Islamic reform in contest: Ahmad hassan and his traditionalist opponents

Studia Islamika

Volumn 7, Issue 2, 2000, Pages 87-116

  Minhaji, Akh ^a  

^a International Journal of Islamic Studies   (Indonesia)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 79954953596     PISSN: 02150492     EISSN: 23556145     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.15408/sdi.v7i2.710     Document Type: Review

References (196)

1. See A. Hassan, "Mentaliteit Pengarang 'Adil', " Pembeht Islam 56 (30 December 1932), 36;.
2. Wali Djoko, "Sajang, Sajang, Atas Saudara jang Tertjinta Mahmoed Pauzl, " Pembela Islam 58 (February 1933), 19;.
3. Soeki, "Pemetjah, " Pembela Islam 34 (September 1931), 5-24;.
4. "Sepatah Kara, " Pembela Islam 16 (December 1930), 2;.
5. TMT., "Pembela Djadi Pembelah, " Pembela Islam 17 (January 1931), 13;.
6. "Pembela Islam dan Moehammadiah, " Pembela Islam 18 (January 1931), 8.
7. "Gobiok, " Pembela Islam 62 (June 1933), 23.
8. M. Oezir, "Soerat Kiriman, " Pembela Islam 24 (April 1931), 27.
9. A. Hassan, "Djawaban Kami kepada jang Membantah Kami, " a supplement to the Pembela Islam 56 (30 December 1932).
10. Sanusi Latief, "Gerakan Kaum Tua di Minangkabau" (Ph.D. diss., IAIN Syarif Hidayatullah, 1988), 256, 267;.
11. Mahmud Yunus, Sejarctb Pendidikan Islam di Indonesia (Jakarta: Mutiara Sumber Widya, 1992), 9-98;.
12. Siradjuddin Abbas, Kumpulan Soal Jawab Keagamaan (Jakarta: Pustaka Tarbiyah, 1987), 4;.
13. "Persatuan Tarbiyah Islamiyah, " in Emiklopedi Islam di Indonesia, ed. Harun Nasution et al. (Jakarta: Departcmen Agama, 1987-1988);.
14. "Persatuan Tarbiyah Islamiyah, " in Ensiklopedi Islam, ed. Kafrawi Ridwan et al. (Jakarta; PT Ichtiar Baru van Hoeve, 1993). For the historical background of Perti and its early development, Latief, "Kaum Tua di Minangkabau, " 248-367.
15. Abbas, SoalJauab Keagamaan, 3-6;.
16. Siradjuddin Abbas, 40 Masalah Agama, vol. 1 (Jakarta: Pustaka Tarbiyah, 1982), 4-13.
17. Abbas, "Masalah Talqm, " in 40 Masalah Agatna, vol. 4, 109.
18. Hassan, "Siapa Men-dla'ifkan Hadiets Talqin?" in Soal-]awab, vol. 3, 977.
19. Siradjuddin Abbas, "Masalah Niyat dan Ushalli, " in 40 Masalah Agama, vol. 4, 243.
20. Abbas, "Masalah Talqin, " 112.
21. Abbas, "Masalah Niyat dan Ushalli, " 243 paragraph 9, and compare it to Hassan, "Melafazhkan Niat." in Soal- ]awab, vol. 1, 94 paragraphs 10 and 11.
22. See Hassan, "Melafazhkan Niat, " 94;.
23. idem, "Tudung Kepala Wanita, Pergaulannya, dan Lain-Lainnya, " dalam Soal-Jawab, vol. 2, 619.
24. Pengajaran Sbalat (Bandung: CV. Diponegoro, 1995), 76, 337;.
25. Wanita Islam: Jilbab, di Podium, Jakatan Tangan (Bangil: Percetakan Persatuan, 1989), 70, 112;.
26. Wanita Islam: Jilbab, di Podium, Jakatan Tangan Men-dla'iefkan Hadiets Talqin?" 976;.
27. Endang Saifuddin Ansliari and Syafiq A. Mughni, Wajah & Wijhab Seorang Mujtabid (Bandung: Firma al-Musiimun, 1985), 64;.
