Does hospital competition save lives? Evidence from the English NHS patient choice reforms

Economic Journal

Volumn 121, Issue 554, 2011, Pages

  Cooper, Zack ^a   Gibbons, Stephen ^a   Jones, Simon ^a   Mcguire, Alistair ^a  

^a LONDON SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

COMPETITION (ECONOMICS); HEALTH SERVICES; HOSPITAL SECTOR; MORTALITY; WELFARE REFORM;

EID: 79960617752     PISSN: 00130133     EISSN: 14680297     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-0297.2011.02449.x     Document Type: Article

References (56)

1. Allen, F. (1984). 'Reputation and product quality', Rand Journal of Economics, vol. 15(3), pp. 311-27.
2. Bloom, N., Propper, C., Seiler, S. and Van Reenan, J. (2010). 'The impact of competition on management quality: evidence from public hospitals', CEP Working Paper - February 14th. London School of Economics.
3. Bradley, E.H., Herrin, J., Elbel, B., McNamara, R.L., Magid, D.J., Nallamothu, B.K., Wang, Y., Normand, S.L., Spertus, J.A. and Krumholz, H.M. (2006). 'Hospital quality for acute myocardial infarction: correlation among process measures and relationship with short-term mortality', JAMA, vol. 296(1), pp. 72-8.
4. Card, D. (1992). 'Using regional variation in wages to measure the effects of the federal minimum wage', Industrial and Labor Relations Review, vol. 46(1), pp. 22-37.
5. Charlson, M., Pompei, P., Ales, K. and MacKenzie, C. (1978). 'A new method of classifying prognostic comorbidity in longitudinal studies: development and validation', Journal of Chronic Disease, vol. 40(5), pp. 373-83.
6. Committee on Second Hand Smoke Exposure and Acute Coronary Events (2009). Second Hand Smoke Exposure and Cardiovascular Effects, Washington, DC: Institute of Medicine.
7. Communities and Local Government Department (2009). 'Indices of Deprivation 2004', available at (last accessed: 31 October 2009).
8. Cooper, Z.N., Gibbons, S., Jones, S. and McGuire, A. (2010a). Does Hospital Competition Improve Efficiency? An Analysis of the Recent Market-based Reforms to the English NHS, London: Centre for Economic Performance.
9. Cooper, Z.N., Gibbons, S., Jones, S. and McGuire, A. (2010b). Does Hospital Competition Save Lives? Evidence From the NHS Patient Choice Reforms, London: London School of Economics.
10. Davies, P., Geppert, J.J., McClellan, M., McDonald, K., Romano, P. and Shojania, K. (2001). Refinement of the HCUP Quality Indicators. Technical Review Number 4 (Prepared by UCSF-Stanford Evidence-based Practice Center under Contract No. 290-97-0013), Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.
11. Department of Health (2002). Delivering the NHS Plan - Next Steps on Investment, Next Steps on Reform, London: Department of Health.
12. Department of Health (2003). Building on the Best - Choice, Responsiveness and Equity in the NHS, London: Department of Health.
13. Department of Health (2004). 'The NHS improvement plan: putting people at the heart of public services', available at (last acessed: 31 October 2009).
14. Department of Health (2005). 'A short guide to NHS foundation trusts', available at (last acessed: 31 October 2009).
15. Department of Health (2009a). 'Department of Health payment by results webpage', available at (last accessed: 31 October 2009).
16. Department of Health (2009b). 'NHS choice time line', available at (last accessed: 31 October 2009).
17. Department of Health (2009c). 'NHS choose and book website', available at (last accessed: 31 October 2009).
18. Dixon, A., Robertson, R. and Bal, R. (2010). 'The experience of implementing choice at point of referral: a comparison of the Netherlands and England', Health Economics, Policy and Law, vol. 5(Special issue 3), pp. 295-317.
19. Dranove, D. and Satterthwaite, M. (1992). 'Monopolistic competition when price and quality are not perfectly observable', Rand Journal of Economics, vol. 23(4), pp. 247-62.
20. Dranove, D. and Satterthwaite, M. (2000). 'The industrial organization of health care markets', in (A. Culyer and J.P. Newhouse, eds.), The Handbook of Health Economics, pp. 1093-139, Amsterdam: Elsevier.
21. Gaynor, M. (2004). 'Competition and quality in hospital markets. What do we know? What don't we know? Economie Publique, vol. 15(2), pp. 3-40.
22. Gaynor, M. (2006). 'Competition and quality in health care markets', Foundations and Trends in Microeconomics, vol. 2(6), pp. 441-508.
23. Gaynor, M. and Haas-Wilson, D. (1999). 'Change, consolidation and competition in health care markets', Journal of Economic Perspectives, vol. 13(1), pp. 141-64.
24. Gaynor, M., Moreno-Serra, R. and Propper, C. (2010). Death by Market Power: Reform, Competition and Patient Outcomes in the National Health Services, Bristol: Bristol University.
25. Gowrisankaran, G. and Town, R.J. (2003). 'Competition, payers, and hospital quality', Health Services Research, vol. 38(6 p 1), pp. 1403-22.
26. Guimaraes, P., Figueirdo, O. and Woodward, D. (2003). 'A tractable approach to the firm location decision problem', Review of Economics and Statistics, vol. 85(1), pp. 201-4.
