Panic in the ER: Maternal drug use, the right to bodily integrity, privacy, and informed consent

Politics and Policy

Volumn 39, Issue 5, 2011, Pages 679-714

  Wolff, Kristina B ^a  

^a Partnerships for Health ^*  (Canada)

Author keywords

Crack cocaine; Drug use; Fetal rights; Health care policy; Informed consent; Moral panic; Pregnancy; Privacy; Privacy rights; Reproductive rights

Indexed keywords

EID: 80054093009     PISSN: 15555623     EISSN: 17471346     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1747-1346.2011.00313.x     Document Type: Article

References (108)

1. Adams, Jacqueline. 1994. "Eye on America: Controversial Program in South Carolina Cracks Down on Pregnant Women Doing Cocaine." CBS Evening News. Broadcasted on March 10.
2. American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Substance Abuse. 1995. "Drug-Exposed Infants. Pediatrics 96: 364-367. Accessed on September 17, 2011. Available online at.
3. Associated Press. 1990. "Court Backs Women's Medical Rights." Los Angeles Times. Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
4. Associated Press. 1998. "Mother Fights Drug Law Imprisonment." The Post and Courier. February 23, B3.
5. Barol, Bill, Linda R. Prout, Karen Fitzgerald, Susan Katz, and Patricia King. 1986. "Cocaine Babies: Hooked at Birth." Newsweek (July 28). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
6. Begley, Sharon, and Mary Hager. 1997. "Hope for 'Snow Babies.'" Newsweek (September 27). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
7. Berger, Peter L., and Thomas Luckmann. 1966. The Social Construction of Reality. New York, NY: Anchor Books.
8. Best, Joel. 1989. Images of Issues: Typifying Contemporary Social Problems. New York, NY: Aldine De Gruyter.
9. Breitbart, Vicki, Wendy Chavkin, and Paul H. Wise. 1994. "The Accessibility of Drug Treatment for Pregnant Women: A Survey of Programs in Five Cities. American Journal of Public Health 84 (10): 1658-1661.
10. Bush-Baskette, Stephanie. 2000. "The War on Drugs and the Incarceration of Mothers. Journal of Drug Issues 30 (4): 919-928.
11. Chasnoff, Ira J. 1988. Drugs, Alcohol, Pregnancy and Parenting. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
12. Chasnoff, Ira J., Harvey J. Landress, and Mark E. Barrett. 1990. "The Prevalence of Illicit-Drug or Alcohol Use during Pregnancy and Discrepancies in Mandatory Reporting in Pinellas County, Florida. The New England Journal of Medicine 322 (17): 1202-1206.
13. Chavkin, Wendy. 1990. "Drug Addiction and Pregnancy: Policy Crossroads. American Journal of Public Health 80 (4): 483-487.
14. Chavkin, Wendy. 1991. "Mandatory Treatment for Pregnant Substance Abusers: Irrelevant and Dangerous. Politics and the Life Sciences 15 (1): 53-54.
15. Chavkin, Wendy. 2001. "Cocaine and Pregnancy-Time to Look at the Evidence. Journal of the American Medical Association 285 (12): 1626-1627.
16. Christensen, Patricia. 1992. "The Criminal Prosecution of Mothers of Drug-Exposed Neonates: A Case Study of a Policy Dilemma." Doctoral dissertation, Medical College of Georgia.
17. Churchville, Victoria. 1988. "D.C. Judge Jails Woman as Protection for Fetus." Washington Post. July 23, A1.
18. Condon, Charles. 1997. "Policy for Addicted Mothers May Become National Model. The State. December 8, A11.
19. Condon, Charles Molony. 1995. "Clinton's Cocaine Babies. Policy Review 72 (Spring): 12-15.
20. Decker, Twila. 1990. "Born on Drugs." The State. December 10, A1.
21. D'Emilio, John, and Estelle B. Freedman. 1997. Intimate Matters: A History of Sexuality in America. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
22. Douglas, Mary, and Aaron Wildavsky. 1982. Risk and Culture. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
23. Dube, Jonathan. 1997. "Case Raising Questions about Pregnant Drug Users." The Charlotte Observer. December 28, B1.
24. Farr, Kathryn Ann. 1995. "Fetal Abuse and the Criminalization of Behavior during Pregnancy. Crime and Delinquency 41 (2): 235-245.
25. Fiske, John. 1996. Media Matters: Race and Gender in U.S. Politics. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
26. Flavin, Jeanne. 2008. Our Bodies Our Crimes: The Policing of Women's Reproduction in America. New York, NY: New York University Press.
27. Frank, Deborah A., Marilyn Augustyn, Wanda Grant Knight, Tripler Pell, and Barry Zuckerman. 2001. "Growth, Development, and Behavior in Early Childhood Following Prenatal Cocaine Exposure: A Systematic Review. Journal of the American Medical Association 285 (12): 1613-1625.
