Miracles and statistics: The casual assumption of independence

Journal of the American Statistical Association

Volumn 83, Issue 404, 1988, Pages 929-940

  Kruskal, William ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO   (United States)

Author keywords

Babbage; Hume; Religion; Safety; Testimony

Indexed keywords

EID: 80054968274     PISSN: 01621459     EISSN: 1537274X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/01621459.1988.10478682     Document Type: Article

References (138)

1. Annet, Peter (1744), The Resurrection of Jesus, London: M. Cooper.
2. Anscombe, F. J. (1978), “Statistical Analysis, Special Problems of: Outliers,” in International Encyclopedia of Statistics, eds. W. H. Kruskal and J. M. Tanur, New York: Free Press, pp. 1039–1944.
3. Archbishops’ Commission (1958), The Church’s Ministry of Healing, London: Church Information Board.
4. Babbage, Charles (1838), The Ninth Bridgewater Treatise: A Fragment (2nd ed.), London: John Murray. (The first edition appeared in 1837.)
5. Barnes, Harry Elmer (1965), An Intellectual and Cultural History of the Western World (3rd ed.), New York: Dover Publications. (First published in 1937.)
6. Bartholomew, David J. (1984), God of Chance, London: SCM.
7. —— (1988), “Probability, Statistics and Theology” (with discussion), Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Ser. A., 151, 137–178.
8. Benson, E. F. (1930), As We Were/A Victorian Peep-Show, London: Longmans, Green.
9. Berkson, Joseph, Magath, Thomas B., and Hurn, Margaret (1939), “The Error of Estimate of the Blood Cell Count as Made With the Hemocytometer,” American Journal of Physiology, 128, 309–323.
10. Berry, R. J. (1986), “What to Believe About Miracles,” Nature, 322, July 24, 321–322.
11. Bertrand, J. (1888), Calcul des Probabilités, Paris: Gauthier-Villars.
12. Bethe, A. H. (1976), “The Necessity of Fission Power,” Scientific American, 234, January, 21–31.
13. Bienaymé [Jules] (1838), “Probabilité des Jugements et des Témoinages,” in Extraits des Procès-Verbaux des Séances, Paris: Société Philomatique de Paris, pp. 93–96.
14. Bradburn, Norman M. (1969), The Structure of Psychological Well-Being, Chicago: Aldine.
15. Brams, Steven J. (1980), Biblical Games: A Strategic Analysis of Stories in the Old Testament, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
16. British Medical Association (1956), “Divine Healing and Cooperation Between Doctors and Clergy,” memorandum to the Archbishops’ Commission on Divine Healing, London: Author.
17. Brown, Colin (1984), Miracles and the Critical Mind, Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
18. Brush, Stephen G. (1974), “The Prayer Test,” American Scientist, 62, 561–563; Correspondence (1975), 63, 6–7.
19. Burns, R. M. (1981), The Great Debate on Miracles/From Joseph Glanvil to David Hume, Lewisburg, PA: Bucknell University Press.
20. Chalmers, Thomas (1842), “On the Consistency Between the Efficacy of Prayer—and the Uniformity of Nature” (Discourses on the Christian Revelation Viewed in Connection With Modern Astronomy / To Which We Added Discourses Illustrative of the Connection Between Theology and General Science), in Works (Vol. 7), Glasgow: Collins, pp. 234–262. (The catalog of the British Museum gives a range of 1836–1842 for the Works, it also appears to say that the Discourses was first published in 1818.)
21. —— (1857), On the Miraculous and Internal Evidences of the Christian Revelation and the Authority of Its Records, New York: Carter. (First published in Edinburgh in 1814.)
22. Church of England (1986), The Nature of Christian Belief (Report of Church of England Bishops), London: Church House.
23. Cook, John (1821), An Inquiry Into the Books of the New Testament, Edinburgh: Waugh & Innes.
24. Cournot, A.-A. (1838), “Sur les Applications du Calcul des Chances à la Statistique Judiciare,” Journal de Mathématiques Pures et Appliquées, 3, 257–334.
25. Cullipp, Platon J. (1969), “The Efficacy of Prayer: a Triple-Blind Study,” Medical Times, 97, 201–204.
