The impact of single-payer health care on physician income in Canada, 1850-2005

American Journal of Public Health

Volumn 101, Issue 7, 2011, Pages 1198-1208

  Duffin, Jacalyn ^a  

^a QUEEN S UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CANADA; ECONOMICS; GROSS NATIONAL PRODUCT; HEALTH INSURANCE; HISTORY; HUMAN; INCOME; PHYSICIAN; PUBLIC HEALTH; STATISTICS; UNITED STATES;

CANADA; GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT; HISTORY, 19TH CENTURY; HISTORY, 20TH CENTURY; HISTORY, 21ST CENTURY; HUMANS; INCOME; NATIONAL HEALTH PROGRAMS; PHYSICIANS; SINGLE-PAYER SYSTEM; UNITED STATES;

EID: 79958865822     PISSN: 00900036     EISSN: 15410048     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.2105/AJPH.2010.300093     Document Type: Review

References (128)

1. Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, Public Law 111-148, 111th Congress, 23 March 2010, HR 3590.
2. S. G. Stolberg, R. Pear, "Obama signed health care overhaul bill with a flourish", New York Times, 23 March 2010, A19.
3. See, for example, P. Armstrong, H. Armstrong, C. Fegan, Universal Health Care: What the United States Can Learn From Canada (New York, NY: The New Press, 1998) ;
4. Bruce Campbell and Greg Marchildon, ed., Medicare: Facts, Myths, Problems, Promise (Toronto, Ontario: Lorimer, 2007) ;
5. Canadian Health Services Research Foundation, "Myth: In Health Care, More is Always Better", Journal of Health Services Research & Policy 14(2009):124-125;
6. Steffie Woolhandler, Terry Campbell, and David U. Himmelstein, "Costs of Health Care Administration in the United States and Canada", New England Journal of Medicine 349(2003):768-775; (Pubitemid 37010782)
7. Joseph S. Ross and Allan S. Detsky, "Comparison of the US and Canadian Health Care Systems: A Tale of 2 Mount Sinais", Journal of the American Medical Association 300(2008):1934-936;
8. Raisa Berlin Deber, "Health Care Reform: Lessons From Canada", American Journal of Public Health 93, no. 1(2003):20-24. (Pubitemid 36055265)
9. Steven J. Katz, Karen Cardiff, Marina Pascali, Morris L. Barer, and Robert G. Evans, "Phantoms in the Snow: Canadians' Use of Health Care Service in the United States", Health Affairs (Millwood) 21, no. 3(2002):19-31.
10. A. E. Carroll and R. T. Ackerman, "Support for National Health Insurance Among U. S. Physicians: 5 Years Later", Annals of Internal Medicine 148, no. 7(2008):566-567. (Pubitemid 351665438)
11. Web site for Charles W. Boustany Jr, MD, Speech given September, 2009, http://boustany.house.gov/index.html (accessed August 27, 2010).
12. Scott Gottlieb, "How ObamaCare Will Affect Your Doctor", Wall Street Journal, May 12, 2009, http://online.wsj.com/article/ SB124208383695408513.html (accessed November 17, 2010).
13. S. J. Katz, S. Zuckerman, and W. P. Welch. "Comparing Physician Fee Schedules in Canada and the United States", Health Care Financing Review 14(1992):141-149; (Pubitemid 23088039)
14. S. E. D. Shortt, The Doctor Dilemma: Public Policy and the Changing Role of Physicians Under Ontario Medicare (Montreal, Quebec: Mc-Gill-Queen's University Press, 1999) ;
15. W. P. Welch, S. J. Katz, and S. Zuckerman, "Physician Fee Levels: Medicare Versus Canada", Health Care Financing Review 14, no. 3(1993):41-54. (Pubitemid 23313932)
16. Ross and Detsky, "Comparison", 1936.
17. Health Canada, "Canada's Health Care System (Medicare)", http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/hcs-sss/medi-assur/indexeng.php (accessed November 17, 2010) ;
18. CBC Digital Archives, "Health Care System", http://archives.cbc.ca/health/health-care-system/topics/90/ (accessed November 17, 2010) ;
19. Canadian Museum of Civilization, "Making Medicine: The History of Health Care in Canada, 1914 to 2007, Online Exhibition", http://www.civilisations.ca/cmc/exhibitions/hist/medicare/mediccredits-e.shtml (accessed November 17, 2010).
