Embryo relinquishment for family building: How should it be conceptualised?

International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family

Volumn 25, Issue 2, 2011, Pages 260-285

  Blyth, Eric ^a   Frith, Lucy ^b   Paul, Marilyn S ^c   Berger, Roni ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF HUDDERSFIELD   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF LIVERPOOL   (United Kingdom)

^c ADELPHI UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 79959509305     PISSN: 13609939     EISSN: 14643707     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/lawfam/ebr003     Document Type: Review

References (85)

1. Bangsbøll, S., Pinborg, A., Yding Anderson, C. and Nyboe Andersen, A. (2004) Patients' attitudes towards donation of surplus cryopreserved embryos for treatment or research', Human Reproduction 19, 2415-19. (Pubitemid 39406710)
2. Beginnings Family Services. 'Embryo Donations Services' http://www.beginnings.ca/embryo-donation/our-services. (Accessed 2 December 2010)
3. Blyth, E. (2007) Conceptions of welfare' in K. Horsey and H. Biggs (eds), Human Fertilisation and Embryology: Reproducing Regulation, London: Routledge-Cavendish, 17-45.
4. Blyth, E., Crawshaw, M., Haase, J. and Speirs, J. (2001) The implications of adoption for donor offspring following donor-assisted conception', Child and Family Social Work 6, 295-304.
5. Blyth, E. and Frith, L. (2009) Donor-conceived people's access to genetic and biographical history: an analysis of provisions in different jurisdictions permitting disclosure of donor identity. International Journal of Law', Policy and the Family 23, 192-210.
6. Boada, M., Rodrigo, C., Veiga, A. and Barri, P. N. (2003) 'The future of frozen embryos: couples' points of view', Human Reproduction 18, xviii68-69.
7. Brzyski, R., Binkley, P., Pierce, J. and Eddy, C. (2000) 'Impact of implementation of an embryo storage fee on embryo disposal activity', Fertility and Sterility 74, 813-815.
8. Brzyski, R., Witz, C., Eddy, C., Pierce, J., Binkley, P. and Shenken, R. (2001) 'Association between donor gametes and choice of embryo donation for final disposition of cryopreserved embryos', Fertility and Sterility 76, S197-98.
9. Burton, P. and Sanders, K. (2004) 'Patient attitudes to donation of embryos for research in Western Australia', Medical Journal of Australia 180, 559-61. (Pubitemid 38868103)
10. Cattoli, M., Borini, A. and Bonu, M. (2004) 'Fate of stored embryos: our 10 years experience', European Journal of Obstetrics, Gynaecology and Reproductive Biology 1155, 516-18.
11. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (2009) Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Report: National Summary 2007, Atlanta, GA: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. http://www.cdc.gov/ART/ART2007/ index.htm (accessed 2 December 2010).
12. Centers for Disease Control and Protection (2010). National Summary Report. http://apps.nccd.cdc.gov/ART/NationalSummaryReport.aspx (accessed 2 December 2010).
13. Collard, C. and Kashmeri, S. (2009). De embriones congelados a siempre familias: Ética del parentesco y ética de la vida en la circulación de embriones entre las parejas donantes y las adoptantes en el programa Snowflakes" (From Frozen Embryos to Forever Families: Kinship Ethics and Life Ethics in the Circulation of Embryos amongst Placing and Adopting Couples in the Snowflakes" Program)', Revista de Antropologia Social 18, 43-65.
14. Cooper, S. (1996) 'The destiny of supernumerary embryos?', Fertility and Sterility 65, 205-6.
15. Crawshaw, M. (2002) 'Lessons from a recent adoption study to identify some of the service needs of, and issues for, donor offspring wanting to know about their donors', Human Fertility 5, 6-12. (Pubitemid 34240120)
16. Crawshaw, M., Blyth, E. and Daniels, K. (2007) 'Past semen donors' views about the use of a voluntary contact register', Reproductive BioMedicine Online 14, 411-17. (Pubitemid 46584374)
17. Crockin, S. (2005) How Do You 'Adopt' a Frozen Egg? The Boston Globe December 4. http://www.boston.com/news/globe/editorial-opinion/oped/articles/ 2005/12/04/how-do-you-adopt-a-frozen-egg/(accessed 2 December 2010).
