septal defect: nonoperative closure during cardiac catheterization. JAMA 1976;235:2506-9.
9. Butera G, Carminati M, Chessa M, Youssef R, Drago M, Giamberti A, Pome G, Bossone E, Frigiola A. Percutaneous versus surgical closure of secundum atrial septal defect: comparison of early results and complications. Am Heart J 2006;151:228-34. (Pubitemid 41815360)
10. Hughes ML, Maskell G, Goh TH, Wilkinson JL. Prospective comparison of costs and short term health outsomes of surgical versus device closure of atrial septal defect in children. Heart 2002; 88:67-70. (Pubitemid 34665006)
11. Kim JJ, Hijazi ZM. Clinical outcomes and costs of Amplatzer transcatheter closure as compared with surgical closure of ostium secundum atrial septal defects. Med Sci Monit 2002;8:787-791.
12. Thomson JDR, Aburawi EH, Watterson KG, Van Doorn C, Gibbs JL. Surgical and transcatheter (amplatzer) closure of atrial septal defects: a prospective comparison of results and cost. Heart 2002;87:466-9. (Pubitemid 34454591)
13. Formigari R, Di Donato RM, Mazzera E, Carotti A, Rinelli G, Parisi F, Pasquini L, Ballerini L. Minimally invasive or interventional repair of atrial septal ddefects in children: experience in 171 cases and comparison with conventional strategies. J Am Coll Cardiol 2001;37:1707-12. (Pubitemid 32386011)
14. Cowley CG, Lloyd TR, Bove EL, Gaffney D, Dietrich M, Rocchini AP. Comparison of results of closure of secundum atrial septal defect by surgery versus Amplatzer septal occluder. Am J Cardiol 2001;88:589-91. (Pubitemid 32778517)
15. Du ZD, Hijazi ZM, Kleinman CS, Silverman NH, Larntz K, for the Amplatzer Investigators. Comparison beteen transcatheter and surgical closure of secundum atrial septal defect in children and adults. J Am Coll Cardiol 2002;39:1836-44. (Pubitemid 34595297)
16. Berger F, Vogel M, Alexi-Meskishvili V, Lange PE. Comparison of results and complicatiosn of surgical and Amplatzer device closure of atrial septal defects. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1999; 118:674-80. (Pubitemid 29474794)
17. Vida VL, Barnoya J, O'Connel M, Leon-Wyss J, Larrazabal LA, Castaneda AR. Surgical versus percutaneous occlusion of ostium secundum atrial septal defects. Results and cost-effective considerations in a low-income country. J Am Coll Cardiol 2006; 47:326-31. (Pubitemid 43063249)
18. Bialkowski J, Karwot B, Szkutnik M, Banaszak P, Kusa J, Skalski J. Closure of atrial septal defects in children. Surgery versus Amplatzer device implantation. Tex Heart Inst J 2004;31:220-3. (Pubitemid 39202702)
19. Durongpisitkul K. Soongswang J, Laohaprasitiporn D, Nana A, Sriyoschati S, Ponvilawan S, Subtaweesin T, Kangkagate C Comparison of atrial septal defect closure using Amplatzer septal occluder with surgery. Pediatr Cardiol 2002;23:36-40. (Pubitemid 36927323)
20. Bettencourt N, Salome N, Carneiro F, Goncalves M, Ribeiro J, Braga JP, Fonseca C, Correia DM, Vouca L, Ribeiro VG. Atrial septal closure in adults: surgery versus Amplatzer. Comparison of results. Rev Port Cardiol 2003;22:1203-11. (Pubitemid 37516873)
21. Jones TK, Latson LA, Zahn E, Fleishman CE, Jacobson J, Vincent R, Kanter K, for the Multicenter Pivotal Study of the Helex Septal Occluder Investigators. Results of the US multicenter pivotal study of the Helex septal occluder for the percutaneous closure of secundum atrial septal defects. J Am Coll Cardiol 2007; 49:2215-21. (Pubitemid 46830741)
22. Vitiello R, McCrindle BW, Nykanen D, Freedom RM, Benson LN. Complications associated with pediatric cardiac catheterization. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1998;32:1433-40. (Pubitemid 28522406)
23. Chessa M, Carminati M, Butera G, Bini RM, Drago M, Rosti L, Giamberti A, Pome G, Bossone E, Frigiola A. Early and late complications associated with transcatheter occlusion of secundum atrial septal defect. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2002;39:1061-5. (Pubitemid 34234131)
24. Guyatt G and Rennie, editors. Users' guide to the Medical literature. A manual for evidence based clinical practice. 2002; Chicago, AMA Press.
25. Higgins JPT, Green S, editors. Cochrane Handbook for systematic reviews of interventions 4.2.6. http://www.cochrane.org/ resources/handbook/hbook.htm (accessed 6 june 2009)
26. Amin Z. Transcatheter closure of secundum septal defects. Catheter Cardiovasc Interv 2006;68:778-87. (Pubitemid 44721106)
27. Webb G, Gatzoulis MA. Atrial septal defects in the adult: recent progress and overview. Circulation 2006;114:1645-53. (Pubitemid 44547435)
28. Brickner ME, Hillis LD, Lange RA. Congenital heart disease in adults. Atrial septal defect. N Engl J Med 2000;342:256-7.
29. DiBardinoDJ, McElhinney DB, Kaza AK, Mayer JE. Analysis of the US Food and Drug Amninistration Manufacturer and User Facility Device Experience database for adverse events involving Amplatzer septal occlude devices and comparison with the Society of Thoracic Surgery congenital cardiac surgery database. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2009;137:1334-41.
30. Benson K, Hartz AJ. A comparison of observational studies and randomized, controlled trials. N Engl J Med 2000;342:1878-86. (Pubitemid 30419053)
31. Concato J, Shah N, Horwitz RI. Randomized, controlled trials, observational studies and the hierarchy of research designs. N Engl J Med 2000;342:1887-92. (Pubitemid 30419054)
32. Biondi-Zoccai GGL, Agostoni P, Abbate A. Parallel hierarchy of scientific studies in cardiovascular medecine. Ital Heart J 2003;4:819-20.