28. Tohir bin Ibrahim, "Oeroesan Koeboer Lagi, " Pembela Islam 22 (March 1931), .
29. Siradjuddin Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " in 40 Masalalj Agama, vol. 2, 241.
30. Hassan, "Melafazhkan Niat, " 94.
31. Abbas, "Masalah Niyat dan Ushalli, " 244.
32. Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 312.
33. Wael B. Hallaq, "Consensus, " in The Oxford Encyclopedia of the Modern Islamic World, ed. John L. Esposito (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995).
34. Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " in 40 Masalah Agama, vol, 2, 201-320.
35. Siradjuddin Abbas, Sejarah dan Keagungan Madzbab Syafi'i (Jakarta: Pustaka Tarbiyah, 1994), .
36. "Perkembangan Madzhab Syafi'i ke Indonesia, " 97-239.
37. Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 7-206, 209;.
38. Abbas, "Foreword" to the first edition of his 40 Masalah Agama, vol. 1, 8-9.
39. Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 4-273.
40. Muhammad b. 'Abd al-Karim al-Shahrastani, Kitabal-Milal waal-NUyd, ed. Muhammad b. Path Allah Badrun (Cairo: Matba'at al-Azhar, 1947), 201.
41. G.H. Hawting, "The Significance of the Slogan Id Hukm Ilia Lilldh and the References to the Hiidud in the Traditions about the Fitna and the Murder of 'Uthman, " Bulletin of the Sdx>ol of Oriental and African Studies 41 (1978), 63-453.
42. Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 7-205.
43. Abbas, Madzbab Syafi'i, 299-300.
44. Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 275, 317.
45. Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 2-270.
46. Siradjuddin Abbas, I'tiqad Ablussunnaio Waljamt'sjh (Jakarta: Pustaka Tarbiyah, 1983), 261.
47. Ibn Batutah, Rihlat Ibn Batuiah (Beirut: Dar Bayrut, 1980), 95.
48. idem, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 9-214, 3-292.
49. "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 46-220, 294-316.
50. Abbas, I'tiqadAhlussunnah, 4-303.
51. Wael B. Hallaq, trans. Ibn Taymiyya Against the Greek Logicians (Oxford; Clarendon Press, 1993), 12;.
52. George Makdisi, "Ibn Taymiya: A Sufi of theQadariya Order, " TheAmerican Journal of Arabic Stduics (1973), 29-118;.
53. George Makdisi, "The Hanbah School and Sufism, " Humamora Islamica 11 (1974), 61-72;.
54. Boletindela Asociacion espanola dc orientalistas 19 (1979), 26-115.
55. Abbas, I'tiqad A blusstmnah, 263.
56. Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 9-264, .
57. Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 64-252.
58. Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 1-270, 273;.
59. Abbas, Madzbab Syafi'i, 5-113.
60. Abbas, Soal Jawab Keagamaan, 99-104;.
61. Abbas, "Masalah Modernisasi Agama, " 2-211, 6-283;.
62. Abbas, Madzhab Syafi'i, 114.
63. A. Hassan, Islam dan Kebangsaan (Bangil: Persatoean Islam, 1941);.
64. A. Hassan, Mernbudakkan Pengertian Islam (Bangil: Toko Timoer, 1946).
65. A, Farichin Chumaidy, "The Jam"iyyah Nahdlatul ''Ulama': Its Rise and Early Development (1926-1945).
66. Similarly, sec Slamet Effcndy Yusuf, Mohammad Icbwan Syam, and Masdar Farid Mas'udi, Dimmika Kaum Santri (Jakarta: CV Rajawali, 1983), 10, 4-13.
67. Chumaidy, "Jam" ivy ah Nahdlatul 'Ulama', ™ 27.
68. Saifuddin Zuhri, Sejarab Kebangkitan Islam dan Perkembangannya di Indonesia (Bandung; Maarif, 1981), 609;.
69. Yusuf, Syam, and Mas'udi, Kaum Santri, 21;.
70. fvacung Marijan, Quo Vadis NU Setelah Kembali ke Kbittab 1926 (Jakarta: Penerbit Erlangga, 1992), 17;.