20. C. David Naylor, Private Practice, Public Payment: Canadian Medicine and the Politics of Health Insurance, 1911-1966 (Montreal, Quebec, and Kingston, Ontario: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1986) ;
21. Aleck Ostry, Change and Continuity in Canada's Health Care System (Ottawa, Ontario: CHA Press, 2006) ;
22. Malcolm G. Taylor, Health Insurance and Canadian Public Policy: The Seven Decisions That Created the Canadian Health Insurance System and Their Outcome, 2nd ed. (Montreal, Quebec, and Kingston, Ontario: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1987) ;
23. C. Stuart Houston, Steps on the Road to Medicare: Why Saskatchewan Led the Way (Montreal, Quebec, and Kingston, Ontario: McGill-Queen's University Press, 2002) ;
24. C. Stuart Houston and Bill Waiser, Tommy's Team: The People Behind the Douglas Years (Calgary, Alberta: Fifth House, 2010).
25. Lewis H. Thomas, The Making of a Socialist: The Recollections of T. C. Douglas (Edmonton, Alberta: The University of Alberta Press, 1982): 7.
26. Jacalyn Duffin and Leslie Falk, "Sigerist in Saskatchewan: The Quest for Balance in Social and Technical Medicine", Bulletin of the History of Medicine 70(1996):658-683; (Pubitemid 126706029)
27. Jacalyn Duffin, "The Guru and the Godfather: Henry E. Sigerist, Hugh Maclean and the Politics of Health Care Reform in 1940s Canada", Canadian Bulletin of Medical History 9, no. 2(1992):191-218.
28. Robin F. Badgley and Samuel Wolfe, Doctors' Strike: Medical Care and Conflict in Saskatchewan (Toronto, Ontario: Macmillan, 1967).
29. Government of Canada, Hospital Insurance and Diagnostic Services Act, Statutes of Canada, 5-6 Elizabeth II (c 28, S1 1957), 1957.
30. Canada Royal Commission on Health Services Report (Ottawa, Ontario: Queen's Printer, 1964-1965): 541-544.
31. Government of Canada, Medical Care Act, Statutes of Canada (c 64, s 1), 1966-1967.
32. Government of Canada, Canada Health Act, Bill C-3, Statutes of Canada, 32-33 Elizabeth II (RSC 1985, c 6; RSC 1989, c C-6), 1984, http://laws. justice.gc.ca/en/c-6/index.html (accessed March 21, 2011).
33. E. Meslin, "The Moral Costs of the Ontario Physicians' Strike", The Hastings Center Report 17(1987):11-14.
34. Pat Armstrong and Hugh Armstrong, Wasting Away: The Undermining of Canadian Health Care (Don Mills, Ontario: Oxford University Press, 2003): 56-58, 168-172;
35. Carolyn Hughes Tuohy, "Canada: Health Care Reform in Comparative Perspective", in Comparative Studies and the Politics of Modern Medical Care, ed. Theodore R. Marmor, Richard Freeman, and Kieke G. H. Okma (New Haven, CT, and London, England: Yale University Press, 2009): 61-87.
36. R. Romanow, Building on Values: The Future of Health Care in Canada (Saskatoon, Saskatchewan: Commission on the Future of Health Care in Canada, 2002) ;
37. Michael Kirby, Reforming Health Protection and Promotion in Canada: Time to Act (Ottawa, Ontario: Standing Senate Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology, 2003).
