The “objectivity” ideal and its limitations in 20th-century british journalism

Journalism Studies

Volumn 9, Issue 4, 2008, Pages 477-493

  Hampton, Mark ^a  

^a LINGNAN UNIVERSITY   (Hong Kong)

Author keywords

Anglo american media traditions; British journalism; Culture of journalism; Objectivity; Professional ideals

Indexed keywords

EID: 79960272101     PISSN: 1461670X     EISSN: 14699699     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/14616700802113060     Document Type: Article

References (65)

1. Aims of Industry 1974 Aims of Industry:evidence for the Royal Commission on the Press, London:Aims of Industry.
2. Astor, J.J., 1954 “The Chairman's Foreword”, in:The Press and the People. The First Annual Report of the General Council of the Press. Press Council, November.
3. Baldasty, Gerald. 1992. The Commercialization of News in the Nineteenth Century, Madison:University of Wisconsin Press.
4. Boyce, George. 1978. “The Fourth Estate:the reappraisal of a concept”. In Newspaper History from the Seventeenth Century to the Present Day, Edited by:Boyce, George, Curran, James, and Wingate, Pauline. 19–40. London:Constable.
5. Briggs, Asa, 1995a [1961] History of Broadcasting in the United Kingdom:Vol. I:The Birth of Broadcasting, Oxford:Oxford University Press.
6. Briggs, Asa, 1995b [1965] History of Broadcasting in the United Kingdom:Vol. II:The Golden Age of Wireless. Oxford:Oxford University Press.
7. British Broadcasting Corporation 1949 Policy Notes for Programme Staff, BBC Written Archives Centre A/ 3065.
8. British Broadcasting Corporation 1955a “News Broadcasting:preamble”, 14 April, BBC Written Archives Centre T16/119/5 TV Policy/ News in Vision, File 3a 1955–May 1957.
9. British Broadcasting Corporation 1955b “Notes on News”, 5 April, BBC Written Archives Centre T16/119/5 TV Policy/ News in Vision, File 3a 1955–May 1957.
10. Bromley, Michael, 2003 “Objectivity and the Other Orwell”, Media History 9, pp. 123–35.
11. Bulletin 1919 No. 7 (April). Reuters Archive LN431, Archive No. 1/ 865315.
12. Bulletin 1921a “Advice from the Chief Editor”, No. 11 (Feb.), pp. 3–4. Reuters Archive LN431, Archive No. 1/ 865315.
13. Bulletin 1921b No. 12 (June). Reuters Archive LN431, Archive No. 1/ 865315.
14. Chalaby, Jean. 1998. The Invention of Journalism, London:Macmillan.
15. Conboy, Martin. 2004. Journalism:a critical history, London:Sage.
16. Cowen, Sir Zelman, 1984 “Guiding Fairness:guarding freedom”, in:The Press and the People. The Thirty-First Annual Report of the General Council of the Press. Press Council.
17. Edgar, Andrew, 1992 “Objectivity, Bias and Truth”, in:Andrew, Belsey and Ruth, Chadwick Ethical Issues in Journalism and the Media, London and New York:Routledge, pp. 112–29.
18. Geary, James, 2006 “In Praise of the Tabs (Sort Of)”, British Journalism Review 17, pp. 41–4.
19. Getler, Michael, and Doyle, Leonard, 2004 “Brits vs. Yanks:who does journalism right?”, Columbia Journalism Review 43, pp. 44–9.
20. Hallin, Daniel C., and Mancini, Paolo, 2004 Comparing Media Systems:three models of media and politics, Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
21. Hamilton, James T., 2004 All the News That's Fit to Sell:how the market transforms information into news, Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
22. Hampton, Mark, 2004 Visions of the Press in Britain, 1850–1950, Urbana and Chicago:University of Illinois Press.
23. Jones, Roderick, 1917 Letter (copy) to the Right Honorable Sir Edward Carson, MP (confidential), 10 November. Reuters Archive LN948, Archive 1/013268.
24. Kaplan, Richard, 2002 Politics and the American Press:the rise of objectivity, 1865–1920, Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
25. King, Cecil, 1962 “Subtle Censorship Is Shackling Britain's Press”, in:Press and the People:The Ninth Annual Report of the General Council of the Press. Press Council, December.
26. L., F.F. 1922 “The Question of Guarantees”, The Graphic, 16 December, p. 908.
27. Martin, Kingsley, 1965 Letter to Harold Wilson, 8 May, Kingsley Martin Papers 14/ 5, University of Sussex.
28. McNair, Brian, 1998 The Sociology of Journalism, London:Arnold.
29. National Union of Journalists 1950 Rules of the National Union of Journalists, Supplement I, Code of Professional Conduct, NUJ Archive, MSS.086/4 Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick.
30. National Union of Journalists 1952a NEC Minutes, 23–24 May, p. 19 57. National Union of Journalists National Executive Council, Minutes XIX, April 1952–April 1953, NUJ Archive, MSS.86/1/NEC/26-27, Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick.
31. National Union of Journalists 1952b Administrative Committee, 27 June, p. 19 78, item 4099. National Union of Journalists National Executive Council, Minutes XIX, April 1952–April 1953, NUJ Archive, MSS.86/1/NEC/26-27, Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick.
