A case of conflicting norms? mobilizing and accountability information in newspaper coverage of the autism-vaccine controversy

Public Understanding of Science

Volumn 20, Issue 5, 2011, Pages 609-626

  Clarke, Christopher E ^a  

^a Department of Obstetrics Gynecology   (United States)

Author keywords

communication; ethics; media; norms; risk; vaccination

Indexed keywords

VACCINE;

ARTICLE; ATTITUDE TO HEALTH; AUTISM; CHEMICALLY INDUCED DISORDER; DECISION MAKING; ETHICS; HUMAN; INFORMATION DISSEMINATION; INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION; METHODOLOGY; PUBLIC HEALTH; PUBLICATION; RISK ASSESSMENT; SOCIAL BEHAVIOR;

AUTISTIC DISORDER; COMMUNICATION; DECISION MAKING; HEALTH KNOWLEDGE, ATTITUDES, PRACTICE; HUMANS; INFORMATION DISSEMINATION; NEWSPAPERS; PUBLIC HEALTH; RISK ASSESSMENT; SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY; VACCINES;

EID: 80051987636     PISSN: 09636625     EISSN: 13616609     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0963662509359490     Document Type: Article

References (75)

1. Advertising Information from Guardian News and Media (2008) "Circulation and Readership," URL (consulted 15 May 2009): www.adinfo-guardian.co.uk/the-guardian/guardian-circulation-and-readership.shtml.
2. Anderson P.Another Media Scare about MMR Vaccine Hits Britain.British Medical Journal.1999;318:1578.
3. Baker J.P.Mercury, Vaccines and Autism: One Controversy, Three Histories.American Journal of Public Health.2008;98 (2): 2-11.
4. Ball L.K.,Evans G.,Bostrom A.Risky Business: Challenges in Vaccine Risk Communication.Pediatrics.1998;101 (3): 453-8.
5. Bandura A.Health Promotion by Social Cognitive Means.Health Education & Behavior.2004;31 (2): 143-64.
6. Barnes M.D.,Hanson C.L.,Novilla L.M.B.,Meacham A.T.,McIntyre E.,Erickson B.C.Analysis of Media Agenda Setting during and after Hurricane Katrina: Implications for Emergency Preparedness, Disaster Response, and Disaster Policy.American Journal of Public Health.2008;98 (4): 604-9.
7. Barnett S.Will a Crisis in Journalism Provoke a Crisis in Democracy?.The Political Quarterly.2002;73 (4): 400-8.
8. Bennett W.L.An Introduction to Journalism Norms and Representations in Politics.Political Communication.1996;13:373-84.
9. Bennett W.L.,Lawrence R.G.,Livingston S.None Dare Call it Torture: Indexing and the Limits of Press Independence in the Abu Ghraib Scandal.Journal of Communication.2006;56 (3): 467-85.
10. Blume S.Anti-vaccination Movements and their Interpretations.Social Science & Medicine.2006;62:625-42.
11. Boseley S.£3m Advert Drive to Promote MMR Jabs: Medical Establishment Seeks to Restore Faith in Vaccine.The Guardian.2001;:1.
12. Boykoff M.T.,Boykoff J.M.Balances as Bias: Global Warming and the U.S.Prestige Press.Global Environmental Change.2004;14:125-36.
13. BrookS.(2007) "Sales of All Quality Dailies Down," The Guardian11May.URL (consulted 20 May 2008): www.guardian.co.uk/media/2007/may/11/abcs.pressandpublishing.
14. BurrellesLuce (2007) "Top 100 U.S.Daily Newspapers," URL (consulted 20 May 2008): www.burrellesluce.com/top100/2007_Top_100List.pdf.
15. Notice to Readers.Thimerosal in Vaccines: A Joint Statement of the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Public Health Service.Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report.1999;48 (26): 563-5.
16. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2009) "Thimerosal in Seasonal Influenza Vaccine," URL (consulted 20 May 2008): www.cdc.gov/flu/about/qa/thimerosal.htm.
17. Cho J.,Shah D.V.,McLeod J.M.,McLeod D.M.,Scholl R.M.,Gotlieb M.R.Campaigns, Reflection, and Deliberation: Advancing an O-S-R-O-R Model of Communication Effects.Communication Theory.2009;19 (1): 66-88.
18. Clarke C.A Question of Balance: The Autism-Vaccine Controversy in the British and American Elite Press.Science Communication.2008;30 (1): 77-107.
19. Davies P.,Chapman S.,Leask J.Antivaccination Activists on the World Wide Web.Archives of Disease in Childhood.2002;87:22-5.
20. DeSilva M.,Muskavitch M.A.,Roche J.P.Print Media Coverage of Antibiotic Resistance.Science Communication.2004;26 (1): 31-43.
21. Donohue G.A.,Olien C.N.,Tichenor P.J.Reporting Conflict by Pluralism, Newspaper Type and Ownership.Journalism Quarterly.1985;62 (3): 489-507.
