Which is the appropriate 3D visualization type for participatory landscape planning workshops? A portfolio of their effectiveness

Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design

Volumn 38, Issue 5, 2011, Pages 921-939

  Hayek, Ulrike Wissen ^a  

^a ETH ZURICH   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

DECISION MAKING; PARTICIPATORY APPROACH; SPATIAL DATA; SPATIAL PLANNING; STAKEHOLDER; THREE-DIMENSIONAL MODELING; VISUALIZATION;

EID: 80054719146     PISSN: 02658135     EISSN: 14723417     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1068/b36113     Document Type: Article

References (44)

1. Al-Kodmany K, 2001, "Visualization tools and methods for participatory planning and design" Journal of Urban Technology 8 1-37
2. Andrienko G, Andrienko N, Jankowski P, Keim D, Kraak M-J, MacEachren A, Wrobel S, 2007, "Geovisual analytics for spatial decision support: setting the research agenda" International Journal of Geographical Information Science 2 839-857
3. Appleton K, Lovett A, 2003, "GIS-based visualisation of rural landscapes: defining 'sufficient' realism for environmental decision-making" Landscape and Urban Planning 65 117-131
4. Appleton K, Lovett A, 2005, "GIS-based visualisation of development proposals: reactions from planning and related professionals" Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 29 321-339
5. Bishop I, Lange E, 2005, "Visualization classified", in Visualization in Landscape and Environmental Planning. Technology and Applications Eds I Bishop, E Lange (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 23-34
6. Cooper R, Scott J E, Kleinschmidt E J, 1999, "New product portfolio management: practices and performance" Journal of Product Innovation Management 16 333-351
7. Cooper R, Scott E, Kleinschmidt E, 2001, "Portfolio management for new product development: results of an industry practices study" R&DManagement 31 361-380
8. Danahy JW, 1997, "Visualization data needs in urban planning and design", in Automatic Extraction of Man-made Objects from Aerial and Space Images (II) Eds A Gruen, E P Baltsavias, O Henricsson (Birkhäuser, Basel) pp 357-366
9. Dockerty T, Lovett A, Sünnenberg G, Appleton K, Parry M, 2005, "Visualising the potential impacts of climate change on rural landscapes" Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 29 297-320
10. Dransch D, 2007, "Designing suitable cartographic multimedia presentations", in Multimedia Cartography Eds W Cartwright, M P Peterson, G Gartner (Springer, Berlin) pp 75-87
11. Ervin S M, 2001, "Digital landscape modelling and visualization: a research agenda" Landscape and Urban Planning 54 49-62
12. Flick U, 2003, "Design und Prozess qualitativer Forschung", in Qualitative Forschung-Ein Handbuch Eds U Flick, E von Kardoff, I Steinke (Rowohlt, Reinbeck bei Hamburg) pp 252-265
13. Flick U, 2004 Triangulation-Eine Einführung (VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, Wiesbaden)
14. Ghadirian P, Bishop I D, 2008, "Integration of augmented reality and GIS: a new approach to realistic landscape visualization" Landscape and Urban Planning 86 226-232
15. Healey P, 2003, "The communicative turn in planning theory and its implications for spatial strategy formation", in Readings in Planning Theory Eds S Campbell, S Fainstein (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 1237-1255
16. Jacoby C, Kistenmacher H, 1998, "Bewertungs-und Entscheidungsmethoden", in Methoden und Instrumente räumlicher Planung: Handbuch Ed. Akademie für Raumforschung und Landesplanung (VSB-Verlagsservice, Braunschweig) pp 146-168
17. Lange E, Hehl-Lange S, 2006, "Integrating 3D visualisation in landscape design and environmental planning" GAIA: Ecological Perspectives for Science and Society 15 195-199
18. Lewis J L, Sheppard S R J, 2006, "Culture and communication: can landscape visualization improve forest management consultation with indigenous communities?" Landscape and Urban Planning 77 291-313
19. Linton J D, Walsh S T, Morabito J, 2002, "Analysis, ranking and selection of R&D projects in a portfolio" R&DManagement 32 139-148
20. Lovett A, Carvalho Ribeiro S, Van Berkel D, Verburg P, Firmino A, 2010, "Representing and communicating rural futures through 3D landscape visualizations-experiences from the RUFUS project", in Peer Reviewed Proceedings of Digital Landscape Architecture 2010 at Anhalt University of Applied Sciences Eds E Buhmann, MPietsch, E Kretzler (Wichmann, Berlin) pp 261-268
21. MacFarlane R, Stagg H, Turner K, Lievesley M, 2005, "Peering through the smoke? Tensions in landscape visualisation" Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 29 341-359
22. Mayring P, 2003, "Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse", inQualitative Forschung: Ein Handbuch Eds U Flick, E von Kardoff, I Steinke (Rowohlt, Reinbeck bein Hamburg) pp 468-475
