Effectiveness of policy level environmental and sustainability assessment: Challenges and lessons from recent practice

Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management

Volumn 13, Issue 1, 2011, Pages 39-65

  Eales, Richard P ^a   Sheate, William R ^a  

^a 1E The Chandlery ^*  (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

alternatives; decision making; effectiveness; institutional inertia; national policy; Strategic environmental assessment; sustainability appraisal

Indexed keywords

DECISION MAKING; ENERGY PLANNING; ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY; POLICY DEVELOPMENT; POLICY IMPLEMENTATION; STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT; SUSTAINABILITY; SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT;

EUROPE; UNITED KINGDOM;

EID: 79955631916     PISSN: 14643332     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1142/S146433321100378X     Document Type: Article

References (62)

1. Cashmore, M, A Bond and B Sadler (2009). Introduction: The effectiveness of impact assessment instruments, Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 27(2), 91-93.
2. Cashmore, M, T Richardson, T Hilding-Ryedvik and L Emmelin (2010). Evaluating the effectiveness of impact assessment instruments: Theorising the nature and implications of their political constitution. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 30, 371-379.
3. CEC (Commission of the European Communities) (2009). Report from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament, The European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions on the application and effectiveness of the Directive on Strategic Environmental Assessment (Directive 2001/42/EC).
4. CLG (Communities and Local Government) (2008a). Sustainability Appraisal and Habitats Regulations Assessment of the Draft Eco-Towns Planning Policy Statement.
5. CLG (Communities and Local Government) (2008b). Sustainability Appraisal and Habitats Regulations Assessment of the Eco-towns Programme.
6. CLG (Communities and Local Government) (2010). Towards a more efficient and effective use of Strategic Environmental Assessment and Sustainability Appraisal in spatial planning. Final Report.
7. COWI and Milieu (2009). Study concerning the report on the application and effectiveness of the SEA Directive (2001/42/EC). Final Report. European Commission DG-ENV.
8. CPRE (1991). Submission by the Council for the Protection of Rural England (CPRE) to the European Commission's five-year review of EC directive 85/337/EEC on environmental assessment: The environmental assessment directive-five years on.
9. Dalal-Clayton, B and B Sadler (2005). Sustainability Appraisal - A Review of International Experience and Practice. London: Earthscan Publications.
10. Department for Transport (2009). Ports: National Policy Statement for England & Wales- Appraisal of Sustainability Report.
11. Department of Energy and Climate Change (2009a). Planning for new energy infrastructure. Appraisal of Sustainability for the Draft National Policy Statements for: Overarching Energy (EN-1), Fossil Fuels (EN-2), Renewables (EN-3), Gas Supply and Gas and Oil Pipelines (EN-4), and Electricity Networks (EN-5).
12. Department of Energy and Climate Change (2009b). Planning for New Energy Infrastructure. Appraisal of Sustainability of the Draft Nuclear National Policy Statement.
13. Department of the Environment (1993). Environmental Appraisal of Development Plans- A Good Practice Guide, Department of the Environment (DoE). London: HMSO.
14. Dryzek, J (2005). The Politics of the Earth: Environmental Discourses, 2nd edition. Oxford: Oxford Universisty Press.
15. Eales, RP and WR Sheate (2010). Opportunities missed, and challenges to come? Town and Country Planning, 79(3), 138-143.
16. Fergusson, M, C Coffey, D Wilkinson, D Baldock, A Farmer, RA Kramer and AG Mazurek (2001). The Effectiveness of EU Council Integration Strategies and Options for Carrying Forward the "Cardiff Process", IEEP/Ecologic, March 2001.
17. Fischer, T and P Gazzola (2006). SEA effectiveness criteria - equally valid in all countries? The case of Italy. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 26, 396-409.