26. Daillé, John (Jean) (trans. T. Smith and G. Jekyll) (1843), A Treatise on the Right Use of the Fathers (2nd ed.), London: Bohn. (First published in 1631.)
27. De Finetti, Bruno (1982), “Probability and My Life,” in The Making of Statisticians, ed. J. Gani, New York: Springer-Verlag, pp. 3–20.
28. Deffeyes, Kenneth S., and MacGregor, Ian D. (1980), “World Uranium Resources,” Scientific American, 238, January, 66–76.
29. Dietl, Paul (1968), “On Miracles,” American Philosophical Quarterly, 5, 130–134.
30. Donaldson, Thomas, and Pollard, William G. (1980), “Life on Other Planets?” American Scientist, 68, 128–131.
31. Eddington, Arthur (1935), New Pathways in Science, New York: Macmillan.
32. Eggleston, Richard (1978), Evidence, Proof and Probability, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson.
33. Eichrodt, Walther (trans. J. A. Baker) (1967), Theology of the Old Testament (Vol. 2), Philadelphia: Westminster. [Published in 1964 as Theologie des Alten Testament (5th ed.), Stuttgart: Ehrenfried Klotz.]
34. Eliade, Mircea (trans. M. L. Ricketts) (1981), Autobiography, Vol. I: 1907–1937, Journey East, Journey West, San Francisco: Harper & Row.
35. Fairley, William B. (1977), “Evaluating the ‘Small’ Probability of a Catastrophic Accident From the Marine Transportation of Liquified Natural Gas,” in Statistics and Public Policy, by W. Fairley and F. Mosteller, Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, pp. 331–353.
36. Fairley, William B., and Mosteller, Frederick (1974), “A Conversation About Collins,” The University of Chicago Law Review, 41, 242–253. [Reprinted, along with other relevant materials, in 1977 in Statistics and Public Policy, Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, pp. 369–379.]
37. Falk, Bernard (1942), The Bridgewater Millions/A Candid Family History, London: Hutchinson. [See the (anonymous) review of this book in The Times Literary Supplement, 41, June 13, 294.]
38. Fienberg, Stephen E. (1971), “Randomization and Social Affairs: The 1970 Draft Lottery,” Science, January 22, 255–261.
39. Flew, Antony (1967), “Miracles,” in Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Vol. 5), New York: Macmillan and Free Press, pp. 346–353.
40. Frank, Jerome D. (1978), “The Medical Power of Faith,” Human Nature, 1, August, 40–47.
41. Frank, Philipp G. (1956), “The Variety of Reasons for the Acceptance of Scientific Theories,” in The Validation of Scientific Theories, ed. P. G. Frank, Boston: Beacon, pp. 3–18.
42. Frye, Northrop (1982), The Great Code: The Bible and Literature, New York: Harcourt, Brace & Jovanovich. [Reviewed by Kermode (1982).]
43. Galton, Francis (1872), “Statistical Inquiries Into the Efficacy of Prayer,” The Fortnightly Review, New Series 12, August, 125–135. [Reprinted in Means (1876, pp. 85–106).]
44. —— (1883), Inquiries Into Human Faculty and Its Development, London: Macmillan. (Second edition published in 1907 by Dent.)
45. Garfield, Eugene (1977), “When Citation Analysis Strikes Ball Lightening,” in Essays of an Information Scientist (Vol. 2, 1974–1976), Philadelphia: ISI Press, pp. 479–490. (First appeared in Current Contents, May 12, 1976.)
46. Garraghan, Gilbert J. (1946), A Guide to Historical Method, ed. J. Delanglez, New York: Fordham University Press.
47. Gilkey, Langdon (1982), “The Creationist Controversy: the Interrelation of Inquiry and Belief,” Science, Technology, & Human Values, 77, Summer, 67–71.
48. Grant, Robert M. (1952), Miracle and Natural Law in Graeco-Roman and Early Christian Thought, Amsterdam: North-Holland.
49. Haldane, J. B. S. (1928), “Science and Theology as Art Forms,” in Possible Worlds and Other Papers, New York: Harper & Bros., pp. 237–252. (Reprinted in 1985 in On Being the Right Size and Other Essays, ed. J. M. Smith, New York: Oxford University Press.)
50. Hartman, David (1976), Maimonides: Torah and Philosophic Quest, Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America.
51. Healy, M. J. R. (1979), “Does Medical Statistics Exist?” Bulletin In Applied Statistics, 6, 137–182.