38. R. Ouellet, "The Chaoulli Decision: A Debate in Which Physicians Must Be Heard", Canadian Medical Association Journal 173, no. 8(2005):896; (Pubitemid 41505006)
39. Marie-Claude Prémont, "Wait-Time Guarantees for Health Services: An Analysis of Quebec's Reaction to the Chaoulli Supreme Court Decision", Health Law Journal 15(2007):43-56.
40. Canadian Institute for Health Information, Health Spending Databases, National Physician Database, http://secure. cihi.ca/cihiweb/dispPage.jsp?cw- page=hhrdata-npdb-e (accessed November 17, 2010) ;
41. British Columbia, Ministry of Health Services, Medical Services Commission, Financial Statement, "Blue Book", http://www.health. gov. bc.ca/msp/financial-statement.html (accessed November 17, 2010). In the 2009 statement, approximately 8800 individual physicians billed roughly Can $3 billion, or approximately Can $340 000 each.
42. S. E. D. Shortt, "Before the Age of Miracles: The Rise, Fall, and Rebirth of General Practice in Canada, 1890-1940", in Health, Disease and Medicine: Essays in Canadian History, ed. Charles G. Roland (Toronto, Ontario: Hannah Institute, 1984): 123-152;
43. Charles G. Roland and B. Rubeshewsky, "The Economic Status of the Practice of Dr. Harmaunus Smith in Wentworth County, 1827-67", Canadian Bulletin of Medical History 5(1988):29-49;
44. Jacalyn Duffin, Langstaff: A Nineteenth-Century Medical Life (Toronto, Ontario: University of To - ronto Press, 1993), 46-58;
45. Robert D. Gidney and Wynn P. J. Millar, Professional Gentlemen: The Professions in Nineteenth-Century Ontario (Toronto, Ontario: University of Toronto Press, 1994): 39-40, 189-195, 403-405.
46. Malcolm C. Urquhart, Historical Statistics of Canada (Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1965) ;
47. F. H. Leacy, Historical Statistics of Canada, 2nd ed. (Ottawa, Ontario: Statistics Canada, 1982).
48. J. Coombs, "Rural Medical Practice in the 1880s: A View From Central Wisconsin", Bulletin of the History of Medicine 64, no. 1(1990):35-62;
49. E. Brooks Holifield, "The Wealth of Nineteenth-Century American Physicians", Bulletin of the History of Medicine 64, no. 1(1990):79-85.
50. Shortt, "Before the Age of Miracles", 135-136.
51. Noah M. Meltz, Manpower in Canada, 1931-1961: Historical Statistics of the Labour Force (Ottawa, Ontario: Department of Manpower and Immigration, Program Development Service, Research Branch, 1969).
52. See also Survey of Physicians in Canada, ed. J. Willard (Ottawa, Ontario: Department of National Health and Welfare, Research and Statistics Division, series 1946-1955).
53. Taxation Statistics (Ottawa, Ontario: Revenue Canada, 1948-1995).
54. Earnings of Physicians in Canada, Health Care Series, 1957-1970 (Ottawa, Ontario: Department of National Health and Welfare, Research and Statistics Directorate, 1963-1972).
55. D. A. Geekie, "Canadian Government Figures Show Near-Halt in 1971-72; Physicians' Income Change", Canadian Medical Association Journal 113, no. 10(1975):1002-1005.
56. D. A. Geekie, Letter, "MD Incomes 1961-67", Canadian Medical Association Journal 110, no. 7(1974):755.
57. [No authors listed], "Earnings of Canadian Physicians, 1959-69", Canadian Medical Association Journal 106, no. 6(1972):719-721.
58. D. A. Geekie, "MD Incomes, 1961-1971", Canadian Medical Association Journal 109(1973):1246, 1249-1250, 1252, 1260.
59. R. D. Fraser, Physician Incomes in Canada (Kingston, Ontario: Queen's University, 1980): 9;
60. Robert G. Evans, Strained Mercy: The Economics of Canadian Health Care (Toronto, Ontario: Butterworths, 1984): 15-16;
61. Robert G. Evans and Morris L. Barer, "Riding North on a South-Bound Horse? Expenditures, Prices, Utilization and Incomes in the Canadian Health Care System", in Medicare at Maturity: Achievements, Lessons and Challenges, ed. Robert G. Evans and Greg L. Stoddart (Calgary, Alberta: The Banff Centre for Continuing Education, 1986): 53-163, esp. 92.
