Cycles in deregulated electricity markets: Empirical evidence from two decades

Energy Policy

Volumn 39, Issue 5, 2011, Pages 2457-2466

  Arango, Santiago ^a,b   Larsen, Erik ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF LUGANO   (Switzerland)

^b UNIVERSIDAD NACIONAL DE COLOMBIA   (Colombia)

Author keywords

Cycles; Deregulation; Electricity markets

Indexed keywords

AUTOCORRELATION ANALYSIS; BEHAVIORAL SIMULATION; CAPACITY PAYMENTS; CAPITAL-INTENSIVE INDUSTRY; CONSUMER PRICES; CYCLES; DEREGULATED ELECTRICITY MARKET; DEREGULATED MARKETS; ELECTRICITY COMPANIES; ELECTRICITY GENERATION; ELECTRICITY MARKET; ELECTRICITY MARKETS; ELECTRICITY SYSTEM; EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE; GENERATION CAPACITY; QUALITATIVE BEHAVIOR; SECURITY OF SUPPLY;

COMMERCE; COMPUTER SIMULATION; ELECTRIC GENERATORS; ELECTRICITY; POWER QUALITY; PROFITABILITY;

DEREGULATION;

AUTOCORRELATION; COMMODITY PRICE; COMPUTER SIMULATION; DEREGULATION; ELECTRICITY GENERATION; ELECTRICITY SUPPLY; HYPOTHESIS TESTING; PROFITABILITY;

CHILE; ENGLAND; UNITED KINGDOM;

EID: 79953315738     PISSN: 03014215     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.enpol.2011.02.010     Document Type: Article

References (93)