27. Hamilton, B.H. and Ho, V. (2000). 'Hospital mergers and acquisitions: does market consolidation harm patients?', Journal of Health Economics, vol. 19(8), pp. 767-91.
28. Jha, A., Orav, E., Li, Z. and Epstein, A. (2007). 'The inverse relationship between mortality rates and performance in the hospital quality alliance measures', Health Affairs, vol. 26(4), pp. 1104-10.
29. Kessler, D.P. and Geppert, J.J. (2005). 'The effects of competition on variation in the quality and cost of medical care', Journal of Economics and Management Strategy, vol. 14(3), pp. 575-89.
30. Kessler, D.P. and McClellan, M.B. (2000). 'Is hospital competition socially wasteful?', The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 115(2), pp. 577-615.
31. Klein, R. (1999). 'Markets, politicians and the NHS', British Medical Journal, vol. 319(7222), pp. 1383-4.
32. Klein, R. (2006). The New Politics of the NHS: From Creation to Reinvention, 5th ed. Oxford, Seattle: Radcliffe.
33. Klein, B. and Leffler, K. (1981). 'The role of market forces in assuring contractual performance', Journal of Political Economy, vol. 89(4), pp. 615-41.
34. Le Grand, J. (1999). 'Competition, cooperation, or control? Tales from the British National Health Service', Health Affairs, vol. 18(3), pp. 27-39.
35. Le Grand, J., Mays, N. and Mulligan, J.-A. (1998). Learning from the NHS Internal Market, London: King's Fund.
36. McClellan, M. and Staiger, D. (1999). 'The quality of health care providers', NBER Working Paper, No. 7327.
37. Meyers, D.G., Neuberger, J.S. and He, J. (2009). 'Cardiovascular effect of bans on smoking in public places: a systematic review and meta-analysis', Journal of the American College of Cardiology, vol. 54(14), pp. 1249-55.
38. OECD (2010). 'OECD health statistics for 2010', available at (last accessed: 14 January 2011).
39. Propper, C. (1996). 'Market structure and prices: the responses of hospitals in the UK national health service to competition', Journal of Public Economics, vol. 61, pp. 307-35.
40. Propper, C., Burgess, S. and Gossage, D. (2008). 'Competition and quality: evidence from the NHS internal market 1991-1996', Economic Journal, vol. 118(1), pp. 138-70.
41. Propper, C., Burgess, S. and Green, K. (2004). 'Does competition between hospitals improve the quality of care? Hospital death rates and the NHS internal market', Journal of Public Economics, vol. 88(7-8), pp. 1247-72.
42. Propper, C. and van Reenen, J. (2010). 'Can pay regulation kill? Panel data evidence on the effect of labor markets on hospital performance', Journal of Political Economy, vol. 118(2), pp. 222-73.
43. Propper, C., Wilson, D. and Burgess, S. (2006). 'Extending choice in English health care: the implications of the economic evidence', Journal of Social Policy, vol. 35(4), pp. 537-57.
44. Propper, C., Wilson, D. and Soderlund, N. (1998). 'The effects of regulation and competition in the NHS internal market: the case of GP fundholder prices', Journal of Health Economics, vol. 17(6), pp. 645-74.
45. Romano, P. and Mutter, R. (2004). 'The evolving science of quality measurement for hospitals: Implications for studies of competition and consolidation', International Journal of Health Care Finance and Economics, vol. 4(2), pp. 131-57.
46. Sage, W.M., Hyman, D.A. and Greenberg, W. (2003). 'Why competition law matters to health care quality', Health Affairs (Millwood), vol. 22(2), pp. 31-44.
47. Sari, N. (2002). 'Do competition and managed care improve quality?', Health Economics, vol. 11(7), pp. 571-84.
48. Schroeder, S.A. (2009). 'Public smoking bans are good for the heart', Journal of the American College of Cardiology, vol. 54(14), pp. 1256-57.
49. Shapiro, C. (1983). 'Premiums for high quality products as returns on reputation', Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 98(4), pp. 659-80.
50. Shen, Y.C. (2003). 'The effect of financial pressure on the quality of care in hospitals', Journal of Health Economics, vol. 22(2), pp. 243-69.
51. Soderlund, N., Csaba, I., Gray, A., Milne, R. and Raftery, J. (1997). 'Impact of the NHS reforms on English hospital productivity: an analysis of the first three years', British Medical Journal, vol. 315(7116), pp. 1126-9.
52. Street, A. and Maynard, A. (2007). 'Activity based financing in England: the need for continual refinement of payment by results', Health Econ Policy Law, vol. 2(Pt 4), pp. 419-27.
53. Vogt, W.B. and Town, R.J. (2006). How Has Hospital Consolidation Affected the Price and Quality of Hospital Care, Princeton, NJ: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
54. Volpp, K.G., Williams, S.V., Waldfogel, J., Silber, J.H., Schwartz, J.S. and Pauly, M.V. (2003). 'Market reform in New Jersey and the effect on mortality from acute myocardial infarction', Health Services Research, vol. 38(2), pp. 515-33.
55. Walker, L., Birkhead, J., Weston, C., Quinn, T., de Belder, M. and van Leeven, R. (2009). Myocardial Ischemia National Audit Project (MINAP). How the NHS manages heart attacks, London: MINAP.
56. World Health Organization (2009). 'International Classification of Diseases 10 Code Framework', available at (last accessed: 1 November 2009).