62. Geekie, "Canadian Government Figures", 1002.
63. Jane M. Fulton, Canada's Health Care System: Bordering on the Possible (Washington, DC: Falkner and Gray, 1993): 69-70.
64. Shortt, Doctor Dilemma, 30.
65. S. Wolfe and R. F. Badgley, "How Much is Enough? The Payment of Doctors-Implications for Health Policy in Canada", International Journal of Health Services 4, no. 2(1974):245-264.
66. Walter C. Mackenzie, "Medicare: The Cost to the Medical Profession [editorial]", Canadian Medical Association Journal 119, no. 9(1978):995.
67. Anon, "Canada's MDs Embittered by Health Plan", Medical World News 20, no. 3(1979):23;
68. Anon, "Canadian Survey Reveals Widespread Dissatisfaction Among Physicians, American Medical News 22, no. 6(1979):17-19.
69. Fraser, Physician Incomes in Canada, 45.
70. Canada Census 1991, 1996, 2001, 2006, "Employment Income of Physicians", for 1990 and 1995, extracted from Statistics Canada, Table CD Series Dimensions 94F0005XCB; for 2000 and 2005 extracted from Statistics Canada, Schedule 8, Employment Income Statistics (Cat.97-563-X2006-0063), http://www.statcan. gc.ca (accessed August 28, 2009).
71. Taking the Pulse: The CMA Physician Resource Survey (Ottawa, Ontario: Canadian Medical Association, 1997).
72. Anon, "Professional Incomes [editorial]", Journal of the American Medical Association 28(1897):1037-1038.
73. F. E. Wallace, "Incomes of Physicians", Journal of the American Medical Association 56(1911):835;
74. H. W. Wiley, "Incomes of Physicians [letter]", Journal of the American Medical Association 56(1911):835.
75. D. B. Cauthen, Letter, "Luxurious Cars: Should Physicians Flaunt their Wealth?" Journal of the American Medical Association 262, no. 12(1989):1631.
76. M. Leven, The Incomes of Physicians: An Economical and Statistical Analysis (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1932).
77. L. S. Reed, Studies of the Incomes of Physicians and Dentists (Washington, DC: Department of Health, Education and Welfare, Social Security Administration, 1968).
78. Michael C. Thornhill, "Physician Income: Historic and Recent Changes in Payment Sources, Income Levels, and Professional Autonomy", in The Business of Medicine, ed. G. Gitnick, F. Rothenberg, and J. L. Weiner (New York, NY: Elsevier, 1991): 7-18;
79. Ha T. Tu and Paul B. Ginsburg, Tracking Report. Losing Ground: Physician Income 1995-2003 (Washington, DC: Center for Studying Health System Change, 2006), http://www.hschange.com/CON-TENT/851/ (accessed November 17, 2010).