18. Daniels, K., Blyth, E., Crawshaw, M. and Curson, R. (2005) 'Previous semen donors and their views regarding the sharing of information with offspring', Human Reproduction 20, 1670-5. (Pubitemid 40852265)
19. Darlington, N. and Matson, P. (1999) 'The fate of cryopreserved human embryos approaching their legal limit of storage within a Western Australian in-vitro fertilization clinic', Human Reproduction 14, 2343-4. (Pubitemid 29425426)
20. Dawson, K. (1997) 'The storage of human embryos', Human Reproduction 12, 6.
21. de Lacey, S. (2005) 'Parent identity and 'virtual' children: why patients discard rather than donate unused embryos', Human Reproduction 20, 1661-1669.
22. de Lacey, S. (2007a) 'Patients' attitudes to their embryos and their destiny: social conditioning?' Best Practice and Research: Clinical Obstetrics and Gynaecology 21, 101-02.
23. de Lacey, S. (2007b) 'Decisions for the fate of frozen embryos: fresh insights into patients' thinking and their rationales for donating or discarding embryos', Human Reproduction 22, 1751-1758.
24. Donor Sibling Registry (DSR) (2010). 'The Donor Sibling Registry: Educating, Connecting and Supporting Donor Families', http://www. donorsiblingregistry.com (accessed 2 December 2010).
25. Downing, B., Mohr, L., Trounson, A., Freeman, L. and Wood, C. (1985) 'Birth after transfer of cryopreserved embryos', Medical Journal of Australia 142, 409-11. (Pubitemid 15042868)
26. Elford, K., Lawrence, C. and Leader, A. (2004) 'Research implications of embryo cryopreservation choices made by patients undergoing in vitro fertilization', Fertility and Sterility 81, 1154-5. (Pubitemid 38452994)
27. Embryoadoption.org (2010)) Embryo Adoption Agencies. http://www. embryoadoption.org/adoption-agencies/embryo-adoption-services-matrix.cfm?CFID= 15118676&CFTOKEN=5559631aaf35c417-A6BF2847-2B3D-C3C9-49225495403E8139 (accessed 2 December 2010).
28. Ethics Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (2009). Defining embryo donation', Fertility and Sterility 92, 1818-19.
29. Federal Register (2002) 'Embryo adoption; public awareness campaigns', Federal Register 67, 48654-60. http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov/cgi-bin/getdoc. cgi?dbname=2002-register&docid=02-18826-filed.pdf (sccessed 2 December 2010).
30. Freundlich, M. (2002) 'Embryo adoption: are we ready for this new frontier?', Adoption Quarterly (editorial) 6, 1-5.
31. Fuscaldo, G., Russell, S. and Gillam, L. (2007) 'How to facilitate decisions about surplus embryos: patients' views', Human Reproduction 22, 3129-38. (Pubitemid 351696786)
32. Fuscaldo, G. and Savulescu, J. (2005) 'Spare embryos: 3000 reasons to rethink the significance of genetic relatedness', Reproductive Biomedicine Online 10, 164-8. (Pubitemid 40246628)
33. Glowka, W., Flemming, S., Fletcher, T., Gebel, B., Ledford, M., Lehto, L., Miller, G., Presley, S., Salter, M. and Barnhart, D. (2007) 'Among the new words', American Speech 82, 97-116.
34. Gurmankinn, A., Sisti, D. and Caplan, A. (2004) 'Embryo disposal practices in IVF clinics in the United States', Politics and Life Sciences 22, 2-6.