22. Donohue G.A.,Tichenor P.J.,Olien C.N.A Guard Dog Perspective on the Role of the Media.Journal of Communication.1995;45 (2): 115-32.
23. Dudo A.D.,Dahlstrom M.F.,Brossard D.Reporting a Potential Pandemic: A Risk-related Assessment of Avian Influenza Coverage in U.S.Newspapers.Science Communication.2007;28 (4): 429-54.
24. Dunwoody S.,Rossow M.Monographs in Environmental Education and Environmental Studies.Grunig L.A., ed.Troy, Oh: North American Association for Environmental Education; 1989:5-21.
25. Food and Drug Administration (2009) "Thimerosal in vaccines," URL (consulted 20 May 2008): www.fda.gov/Cber/vaccine/thimerosal.htm.
26. Francois G.,Duclos P.,Margolis H.,Lavanchy D.,Siegrist C.,Meheus A., et al.Vaccine Safety Controversies and the Future of Vaccination Programs.Pediatric Infectious Diseases.2005;24:953-61.
27. Griffin R.J.,Dunwoody S.,Gehrmann C.The Effects of Community Pluralism on Press Coverage of Health Risks from Local Environmental Contamination.Risk Analysis.1995;15 (4): 449-58.
28. Griffin R.J.,Dunwoody S.,Zabala F.Public Reliance on Risk Communication Channels in the Wake of a Cryptosporidium Outbreak.Risk Analysis.1998;18 (4): 367-75.
29. Griffin R.J.,Yang Z.,ter Huurne E.,Boerner F.,Ortiz S.,Dunwoody S.After the Flood: Anger, Attribution, and the Seeking of Information.Science Communication.2008;29 (3): 285-315.
30. HargreavesI.LewisJ.SpeersT.(2003) Towards a Better Map: Science, the Public and the Media.URL (consulted 20 May 2008): www.esrcsocietytoday.ac.uk/ESRCInfoCentre/Images/Mapdocfinal_tcm6-5505.pdf.
31. Haug C.J.Human Papillomavirus Vaccination: Reasons for Caution.New England Journal of Medicine.2008;359:861-2.
32. Horton R.The Lessons of MMR.Lancet.2004;363 (9411): 747-9.
33. Institute for Vaccine Safety (2009) "Thimerosal Content in Some U.S.Licensed Vaccines," URL (consulted 20 May 2008): www.vaccinesafety.edu/thi-table.htm.
34. Immunization Safety Review: Vaccines and Autism.Washington, DC: The National Academies Press; 2004:.
35. Isaacson W.How to Save Your Newspaper.Time.2008;173 (6): 30-3.
36. "Jabs Link to Autism 'Dispelled'" (2006) BBC News5July.URL (consulted 20 May 2008): news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/5149670.stm.
37. Leask J.,Chapman S.'The Cold Hard Facts': Immunization and Vaccine-preventable Diseases in Australia's Newsprint Media, 1993-1998.Social Science & Medicine.2002;54:445-57.
38. Lemert J.B.News Contexts and the Elimination of Mobilizing Information: An Experiment.Journalism Quarterly.1984;61 (2): 243-9.
39. Lemert J.B.,Ashman M.G.Extent of Mobilizing Information in Opinion and News Magazines.Journalism Quarterly.1983;60 (4): 657-62.
40. Lemert J.B.,Mitzman B.N.,Seither M.A.,Cook R.H.,Hackett R.Journalists and Mobilizing Information.Journalism Quarterly.1977;54 (4): 721-6.
41. Lewis J.,Speers T.Misleading Media Reporting? The MMR Story.Nature Reviews: Immunology.2003;3:913-18.
42. McComas K.A.Even the 'Best Laid' Plans Go Wrong: Strategic Risk Communication for New and Emerging Risks.EMBO Reports.2004;5:S61-S65.
43. McLeod J.M.,Scheufele D.A.,Moy P.Community, Communication, and Participation: The Role of Mass Media and Interpersonal Discussion in Local Political Participation.Political Communication.1999;16:315-36.
44. McManus J.Serving the Public and Serving the Market: A Conflict of Interest?.Journal of Mass Media Ethics.1992;7 (4): 196-208.
45. McManus J.A Market-based Model of News Production.Communication Theory.1995;5 (4): 301-38.
46. Mason B.W.,Donnelly P.D.Impact of a Local Newspaper Campaign on the Uptake of the Measles Mumps and Rubella Vaccine.Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health.2000;54:473-4.
47. Mondo Newspapers (2009) "Readership of the Top 100 U.S.Newspapers," URL (consulted 16 January 2009): www.mondonewspapers.com/usa/readership.html.
48. Moriarty C.M.,Stryker J.E.Prevention and Screening Efficacy Messages in Newspaper Accounts of Cancer.Health Education Research.2008;23 (3): 487-98.
49. Murch S.H.,Anthony A.,Casson D.H.,Malik M.,Berelowitz M.,Dhillon A.P.,Thomson M.A.,Valentine A.,Davies S.E.,Walker-Smith J.A.Retraction of an Interpretation.Lancet.2004;363 (9411): 750.