1. Alvarez-Ramirez J., Escarela-Perez R., Espinosa-Perez G., Urrea R. Dynamics of electricity market correlations. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications 2009, 388(11):2173-2188.
2. Arango, A., Castañeda, J., Larsen, E., 2011. Mothballing in power markets: an experimental study. Working Paper, University of Lugano, Switzerland, 12 pp.
3. Arango, S. 2006. Essays on commodity cycles based on expanded Cobweb experiments of electricity markets. Ph.D. Thesis, The University of Bergen, Norway. ISBN: 82-308-0290-4. Available on line at http://https://bora.uib.no/handle/1956/2027.
4. Arango, S., Larsen, E.R., 2010. The environmental paradox in generation: how South America gradually became more dependent on thermal generation. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 14(9), 2956-2965; Working Paper, University of Lugano, Switzerland.
5. Assili M., Hossein M., Javidi D.B., Ghazi R. An improved mechanism for capacity payment based on system dynamics modeling for investment planning in competitive electricity environment. Energy Policy 2008, 36(10):3703-3713.
6. Ausubel L.M., Cramtom P. Using forward markets to improve electricity market design. Utilities Policy 2010, 18(4):195-200.
7. Backus G., Bayliss S. The Dynamics of U.S. Electrical Utility Regulation 1996, Department of Energy, Office of Utility Technology, Washington, DC.
8. Bakken, B.E., 1993. Learning and transfer of understanding in dynamic decision environment. Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis, MIT, Cambridge, MA, 255 pp.
9. Berends P., Romme A. Cyclicality of capital-intensive industries: a system dynamics study of the paper industry. Omega 2001, 29:543-552.
10. Bidwell M., Henney A. Will the new electricity trading arrangements ensure generation adequacy?. The Electricity Journal 2004, 17(7):15-38.
11. Botterud, A. Doorman, G., 2008. Generation Investment and Capacity Adequacy in Electricity Markets. International Association for Energy Economics, Second Quarter.
12. Brennan M.J., Schwartz E.S. Evaluating natural resource investments. Journal of Business 1985, 58(2):135-157.
13. Bunn D.W., Larsen E.R. Assessment of the uncertainty in future UK electricity investment using an industry simulation model. Utilities Policy 1994, 4(3):229-236.
14. Bunn D.W., Larsen E.R. Sensitivity of reserve margin to factors influencing investment behaviour in the electricity market of England and Wales. Energy Policy 1992, 20(5):420-429.
15. Caramanis M.C. Investment decisions and long-term planning under electricity spot pricing. IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems 1982, PAS-101(12):4640-4648.
16. Caramanis M.C., Bohn R.E., Schweppe F.C. Optimal spot pricing: practice and theory. IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems 1982, PAS-101(9):3234-3245.
17. Cashin P., McDermott C., Scott, A.J. Booms and slumps in world commodity prices. Journal of Development Economics 2002, 69:277-296.
18. Cashin, P., & Patillo, C., 2000. Terms of Trade Shocks in Africa: Are they Short-Lived of Long Live? Working Paper 00/72, International Monetary Fund, Washington.
19. CDEC-SIC, 2009. Operation Statistics (several years). Central Interconnected Electric System/Load Economic Dispatch Center. Santiago, Chile. Available at Last visit in November 2009. http://https://www.cdec-sic.cl/datos/anuario2009_ing.pdf.
20. CIA, 2009. CIA The World Factbook. Available at Last visit in November 2009. http://https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/.
21. Cramton C., Stoft S. Forward reliability markets: less risk, less market power, more efficiency. Utilities Policy 2008, 16(3):194-201.
22. Cuddington J.T., Urzua C.M. Trends and cycles in the net barter terms of trade: a new apporach. The Economic Journal 1989, 99(396):426-442.
23. de Vries L., Heijnen P. The impact of electricity market design upon investment under uncertainty: the effectiveness of capacity mechanisms. Utilities Policy 2008, 16(3):215-227.
24. de Vries, L.J., Hakvoort, R.A., 2004. The Question of Generation Adequacy in Liberalised Electricity Markets. Working Papers No. 120.2004, Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei.
25. Deaton A. Commodity prices and growth in Africa. The Journal of Economic Perspectives 1999, 13(3):23-40.
26. Deaton A., Laroque G. On the behaviour of commodity prices. Review of Economic Studies 1992, 59:1-24.
27. Deaton A., Laroque G. Competitive storage and commodity price dynamics. Journal of Political Economy 1996, 104:896-923.
28. Deaton A., Laroque G. A model of commodity prices after Sir Arthur Lewis. Journal of Development Economics 2003, 71:289-310.