28. Garcia, Sandra Anderson. 1993. "Maternal Drug Abuse: Laws and Ethnics as Agents of Just Balances and Therapeutic Interventions. The International Journal of the Addictions 28 (13): 1311-1339.
29. Golden, Janet. 2005. Message in a Bottle: The Making of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
30. Gomez, Laura E. 1997. Misconceiving Mothers: Legislators, Prosecutors, and the Politics of Prenatal Drug Exposure. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
31. Government Accounting Office. 1994. Medicaid Prenatal Care: States Improve Access and Enhance Services, but Face Challenges. Washington, DC: Government Accounting Office.
32. Gross, Jane. 1985. "A New, Purified Form of Cocaine Causes Alarm as Abuse Increases." New York Times (November 29). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
33. Gustavsson, Nora S., and Ann E. MacEachron. 1997. "Criminalizing Women's Behavior. Journal of Drug Issues 27 (3): 673-687.
34. Harvard Law Review. 1988. "Maternal Rights and Fetal Wrongs: The Case against the Criminalization of 'Fetal Abuse.'" Harvard Law Review 101 (5): 994-1012.
35. Hoffman, Jan. 1990. "Pregnant, Addicted-and Guilty?" New York Times (August 19). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
36. Horger, Edgar O. III, Shirley B. Brown, and Charles Molony Condon. 1990. "Cocaine in Pregnancy: Confronting the Problem. The Journal of the South Carolina Medical Association 86 (10): 527-531.
37. Humphries, Drew. 1999. Crack Mothers: Pregnancy, Drugs, and the Media. Columbus: OH: Ohio State University Press.
38. Humphries, Drew, John Dawson, Valerie Cronin, Phylis Keating, Chris Wisniewski, and Jeannine Eichfeld. 1992. "Mothers and Children, Drugs and Crack: Reactions to Maternal Drug Dependency." In The Criminalization of a Woman's Body, edited by Drew Humphries. New York, NY: Haworth Press, Inc. 81-99.
39. Inciardi, James A., Dorothy Lockwood, and Anne E. Pottieger. 1993. Women and Crack-Cocaine. New York, NY: MacMillan Publishing Company.
40. Jenkins, Nate. 2010. "New Laws in Nebraska Add Restrictions on Abortions." CNSNews. Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
41. Jos, Philip H., Mary Faith Marshall, and Martin Perlmutter. 1995. "The Charleston Policy on Cocaine Use during Pregnancy: A Cautionary Tale. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 23 (2): 120-128.
42. Kandall, Stephen R., and Wendy Chavkin. 1992. "Substance Use During Pregnancy: Legal and Social Responses: Illicit Drugs in America: History, Impact on Women and Infants, and Treatment Strategies for Women. The Hastings Law Journal 43 (March): 615-643.
43. Kantrowitz, Barbara, Pat Wingert, Nonny De La Pena, Jeanne Gordon, and Tim Padgett. 1990. "The Crack Children." Newsweek (February 12). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
44. Kerr, Peter. 1987. "Crack Addiction: The Tragic Toll on Women and Their Children." New York Times (February 9). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
45. Koren, Gideon, and Naomi Klein. 1991. "Bias against Negative Studies in Newspaper Reports of Medical Research. Journal of the American Medical Association 266 (13): 1824-1826.
46. Krauthamer, Charles. 1989. "Children of Cocaine." Washington Post. July 30, C7.
47. Kroft, Steve. 1994. "Cracking Down." CBS 60 Minutes. Broadcast on November 20.
48. Lacayo, Richard, and Barbara Cornell. 1990. "Do the Unborn Have Rights?" Time (November 8). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
49. Langone, John, Shelagh Donoghue, and Dennis Wyss. 1988. "Crack Comes to the Nursery." Time (September 19). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
50. Lehigh, Scot. 1996. "Common Sense, or a New Way to Ban Abortion?" Boston Globe (September 15). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
51. Lewin, Tamar. 1997. "Abuse Laws Cover Fetus, a High Court Rules." New York Times (October 30). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
52. Litt, Jacquelyn, and Maureen McNeil. 1997. "Biological Markers and Social Differentiation: Crack Babies and the Construction of the Dangerous Mother. Health Care for Women International 18 (1): 31-41.
53. Logli, Paul A. 1990. "Drugs in the Womb: The Newest Battlefield in the War on Drugs. Criminal Justice Ethics 9 (1): 23-29.