35. Hammarberg, K. and Tinney, L. (2006) 'Deciding the fate of supernumerary frozen embryos: a survey of couples' decisions and the factors influencing their choice', Fertility and Sterility 86, 86-91. (Pubitemid 43962944)
36. Hammond, K., Steinkampf, M. and Cataldo, N. (2009) 'Embryo donation in the USA: a 2008 practice survey of reproductive health professionals', Fertility and Sterility 92, S133.
37. Hoffman, D., Zellman, G., Fair, C., Mayer, J., Zeitz, J., Gibbons, W. and Turner, T. (2003) 'Cryopreserved embryos in the United States and their availability for research', Fertility and Sterility 79, 1063-9. (Pubitemid 36547839)
38. Hounshell, C. and Chetkowski, R. (1996) 'Donation of frozen embryos after in vitro fertilization is uncommon', Fertility and Sterility 66, 837-41.
39. Hurwitz, J., Lederman, M., Jindal, S., Lieman, H. and Santoro, N. (2005) 'Embryo donation (ED): an increasingly popular option in the United States', Fertility and Sterility 84, PS235-6.
40. Jain, T. and Missmer, S. (2008) 'Support for selling embryos among infertility patients', Fertility and Sterility 90, 564-8.
41. Jones, H. Jr., Cohen, J., Cooke, I., Kempers, R., Brinsden, P. and Saunders, D. (2010) 'IFFS Surveillance 2010' Fertility and Sterility, doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2010.08.011.
42. Kingsberg, S., Applegarth, L. and Janata, J. (2000) 'Embryo donation programs and policies in North America: survey results and implications for health and mental health professionals', Fertility and Sterility 73, 215-20. (Pubitemid 30060348)
43. Klipstein, S., Reindollar, R., Regan, M. and Alper, M. (2001)) 'Gender bias in the disposition of frozen embryos', Fertility and Sterility 76, 1181-4. (Pubitemid 33116383)
44. Klock, S., Sheinin, S. and Kazer, R. (2001) 'The disposition of unused frozen embryos', New England Journal of Medicine 345, 69-70.
45. Kovacs, G., Breheny, S. and Dear, M. (2003) 'Embryo donation at an Australian university in-vitro fertilisation clinic: issues and outcomes', Medical Journal of Australia 178, 127-9. (Pubitemid 36949506)
46. Lanzendorf, S., Ratts, V., Keller, S. and Odem, R. (2010) 'Disposition of cryopreserved embryos by infertility patients desiring to discontinue storage', Fertility and Sterility 93, 486-9.
47. Laruelle, C. and Englert, Y. (1995) 'Psychological study of in vitro fertilization -embryo transfer participants' attitudes toward the destiny of their supernumerary embryos', Fertility and Sterility 63, 1047-50.
48. Little, P., Everitt, H., Williamson, I., Warner, G., Moore, M., Gould, C., Ferrier, K. and Payne, S. (2001)) 'Preferences of patients for patient centred approach to consultation in primary care: observational study', British Medical Journal 322, 1-7.
49. Lornage, J., Chorier, H., Boulieu, D., Mathieu, C. and Czyba, J. (2005) 'Six years' follow-up of cryopreserved human embryos', Human Reproduction 10, 2610-16.
50. Lyerly, A., Steinhauser, K., Namey, E., Tulsky, J., Cook-Deegan, R., Sugarman, J., Walmer, D., Faden, R. and Wallach, E. (2006) 'Factors that affect infertility patients' decisions about disposition of frozen embryos', Fertility and Sterility 85, 1623-30. (Pubitemid 43816419)
51. Lyerly, A., Steinhauser, K., Voils, C., Namey, E., Alexander, C., Bankowski, B., Cook-Deegan, R., Dodson, W., Gates, E., Jungheim, E., McGovern, P., Myers, E., Osborn, B., Schlaff, W., Sugarman, J., Tulsky, J., Walmer, D., Faden, R. and Wallach, E. (2010) 'Fertility patients' views about frozen embryo disposition: results of a multi-institutional U.S. survey', Fertility and Sterility 93, 499-509.
