Tracking the debate around marine protected areas: Key issues and the BEG framework

Environmental Management

Volumn 47, Issue 4, 2011, Pages 546-563

  Thorpe, Andy ^a   Bavinck, Maarten ^b   Coulthard, Sarah ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF PORTSMOUTH   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF AMSTERDAM   (Netherlands)

^c UNIVERSITY OF ULSTER   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Content analysis; Governance; Marine fisheries; Marine protected area

Indexed keywords

COMPLEX PROBLEMS; CONTENT ANALYSIS; GOVERNANCE; JOURNAL ARTICLES; KEY ISSUES; MARINE ENVIRONMENT; MARINE FISHERY; MARINE PROTECTED AREA; POLICY DOCUMENTS; SCIENTIFIC RESEARCHES;

ENGINEERING RESEARCH; FISHERIES; MULTI AGENT SYSTEMS;

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION;

COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT; CONSERVATION MANAGEMENT; DEEP-SEA FISHERY; GOVERNANCE APPROACH; MARINE ENVIRONMENT; MARINE PARK; MARINE POLICY; PROTECTED AREA;

ARTICLE; BIOLOGY; DOCUMENTATION; ECOLOGY; ECONOMIC ASPECT; ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT; ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; MANAGEMENT; MARINE ENVIRONMENT; MARINE PROTECTED AREAS; NOMENCLATURE; RESEARCH; SOCIAL ASPECT; THEORY;

ANIMALS; BIODIVERSITY; CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES; ECOSYSTEM; ENVIRONMENT; ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY; FISHERIES; GOVERNMENT REGULATION; HUMANS; OCEANS AND SEAS; POPULATION DENSITY; SOCIOECONOMIC FACTORS;

EID: 79955602010     PISSN: 0364152X     EISSN: 14321009     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s00267-011-9632-5     Document Type: Article

References (119)