32. National Union of Journalists 1953 NEC Minutes, 27–28 February, p. 19 271, item 4409, NUJ Archive MSS.86/1/NEC/26-27, Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick.
33. National Union of Journalists 1995 “Ethics”, in:Your Union at Work:report and accounts for 1995 plus the Union's who's who, National Union of Journalists Archive MSS.86/4/2, Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick.
34. National Union of Journalists 1970 NUJ Rule Book, Appendix A, Code of Professional Conduct. NUJ Archive MSS.86/4/4/1, Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick.
35. National Union of Journalists 1974–5 National Union of Journalists Annual Report, 1974–75, NUJ Archive, MSS.86/4/2, Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick.
36. National Union of Journalists 1977 ADM:report of the 70th Annual Delegate Meeting of the National Union of Journalists at The King's Hall, Ilkley, April 19th–22nd. NUJ Archive, MSS.86/4/3, Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick.
37. National Union of Journalists 1979 ADM:Report of the 72nd Annual Delegate Meeting of the National Union of Journalists at Dam Park Hall, Ayr, April 24th–27th. NUJ Archive, MSS.86/4/3, Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick.
38. National Union of Journalists 2007 “Code of Conduct”, http://media.gn.apc.org/nujcode.html, accessed 2 November 2007.
39. Neill, Patrick, 1979 “Pains and Penalties? … or Persuasion”, in:Press and the People:The Twenty-sixth Annual Report of the General Council of the Press. Press Council.
40. Nicholas, Siân, 1996 The Echo of War:home front propaganda and the wartime BBC, 1939–1945, Manchester:Manchester University Press.
41. O'Malley, Tom, 1994 Closedown? The BBC and Government broadcasting policy, 1979–92, London:Pluto.
42. O'Malley, Tom, 2000 “The History of Self-regulation”, in:Tom O'Malley and Clive Soley, Regulating the Press, London:Pluto.
43. Press Council 1954a The Press and the People. The First Annual Report of the General Council of the Press. Press Council, October.
44. Press Council 1954b “The Press Council. What It Is and What It Does”, in:The Press and the People. The First Annual Report of the General Council of the Press. Press Council, October.
45. Press Council 1955 The Press and the People. The Second Annual Report of the General Council of the Press. Press Council, December.
46. Press Council 1956 The Press and the People:The Third Annual Report of the General Council of the Press. Press Council, November.
47. Press Council 1958 The Press and the People:The Fifth Annual Report of the General Council of the Press. Press Council, November.
48. Read, Donald, 1999 The Power of News:the history of reuters, 2nd edn, Oxford:Oxford University Press.
49. Reuter 1955 “Instructions Issued to Journalists”. Reuters Archive LN73, Archive No. 1/8811101.
50. Reuter 1992 Reuters Handbook for Journalists, compiled by Ian Macdowall, Oxford:Butterworth-Heinemann. Reuters Archive LN 552, Archive 1/940105.
51. Reuter 2001 “Daily Briefing”. Reuters Archive LN 1026, Archive 1/014606.
52. Scannell, Paddy, and Cardiff, David, 1991 A Social History of British Broadcasting, Vol. One, 1922–1939:serving the nation, Oxford:Basil Blackwell.
53. Schiller, Dan, 1981 Objectivity and the News:the public and the rise of commercial journalism, Philadelphia:University of Pennsylvania Press.
54. Schudson, Michael, 1978 Discovering the News:a social history of American newspapers, New York:Basic Books.
55. Schudson, Michael, 2001 “The Emergence of the Objectivity Norm in American Journalism”, in:Michael, Hechter and Karl-Dieter, Opp Social Norms, New York:Russell Sage Foundation, pp. 165–85.
56. Scott, C.P., 1921 “A Hundred Years”, Manchester Guardian, 5 May.
57. Scott, C.P., 1924 Letter to Ramsay McDonald, 27 May, Manchester Guardian Archives 336/ 121, John Rylands Library, University of Manchester.
58. Smith, A.nthony. 1978. “The Long Road to Objectivity and Back Again:the kinds of truth we get in journalism”. In Newspaper History from the Seventeenth Century to the Present Day, Edited by:Boyce, G.eorge, Curran, J.ames, and Wingate, P.auline. 153–71. London:Constable.
59. Steed, Wickham, 1923 Letter to [illegible], British Library Add. Mss. 74120.ff/ 147–51.
60. The Spectator 1918 “A Northcliffe Ministry”, 120, pp. 76–7.
61. Thomas, James, 2005 Popular Newspapers, the Labour Party and British Politics, London and New York:Routledge.
62. Tuchman, Gaye, 1972 “Objectivity as Strategic Ritual:an examination of newsmen's notions of objectivity”, The American Journal of Sociology 77, pp. 660–79.
63. Tunstall, Jeremy, and Machin, David, 1999 The Anglo-American Media Connection, Oxford:Oxford University Press.
64. Ward, Stephen J.A., 2004. Invention of Journalism Ethics, Montreal and Kingston:McGill-Queen's University Press.
65. Wiener, Joel H., and Hampton, Mark. 2007. Anglo-American Media Interactions, 1850–2000, Basingstoke:Palgrave.