52. MacCallum, F. (2009) 'Embryo donation parents' attitudes towards donors: Comparison with adoption', Human Reproduction 25, 517-23.
53. McMahon, C., Gibson, F., Cohen, J., Leslie, G., Tennant, C. and Saunders, D. (2000) 'Mothers conceiving through in vitro fertilization: siblings, setbacks & embryo dilemmas', Reproductive Technology 10, 131-5.
54. McMahon, C., Gibson, F., Leslie, G., Saunders, D., Porter, K. and Tennant, C. (2003) 'Embryo donation for medical research: attitudes and concerns of potential donors', Human Reproduction 18, 871-7. (Pubitemid 36426974)
55. McMahon, C. and Saunders, D. (2009) 'Attitudes of couples with stored frozen embryos toward conditional embryo donation', Fertility and Sterility 91, 140-7.
56. Mead, N. and Bower, P. (2002) 'Patient-centred consultations and outcomes in primary care: a review of the literature', Patient Education and Counseling 48, 51-61. (Pubitemid 36151681)
57. Melamed, R., Bonetti, T., Braga, D., Madaschi, C., Jaconelli, A. Jr. and Borges, E.Jr. (2009) 'Deciding the fate of supernumerary frozen embryos: parents' choices', Human Fertility 12, 185-90.
58. Mohler-Kuo, M., Zellweger, U., Duran, A., Hohl, M., Gutzwiller, F. and Mutsch, M. (2009) 'Attitudes of couples towards the destination of surplus embryos: results among couples with cryopreserved embryos in Switzerland', Human Reproduction 24, 1930-8.
59. Moutel, G., Gregg, E., Meningaud, J. P. and Herve, C. (2002) 'Developments in the storage of embryos in France and the limitations of the laws of bioethics. Analysis of procedures in 17 storage centres and the destiny of stored embryos', Medical Law 21, 587-604. (Pubitemid 35173933)
60. Nachtigall, R., Becker, G., Friese, C., Butler, A. and MacDougall, K. (2005) 'Parents' conceptualization of their frozen embryos complicates the disposition decision', Fertility and Sterility 84, 431-4. (Pubitemid 41125266)
61. Nachtigall, R., MacDougall, K., Harrington, J., Duff, J., Lee, M. and Becker, G. (2009) 'How couples who have undergone in vitro fertilization decide what to do with surplus frozen embryos', Fertility and Sterility 92, 2094-6.
62. Nachtigall, R., MacDougall, K., Lee, M., Harrington, J. and Becker, G. (2010) 'What do patients want? Expectations and perceptions of IVF clinic information and support regarding frozen embryo disposition', Fertility and Sterility, doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2010.02.023.
63. Newton, C., Fisher, J., Feyles, V., Tekpetey, F., Hughes, L. and Isacsson, D. (2007) 'Changes in patient preferences in the disposal of cryopreserved embryos', Human Reproduction 22, 3124-8. (Pubitemid 351696773)
64. Newton, C., McDermid, A., Tekpetey, F. and Tummon, I. (2003) 'Embryo donation: attitudes toward donation procedures and factors predicting willingness to donate', Human Reproduction 18, 878-84. (Pubitemid 36426975)
65. Office of Population Affairs, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2010) Embryo Adoption Funding. http://www.hhs.gov/opa/embryoadoption/ funding/index.html (Accessed 2 December 2010).
66. Oghoetuoma, J., McKeating, C., Horne, G., Brison, D. and Lieberman, B. (2000) 'Use of in vitro fertilization embryos cryopreserved for 5 years or more', Lancet 355, 1336. (Pubitemid 30199012)
67. Oke, K., Hammarberg, K. and Blood, J. (1998) 'Frozen embryos - what decisions to make?' 17th Annual Scientific Meeting of the Fertility Society of Australia, Hobart (abstract), 30.