50. National Health Service (2008) "Immunization Information," URL (consulted 12 June 2009): www.immunisation.nhs.uk/Vaccines/MMR/The_vaccine/Single_vs_triple_vaccine.
51. Nicodemus D.M.Mobilizing Information: Local News and the Formation of a Viable Political Community.Political Communication.2004;21:161-76.
52. Nield L.S.Anti-vaccine Media: Its Impact - and Strategies to Combat It.Consultant for Pediatricians.2008;7 (9): 1-2.
53. Offit P.A.Thimerosal and Vaccines: A Cautionary Tale.New England Journal of Medicine.2007;357 (13): 1278-9.
54. Offit P.A.Autism's False Prophets: Bad Science, Risky Medicine, and the Search for a Cure.New York: Columbia University Press; 2008:.
55. Offit P.A.,Coffin S.E.Communicating Science to the Public: MMR Vaccine and Autism.Vaccine.2006;22:1-6.
56. ParkM.(2009) "Autism Ruling Fails to Convince Many Vaccine-link Believers," URL (consulted 18 February 2009): www.cnn.com/2009/HEALTH/02/12/court.autism.reactions/index.html.
57. Parker S.K.,Schwartz B.,Todd J.,Pickering L.K.Thimerosal-containing Vaccines and Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Critical Review of Published Original Data.Pediatrics.2004;114:793-804.
58. Petts J.,Niemeyer S.Health Risk Communication and Amplification: Learning from the MMR Vaccination Controversy.Health, Risk & Society.2004;6 (1): 7-23.
59. Pew Research Center for the People & the Press (2006) "Online Papers Modestly Boost Newspaper Readership," URL (consulted 15 May 2009): people-press.org/report/282/online-papers-modestly-boost-newspaper-readership.
60. Poland G.A.,Jacobsen R.M.Understanding Those Who Do Not Understand: A Brief Review of the Anti-vaccine Movement.Vaccine.2001;19:2440-5.
61. Prue C.E.,Lackey C.,Swenarski L.,Gantt J.M.Communication Monitoring: Shaping CDC's Emergency Risk Communication Efforts.Journal of Health Communication.2003;8 (3): 35-49.
62. Roche J.P.,Muskavitch M.A.Limited Precision in Print Media Communication of West Nile Virus Risks.Science Communication.2003;24 (3): 353-65.
63. Rossow M.D.,Dunwoody S.Inclusion of 'Useful' Details in Newspaper Coverage of a High-level Nuclear Waste Siting Controversy.Journalism Quarterly.1991;68:87-100.
64. Ryan M.Journalistic Ethics, Objectivity, Existential Journalism, Standpoint Epistemology, and Public Journalism.Journal of News Media Ethics.2001;16 (1): 3-22.
65. Scheufele D.A.,Shah D.V.Personality Strength and Social Capital: The Role of Dispositional and Informational Variables in the Production of Civic Participation.Communication Research.2000;27 (2): 107-31.
66. SeymourJ.A.(2008) "About Face: Media Outlets Turn on 'Cancer Vaccine' Maker," URL (consulted 15 May 2009): www.businessandmedia.org/articles/2008/20080827143336.aspx.
67. Shah D.V.Civic Engagement, Interpersonal Trust, and Television Use: An Individual-level Assessment of Social Capital.Political Psychology.1998;19 (3): 469-96.
68. Siebert F.S.,Peterson T.,Schramm W.Four Theories of the Press.Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press; 1963:.
69. Smith M.J.,Ellenberg S.S.,Bell L.M.,Rubin D.M.Media Coverage of the Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccine and Autism Controversy and its Relationship to MMR Immunization Rates in the United States.Pediatrics.2008;121:e836-e843.
70. Stephens L.F.News Narrative about Nano S&T in Major U.S.and Non-U.S.Newspapers.Science Communication.2005;27 (2): 175-99.
71. Telegraph Media Solutions (2009) "Key Facts," URL (consulted 15 May 2009): advertising.telegraph.co.uk/static/KeyFacts.aspx.
72. Valenti J.M.Ethical Decision Making in Environmental Communication.Journal of Mass Media Ethics.1998;13 (4): 219-13.
73. Vasterman P.,Yzermans C.J.,Dirkzwager A.J.E.The Role of the Media and Media Hypes in the Aftermath of Disasters.Epidemiological Reviews.2005;27:107-14.
74. Wakefield A.J.,Murch S.H.,Anthony A.,Linnell J.,Casson D.M.,Malik M.,Berelowitz M.,Dhillon A.P.,Thomson M.A.,Harvey P.,Valentine A.,Davies S.E.,Walker-Smith J.A.Ileal-Lymphoid-Nodular Hyperplasia, Non-specific Colitis, and Pervasive Developmental Disorder in Children.Lancet.1998;351 (9103): 637-41.
75. World Health Organization (2009) "Benefits of Immunization," URL (consulted 12 June 2009): www.who.int/entity/immunization_delivery/benefits_of_immunization/en/index.html.