52. Heller, Joseph (1958), “Maimonides’ Theory of Miracles,” in Between East and West, ed. A. Alexander, London: East & West Library, pp. 112–127.
53. Heyde, C. C., and Seneta, E. (1977), I. J. Bienaymé/Statistical Theory Anticipated, New York: Springer-Verlag.
54. Hooper, George (1689), A Fair and Methodical Discussion …, London: Chiswell.
55. —— (1699), “A Calculation of the Credibility of Human Testimony,” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, 21, 359–365. (There has been disagreement about the authorship of this paper. It appeared in Hooper’s Works, published by Oxford University Press in 1757 and 1855.)
56. House of Bishops (1986), The Nature of Christian Belief, London: Church House.
57. Hume, David (1975), “of Miracles,” in An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding (3rd ed.), ed. L. A. Selby-Bigge, revised by P. H. Nidditch, Oxford, U.K.: Clarendon Press, sec. 10, p. 109–131. (First published in 1748; this is from the posthumous 1777 ed.)
58. Joyce, C. R. B., and Weldon, R. M. C. (1965), “The Objective Efficacy of Prayer: a Double-Blind Clinical Trial,” Journal of Chronic Diseases, 18, 367–377.
59. Kac, Mark (1982), “The Search for the Meaning of Independence,” in The Making of Statisticians, ed. J. Gani, New York: Springer-Verlag, pp. 62–72.
60. Kermode, Frank (1982), Review of The Great Code: The Bible and Literature, by N. Frye, The New Republic, 186, June 9, 30–33.
61. Kiefer, J. (1979), “Comments on Taxonomy, Independence, and Mathematical Models (with Reference to a methodology of Machol and Singer),” Mycologia, 71, 343–378.
62. Koblitz, Neal (1981), “Mathematics as Propaganda,” in Mathematics Tomorrow, ed. L. A. Steen, New York: Springer-Verlag, pp. 111— 120.
63. Kramer, Jane (1985), “Letter From Europe,” The New Yorker, 61, April 15, 73–89.
64. Kruskal, William H. (1960), “Some Remarks on Wild Observations,” Technometrics, 2, 1–3.
65. Labarthe, Darwin R., Hawkins, C. Morton, and Remington, Richard D. (1973), “Evaluation of Performance of Selected Devices for Measuring Blood Pressure,” The American Journal of Cardiology, 32, 546–553.
66. Lapp, Ralph E. (1974), “Nuclear Salvation or Nuclear Folly?” The New York Times Magazine, February 10, 10–73.
67. Lewis, C. S. (1960), Miracles/A Preliminary Study (2nd ed.), New York: Macmillan. (First published in 1947.)
68. Lewis, George Cornewall (1849), An Essay On the Influence of Authority in Matters of Opinion, London: Parker.
69. Lewis, Harold W. (1980), “The Safety of Fission Reactors,” Scientific American, 242, March, 53–65.
70. Locke, John (1959), An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, ed. A. C. Fraser, New York: Dover. (First published in 1690; Fraser edition published in 1894.)
71. Lorenz, Konrad Z. (1974), “Analogy as a Source of Knowledge,” Science, 185, July 19, 229–234.
72. Lyttle, Bradford (1982), “The Apocalypse Equation,” Harvard Magazine, 89, March-April, 19–20.
73. Machol, Robert E. (1975), “The Titanic Coincidence,” Interfaces, 5, 53–54.
74. —— (1980), “Comments on Taxonomy—A Response,” Mycologia, 72, 1222–1224.
75. Madansky, Albert (1986), “On Biblical Censuses,” Journal of Official Statistics, 2, 561–569.
76. Mahalanobis, P. C. (reported by J. Tucker, Jr.) (1947), “Summary of Lecture on the Combination of Data From Tests Conducted at Different Laboratories,” ASTM Bulletin, No. 144, 63–65.
77. Maimonides, Moses (trans. S. Pines) (1963), The Guide of the Perplexed, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
78. Marshall, Eliot (1986), “Academy Membership Fight Goes Public,” Science, 234, 1192–1194; Follow-up (1987), 236, 661–662.
79. Marty, Martin E. (1977), “Science Versus Religion: An Old Squabble Simmers Down,” Saturday Review, 5, December 10, 29–35.
80. Mascall, E. L. (1956), Christian Theology and Natural Science, New York: Ronald.
81. Mason, Brian (1967), “Meteorites,” American Scientist, 55, 429–455.
82. McArthur, Harvey K. (1965), “A Survey of Recent Gospel Research,” in New Theology No. 2, eds. M. E. Marty and D. G. Peerman, New York: Macmillan, pp. 201–221. (First published in 1964.)