68. Ontario Medical Association (2010) 'Patient-centred care', Ontario Medical Review, June 34-49.
69. Paul, M. S. and Berger, R. (2007) 'Topic avoidance and family functioning in families conceived with donor insemination', Human Reproduction 22, 2566-71. (Pubitemid 47289074)
70. Paul, M. S., Berger, R., Blyth, E. and Frith, L. (2010) 'Relinquishing frozen embryos for conception by infertile couples', Family, Systems and Health 28, 258-73.
71. Provoost, V., Pennnings, G., De Sutter, P., Gerris, J., Van de Velde, A., De Lissnyder, E. and Dhont, M. (2009) 'Infertility patients' beliefs about their embryos and their disposition preference', Human Reproduction, doi:10.1093/humrep/den486.
72. Provoost, V., Pennings, G., De Sutter, P., Gerris, J., Van de Velde, A. and Dhont, M. (2010) 'Patients' conceptualization of cryopreserved embryos used in their fertility treatment', Human Reproduction 25, 705-13.
73. Roberts, E. (2007) 'Extra embryos: the ethics of cryopreservation in Ecuador and elsewhere', American Ethnology 34, 181-99.
74. Saunders, D., Bowman, M., Grierson, A. and Garner, F. (1995) 'Frozen embryos: too cold to touch? The dilemma ten years on', Human Reproduction 10, 3081-5.
75. Sehnert, B. and Chetkowski, J. (1998) 'Secondary donation of frozen embryos is more common after pregnancy initiation with donated eggs than after in vitro fertilization-embryo transfer and gamete intrafallopian transfer', Fertility and Sterility 69, 350-2. (Pubitemid 28117119)
76. Shelden, R., Beloni, J., Corsan, G. and Kemman, E. (1997) 'The fate of cryopreserved human preembryos. P 256', Fertility and Sterility 68, S215.
77. Snowflakes®. (2010) Embryo Adoption Program. Frequently Asked Questions by Adopting Families. Revised April 27. http://www.nightlight.org/ downloads/nightlight-embryo-overview.pdf (accessed 2 December 2010).
78. Söderström-Anttila, V., Foudila, T., Ripatti, U. R. and Siegberg, R. (2001) 'Embryo donation: outcome and attitudes among embryo donors and recipients', Human Reproduction 16, 1120-8. (Pubitemid 32544680)
79. Sperm Bank of California (2010) 'Identity-Release Program' http://www.thespermbankofca.org/pages/page.php?pageid=45 (accessed 2 December 2010).
80. Stewart, M. (2001) 'Towards a global definition of patient centred care', British Medical Journal 322, 444-5.
81. Syrop, H., Sparks, E., Van Voorhis, J., Hahn, J., Kantamneni, J. and Stovall, D. (1995) 'Embryo adoption and embryo research: will patients donate their embryos?', American Society of Reproductive Medicine Annual Meeting. Abstract.
82. Trounson, A., Leeton, J., Besanko, M., Wood, C. and Conti, A. (1983) 'Pregnancy established in an infertile patient after transfer of a donated embryo fertilised in vitro', British Medical Journal 286, 835-8. (Pubitemid 13152399)
83. Trounson, A. and Mohr, L. (1983) 'Human pregnancy following cryopreservation, thawing and transfer of an eight-cell embryo', Nature 305, 707-9. (Pubitemid 13021518)
84. Van Voorhis, B., Grinstead, D., Sparks, A., Gerard, J. and Weie, R. (1999) 'Establishment of a successful donor embryo program: medical, ethical, and policy issues', Fertility and Sterility 71, 604-8. (Pubitemid 29149406)
85. Zweifel, J., Christianson, M., Jaeger, A., Olive, D. and Lindheim, S. (2007) 'Needs assessment for those donating to stem cell research', Fertility and Sterility 88, 560-4. (Pubitemid 47368254)