54. Logli, Paul A. 1992. "The Prosecutor's Role in Solving the Problems of Prenatal Drug Use and Substance Abused Children. The Hastings Law Journal 43 (2): 559-567.
55. Lupton, Deborah. 2009. "Risk as Moral Danger: The Social and Political Functions of Risk Discourse in Public Health." In The Sociology of Health and Illness, edited by Peter Conrad. New York, NY: Worth Publishers. 460-467.
56. Maschke, Karen J. 1995. "Prosecutors as Crime Creators: The Case of Prenatal Drug Use. Criminal Justice Review 20 (1): 21-33.
57. Mason, Carol. 2000. "Cracked Babies and the Partial Birth of a Nation: Millennialism and Fetal Citizenship. Culture Studies 14 (1): 35-60.
58. McFadden, Cynthia. 2000. "Nightline, How Far Can You Go to Protect an Unborn Child?" ABC. Broadcasted on September 27.
59. Miami Herald. 2011. "Scott Signs Abortions Bills into Law." CBS Miami. Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
60. Nalty, Dennis F., William M. Sappenfeld, Brenda J. Colley, Harold D. Gabek, Mary Pease, and Edward Williams. 1991. "South Carolina Prevalence Study of Drug Use among Women Giving Birth." South Carolina Council on Maternal, Infant and Child Health. Columbia, SC: South Carolina Office of the Governor.
61. NARAL Pro-Choice America. 2011. "Abortion." Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
62. National Advocates for Pregnant Women. 2006. "South Carolina: Leading the Nation in the Prosecution and Punishment of Pregnant Women." Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
63. Netter, Sarah. 2010. "Utah Abortion Bill: Punishing Miscarriages of Preventing Crime?" ABC News. Accessed on July 14. Available online at.
64. Neuspiel, Daniel R. 1996. "Racism and Perinatal Addiction. Ethnicity & Disease 6 (1-2): 47-55.
65. Oberman, Michelle. 1992. "Substance Abuse during Pregnancy: Legal and Social Responses: Sex, Drugs, Pregnancy and the Law: Rethinking the Problems of Pregnant Women Who Use Drugs. The Hastings Law Journal 43 (March): 505-548.
66. Office of National Drug Control Policy. 1988. Anti-Drug Abuse Act of 1988. Washington, DC: U.S. Congress.
67. Ortiz, Ana T., and Laura Briggs. 2003. "The Culture of Poverty, Crack Babies, and Welfare Cheats: The Making of the 'Healthy White Baby Crisis.'" Social Text 76 (21): 39-57.
68. Paltrow, Lynn M. 1990. "When Becoming Pregnant Is a Crime. Criminal Justice Ethics 9 (1): 41-47.
69. Paltrow, Lynn M. 1992. "Criminal Prosecutions against Pregnant Women." National Advocates for Pregnant Women. Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
70. Paltrow, Lynn M. 1998. "Punishing Women for Their Behavior during Pregnancy: An Approach that Undermines the Health of Women and Children." In Drug Addiction Research and the Health of Women, edited by Cora Lee Wetherington and Adele B. Roman. Rockville, MD: National Institutes of Health. 467-501.
71. Paltrow, Lynn M. 1999. "Pregnant Drug Users, Fetal Persons, and the Threat to Roe v. Wade. Albany Law Review 62 (3): 999-1148.
72. Paltrow, Lynn M., David S. Cohen, and Corinne A. Carey. 2000. "Year 2000 Overview: Governmental Responses to Pregnant Women Who Use Alcohol or Other Drugs." National Advocates for Pregnant Women. Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
73. Paltrow and Plaintiffs. 2001. "Conversations with the Author." Charleston, SC. March.
74. Planned Parenthood. 2011. "Abortion." Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
75. Pooser, Claire. 1990. "Report Blasts Jailing Mothers on Drugs." The Post and Courier. February 11, B1.
76. Reeves, Jimmie L., and Richard Campbell. 1994. Cracked Coverage: Television News, the Anti-Cocaine Crusade, and the Reagan Legacy. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
77. Reinarman, Craig, and Harry G. Levine. 1997a. "Crack in Context: America's Latest Demon Drug." In Crack in America: Demon Drugs and Social Justice, edited by Craig Reinarman and Harry G. Levine. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. 1-17.
78. Reinarman, Craig, and Harry G. Levine. 1997b. "Punitive Prohibition in America." In Crack in America: Demon Drugs and Social Justice, edited by Craig Reinarman and Harry G. Levine. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. 321-323.
79. Richardson, Gale A., Nancy L. Day, and Peggy J. McGaugey. 1993. "The Impact of Prenatal Marijuana and Cocaine Use on the Infant and Child. Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology 36 (2): 302-318.
80. Roberts, Dorothy. 1997. Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction, and the Meaning of Liberty. New York, NY: Pantheon Books.