1. Agardy T (1993) Accommodating ecotourism in multiple use planning of coastal and marine protected areas. Ocean and Coastal Management 20:219-239
2. Agardy T, Bridgewater P, Crosby MP et al (2003) Dangerous targets? Unresolved issues and ideological clashes around marine protected areas. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystem 13:353-367 (Pubitemid 36900906)
3. Alaska Department of Fish and Game (2002) Marine protected areas in Alaska: recommendations for a public process (Report to the Alaska Board of Fisheries). Juneau, Alaska
4. Alcala AC (2004) Marine reserves as tools for fishery management and biodiversity conservation: natural experiments in the Central Philippines, 1974-2000. Available at: www.unep.org/bpsp/Fisheries/Fisheries%20Case%20Studies/ ALCALA.pdf (Last Accessed 27 May 2009)
5. Allison GW, Lubchenco JM, Carr MH (1998) Marine reserves are necessary but not sufficient for marine conservation. Ecological Applications 8:79-92
6. Andrianarivo C, de Roland R, Rajaonarison L et al (1999) Status and management of marine protected areas in Madagascar. International Coral Reef Action Network Eastern African Component (ICRAN Project). UNEP/FAO MT/1100-99-70
7. Arkema KK, Abramson SC, Dewsbury BM (2006) Marine ecosystem-based management: from characterization to implementation. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 4(10):525-532 (Pubitemid 44904691)
8. Ashworth JS, Ormond RFG (2005) Effects of fishing pressure and trophic group on abundance and spillover across boundaries of a no-take zone. Biological Conservation 121:333-344 (Pubitemid 39151672)
9. Barnes C, McFadden KW (2008) Marine ecosystem approaches to management: challenges and lessons in the United States. Marine Policy 32(3):387-392 (Pubitemid 351478252)
10. Becker N, Choresh Y (2006) Economic aspects of Marine Protected Areas (MPAs). UNEP, Tunisia
11. Beverton RJH, Holt SJ (1957) On the dynamics of exploited fish populations. Chapman and Hall, London
12. Boersma PD, Parrish JK (1999) Limiting abuse: marine protected areas, A limited solution. Ecological Economics 31:287-304
13. Bohnsack JA (1998) Application of marine reserves to reef fisheries. Australian Journal of Ecology 23:298-304
14. Botsford LW, Micheli F, Parma AM (2007) Biological and ecological considerations in the design, implementation and success of MPAs. In: Report and documentation of the expert workshop on marine protected areas and fisheries management: review of issues and considerations 12-14 June. FAO Fisheries Report No. R825. FAO, Rome
15. Brown K, Adger WN, Tompkins E et al (2001) Trade-off analysis for marine protected area management. Ecological Economics 37:417-434 (Pubitemid 32540412)
16. California Department of Fish and Game (2004) Marine protected areas past processes overview. Available at: www.dfg.ca.gov/MLPA/meeting-100608.asp (Last Accessed 27 May 2009)
17. Chapman MR, Kramer DL (1999) Gradients in coral reef fish density and size across the Barbados marine reserve boundary: effects of reserve protection and habitat characteristics. Marine Ecology Progress Series 181:48109
18. Charles AT (2001) Sustainable fishery systems. Blackwell Science, Oxford
19. Charles AT, Sanders J (2007) Issues arising on the interface of MPAs and fisheries management. In: Report and documentation of the workshop on marine protected areas and fisheries management: review of issues and considerations 12-14 June. FAO Fisheries Report No. R825. FAO, Rome
20. Charles AT, Wilson L (2009) Human dimensions of marine protected areas. ICES Journal of Marine Science 66(1):6-15
21. Christensen A, Mosegaard H, Jensen H (2008) Spatially resolved fish population analysis for designing MPAs: influence on inside and neighbouring habitats. ICES Journal of Marine Science 66(1):56-63
22. Christie P (2004) Marine protected areas as biological successes and social failures in Southeast Asia. American Fisheries Society Symposium 42:155-164
23. Christie P, White AT (2007) Best practices for improved governance of coral reef marine protected areas. Coral Reefs 26:1047-1056 (Pubitemid 350277541)
24. Christie P, Mccay BJ, Miller ML et al (2003) Towards developing a complete understanding: a social science research agenda for marine protected areas. Fisheries 28(12):22-26 (Pubitemid 38051059)