29. Denton M.J., Rassenti S.J., Smith V.L., Backerman R.S. Market power in a deregulated electrical industry. Decision Support Systems 2001, 30(3):357-381.
30. DiPasquale D., Wheaton W.C. Urban Economics and Real Estate Markets 1996, Prentice Hall.
31. DUKES, 2009. Digest of UK energy statistics' (DUKES) Plant capacity: United Kingdom (DUKES 5.7). Available at http://www.decc.gov.uk/en/content/cms/statistics/source/electricity/electricity.aspx.
32. ENTSOE, 2009. Nordic annual report (several years). European Network of Transmission System Operators for Electricity. Available at Last visit November 2009. http://www.entsoe.eu//index.php?id=66.
33. EuroStat, 2010. European Statitics,, last visit on December 2010. http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat.
34. Ezekiel M. The Cobweb Theorem. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 1938, 52(2):255-280.
35. Fishbone L.G., Abilock H. Markal, a linear-programming model for energy systems analysis. International Journal of Energy Research 1981, 5(4):353-375.
36. Ford A. Cycles in competitive electricity markets. Energy Policy 1999, 27:637-658.
37. Ford A. Waiting for the boom: a simulation study of power plant construction in California. Energy Policy 2001, 29:847-869.
38. Ford A. Boom and bust in power plant construction: lessons from the California electricity crisis. Journal of Industry, Competition and Trade 2002, 2(1-2):59-74.
39. Gilbert C.L. Trends and volatility in agricultural commodity prices. Agricultural Commodity Markets and Trade: New Approaches to Analyzing Market Structure and Instability 2006, 31-60. Edward Elgar Publishing and FAO, Cheltenham Glos. A. Sarris, D. Hallam (Eds.).
40. Gnansounou E., Pierre S., Quintero A., Dong J., et al. Toward a multi-agent architecture for market oriented planning in electicity supply industry. International Journal of Power and Energy Systems 2007, 27:82-91.
41. Gnansounou E., Pierre S., Quintero A., Dong J., Lahlou A. A multi-agent approach for planning activities in decentralized electricity markets. Knowledge-Based Systems 2007, 20:406-418.
42. Green R. Investments in generation capacity. Competitive Electricity Markets and Sustainability 2006, 21-53. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham. F. Lévĉque (Ed.).
43. Green R. Electricity and markets. The New Energy Paradigm 2007, Oxford University Press, United Kingdom. Helm (Ed.).
44. Haikel, K.M., 2009a. A game theoretic model for generation capacity adequacy in electricity markets: A comparison between incentive mechanisms. Working Paper WP 9-05, GATE Groupe d'Analyse et de Théorie Économique.
45. Haikel, K.M., 2009b. Long term system adequacy in the energy system: capacity obligations vs reliability contracts: the French Electricity Market. Working Paper WP 9-05, GATE Groupe d'Analyse et de Théorie Économique.
46. He X., Westerhoff F.H. Commodity markets, price limiters and speculative price dynamics. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 2005, 29(9):1577-1596.
47. Helm D. The New Energy Paradigm 2007, Oxford University Press, United Kingdom.
48. Hunt S. Making Competition Work in Electricity 2002, Wiley, New York, NY.
49. IEA Statistics, 2011. International Energy Agency, OECD/IEA,, last visit on January 2011. http://wds.iea.org.
50. IEA, 1999. Electricity Market Reform: An IEA Handbook. International Energy Agency, OECD, 107 pp.
51. IEA, 2001. Competition in Electricity Markets. OECD/IEA, Paris, France.
52. IEA, 2002. Security of Supply in Electricity Markets: Evidence and Policy Issues. OECD/IEA, Paris, France, 177 p.
53. IEA, 2003. Power Generation Investment in Electricity Markets Competition in Electricity Markets. OECD/IEA, Paris, France, 104 pp.
54. IEA, 2007. Tackling Investment Challenges in Power Generation in IEA Countries. OECD/IEA, Paris, France, 210 pp.
55. Joskow, P., 2008. Lessons Learned from Electricity Market Liberalization. The Energy Journal, Special Issue on The Future of Electricity, Papers in Honor of David Newbery, pp. 9-42.
56. Joskow P., Tirole J. Reliability and competitive electricity markets. RAND Journal of Economics 2007, 38(1):60-84.
57. Kadoya T., Sasaki T., Ihara S., Larose E., Sanford M., Graham A.K., Stephens C.A., Eubanks C.K. Utilizing system dynamics modeling to examine impact of deregulation on generation capacity growth. Proceedings of the IEEE 2005, 93(11):2060-2069.
58. Kiesling L., Wilson B.J. An experimental analysis of the effects of automated mitigation procedures on investment and prices in wholesale electricity markets. Journal of Regulatory Economics 2007, 31(3):313-334.
59. Kirschen D.S., Strbac G. Fundamentals of Power Systems Economics 2004, Wiley, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester.