71. Abubakar Atjeh, Sedjarah Hidup K.H.A. Wahid Hasjim dan Karangan Terstar (Djakarta: T.p., 1957), 469, 476.
72. Atjeh, Wahid Hasjim, 505, 509;.
73. Yumis, Pendidikan Islam, 240, 243;.
74. Zuhri, Kebangkitan Islam, 610, .
75. Indonesian Political Thinking 1945-1965 (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, i 970), .
76. Pengurus Besar Nahdlatul Ulama, Keputusan Munas Alim Ulama & Konbes Nahdlatul Ulama di Bandarlampung (Semarang; Somber Barokah, 1992), 3-9;.
77. "Sistem Pen gam bi lan Keputusan I Iukum, " Aula (February 1992), 8-32;.
78. Aziz Masyhuri, "Sistem Pengambilan Keputusan Hukum dalam Bahtsul Masail di Lingkungan NU, " Aula (October 1994), 5-40, 55.
79. Agil Husin Al-Munawar, "Mazhab dalam Pandangan NU, Fiqh dan Teologi, " Aula (September 1992), 51, 7-56.
80. "Menghalalkan Ijtibad di Bandarlampung, " Tempo (1 February 1992), 31.
81. Ahmad Siddiq, "Pokok-Pokok Pikiran Nahdlatul Ulama tcntang 'Tajdid', " Asy Syir'ah 1 (1988), 45.
82. Chumaidy, "Jam'iyyah Nahdlatul 'Ukma'" 41.
83. Yusuf, Syam, and Mas'udi, Kaum Santri, 27.
84. Syafiq A. Mughni, Hassan Bandung: Pemikir Islam Radikal (Surabaya: PT. Bina Ilmu, 1980), 96.
85. A. Hassan, RisalabAl-Madz-hab (Bangil: Persatuan Islam, 1956), 5-17, 20.
86. Howard M. Federspiel, Persatuan Islam: Islamic Reform in Twentieth Century Indonesia (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1970), 162.
87. Marijan, Quo Vadis NU, 21;.
88. Imran Hamzah, "Katanya Mazhab Empat, Tapi..., Aula (February 1994), 34.
89. "Pinjam Mazhab (Lain), Apa Salahnya?" Tempo (14 March 1992), 69;.
90. Mughni, Hassan Bandung, 96.
91. "Pinjam Mazhab (Lain), Apa Salahnya?" 69;.
92. Malik Madaniy, "Cara Pengambilan Keputusan Hukum Islam dalam Bachtsul Masail Nahdlatul Ulama (Sebuah Alternatif Pengembangan), " Aula (December 1991), 59.
93. "Pinjam Mazhab (Lain), Apa Salahnya?" 59.
94. Arief Muhaimin, "Ruat Para Pembaca dan Ust. Sapco Waluyo, " Al-Muslimun 300 (1995), 4.
95. Machfudz Shiddiq, Di Sekitar Soal Idjtibad dan Taqlid (Surabaja: Nahdlatul-'Oelama', 1940).
96. Feith and Castles, Indonesian Political Thinking, 210;.
97. Chumaidy, "Jam"iyyah Nahdlatul 'Ulama', " 115;.
98. Yusuf, Syam, and Mas'udi, Kaum Santri, 6;.
99. Abdul Karim Husain, NUMenyongsong Tahun 2000 (Kendal; CV. MA. Noer Chamid, 1989), 10;.
100. Afifuddin Muhajir, "ImplementasiSistem Pengambilan Keputusan Hukum dalam Rahtsul Masail NU, " Aula (November 1994), 83.
101. Wael B. Hallaq, "On the Origins of the Controversy about the Existence of Mujtabids and the Gate of Ijtihad, " Studia Islamka, 43 (1946), 41-129.
102. Chumaidy, "Jam'iyyah Nahdlatul 'Ulama', " 115.
103. Sfiiddiq, Idjtihadclan Taqlid, 8-56;.
104. Reinhan, "Transcendence and Social Practice, " 1-20;.
105. Makdisi, "Freedoom in Islamic Jurisprudence-. Ijtihad, Taqlid and Academic Freedomin The Concept of Freedom in the Middle Ages: Islam, Byzantium and the West (Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1985), 82.