25. Christie P, Pollnac RB, Oracion EG et al (2009) Back to basics: an empirical study demonstrating the importance of local-level dynamics for the success of tropical marine ecosystem-based management. Coastal Management 37:349-373
26. Chuenpagdee R, Jentoft S (2007) Step zero for fisheries comanagement: what precedes implementation. Marine Policy 31:657-668 (Pubitemid 47224612)
27. Chuenpagdee R, Fraga J, Euán-Avila J (2002) Community perspectives towards a marine reserve: a case study of San Felipe, Yucatán, Mexico. Coastal Management 30:183-191 (Pubitemid 34416311)
28. Cicin-Sain B, Belfiore S (2005) Linking marine protected areas to integrated coastal and ocean management: a review of theory and practice. Ocean and Coastal Management 11-12(48):847-868 (Pubitemid 43243635)
29. Costanza R, Andrade F, Antunes P et al (1998) Principles for sustainable governance of the oceans. Science 281(5374):198-199 (Pubitemid 28334493)
30. Davis D, Banks S (1997) Whale sharks in Ningaloo Marine Park: managing tourism in an Australian marine protected area. Tourism Management 18(5):259-271
31. Diegues AC (2008) Marine protected areas and artisanal fisheries in Brazil, Samudra Monagraph. International Collective in Support of Fishworkers, Chennai
32. Doherty P, Fowler T (1994) An empirical test of recruitment limitation in a coral reef fish. Science 263:935-939
33. EMPAFISH (2006) Economic analysis of marine protected areas: a literature review. Booklet #3. Available at: www.cimar.org/epbrs/Documents/Reports/ Economic%20evaluation%20of%20MPAs.pdf (Last Accessed 20 May 2009)
34. Fanning L, Mahon R, McConney P et al (2007) A large marine ecosystem governance framework. Marine Policy 31:434-443 (Pubitemid 46671082)
35. FAO (2007) Report and documentation of the expert workshop on marine protected areas and fisheries management: review of issues and considerations, 12-14 June. FAO Fisheries Report No. R825. FAO, Rome
36. Fauzi A, Buchary EA (2002) A socio-economic perspective of environmental degradation at Kepulauan Seribu Marine National Park, Indonesia. Coastal Management 30(2):167-181 (Pubitemid 34416310)
37. FERM (2007) A review of the business exit (licence buyout) assistance component of the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park structural adjustment package. Final Report. Fisheries Economics, Research Management Pvt. Ltd. Available at: http://www.environment.gov.au/coasts/publications/gbrmp-adjustment-package.html (Last Accessed 26 May 2009)
38. Fogarty MJ, Bohnsack JA, Dayton PK (2000) Marine reserves and resource management. In: Sheppard C (ed) Seas at the millennium: an environmental evaluation. Elsevier, Amsterdam
39. Goñi R, Adlkerstein S, Alvarez-Berastegui D et al (2008) Spillover from six mediterranean marine protected areas: evidence from artisanal fisheries. Marine Ecology Progress Series 366:59-74
40. Gossling S (1999) Ecotourism: a means to safeguard biodiversity and ecosystem functions? Ecological Economics 29(2):303-320
41. Grafton RQ, Kompas T, Schneider V (2005) The bioeconomics of marine reserves: a selected review with policy implications. Journal of Bioeconomics 7:161-178 (Pubitemid 41479006)
42. Grigg RW (1994) Effects of sewage discharge, fishing pressure and habitat complexity on coral ecosystems and reef fishes in Hawaii. Marine Ecology Progress Series 103:25-34
43. Guénette S, Lauck T, Clark C (1998) Marine reserves: from Beverton Holt to the present. Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries 8:251-272 (Pubitemid 29276051)
44. Halim Y, Morcos S (eds) (1995) Workshop on oceanographic input to integrated coastal zone management in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. UNESCO, Paris
45. Hall SJ (1998) Closed areas for fisheries management - the case consolidates. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 13:297-298
46. Halpern B (2003) The impact of marine reserves: do they work and does reserve size matter? Ecological Applications 13:S117-S137
47. Hannesson R (1998) Marine reserves: what would they accomplish? Marine Resource Economics 13:159-170
48. Harmelin-Vivien M, Le Diréach L, Bayle-Sempere J et al (2008) Gradients of abundance and biomass across reserve boundaries in six mediterranean marine protected areas: evidence of fish spillover? Biological Conservation 141:1829-1839
