Critical appraisal on the identification of Reference Conditions for the evaluation of ecological quality status along the Emilia-Romagna coast (Italy) using M-AMBI

Marine Pollution Bulletin

Volumn 62, Issue 8, 2011, Pages 1725-1735

  Paganelli, Daniele ^a   Forni, Giulia ^a   Marchini, Agnese ^a   Mazziotti, Cristina ^b   Occhipinti Ambrogi, Anna ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF PAVIA   (Italy)

^b Regione Emilia Romagna   (Italy)

Author keywords

Adriatic Sea; Ecological quality status; European Water Directive; Marine benthos

Indexed keywords

ADRIATIC SEA; BENTHIC INDICES; DATA SETS; ECOLOGICAL KNOWLEDGE; ECOLOGICAL QUALITY; ECOLOGICAL STATUS; ENVIRONMENTAL DISTURBANCES; EUROPEAN WATER DIRECTIVE; EUROPEAN WATER FRAMEWORK DIRECTIVE; MARINE BENTHOS; MARINE ENVIRONMENT; OBSERVATION DATA; REFERENCE CONDITION; SPATIAL GRADIENTS; STATISTICAL APPROACH; WATERBODIES;

WATER CONSERVATION;

ECOLOGY;

BENTHOS; DATA SET; ENVIRONMENTAL DISTURBANCE; MARINE ECOSYSTEM; MARINE POLICY; STATISTICAL ANALYSIS; WATER QUALITY;

ALGAL BLOOM; ARTICLE; CONTROLLED STUDY; ECOLOGY; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; ESTUARY; HUMAN IMPACT (ENVIRONMENT); ITALY; MACROBENTHOS; MARINE BIOTIC INDEX; MUCILAGE; NUTRIENT LOADING; POPULATION DENSITY; RIVER ECOSYSTEM; SEASHORE; SEASONAL VARIATION; SPECIES DIVERSITY; SPECIES RICHNESS; STATISTICAL ANALYSIS; TROPHIC LEVEL; VALIDITY; WATER FLOW; WATER POLLUTANT; WATER STANDARD;

ANIMALS; BIODIVERSITY; ECOSYSTEM; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; EVALUATION STUDIES AS TOPIC; ITALY; MARINE BIOLOGY; OCEANS AND SEAS; WATER POLLUTANTS;

ADRIATIC SEA; EMILIA-ROMAGNA; ITALY; MEDITERRANEAN SEA;

EMILIA;

EID: 79960412112     PISSN: 0025326X     EISSN: 18793363     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.marpolbul.2011.05.027     Document Type: Article

References (90)