80. W. A. Richardson, "Physicians' Income", Medical Economics 25, no. 12(Sep. 1948):59):59;26(Oct. 1948):63):63;26(Nov. 1948):59):59;26(June 1949):63):63;
81. Arthur Owens, "Doctors' Earnings: Inflation Edges Ahead", Medical Economics 55, no. 19(Sep. 1978):226-231, 234-235, 241-242;
82. Arthur Owens, "Doctors' Earnings: Look What's Happening to Your Buying Power", Medical Economics 56, no. 19(Sep. 1979):190-194, 196-202;
83. Arthur Owens, "Earnings: Have They Flattened Out for Good? Medical Economics 63, no. 18(Sep. 1986):162-181;
84. Arthur Owens, "How Much Did Your Earnings Grow Last Year?" Medical Economics 65, no. 17(Sep. 1988):159-163, 166-168, 170;
85. Arthur Owens, "Earnings: Are You One of Those Losing Ground?" Medical Economics 66, no. 17(1989):130-137, 141-142, 147-148;
86. Arthur Owens, "Earnings Make a Huge Breakthrough", Medical Economics 67, no. 17(Sep. 1990):90-94, 104-105, 108;
87. H. D. Larkin, "High Incomes, Low Costs: How Do They Do It?" Medical Economics 75, no. 17(Sep. 1998):92-94, 97-100, 106;
88. J. H. Goldberg, "Doctor's Incomes: Who's Up, Who's Down?" Medical Economics 75, no. 17(Sep. 1998):166-168, 171-177, 181-182;
89. J. H. Goldberg, "Doctor's Earnings Make a Stride", Medical Economics 76, no. 18(Sep. 1999):172-175, 178, 183-186;
90. L. W. Ghormley, "I Was Wrong. Medicare Is Great!" Medical Economics 79, no. 9(May 2002):71-72, 77;
91. Robert Lowes, "Earnings. Primary Care Tries to Hang on", Medical Economics 81, no. 18(Sep. 2004):52-54, 56, 58;
92. Wayne J. Guglielmo, "Physicians' Earnings: Our Exclusive Survey", Medical Economics 80, no. 18(Sep. 2004):71-72, 76-79;
93. Charlotte L. Rosenberg, "Goodbye Charity Clinics: Fee for Service Is Moving in", Medical Economics 51, no. 20(1974):145.
94. See also Milan Korcok, "US Physicians' Earnings. Part I: They Spend More but Still Keep More", Canadian Medical Association Journal 120, no. 2(1979):187-189.
95. R. G. Leland, "Income from Medical Practice", Journal of the American Medical Association 96(1931):1683-1691.
96. Marcus S. Goldstein, "Medical Group Practice in the United States", Journal of the American Medical Association 142(1950):1049-1052;
97. Frank G. Dickinson and Charles E. Bradley, "Survey of Physicians' Incomes", Journal of the American Medical Association 14 6(1951):1249-255;
98. Anon., "Sample of 1951 Physicians' Incomes", Journal of the American Medical Association 149, no. 2(1952):149-167.
99. Martin L. Gonzalez et al., Physician Marketplace Statistics (Chicago, IL: AMA Center for Health Policy Research, 1988-1998) ;
100. John D. Wasenaar and Sara L. Thran, Physician Socioeconomic Statistics, 2000-2002 edition (Chicago, IL: AMA Center for Health Policy Research, 2003).
101. For historical exchange rate of Canadian dollars to US dollars, see "Pacific Exchange Rate Service" of Sauder School of Business, University of British Columbia, at http://fx.sauder.ubc.ca/etc/USDpages.pdf (accessed November 17, 2010).
102. A. Maddison, The World Economy: A Millenial Perspective (Paris, France: Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, 2001) ;
103. Angus Maddison, The World Economy: Historical Statistics (Paris, France: Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, 2003) ;
104. Jean-Pierre Maynard, A Comparison of GDP per Capita in Canada and the United States From 1994 to 2005 (Ottawa, Ontario: Statistics Canada, 2007) ;
105. Factbook 2009: Economic, Environmental and Social Statistics: Macroeconomic Trends - Gross Domestic Product (GDP) - Size of GDP (Paris, France: Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, 2009).
106. Richard M. Scheffler, Is There a Doctor in the House? Market Signals and To - morrow's Supply of Doctors (Stanford, CA: Stanford General Books, 2008): 73.
107. R. Collier "Long-Form Census Change Worries Health Researchers", Canadian Medical Association Journal, News, July 22, 2010, http://www.cmaj. ca/cgi/rapidpdf/cmaj.109-3322v1 (accessed November 17, 2010).
108. Anon., Editorial: "Save the Census: The Canadian Government Should Rethink Its Decision to Change the Way Census Data Are Collected", Nature 466, no. 7310(2010):1043.