49. Hauck M (2008) Rethinking small-scale fisheries compliance. Marine Policy 32(4):635-642
50. Hoagland P, Kaoru Y, Broadus JM (1995) A methodological review of net benefit evaluation for marine reserves. Environmental Economics Series Paper No.027, World Bank, Washington
51. Hoffmann E, Pérez-Rufaza A (2008) Marine protected areas as a tool for fishery management and ecosystem conservation: an introduction. ICES Journal of Marine Science 66(1):1-5
52. Hooker SK, Whitehead H, Gowans S (1999) Marine protected area design and the spatial and temporal distribution of cetaceans in a submarine canyon. Conservation Biology 13(3):592-602 (Pubitemid 29267069)
53. IUCN (1976) An international conference on marine parks and reserves: papers and proceedings of an international conference held in Tokyo, 12-14 May. IUCN, Morges (Switzerland)
54. IUCN World Commission on Protected Areas (IUCN-WCPA) (2008) Establishing resilient marine protected area networks - making it happen. IUCN-WCPA, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the Nature Conservancy, Washington, DC
55. Jameson SC, Tupper MH, Ridley JM (2002) The three screen doors: can marine "protected" areas be effective? Marine Pollution Bulletin 44:1177-1183
56. Jentoft S (2007a) Institutions in fisheries: what they are, what they do, and how they change. Marine Policy 28:137-149
57. Jentoft S (2007b) Beyond fisheries management: the Phronetic dimension. Marine Policy 30:671-680
58. Jentoft S (2007c) In the power of power: the understated aspect of fisheries and coastal management. Human Organization 66(4):426-437
59. Jentoft S, van Son TC, Bjorkan M (2007) Marine protected areas: a governance system analysis. Human Ecology 35(5):611-622 (Pubitemid 47500275)
60. Johannes RE (2000) Palau: Protection of reef fish spawning aggregations (P321-3). In: Salm RV, Clark JR (eds) Marine and coastal protected areas. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland
61. Johnson DR, Funicelli NA, Bohnsack JA (1999) Effectiveness of an existing estuarine no-take fish sanctuary within the Kennedy Space Center, Florida. North American Journal of Fisheries Management 19:436-453 (Pubitemid 29405224)
62. Jones PJS (2009) Equity, justice and power issues raised by no-take marine protected area proposals. Marine Policy 33:759-765
63. Jones GP, McCormick MI, Srinivasan M, Eagle JA (2004) Coral decline threatens fish biodiversity in marine reserves. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States 101(21):8251-8253 (Pubitemid 38698086)
64. Kelleher G, Bleakley C, Wells SM (eds) (1995) A global representative system of marine protected areas. World Bank/IUCN, Washington, DC
65. Kelly S, MacDiarmid AB, Scott D, Babcock R (2001) The value of a spill-over fishery for spiny lobsters around a marine reserve in northern New Zealand. UBC Fisheries Centre Research Reports 9(8):62-70
66. Kooiman J, Bavinck M (2005) The governance perspective. In: Kooiman J, Bavinck M, Jentoft S, Pullin R (eds) Fish for life-interactive governance for fisheries. Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam, pp 11-24
67. Lauck T, Clark CW, Mangel M et al (1998) Implementing the precautionary principle in fisheries management through marine reserves. Ecological Applications 8(1):72-78
68. Le Quesne WJF (2007) Are flawed MPAs any good or just a new way of making old mistakes? ICES Journal of Marine Science 66:132-136
69. Leeworthy VR, Wiley PC (2003) Socioeconomic impact analysis of marine reserve alternatives for the Channel Islands National Marine Sanctuary. US Department of Commerce, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Ocean Service (Special Project), Silver Spring, MD
70. Lubchenco J, Palumbi SR, Gaines SD, Andelman S (2006) Plugging a hole in the ocean: the emerging science of marine reserves. Ecological Applications 13(1):S3-S7 (Pubitemid 36872563)
71. Martin K, Samoilys MA, Hurd AK, Meliane I, Lundin CG (2007) Experiences in the use of marine protected areas with fisheries management objectives-a review of case studies. In Report and documentation of the workshop on marine protected areas and fisheries management: review of issues and considerations 12-14 June. FAO Fisheries Report No. R825. FAO, Rome
72. Mascia M (2004) Social dimensions of marine reserves. In: Sobel J, Dahlgren C (eds) Marine reserves: a guide to science, design, and use. Island Press, Washington