18. Fischer, TB (2005). Having an impact? Context elements for effective SEA application in transport policy, plan and programme making. Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 7(3), 407-432. (Pubitemid 41309163)
19. Fischer, TB (2010). Reviewing the quality of strategic environmental assessment reports for English spatial plan core strategies. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 30, 62-69.
20. Gazzola, P (2008). What appears to make SEA effective in different planning systems. Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 10(1), 1-24. (Pubitemid 351772111)
21. Gibson, RB (2006). Beyond the pillars: Sustainability assessment as a framework for effective integration of social. Economic and ecological consideration in significant decision-making. Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 8(3), 259-280.
22. Gibson, RB, S Hassan, S HoItz, J Tansey and G Whitelaw (2005). Sustainability Assessment: Criteria, Processes and Applications. 240 pp, London: Earthscan Publications.
23. Hertin, J, J Turnpenny, A Jordan,MNilsson, D Russel and B Nykvist (2009). Rationalising the policy mess? Ex ante policy assessment and the utilisation of knowledge in the policy process. Environment and Planning A, 41(5), 1185-2000.
24. IAIA (International Association for Impact Assessment)(2002). SEA Performance Criteria, International Association for Impact Assessment (IAIA), available at http://www.iaia. org/publicdocuments/special-publications/sp1.pdf [accessed 10 January 2011].
25. IEMA (Institute of Environmental Management and Assessment) (2004). SEA Review Criteria.
26. João, E (2007). A research agenda for data and scale issues in Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA). Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 27(5), 479-491. (Pubitemid 46824110)
27. Kørnøv, L and WAH Thissen (2000). Rationality in decision and policy-making: Implications for strategic environmental assessment. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 18(3), 191-200.
28. Mitting, J (2009). Judgment in, City and District Council of St Albans and Hertfordshire County Council v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government [2009] EWHC 1280 (Admin), 20 May 2009.
29. Morrison-Saunders, A and T Fischer (2006). What is wrong with EIA and SEA anyway?- A sceptic's perspective on sustainability assessment. Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 8(1), 1-21.
30. Neumayer, E (2003). Weak Versus Strong Sustainability, 2nd edition. Edward Elgar Publishing.
31. Nilsson,Mand H Dalkman (2001). Decisionmaking and strategic environmental assessment. Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 3(3), 305-327.
32. Noble, B (2000). Strategic environmental assessment: What is it and what makes it strategic? Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 2(2), 203-224.
33. Noble, B (2002). The Canadian experience with SEA and sustainability. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 22, 3-16. (Pubitemid 34054318)
34. Offical Journal (2001). Directive 2001/42/EC of the European parliament and of the council of 27 June 2001 on the assessment of the effects of certain plans and programmes on the environment, OJ L 197, 21 July 2001, pp. 30-37.
35. Owens, S, T Rayner and O Bina (2004). New agendas for appraisal: Reflections on theory. practice and research. Environment and Planning A, 36, 1943-1959. (Pubitemid 39583697)
36. Partidário, MR (2000). Elements of an SEA framework - improving the added-value of SEA. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 20, 647-663.
37. Partidário, MR, WR Sheate, O Bina, H Byron and B Augusto (2009). Sustainability assessment for agriculture scenarios in Europe's mountain areas: Lessons from six study areas, Environmental Management, 43, 144-165.
38. Phillips, P andWSheate (2010). A new SEA pathway: Reflecting on strategic environmental assessment in Scotland. The Environmentalist, 104, 19-22.
39. Pope, J and W Grace (2006). Sustainability assessment in context: Issues of process, policy and governance. Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 8(3), 373-398. (Pubitemid 44603832)
40. Retief, F (2007). A performance evaluation of strategic environmental assessment (SEA) processes within the South African context, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 27, 84-100. (Pubitemid 44940904)