23. Nicholson-Cole S A, 2005, "Representing climate change futures: a critique on the use of images for visual communication" Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 29 255-273
24. Orland B, Budthimedhee K, Uusitalo J, 2001, "Considering virtual worlds as representations of landscape realities and as tools for landscape planning" Landscape and Urban Planning 54 139-148
25. Salter J, Sheppard S R J, Cavens D, Meitner M, 2005, "Planning, communicating, designing and decision making for large scale landscapes", in Visualization in Landscape and Environmental Planning. Technology and Applications Eds I Bishop, E Lange (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 120-124
26. Salter J D, Campbell C, Journeay M, Sheppard S R J, 2009, "The digital workshop: exploring the use of interactive and immersive visualisation tools in participatory planning" Journal of Environmental Management 90 2090-2101
27. Schmid A, 2004 UNESCO Biosphäre Entlebuch: Modell für eine nachhaltige Regionalentwicklung? Konzept Zielerreichungskontrolle (Biosphärenmanagement UNESCO Biosphäre Entlebuch, Schüpfheim, Switzerland)
28. Scholles F, 2001, "Die Nutzwertanalyse und ihre Weiterentwicklung", in Handbuch Theorien + Methoden der Raum-und Umweltplanung Eds D Fürst, F Scholles (Dortmunder Vertrieb für Bau-und Planungsliteratur, Dortmund) pp 231-247
29. Schroth O, Wissen U, Schmid WA, 2006, "Developing new images of rurality-interactive 3D visualizations for participative landscape planning workshops in the Entlebuch UNESCO Biosphere Reserve" dis P 166(3) 26-34
30. Schroth O, Wissen Hayek U, Lange E, Sheppard S, Schmid WA, 2011, "A multiple-case study of landscape visualizations as a tool in transdisciplinary planning workshops" Landscape Journal 30 53-71
31. Sheppard S R J, 2001, "Guidance for crystal ball gazers: developing a code of ethics for landscape visualization" Landscape and Urban Planning 54 183-199
32. Sheppard S R J, 2005, "Validity, reliability and ethics in visualization", inVisualization in Landscape and Environmental Planning. Technology and Applications Eds I Bishop, E Lange (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 79-97
33. Sheppard S R J, Cizek P, 2009, "The ethics of Google Earth: crossing thresholds from spatial data to landscape visualisation" Journal of Environmental Management 90 2102-2117
34. Strauss A L, 1998 Grundlagen qualitativer Sozialforschung: Datenanalyse und Theoriebildung in der empirischen und soziologischen Forschung (Wilhelm Fink Verlag, Munich)
35. Stroebe W, Nijstad B A, Rietzschel E F, 2010, "Beyond productivity loss in brainstorming groups: the evolution of a question"Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 43 157-203
36. Tseng I, Moss J, Cagan J, Kotovsky K, 2008, "The role of timing and analogical similarity in the stimulation of idea generation in design" Design Studies 29 203-221
37. Vollmuth H J, 2008 Controlling Instrumente von A-Z (Haufe, Freiburg)
38. Wergles N, Muhar A, 2009, "The role of computer visualization in the communication of urban design-a comparison of viewer responses to visualizations versus on-site visits" Landscape and Urban Planning 91 171-182
39. Williams K J H, Ford R M, Bishop I D, Loiterton D, Hickey J, 2007, "Realism and selectivity in data-driven visualisations: a process for developing viewer-oriented landscape surrogates" Landscape and Urban Planning 81 213-224
40. Wissen U, 2009 Virtuelle Landschaften zur partizipativen Planung-Optimierung von 3D Landschaftsvisualisierungen zur Informationsvermittlung (vdf Verlag, Zürich)
41. Wissen U, Grêt-Regamey A, 2009, "Identifying the regional potential for renewable energy systems using ecosystem services and landscape visualizations", in Proceedings of the European IALE Conference 2009, European Landscapes in Transformation: Challenges for Landscape Ecology and Management available at http://www.irl.ethz.ch/plus/people/uwissen/IALE wissen gret-regamey.pdf
42. Wissen U, Lange E, Schmid WA, 2005, "User friendly design of indicators in 3D visualisations for public assessment of landscape functions and processes", in Proceedings of the Conference Our Shared Landscape 2005 Eds E Lange, D Miller (ETH, Zurich) pp 170-171
43. Wissen U, Schroth O, Lange E, Schmid WA, 2008, "Approaches to integrating indicators into 3D landscape visualisations and their benefits for participative planning situations" Journal of Environmental Management 89 184-196
44. Wissen Hayek U, Halatsch J, Kunze A, Schmitt G, Grêt-Regamey A, 2010, "Integrating natural resource indicators into procedural visualisation for sustainable urban green space design", in Peer Reviewed Proceedings of Digital Landscape Architecture 2010 at Anhalt University of Applied Sciences Eds E Buhmann, M Pietsch, E Kretzler (Wichmann, Berlin) pp 339-347