83. McCormick, Charles Tilford (1972), Handbook of the Law of Evidence (2nd ed.), ed. E. W. Cleary, St. Paul, MN: West Publishing.
84. McKinnon, Alastair (1967), “‘Miracle’ and ‘Paradox’,” American Philosophical Quarterly, 4, 308–314.
85. Means, John O. (ed.) (1876), The Prayer-Gauge Debate, Boston: Congregational Publishing Society.
86. Meier, Paul, and Zabell, Sandy (1980), “Benjamin Peirce and the Howland Will,” Journal of the American Statistical Association, 75, 497–506.
87. Mill, John Stuart (1885), Nature, the Utility of Religion and Theism, London: Longmans, Green. [First published in 1874. For a full version see the 1969 Toronto edition, subtitled “Three Essays on Religion” (Vol. 10 of the Collected Works).]
88. —— (1952), A System of Logic/Ratiocinative and Inductive (8th ed.), London: Longmans, Green. [First published in 1843. Second edition 1846. For full scholarly treatment see the 1973 edition (Vol. 7), University of Toronto Press.]
89. —— (1969), Collected Works, Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
90. —— (1973), A System of Logic/Ratiocinative and Inductive, Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
91. National Research Council (1982), “Reexamination of Acoustic Evidence in the Kennedy Assassination,” Science, 218, October 8, 127–133; Correction (1982), 218, November 15, 521.
92. Owen, David (1987), “Hume Versus Price on Miracles and Prior Probabilities: Testimony and the Bayesian Calculation,” The Philosophical Quarterly, 37, 187–202.
93. Page, E. S. (1978), “Process Control,” in International Encyclopedia of Statistics, eds. W. H. Kruskal and J. M. Tanur, New York: Free Press, pp. 809–812.
94. Patey, Douglas Lane (1984), Probability and Literary Form/Philosophic Theory and Literary Practice in the Augustan Age, Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press.
95. Pearson, Karl (1924), “Historical Note on the Origin of the Normal Curve of Error,” Biometrika, 16, 402–404.
96. —— (1924–1930), The Life, Letters and Labours of Francis Galton, Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press.
97. Pearson, Karl (1978), The History of Statistics in the 17th and 18th Centuries, ed. E. S. Pearson, London: Charles W. Griffin. (Lectures given in 1921–1933.)
98. Peirce, C. S. (1958), “The Laws of Nature and Hume’s Argument Against Miracles,” Values in a Universe of Chance/Selected Writings of Charles S. Peirce (1839–1914), ed. P. P. Wiener, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, pp. 289–321. (Written in 1901.)
99. Perrin, Norman (1977), The Resurrection According to Matthew, Mark, and Luke, Philadelphia: Fortress.
100. Poe, Edgar Allan (1904), “The Mystery of Marie Roget,” in Works (Vol. 1), New York: Collier, pp. 248–327. (First published in 1842.)
101. Pomeroy, Ralph S. (1962), “Hume on the Testimony for Miracles,” Speech Monographs, 29, 1–12.
102. Portnoy, Stephen (1988), “Statistics and Religious Studies,” in Encyclopedia of Statistical Sciences (Vol. 8), eds. S. Kotz and N. L. Johnson, New York: John Wiley, pp. 679–683.
103. Portnoy, Stephen L., and Petersen, David L. (1984), “Biblical Texts and Statistical Analysis: Zechariah and Beyond,” Journal of Biblical Literature, 103, 11–21.
104. Price, Richard (1777), “On the Importance of Christianity, the Nature of Historical Evidence, and Miracles,” in Four Dissertations (4th ed.), London: Cadell, Dissertation 4. (First published in 1767.)
105. Prior, A. N. (1955), “Can Religion Be Discussed?” in New Essays in Philosophical Theology, eds. A. Flew and A. MacIntyre, London: SCM, pp. 1–11. [First appeared in Australian Journal of Philosophy (1942).]
106. Ramsey, I. T. (1971), “Our Understanding of Prayer,” Archbishops’ Commission on Christian Doctrine Occasional Paper 1, London: SPCK.
107. Romanes, Ethel (1908), The Life and Letters of George John Romanes (6th impression), London: Longmans, Green.
108. Romanes, George J. (1874), Christian Prayer and General Laws, London: Macmillan. (Includes the Burney Prize essay for 1873.)