1. Albayrak S., Balkis H., Zenetos A., Kurun A., Kubanç C. Ecological quality status of coastal benthic ecosystems in the Sea of Marmara. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2006, 52:790-799.
2. Albertelli G., Bedulli D., Cattaneo-Vietti R., Chiantore M., Giacobbe S., Jerace S., Leopardi M., Priano F., Schiapparelli S., Spanò N. Trophic features of benthic communities in the Northern Adriatic Sea. Biol. Mar. Medit. 1998, 5(1):136-143.
3. Ambrogi R. Influenza degli apporti fluviali sulle biocenosi bentoniche costiere. Nova Thalassia 1989, 10(1):221-236.
4. Ambrogi R., Bedulli D., Occhipinti-Ambrogi A. Variazioni nella ripartizione tra gruppi trofici di organismi di fondo mobile nell'area marina del delta del padano. Oebalia 1989, 15(1):47-55.
5. Ambrogi R., Bedulli D., Zurlini G. Spatial and temporal patterns in structure of macrobenthic assemblages. A three-year study in the Northern Adriatic Sea in front of the Po river delta. Mar. Ecol. 1990, 11:25-41.
6. Andersen J.H., Conley D.C., Hedal S. Palaeoecology, reference conditions and classification of ecological status: the EU Water Framework Directive in practice. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2004, 49:283-290.
7. ARPA Emilia-Romagna, 2009. Annuario regionale dei dati ambientali 2009. Available at: (accessed May 9th 2011). http://www.arpa.emr.it/pubblicazioni/generale/notizie_1789.asp.
8. Artioli Y., Bendoricchio G., Palmeri L. Defining and modelling the coastal zone affected by the Po river (Italy). Ecol. Model. 2005, 184:55-68.
9. Bakalem A., Ruellet T., Dauvin J.C. Benthic indices and ecological quality of shallow Algeria fine sand community. Ecol. Indicators 2009, 9:395-408.
10. Bigot L., Gremare A., Amouroux J.M., Frouin P., Maire O., Gaertner J.C. Assessment of the ecological quality status of soft-bottoms in Reunion Island (tropical Southwest Indian Ocean) using AZTI marine biotic indices. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2008, 56:704-722.
11. Borja Á. The European Water Framework Directive: a challenge for nearshore, coastal and continental shelf research. Cont. Shelf Res. 2005, 25:1768-1783.
12. Borja Á., Tunberg B.G. Assessing benthic health in stressed subtropical estuaries, eastern Florida, USA; using AMBI and M-AMBI. Ecol. Ind. 2011, 11:295-303.
13. Borja Á., Franco J., Pèrez V. A marine biotic index to establish the ecological quality of soft-bottom benthos within European estuarine and coastal environments. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2000, 40:1100-1114.
14. Borja Á., Muxika I., Franco J. The application of a Marine Biotic Index to different impact sources affecting soft-bottom benthic communities along European coasts. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2003, 46:835-845.
15. Borja Á., Josefson A.B., Miles A., Muxika I., Olsgard F., Phillips G., Rodríguez J.G., Rygg B. An approach to the intercalibration of benthic ecological status assessment in the north Atlantic ecoregion, according to the European Water Framework Directive. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2007, 55:42-52.
16. Borja Á., Mader J., Muxika I., Rodríguez J.G., Bald J. Using M-AMBI in assessing benthic quality within the Water Framework Directive: Some remarks and recommendations. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2008, 56:1377-1379.
17. Borja Á., Dauer D.M., Díaz R., Llansó R.J., Rodríguez J.G., Schaffner L. Assessing estuarine benthic quality conditions in Chesapeake Bay: a comparison of three indices. Ecol. Indicators 2008, 8:395-403.
18. Borja Á., Miles A., Occhipinti-Ambrogi A., Berg T. Current status of macroinvertebrate methods used for assessing the quality of European marine waters: implementing the Water Framework Directive. Hydrobiologia 2009, 633:181-196.
19. Borja Á., Muxika I., Rodriguez J.G. Paradigmatic responses of marine benthic communities to different anthropogenic pressures, using M-AMBI, within the European Water Framework Directive. Mar. Ecol. 2009, 30:214-227.
20. Borja Á., Bald J., Franco J., Larreta J., Muxika I., Revilla M., Rodrìguez J.G., Solaun O., Uriarte A., Valencia V. Using multiple ecosystem components, in assessing ecological status in Spanish (Basque Country) Atlantic marine waters. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2009, 59:54-64.