73. McClanahan TR, Kuanda-Auarara B (1996) Fishery recovery in a coral reef marine park and its effects on the adjacent fishery. Conservation Biology 10:1792-1805
74. McNeill SE (1994) The selection and design of marine protected areas: Australia as a case study. Biodiversity and Conservation 3:586-605
75. Mora C, Andrèfouët S, Costello MJ et al (2006) Ecology. Coral reefs and the global network of marine protected areas. Science 312(5781):1750-1751
76. MPAGlobal. A data-base of the world's marine protected areas. Available at: http://mpaglobal.org/index.php?action=aboutus (Last Accessed 20 January 2009)
77. MSNBC (2009) Bush creates huge marine sanctuaries. 6 January
78. Murawski SA, Wigley SE, Fogarty MJ et al (2008) Effort distribution and catch patterns adjacent to temperate MPAs. ICES Journal of Marine Science 62(6):1150-1167 (Pubitemid 41208087)
79. National Research Council (2001) Marine protected areas: tools for sustaining ocean ecosystems. National Academy Press, Washington. Available at: www.nap.edu/catalog/9994.html (Last Accessed 25 May 2009)
80. Niesten E, Bruner A, Rice R, Zurita P (2008) Conservation incentive agreements: an introduction and lessons learned to date. Conservation International (draft)
81. Noël J-F, Weigel J-Y (2007) Marine protected areas: from conservation to sustainable development. International Journal of Sustainable Development 10(3):233-250 (Pubitemid 351441841)
82. Nsiku E (2001) Lake Malawi National Park Fisheries: basic assessment of benefits and impact. UBC Fisheries Centre Research Reports 9(8):131-140
83. Ostrom E (1990) Governing the commons: the evolution of institutions for collective action. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
84. Parrish R (1999) Marine reserves for fisheries management: why not? CalCOFI conference symposium: a continuing dialogue on notake reserves for resource management. Asilomar California, 4 November
85. Pauly D (2006) Major trends in small-scale marine fisheries, with emphasis on developing countries, and some implications for the social sciences. Maritime Studies (MAST) 4(2):7-22
86. Pendleton LH (2004) Understanding the potential economic value of marine wildlife viewing and whale watching in California: executive summary. Avaliable at: www.dfg.ca.gov/mlpa/pdfs/draft-whale.pdf (Last Accessed 25 May 2009)
87. Pérez-Rufaza A, Martin E, Marcos C et al (2008) Modelling spatial and temporal scales for spill-over and biomass exportation from MPAs and their potential for fisheries enhancement. Journal for Nature Conservation 16:234-255
88. Pitcher T, Pauly D (Eds) (1998) Beverton and holt jubilee (special issue). Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries 8:225-227
89. Polachek T (1990) Year round closed areas as a management tool. Natural Resource Modelling 4(3):327-354
90. Pollnac RB, Poggie JJ (2006) Job satisfaction in the fishery in two southeast Alaskan towns. Human Organization. 65(3):329-340
91. Pollnac RB, Pomeroy RS (2005) Factors affecting the long-term sustainability of integrated coastal management projects in the Philippines and Indonesia. Ocean and Coastal Management 48:233-251 (Pubitemid 40850084)
92. Pollnac RB, Crawford BR, Gorospe MLG (2001a) Discovering factors influencing the success of community-based marine protected areas in the Visayas Philippines. Ocean and Coastal Management 44:683-710 (Pubitemid 34140103)
93. Pollnac RB, Pomeroy RS, Harkes I (2001b) Fishery policy and job satisfaction in three southeast Asian fisheries. Ocean and Coastal Management 44:531-544 (Pubitemid 33023560)
94. Pomeroy RS, Berkes F (1997) Two to tango: the role of government in fisheries co-management. Marine Policy 21:465-480
95. Pomeroy RS, Mascia MB, Pollnac RB (2007) Marine protected areas: the social dimension. In: Report and documentation of the workshop on marine protected areas and fisheries management: review of issues and considerations 12-14 June. FAO Fisheries Report No. R825. FAO, Rome
96. QPIF (Queensland Primary Industries and Fisheries) (2009) Performance measurement system: Queensland Coral Fishery. Available at: www.environment.gov. au/coasts/fisheries/qld/coral/pubs/performance-measurement-april09.pdf (Last Accessed 26 May 2009)
97. Ramos AA (1992) Impacts Biologiques et Economiques de la Réserve Maritime de Tabarca. MEDPAN News #3:59-66