109. J. Holahan, J. Hadley, W. Scanlon, R. Lee, and J. Bluck, "Paying for Physician Services Under Medicare and Medicaid", Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 57, no. 2(1979):183-211, esp. 191-192;
110. John Holahan and William Scanlon, Price Controls, Physician Fees, and Physician Incomes From Medicare and Medicaid (Washington, DC: The Urban Institute, 1978) ;
111. Theodore R. Marmor, The Politics of Medicare, 2nd ed. (New York, NY: Aldine de Gruyter, 2000): 84, 98.
112. V. R. Fuchs, J. S. Hahn, "How Does Canada Do It? A Comparison of Expenditures for Physicians' Services in the United States and Canada", New England Journal of Medicine 323, no. 13(1990):884-890. (Pubitemid 20341559)
113. Woolhandler, Campbell, and Himmelstein, "Costs of Health Care Administration";
114. James G. Kahn, Richard Kronick, Mary Kreger, and David N. Gans, "The Cost of Health Insurance Administration in California: Estimates for Insurers, Physicians, and Hospitals", Health Affairs (Millwood) 24, no. 6(2005):1629-1639;
115. Lawrence P. Casalino, Sean Nicholson, David N. Gans, Terry Hammons, Dante Morra, Theodore G. Karrison, and Wendy Levinson, "What Does It Cost Physician Practices to Interact with Health Insurance Plans", Health Affairs (Millwood) web exclusive 28(2009):w533-w543.
116. Pol de Vos, "Health Report on Cuba. 'No One Left Abandoned': Cuba's National Health System Since the 1959 Revolution", International Journal of Health Services 35(2005):189-207; (Pubitemid 40315847)
117. Pol de Vos and Patrick Van der Stuyft, "The Right to Health in Times of Economic Crisis: Cuba's Way", Lancet 374, no. 9701(2009):1575-1576;
118. Tania M. Jenkins, "Patients, Practitioners, and Paradoxes: Responses to the Cuban Health Crisis of the 1990s", Qualitative Health Research 18, no. 10(2008):1384-1400, esp. 1392 and 1399;
119. World Health Organization, "Cuba; Country Coordination Strategy at a Glance", April 2009, http://www.who.int/countryfocus/cooperation-strategy/ ccsbrief-cub-en.pdf (accessed November 17, 2010) ;
120. Jessica Moe, "Letter from Cuba", Canadian Family Physician, 57(2011):458-459.
121. E. Andaya, "The Gift of Health: Socialist Medical Practice and Shifting Material and Moral Economies in Post-Soviet Cuba", Medical Anthropology Quarterly 23, no. 4(2009):357-374.
122. Wolfe and Badgley. "How Much Is Enough?";
123. Howard J. Curzer, "Do Physicians Make Too Much Money?" Theoretical Medicine 13, no. 1(1992):45-65;
124. Nancy S. Jecker and Eric M. Meslin, "United States and Canadian Approaches to Justice in Health Care: A Comparative Analysis of Health Care Systems and Values", Theoretical Medicine 15, no. 2(1994):181-200; (Pubitemid 24285747)
125. David L. Schiedermayer, "The Profession at the Fault Line: The Ethics of Physician Income", in Bioethics and the Future of Medicine: A Christian Appraisal, eds. John F. Kilner, Nigel M. de S. Cameron, and David L. Schiedermayer (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1995), 68-78.
126. Ontario, Ministry of Finance, Public Sector Salary Disclosure, at http://www.fin. gov. on. ca/en/publications/salarydisclosure/2010/ (accessed November 16, 2010).
127. A. Radwanski, "Sunshine Salary List Poses a Problem for McGuinty", Globe and Mail, April 1, 2010, A7;
128. Chad Skelton and Lori Culbert, "Number of Public Servants Earning More Than $100, 000 Jumps 22 Per Cent in Two Year", Vancouver Sun, 2010, http://www2.canada.com/vancouversun/news/westcoastnews/story.html?id= f65ebd81-c144-495ebdee-be4c30b58008&k=36581 (accessed March 11, 2011).