21. Borja Á., Barbone E., Basset A., Borgersen G., Brkljacic M., Elliott M., Garmendia J.M., Marques J.C., Mazik K., Muxica I., Neto J.M., Norling K., Rodríguez J.G., Rosati I., Rygg B., Teixeira H., Trayanova A. Response of single benthic metrics and multi-metric methods to anthropogenic pressure gradients, in five distinct European coastal and transitional ecosystems. Mar. Poll. Bull. 2011, 62:499-513.
22. Bouchet V.M.P., Sauriau P.G. Influence of oyster culture practices and environmental conditions on the ecological status of intertidal mudflats in the Pertuis Charentais (SW France): a multi-index approach. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2008, 56:1898-1912.
23. Brondi, A., Cicero, A.M., Magaletti, E., Giovanardi, F., Scarpato, A., Silvestri, C., Spada, E., Casazza, G., 2003. Italian Coastal Typology for the European Water Framework Directive. In: Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on the Mediterranean Coastal environment. MEDCOAST E 03, E. Özhan 7-11 October 2003, Ravenna. Vol II, 1179-1188.
24. Costa-Dias S., Sousa R., Antunes C. Ecological quality assessment of the lower Lima estuary. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2010, 6:234-239.
25. Cozzi, S., Cantoni, C., Precali, R., Degobbis, D., Catalano, G., Supic, N., 2005. Relationship among hypoxia, mucilage events and circulation in the Northern Adriatic Sea. Geophysical Res. Abstracts 7, EGU05-A-08829.
26. Dauvin J.C., Ruellet T. The estuarine quality paradox: is it possible to define an ecological quality status for specific modified and naturally stressed estuarine ecosystems?. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2009, 59:38-47.
27. Dauvin J.C., Ruellet T., Desroy N., Janson A.-L. The ecological quality status of the Bay of Seine and the Seine estuary: use of biotic indices. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2007, 55:241-257.
28. Dauvin J.C., Bellan G., Bellan-Santini D. Benthic indicators: from subjectivity to objectivity - Where is the line?. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2010, 60:947-953.
29. de Bello F., Lavorel S., Díaz S., Harrington R., Cornelissen J.H.C., Bardgett R.D., Berg M.P., Cipriotti P., Feld C.K., Hering D., Martins da Silva P., Potts S.G., Sandin L., Sousa J.P., Storkey J., Wardle D.A., Harrison P.A. Towards an assessment of multiple ecosystem processes and services via functional traits. Biodivers. Conserv. 2010, 19:2873-2893.
30. De Paz L., Patrício J., Marques J.C., Borja A., Laborda A.J. Ecological status assessment in the lower Eo estuary (Spain). The challenge of habitat heterogeneity integration: a benthic perspective. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2008, 56:1275-1283.
31. Degobbis D., Precali R., Ivancic I., Smodlaka N., Fuks D., Kveder S. Long-term changes in the northern Adriatic ecosystem related to anthropogenic eutrophication. Int. J. Environ. Pollut. 2000, 13:495-533.
32. Diaz R.J., Solan M., Valente R.V. A review of approaches for classifying benthic habitats and evaluating habitat quality. J. Environ. Manage. 2003, 73:165-181.
33. Elliott M., Quintino V. The Estuarine Quality Paradox, Environmental Homeostasis and the difficulty of detecting anthropogenic stress in naturally stressed areas. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2007, 54:640-645.
34. Emilia-Romagna A.R.P.A. Eutrofizzazione delle acque costiere dell'Emilia-Romagna, Rapporto annuale 2006, Arpa Struttura Oceanografica Daphne. Pubbl. Assessorato Agricoltura, Ambiente e Sviluppo Sostenibile, Bologna.
35. European Commission, 2000. Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 October 2000 Establishing a Framework for Community Action in the Field of Water Policy. Official Journal of the European Union L 327, 1-72.
36. European Commission, 2008. Directive 2008/56/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 June 2008 Establishing a Framework for Community Action in the Field of Marine Environmental Policy. Official Journal of the European Union L 164, 19-40.