81. Sheppard, Kate. 2011. "South Dakota Moves to Legalize Killing Abortion Providers." Mother Jones. Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
82. Siegel, Barry. 1994. "In the Name of the Children: Get Treatment or Go to Jail, One South Carolina Hospital Tells Drug-Abusing Pregnant Women. Now It Faces a Lawsuit and a Civil-Rights Investigation." Los Angeles Times (August 7). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
83. Siegel, Loren. 1997. "The Pregnancy Policy Fight the War on Drugs." In Crack in America: Demon Drugs and Social Justice, edited by Craig Reinarman and Harry G. Levine. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. 249-359.
84. Smith, Lynn. 1998. "Crack Moms Get Paid to Undergo Sterilization." The Toronto Star. May 14. Accessed February 21, 2001. Available at.
85. South Carolina Budget and Control Board. 1980-2000. Accessed on May 19, 2003. Available online at.
86. South Carolina Budget and Control Board. 1986. "State Rankings" and "Employment" in 1986 South Carolina Statistical Abstracts, 16-17, 141, 310.
87. South Carolina Budget and Control Board. 1991. "Vital Statistics" in 1991 South Carolina Statistical Abstracts, 344, 347.
88. South Carolina Budget and Control Board. 1996. "Vital Statistics" in 1996 South Carolina Statistical Abstracts, 383-384, 388.
89. Sundby, Alex. 2011. "South Dakota Justifiable Homicide Bill Under Fire as Critics Say it Invites Murder of Abortion Doctors." CBS News Political Hotsheet. Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
90. Trafford, Abigail. 1998. "Should Women Who Use Drugs While Pregnant Be Locked Up?" Washington Post. August 18, 6.
91. U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics. 1992. Drugs, Crime and the Justice System. Technical Report No. NCJ-133652. Washington DC: U.S. Bureau of Justice.
92. U.S. House. 1980. "The Use of Drugs during Pregnancy." Select Committee on Narcotics Abuse and Control, 96 Cong. 16 (1980).
93. U.S. House. 1989. "Born Hooked: Confronting the Impace of Perinatal Substance Abuse." Select Committee on Children, Youth and Familise, 101 Cong. 43 (1989).
94. U.S. House. 1990. "Falling through the Crack: The Impact of Drug-Exposed Children on the Child Welfare System." Committee on Labor and Human Relations, 101 Cong. 846 (1990).
95. U.S. House. 1991. "An Examination of Barriers to Pre and Postnatal Care for High-Risk Women and Infants." Select Committee on Hunger, 101 Cong. 102 (1991).
96. U.S. House. 1998. Subcommittee on National Security, Internal Affairs, and Criminal Justice, Committee on Government Reform and Oversight, 105 Cong. 327 (1998).
97. st session. Congressional Record 112, no. 15 (17 February): E289, H1163-H1167.
98. U.S. Public Law 99-570. 1986. 99th Congress. 2d session. 27 October, 1986. Anti-Drug Abuse Act of 1986.
99. U.S. Senate. 1989. "Born Hooked: Confronting the Impact of Perinatal Substance Abuse." Select Committee on Children, Youth and Families. Washington, DC: United States Congress.
100. U.S. Senate. 1990. "Beyond the Stereotypes: Women, Addiction, and Perinatal Substance Abuse." Select Committee on Children, Youth and Families. Washington, DC: United States Congress.
101. Vargas, Theresa. 2010. "Once Written Off, 'Crack Babies' Have Grown into Success Stories." Washington Post (April 18). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
102. Walsh, Edward. 1996. "In Case against Alcoholic Mother, Underlying Issue Is Fetal Rights." Washington Post. October 7, A4.
103. Washington, Harriet A. 2006. Medical Apartheid: The Dark History of Medical Experimentation on Black Americans from Colonial Times to the Present. New York, NY: Doubleday.
104. Washington Times. 1995. "Woman Chooses Sterilization Over Jail." Washington Times. February 12, A2.
105. Wetherell, Margaret, and Jonathan Potter. 1992. Mapping the Language of Racism: Discourse and the Legitimation of Exploitation. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
106. Willwerth, James, Mary Cronin, and Christine Gorman. 1991. "Should We Take Away Their Kids?" Time (May 13). Accessed on July 14, 2011. Available online at.
107. Zola, Irving K. 2009. "Medicine as an Institution of Social Control." In The Sociology of Health and Illness, edited by Peter Conrad. New York, NY: Worth Publishers. 470-480.
108. Zuckerman, Barry, and Deborah A. Frank. 1992. "'Crack Kids': Not Broken. Pediatrics 89 (2): 337-339.