41. Runhaar,H (2009). Putting SEA in context: A discourse perspective on how SEA contributes to decision-making. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 29, 200-209.
42. Sadler, B (2005). Strategic Environmental Assessment at the Policy Level: Recent Progress, Current Status and Future Prospects, Report prepared by Regional Environment Centre on behalf of Ministry of the Environment, Czech Republic.
43. Sadler, B and R Verheem (1996). Strategic Environmental Assessment: Status, Challenges and Future Directions. Ministry of Housing. Spatial Planning and the Environment of the Netherlands.
44. Scottish Government (2008). National Planning Framework 2 SEA Environmental Report.
45. Scottish Government (2010). Strategic Environmental Assessment Pathfinder Project Stage 1 and 2: Combined Summary Report.
46. Sheate, WR (1994). Making an Impact: A Guide to EIA Law and Policy, 1st edition. London: Cameron May.
47. Sheate, WR (2008). Letter to the BARD Campaign Reviewing Eco-Towns Sustainability Appraisal Reports, available at http://www.bardcampaign.com/ press/pressreleases/ 198064/the-sheate-report.html [accessed 6 January 2011].
48. Sheate, WR (2009). Affidavit on behalf of the Applicant in Irwin Glenbank Ltd v Department of the Environment, Northern Ireland.
49. Sheate, WR, S Dagg, J Richardson, R Aschemann, J Palerm and U Steen (2001). SEA and Integration off the Environment into Strategic Decision-Making (3 Volumes), Final Report to the European Commission, DO XI, Contract No. B4-3040/99/136634/MAR/ B4 available at http://ec.europa.eu/environment/eia/sea- support.htm, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg, 438 p, 2003.
50. Sheate, WR, S Dagg, J Richardson, R Aschemann, J Palerm and U Steen (2003). Integrating the environment into strategic decision-making: Conceptualizing policy SEA. European Environment, 13(I), 1-18. (Pubitemid 36238444)
51. Sheate, WR and MR Partidário (2010). Strategic approaches and assessment techniques- Potential for knowledge brokerage towards sustainability. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 30, 278-288.
52. Sheate, WR and C Twigger-Ross (2010). A report to Patrick Campbell and Company Solicitors Early and Effective Participation in SEA, in the Case of McGinty v Scottish Ministers, November 2010.
53. Stookes, P (2011). EIA - A precautionary tale. The Environmentalist, 109, 16-17.
54. Sustainable Development Research Network (2008). Issues for the Practice of Sustainability Appraisal in Spatial Planning - A Review. Final Workstream Report. Prepared by Land Use Consultants and the Royal Town Planning Institute (RTPI).
55. Theophilou, V, A Bond and M Cashmore (2009). Application of the SEA directive to EU structural funds: Perspectives on effectiveness. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 30(2), 136-144.
56. Therivel, R, G Christian, C Craig, R Grinham, D Mackins, J Smith, T Sneller, R Turner, D Walker and M Yamane (2009). Sustainability-focused impact assessment: English experiences. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 27(2), 155-168.
57. UNECE (1998). Aarhus Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in Decision-Making and Access to Justice in Environmental Matters, available at http:// www.unece.org/env/pp/.
58. Wallington, T, O Bina and W Thissen (2007). Theorising strategic environmental assessment: Fresh perspectives and future challenges. Environ Impact Assess Rev, 27, 569-584. (Pubitemid 47302164)
59. WCED (World Commission on Environment and Development) (1987). Our Common Future, Report of the Brundtland Commission, Oxford University Press.
60. Weatherup, J (2007). Judgment in (1) An Application by Seaport Investments Limited (2) An Application by Magherafelt District Council, FP McCann (Developments) Limited, Younger Homes Limited, Herron Bros Limited, G Small Contracts and Creagh Concrete Products Limited in Northern Ireland: No. [2007] NIQB 62, 7 September 2007.
61. Weiland, U (2010). Strategic environmental assessment in Germany - practice and open questions. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 30(3), 211-217.
62. Wood, C (1995). Environmental Impact Assessment: A Comparative Review, Longman 1st edition.