37. Forchino A., Borja Á., Brambilla F., Rodríguez J.G., Muxica I., Terova G., Saroglia M. Evaluating the influence of off-shore cage aquaculture on the benthic ecosystem in Alghero Bay (Sardinia, Italy) using AMBI and M-AMBI. Ecol. Ind. 2011, 11:1112-1122.
38. Forni G., Occhipinti-Ambrogi A. Daphne: a new multimetric benthic index for the quality assessment of marine coastal environment in the Northern Adriatic Sea. Chem. Ecol. 2007, 23:427-442.
39. Grall J., Chauvaud L. Marine eutrophication and benthos: the need for new approaches and concepts. Glob. Chang. Biol. 2002, 8:813-830.
40. Grall J., Glémarec M. Using biotic indices to estimate macrobenthic community perturbations in the Bay of Brest. Est. Coast. Shelf Sci. 1997, 44(Suppl. A):43-53.
41. Grimes S., Ruellet T., Dauvin J.-C., Boutiba Z. Ecological Quality Status of the soft-bottom communities on the algerian coast: general patterns and diagnosis. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2010, 60:1969-1977.
42. Josefson A.B., Hansen J.L.S., Asmund G., Johansen P. Threshold response of benthic macrofauna integrity to metal contamination in West Greenland. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2008, 56:1265-1274.
43. Justic D., Rabalais N.N., Turner R.E., Dortch Q. Changes in nutrient structure of river-dominated coastal waters: stoichiometric nutrient balance and its consequence. Estuar. Coastal Shelf Sci. 1995, 40:263-280.
44. Kröncke I., Reiss H. Influence of macrofauna long-term natural variability on benthic indices used in ecological quality assessment. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2010, 60:58-68.
45. Labrune C., Amouroux J.M., Sarda R., Dutrieux E., Thorin S., Rosenberg R., Grémare A. Characterization of the ecological quality of the coastal Gulf of Lions (NW Mediterranean). A comparative approach based on three biotic indices. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2006, 52:34-47.
46. Marchetti R. The problems of the Emilia-Romagna coastal waters: facts and interpretations. Marine coastal eutrophication 1992, 21-33. Elsevier, Amsterdam. R.A. Vollenweider, R. Marchetti, R. Viviani (Eds.).
47. Marchini A. Fuzzy indices of ecological conditions: review of techniques and applications. Fuzzy Logic: Theory 2009, 115-172. Programming and Applications. Novascience Publishers, New York. R.E. Vargas (Ed.).
48. Marchini A., Munari C., Mistri M. Functions and ecological status of eight Italian lagoons examined using Biological Traits Analysis (BTA). Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2008, 56:1076-1085.
49. Marin-Guirao L., Cesar A., Marin A., Lloret J., Ruben V. Establishing the ecological quality status of soft-bottom mining-impacted coastal water bodies in the scope of the Water Framework Directive Establishing the ecological quality status of soft-bottom mining-impacted coastal water bodies in the scope of the Water Framework Directive. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2005, 50:374-387.
50. Martinez-Crego B., Alcoverro T., Romero J. Biotic indices for assessing the status of coastal waters: a review of strengths and weaknesses. J. Environ. Monit. 2010, 12:1013-1028.
51. Mazziotti C., Ferrari C.R., Montanari G., Benzi M., Silvestri C., Rinaldi A. Tendenza evolutiva del fenomeno eutrofico nelle acque costiere emiliano-romagnole: 1982-2004. Biol. Mar. Medit. 2006, 13(1):105-113.
52. Mingazzini M., Thake B. Summery and conclusions of the workshop on marine mucilages in the Adriatic Sea and elsewhere. Sci. Total Environ. 1995, 165:9-14.
53. Montanari G., Pinardi N., 2006. The currents of Emilia-Romagna coastal strip during the period 1995-2002. I Quaderni di Arpa 160 pp.
54. Montanari G., Rinaldi A. Eutrofizzazione delle acque costiere in Emilia-Romagna: tendenze evolutive dei processi atossici. Biol. Mar. Medit. 2008, 15(1):42-45.
55. Munari C., Mistri M. Towards the application of the Water Framework Directive in Italy: Assessing the potential of benthic tools in Adriatic coastal transitional ecosystems. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2010, 60:1040-1050.
56. Munari C., Tessari U., Rossi R., Mistri R. The ecological status of Karavasta Lagoon (Albania): Closing the stable door before the horse has bolted?. Mar. Environ. Res. 2010, 69:10-17.