106. Mohammad Fadel, "The Social Logic of Taqlid and the Rise of the Mukhtaar, " Islamic Law and Society 3 (1996), 193-233;.
107. Hallaq, History of Islamic Legal Theories, 81-179;.
108. Sherman A. Jackson, "Defence of Two-Tiered Orthodoxy, 138.
109. Chumaidy, "Jam'iyyah Nahdlatul 'Ulama', " 116, .
110. Naoeli, "Bantahan, " Pembela Islam 17 (January 1931), 36.
111. Marijan, Quo Vadis NU, 30, .
112. Feith and Castles, Indonesian Political Thinking, 210.
113. Yusuf, Syam, and Mas'udi, Kaum Santri, 22;.
114. Marijan, Quo VaeHs NU, 3.
115. Al-Munawar, "Mazhab, " 8-57.
116. Penguins Besar Nahdlatul Ulama, Ahkdm al-Fuqaba', vol, 1 (Semarang: Toha Putra, 1960), 69-70.
117. "Dihukumi Setelah Lama Tak Jelas, " Aula (October 1995), 88.
118. A.R. Baswedan, "Perkembangan Fikiran Dikalangan Umat Islam, " Hikmah 4 (23 January 1954), 4, .
119. A. Hassan, Kesopanan Tinggi Secara Islam (Bandung: C.V. Diponegoro, 1993), 28.
120. Al-Munawar, "Mazhab, " 55.
121. Fenh and Castles, Indonesian Political Thinking, 210.
122. Zuhri, Kebangkitan Islam, 615.
123. Hallaq, "Gate of Ijtihad, " 32.
124. Hassan, Ijma', 124.
125. Abdul- wahhab, "Djawaban jang Tak Poetoes Asa, " Pembela Islam 49 (July 1932), 8;.
126. M. Nat- sir, Islam dan Akal Merdeka (Jakarta: Media Da'wah, 1988), 31;.
127. Zuayia, Usui al-Fiqh, vol. 2, 1130;.
128. Mahmasani, Falsafat al-Tasbri', 187;.
129. Shawkam, al-Qaul al-Mufid, 3-22.
130. Hassan, R isalab AI Madzhab, 3940;.
131. Hamka, "Al-Mawaa'izh Sjaich Hasjini Asj'ari, " Pandji Masjarakat 5 (15 August 1959), 5-6.
132. Chumaidy, "Jam1 lyyah Nahdlatul 'Ulama', " 159.
133. Madaniy, "Pengambilan Keputusan Ilukum Islam, " 54;.
134. "Dihukumi Setelah Lama TakJelas, " 86;.
135. "Pintu Ijtihad Sudah Kctemu Kuncinya, " Aula (Febman' 1992), 29;.
136. "Pinjam Mazhab (Lain), Apa Salahnya?" 69;.
137. Husain, Menyongsong Tahun 2000, 8;.
138. "Menghalalkan Ijtihad di Bandarlampung, " 30, .
139. Al-Munawar, "Mazhab, " 534.
140. Shiddiq, Idjtihad dan Taqlid, 59.
141. Hassan, Ijma', 72, 130.
142. Madaniy, "Pengambilan Keputusan Hukum Islam, " 54.
143. Bukharl, Sahih al-Bukbari, vol, 5, 2;.
144. Ahmad, "Theory and Practice, " 185;.
145. Schacht, "Classicisms, traditionalisme et ankylose, " 148;.
146. Friedmann, Prophecy Continuous, 5-94.
147. "Soeal-D jawab, " Pembela Islam 2 (April 1956), 16.
148. "Verslag Debat Tacjlied, " Al-Ltsaan 1 (27 (December 1935), 9-28.
149. Hassan, "Samboengan, " 2-41.
150. Mahmasanf, Falsafat al-Tashn, 5-184.
151. Hallaq, "Introduction: Issues and Problems, " 6-135.
152. Hallaq, "Gate of Ijtihad, " 25;.
153. Calder, "Nawawi's Typology of Muftis" 159 note 42, 160 note 46.
154. Dasuqi, al-Ijtihad -wa al-Taql'id, 203;.
155. Zuhayli, Usui d-Fiqh, vol. 2, 1121;.
156. Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah, Flam al-Muwaqqi'in, vol. 2, 171, 178;.