109. Rousseau, Jean Jacques (trans. B. Foxley) (1911), Émile, London: Deut. [First published in 1762. The quotation is from “The Creed of a Savoyard Priest” (book 4).]
110. Schabas, Margaret (1983), “John Stuart Mill to William Stanley Jevons: An Unpublished Letter,” The Mill News Letter, 18, No. 2, 24–28.
111. Smart, Ninian (1964), Philosophers and Religious Truth, London: SCM.
112. Sobel, Jordan Howard (1987), “On the Evidence of Testimony for Miracles: A Bayesian Interpretation of David Hume’s Analysis,” The Philosophical Quarterly, 37, 166–186.
113. Spence, Janet T., and Helmreich, Robert L. (1978), Masculinity & Femininity/Their Psychological Dimensions, Correlates, & Antecedents, Austin: University of Texas Press.
114. Stead, W. T. (1891), “The Prince of Wales,” The Review of Reviews, 4, 23–34. [Ascription of authorship comes from Benson (1930, p. 211) and from internal evidence.]
115. Stephen, Leslie (1962), History of English Thought in the Eighteenth Century (3rd ed.), New York: Harcourt, Brace & World. (First published in 1876.)
116. Stevens, William Arnold, and Burton, Ernest DeWitt (1905), A Harmony of the Gospels for Historical Study (4th ed.), New York: Charles Scribner.
117. Stewart, Balfour (1878), “Science and a Future State,” The Princeton Review, 54, 399–408.
118. Stigler, Stephen (1986), “John Craig and the Probability of History: From the Death of Christ to the Birth of Laplace,” Journal of the American Statistical Association, 81, 879–887.
119. Stokes, G. G. (1891), Natural Theology, London: Black.
120. Strauss, David Friedrich [trans. G. Eliot (M. Evans)] (1892), The Life of Jesus, London: Swan Sonnenschein. (First published in 1835, in Tübingen, as Das Leben Jesu.)
121. Swerdlow, Noel M. (1979), “Ptolemy on Trial,” The American Scholar, 48, 523–531. (Essay-review of R. R. Newton’s The Crime of Claudius Ptolemy, Johns Hopkins University Press.)
122. Swinburne, R. G. (1968), “Miracles,” Philosophical Quarterly, 18, 320–328.
123. —— (1970), The Concept of Miracle, London: Macmillan.
124. Thomas, Jo (1985), “Toward the Blunt Bishop, Thatcher Is Irreverent,” New York Times, May 9.
125. Thompson, Harold William (1931), A Scottish Man of Feeling, London: Oxford University Press.
126. Trench, Richard Chenevix (1860), Notes on the Miracles of Our Lord (2nd Amer, ed.), New York: Appleton.
127. Trinklein, Frederick E. (1971), The God of Science, Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
128. Turner, Frank M. (1974), “Rainfall, Plagues, and the Prince of Wales: A Chapter in the Conflict of Religion and Science,” Journal of British Studies, 13, 46–65.
129. Tyndall, John (1871), “Prayer and Natural Law,” in Fragments of Science for Unscientific People, London: Longmans, Green, pp. 31–38. [First published in Mountaineering (1861).]
130. Uman, M. A. (1982), Review of Ball Lightening and Bead Lightening, by J. D. Barry, American Scientist, 80, 535–536.
131. Van Leeuwen, Henry G. (1963), The Problem of Certainty in English Thought/1630–1690, the Hague: Nijhoff.
132. Venn, John (1962), The Logic of Chance (4th ed.), New York: Chelsea Publishing. (First published in 1866; 3rd ed. 1888.)
133. Walker, D. P. (1975), Spiritual and Demonic Magic/From Ficino to Campanella, South Bend, IN: University of Notre Dame Press. (First published in 1958.)
134. Westrum, Ron (1978), “Science and Social Intelligence About Anomalies: The Case of Meteorites,” Social Studies of Science, 8, 461–493.
135. Wright, B. M., and Dore, C. F. (1970), “A Random-Zero Sphygmomanometer,” The Lancet, 1, February 14, 337–338.
136. Young, J. R. (1844), An Elementary Treatise on Algebra, Theoretical and Practical (4th ed.), London: Souter & Law.
137. —— (1846), Three Lectures A ddressed to the Students of Belfast College on Some of the Advantages of Mathematical Study to Which Is Added an Examination of Hume’s Argument Against Miracles, London: Souter & Law.
138. Zabell, S. L. (in press), “The Probabilistic Analysis of Testimony,” Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference, 20.