57. Muniz P., Venturini N., Pires-Vanin A.M.S., Tommasi L.R., Borja Á. Testing the applicability of a Marine Biotic Index (AMBI) to assessing the ecological quality of soft-bottom benthic communities, in the South America Atlantic region. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2005, 50:624-637.
58. Muxika I., Borja Á., Bonne W. The suitability of the marine biotic index (AMBI) to new impact sources along European coasts. Ecol. Indic. 2005, 5:19-31.
59. Muxika I., Borja Á., Bald J. Using historical data, expert judgement and multivariate analysis in assessing Reference Conditions and benthic ecological status, according to the European Water Framework Directive. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2007, 55:16-29.
60. N'Siala G.M., Grandi V., Iotti M., Montanari G., Prevedelli D., Simonini R. Responses of the Northern Adriatic Ampelisca-Corbula community to seasonality and short-term hydrological changes in the Po river. Mar. Environ. Res. 2008, 66:466-476.
61. Occhipinti-Ambrogi A., Forni G., Silvestri C., Argyrou M., Jordana E., Mavrič B., Pinedo S., Simboura N., Urbanič G. The Mediterranean intercalibration exercise on soft-bottom benthic invertebrates with special emphasis on the Italian situation. Mar. Ecol. 2009, 30:495-504.
62. PA U.S.E. Rapid Bioassessment Protocols for Use in Wadeable Streams and Rivers, EPA 841-B-99-002, U.S 1999, EPA, Washington, DC.
63. Pearson T.H., Rosenberg R. Macrobenthic succession in relation to organic enrichment and pollution of the marine environment. Oceanogr. Mar. Biol. 1978, 16:229-311.
64. Pirrone N., Trombino G., Cinnirella S., Algieri A., Bendoricchio G., Palmeri L. The Driver-Pressure-State-Impact-Response (DPSIR) approach for integrated catchment-coastal zone management: preliminary application to the Po catchment-Adriatic Sea coastal zone system. Reg. Environ. Change 2005, 5:111-137.
65. Pischedda L., Poggiale J.C., Cuny P., Gilbert F. Imagine oxygen distribution in marine sediments. The importance of bioturbation and sediment heterogeneity. Acta Biotheor. 2008, 56:123-135.
66. Ponti M., Pinna M., Basset A., Moncheva S., Trayanova A., Georgescu L.P., Beqiraj S., Orfanidis S., Abbiati M. Quality assessment of Mediterranean and Black Sea transitional waters: comparing responses of benthic biotic indices. Aquatic Conserv.: Mar. Freshw. Ecosyst. 2008, 18:62-75.
67. Prato S., Morgana J.G., La Valle P., Finoia M.G., Lattanzi L., Nicoletti L., Ardizzone G.D., Izzo G. Application of biotic and taxonomic distinctness indices in assessing the Ecological Quality Status of two coastal lakes: Caprolace and Fogliano lakes (Central Italy). Ecol. Indic. 2009, 9:568-583.
68. Puente A., Diaz R.J. Is it possible to assess the ecological status of highly stressed natural estuarine environments using macroinvertebrates indices?. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2008, 56:1880-1889.
69. REFCOND, 2003. Guidance on establishing Reference Conditions and ecological status class boundaries for inland surface waters. Produced by Working Group 2.31 Reference Conditions for inland surface (REFCOND), Common Implementation Strategy of the Water Framework Directive, European Commission, 86pp.
70. Rinaldi A., Vollenweider R.A., Montanari G., Ferrari C.R., Ghetti A. Mucilages in Italian seas: the Adriatic and Tyrrhenian seas. Sci. Total Environ. 1995, 165:165-183.
71. Rosenberg R., Blomqvist M., Nilsson H.C., Cederwall H., Dimming A. Marine quality assessment by use of benthic species-abundance distributions: a proposed new protocol within the European Union Water Framework Directive. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2004, 49:728-739.
72. Ruellet T., Dauvin J.C. Benthic indicators: analysis of the threshold values of ecological quality classifications for transitional waters. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2007, 54:1707-1714.
73. Ruellet T., Dauvin J.C. Comments on Muxika et al. (2007). "Using historical data, expert judgement and multivariate analysis in assessing Reference Conditions and benthic ecological status, according to the european Water Framework Directive" Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2007, 56:1234-1235.