98. Ruitenbeek HJ, Ridgely M, Dollar S, Huber R (1999) Optimisation of economic policies and investment projects using a fuzzy logic based cost-effectiveness model of coral reef quality: empirical results from Montego Bay, Jamaica. Coral Reefs 18:381-392
99. Russ GR, Alcala AC, Maypa AP et al (2004) Marine reserve benefits local fishery. Ecological Applications 14:597-606 (Pubitemid 38377411)
100. Salm RV, Clark JR (1984) Marine and coastal protected areas: a guide for planners and managers, 3rd edn. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland
101. Salm RV, Clark JR (2000) Marine and coastal protected areas: a guide for planners and managers, 3rd edn. IUCN, Gland (Switzerland), p 370
102. Samonte-Tan GPB, White AT, Tercero MA et al (2007) Economic valuation of coastal and marine resources: Bohol Marine Triangle, Philippines. Coastal Management 35:319-338 (Pubitemid 46566589)
103. Sanchirico JN, Cochran KA, Emerson PM (2002) Marine protected areas: economic and social implications. Resources for the Future, Washington, DC
104. Schlager E, Ostrom E (1993) Property rights regimes and coastal fisheries: an empirical analysis. In: Anderson TL, Simmons RT (eds) The political economy of customs and culture: informal solutions to the commons problem. Rowman & Littlefield, Lanham, pp 13-41
105. Sobel J, Dahlgren C (eds) (2004) Marine reserves: a guide to science, design, and use. Island Press, Washington
106. Stewart RR, Noyce T, Possingham HP (2003) Opportunity cost of ad hoc marine reserve design decisions: an example from South Australia. Marine Ecology Progress Series 253:25-38 (Pubitemid 36708515)
107. Subade RF (2007) Mechanisms to capture economic values of marine biodiversity: the case of the Tubbataha Reefs UNESCO World Heritage Site, Philippines. Marine Policy 31:135-142
108. Taylor N, Buckenham B (2003) Social impacts of marine reserves in New Zealand, science for conservation 217. Available at:www.tarfish.org/documents/ Social%20Impacts%20of%20Marine%20Reserves%20in%20 (Last Accessed 24 May 2009)
109. Tonge J, Moore SA (2007) Importance-satisfaction analysis for marine park hinterlands: a Western Australian case study. Tourism Management 28:768-776
110. Turner SJ, Thrush SF, Hewitt JE et al (1999) Fishing impacts and the degradation or loss of habitat structure. Fisheries Management and Ecology 6:401-420
111. Turpie J, Clark B, Hutchings K (2006) The economic value of marine protected areas along the Garden Route Coast, South Africa, and implications of changes in size and management. Anchor Environmental Consultants, Cape Town
112. Walley CJ (2004) Rough waters, nature and development in an East African Marine Park. Princeton University Press, New Haven, NJ
113. Ward TJ, Heinemann D, Evans N (2001) The role of marine reserves as fisheries management tools: a review of concepts, evidence and international experience. Bureau of Rural Sciences, Kinston (Australia). Available at: www.nap.edu/catalog/9994.html (Last Accessed 20 May 2009)
114. Weinstein MP, Baird RC, Conover DO et al (2007) Managing coastal resources in the 21st century. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 5:43-48
115. White AT, Courtney CA (2002) Experience with marine protected area planning and management in the Philippines. Coastal Management 30:1-26 (Pubitemid 34147566)
116. Whitmarsh D, Mardle S, James C et al (2003) Evaluation of frameworks of analysis employed in studies of exclusion zones. In: Pickering H (ed) The value of exclusion zones as fisheries management tool: a strategic evaluation and the development of an analytical framework for Europe. CEMARE Report, University of Portsmouth, UK
117. Wilcox C, Pomeroy C (2003) Do commercial fishers aggregate around marine reserves? Evidence for big creek ecological reserve, Central California. North American Journal of Fisheries Management 23:241-250 (Pubitemid 36326106)
118. Willis T (2003) Comment: burdens of evidence and the benefits of marine reserves: putting Descartes before des horse. Environmental Conservation 30(2):97-103
119. Yamasaki A, Kuwahara A (1990) Preserved area to effect recovery of overfished zumai crab stocks off Kyoto Prefecture. In: Proceedings of the international symposium of king and tanner crabs, 28-30 November. Anchorage, Alaska