60. Kočan M. Cyclic behavior in dynamic investment decisions for deregulated energy markets. Central European Journal of Operations Research 2008, 16(1):67-78.
61. Krapels, E., Stagliano, V., 1996. Power in the commodity markets. Public Utilities Fortnightly.
62. Kummerow M.A. System dynamics model of cyclical office oversupply. Journal of Real Estate Research 1999, 18(1):233-255.
63. Larsen E.R., Bunn D.W. Deregulation in the electricity sector: understanding strategic and regulatory risk. Journal of the Operational Research Society 1999, 50:337-344.
64. Littlechild S. Competition and contracts in the Nordic residential electricity markets. Utilities Policy 2006, 14(3):135-147.
65. Loehr G. Ten myths about electric deregulation. Public Utilities Fortnightly 1998, 15.
66. Lomi A., Larsen E. Learning without experience: understanding the strategic implications of deregulation and competition in the electricity industry. European Management Journal 1999, 17(2):151-163.
67. Muth J. Rational expectations and the theory of price movements. Econometrica 1961, 29(3):315-335.
68. Nerlove M. Adaptive expectations and cobweb phenomena. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 1958, 72(2):227-240.
69. Newbery D. Power markets and market power. The Energy Journal 1995, 16(3):41-66.
70. Olsina F., Garcés F., Haubrich H.-J. Modeling long-term dynamics of electricity markets. Energy Policy 2006, 34(12):1411-1433.
71. Ozturk I. A literature survey on energy-growth nexus. Energy Policy 2010, 38(1):340-349.
72. POSTNOTE, 2003. Security of Electricity Supplies. Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology, September 2003, Number 203, 4 pp. Available at, last visit October, 2009. http://www.parliament.uk/post/pn203.pdf.
73. Raineri R. Chile: Where it all started. Electricity Market Reform: An International Perspective. Serie: Global Energy Policy and Economics 2006, 77-108. Elsevier. F.P. Sioshansi, W. Pfaffenberger (Eds.).
74. Randers J., Göluke U. Forecasting turning points in shipping freight rates: lessons from 30 years of practical effort. System Dynamics Review 2007, 23(2):253-284.
75. Rassenti S.J., Smith V.L., Wilson B.J. Controlling market power and price spikes in electricity networks: demand-side bidding. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2003, 100(5):2998-3003.
76. Redl C., Haasa R., Hubera C., Böhm B. Price formation in electricity forward markets and the relevance of systematic forecast errors. Energy Economics 2009, 31(3):356-364.
77. Roques F.A. Market design for generation adequacy: healing causes rather than symptoms. Utilities Policy 2008, 16(3):171-183.
78. Roques F.A., Newbery D.M., Nuttall W.J. Investment incentives and electricity market design: the British experience. Review of Network Economics 2005, 4(2):93-128.
79. 2003, IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ. G. Rothwell, T. Gómez (Eds.).
80. Sensfuß, F., Ragwitz, M., Genoese, M., Möst, D., 2007. Agent-based simulation of electricity markets-a literature review. Working Paper 5/2007, Fraunhofer Institute, Systems and Innovations Research.
81. Sharp J.A. The dynamics of the UK chemical plant investment cycle. European Journal of Operational Research 1982, 9:238-247.
82. Competitive Electricity Markets 2008, Elsevier, Amsterdam. F. Sioshansi (Ed.).
83. Electricity Market Reform 2006, Elsevier, Oxford. F. Sioshansi, W. Pfaffenberger (Eds.).
84. Slutsky E. The summation of random causes as the source of cyclic processes. Econometrica 1937, 5:105-135.
85. Spraos J. The statistical debate of the Net Barter terms of the trade between primary commodities and manufactures. The Economic Journal 1990, 90:107-128.
86. Sterman, J.D., 2000. Business Dynamics: Systems Thinking and Modeling for a Complex World. Irwin/McGraw-Hill.
87. Stoft S.E. Power System Economics: Designing Markets for Electricity 2002, IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ.
88. Sweeney J.L. The California Electricity Crisis 2002, Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA.
89. SYS, 2009. National Grid: Seven Year Statement. Several years report. Available on line at Last visit on November, 2009. http://www.nationalgrid.com/uk/Electricity/SYS/.
90. Tesfatsion L., Judd K.L. Handbook of Computational Economics 2006, vol. 2. North-Holland, Amsterdam.
91. The Economist, 2009. The looming electricity crunch, Dark days ahead. The Economist, August 8, 2009, pp. 27-29.
92. White A. Concentrated power. Public utilities fortnightly. Arlington 2005, 143(2):43-47.
93. Wittmann T. Agent-based Models of Energy Investment Decisions 2008, Physica-Verlag, Heidelberg.