74. Salvetti R., Azzellino A., Vismara R. Diffuse source apportionment of the Po river eutrophying load to the Adriatic Sea: assessment of Lombardy contribution to Po river nutrient load apportionment by means of an integrated modelling approach. Chemosphere 2006, 65:2168-2177.
75. Shelford V.E. Animal communities in temperate America. Bulletin no.5 of The Geographic Society of Chicago 1913, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL, pp. 362.
76. Simboura, N., 2004. Bentix index vs. biotic index in monitoring: an answer to Borja et al., 2003. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 48, 404-405.
77. Simboura N., Argyrou M. An insight into the performance of benthic classification indices tested in Eastern Mediterranean coastal waters. Mar. Pollut. Bull 2010, 60:701-709.
78. Simboura N., Reizopoulou S. An intercalibration of classification metrics of benthic macroinvertebrates in coastal and transitional ecosystems of the Eastern Mediterranean ecoregion (Greece). Mar. Pollut. Bull 2008, 56:116-126.
79. Simboura N., Zenetos A. Benthic indicators to use in Ecological Quality classification of Mediterranean soft bottom marine ecosystem, including a new biotic index. Medit. Mar. Sci. 2002, 3(2):77-111.
80. Simonini R., Grandi V., N'Siala G.M., Iotti M., Montanari G., Prevedelli D. Assessing the ecological status of the North-western Adriatic Sea within the European Water Framework Directive: a comparison of Bentix, AMBI and M-AMBI methods. Mar. Ecol. 2009, 30:241-254.
81. Spillman C.M., Imberger J., Hamilton D.P., Hipsey M.R., Romero J.R. Modelling the effects of Po River discharge, internal nutrient cycling and hydrodynamics on biogeochemistry of the Northern Adriatic Sea. J. Mar. Syst. 2007, 68:167-200.
82. Struglia M.V., Mariotti A., Filograsso A. River discharge in the Mediterranean Sea: climatology and aspects of the observed variability. J. Climate 2004, 17:4740-4751.
83. Tataranni M., Lardicci C. Performance of some biotic indices in the real variable world: a case study at different spatial scales in North-Western Mediterranean Sea. Environ. Pollut. 2010, 158:26-34.
84. Teixeira H., Borja Á., Weisberg S.B., Ananda Ranasinghe J., Cadien D.B., Dauer D.M., Dauvin J.-C., Degraer S., Diaz R.J., Grémare A., Karakassis I., Llansó R.J., Lovell L.L., Marques J.C., Montagne D.E., Occhipinti-Ambrogi A., Rosenberg R., Sardá R., Schaffner L.C., Velarde R.G. Assessing coastal benthic macrofauna community condition using best professional judgement - Developing consensus across North America and Europe. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2010, 60:589-600.
85. Tomassetti P., Persia E., Mercatali I., Vani D., Marusso V., Porello S. Effects of mariculture on macrobenthic assemblages in a western Mediterranean site. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2009, 58:533-541.
86. Trombino G., Pirrone N., Cinnirella S. A Business-As-Usual scenario analysis for the Po basin-North Adriatic continuum. Water Resour. Manage. 2007, 21:2063-2074.
87. Tueros I., Borja Á., Larreta J., Germán Rodríguez J., Valencia V., Millán E. Integrating long-term water and sediment pollution data, in assessing chemical status within the European Water Framework Directive. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2009, 58:1389-1400.
88. Vollenweider R.A., Rinaldi A., Montanari G. Eutrophication, structure and dynamics of marine coastal system: results of ten years monitoring along the Emilia-Romagna coast (Northwest Adriatic Sea). Marine coastal eutrophication 1992, 63-106. Elsevier, Amsterdam. R.A. Vollenweider, R. Marchetti, R. Viviani (Eds.).
89. Vollenweider R.A., Giovanardi F., Montanari G., Rinaldi A. Characterization of the trophic conditions of marine coastal waters with special reference to the NW Adriatic Sea: proposal for a trophic scale, turbidity and generalized water quality index. Environmetrics 1998, 9:329-357.
90. Zavattarelli M., Raicich F., Bregant D., Russo A., Artegiani A. Climatological biogeochemical characteristics of the Adriatic Sea. J. Marine Syst. 1998, 18:227-263.