157. Peters, "Idjtihad and Taqlid, " 140.
158. Hassan, "Berita Nahdlatoel-'Oelama' tentang Taqlied, " Al-Lisaan 4 (7 March 1936), 28-30;.
159. Mughni, Hassan Bandung, 414;.
160. "Boeat Orang Matikah atau Orang Hidup?" 8.
161. Hassan, "Berita Nahdlatoel-'Oelama', " 29-30.
162. A. Hassan, "Gambar, " Pembela Islam 4 (January 1930), 49-51;.
163. A. Hassan. "Dari Hal Gambar, " in Soal-Jawab, vol. 1, 63-347.
164. Atjeh, WahidHasjim, 216.
165. Yusuf, Syam, and Mas'udi, Kaum Santri, 9, 4-13.
166. A. Hassan, "PSII dengan Salat, " Pembela Islam 49 (July 1932), 20;.
167. Yusuf, Syam, and Mas'udi. "Mas-Aiah Foeroe', " Pembela Islam 2 (April 1956), 18;.
168. Yusuf, Syam, and Mas'udi. "Lagi-Lagi Masalah Foeroe', " Pembela Islam 44 (March 1932), 78;.
169. A. Hassan, "Openbare Debut PSII dengan Kaoem-Kaoem Foeroe', " Pembela Islam 44 '(March 1932), 434.
170. A. Hassan, "Toean Salim Djadi D joe roe Foeroe', " Al-Lisaan 24 (April 1938), 21;.
171. Mughni, Hassan Bandung, 8-97;.
172. "Isa Anshary; Pertentangan Ideologic Tak Perlu Timbulkan Perpetjahan Nasional, " Suara Merdeka (28 December 1954), 3.
173. Ilusain Al-Habsji, RisdahLabirfjfitMadzhab;angMengbaramkanMadzhab! (Surabaja: P.P. Alaydrus, 1956), 4-5.
174. Hassan, Mendjawab Buku Bantaban, 5.
175. Husain Al-Habsji, Risalab Haramkah Orang Bermadzhab? (Surabaja: Toko Kitab Assegaf, 1957), 5.
176. Habsji, Lahimja Madzhab, 2-11, .
177. Hassan, Mendjawab Buku Bantaban, 12, 21.
178. Habsji, Haramkah Orang Bermadzhab? 2-11.
179. Habsji, Lahimja Madz hab, 25, 30;.
180. Habsji, Haramkah Orang Bermadzhab? 13.
181. Habsji, Lahimja Madzhab, 6-14, 19.
182. Khafif, Ikbtilaf al-Fuqaha', 110;.
183. Shafi'I, Risalab, 4-562;.
184. Muhammad I lasbi Ash-Shiddieqy, Sebab-Sebab Perbedaan Fabam Para Ulama dalam Hukum-FIukum Sjard (Jogjakarta: IAIN Sunan Kalijaga, 1969), 3, 5.
185. Habsji, Labirnja Madzhab, 32.
186. Hassan, Ijma', 120.
187. Ibn 'Abd al-Barr, Bayan al- 'Ilm, 394.
188. Habsji, Haramkah Orang Bermadzhab? 15.
189. Djaja, Hassan, 29.
190. Hassan, Men jawab Buku Bantaban, 4-5, 27.
191. A. Hassan, "Masih Mahu Tjari- Tjari Djuri, " a pamphlet issued on 10 December 1956.
192. Habsji, Haramkah Orang Bermadzhab? 4.
193. E, Gellner, "A Pendulum Swing Theory of Islam, " Annates de sociologie (1968), 5-14, .
194. Roland Robertson (Victoria, Australia: Penguin Books, 1969), 38-127.
195. Kerr, Islamic Reform, 75.
196. Hatm H. Cohn, "Secularization of Divine Law, " Scripta Hierosolymitana 16 (1966), 55-103.