Wind Power Compensation is not for the Birds: An Opinion from an Environmental Economist

Restoration Ecology

Volumn 19, Issue 2, 2011, Pages 147-153

  Cole, Scott G ^a  

^a SWEDISH UNIVERSITY OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES   (Sweden)

Author keywords

Compensatory mitigation; Compensatory restoration; EIA; No net loss; Restoration scaling

Indexed keywords

CONSERVATION MANAGEMENT; ECOLOGICAL IMPACT; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT; HABITAT MANAGEMENT; WILDLIFE MANAGEMENT; WIND POWER; WIND TURBINE;

AVES; RAPTORES;

EID: 79952256373     PISSN: 10612971     EISSN: 1526100X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1526-100X.2010.00771.x     Document Type: Article

References (55)

1. Ahlen, I. 2008. Vindkraft-ett hot för fåglar och fladdermöss? (Wind power-a threat for birds and bats?) In Swedish. Biodiverse 13:10-11. URL [accessed on 10 March 2010].
2. Arnett, E. B., W. K. Brown, W. P. Erickson, J. K. Fiedler, B. L. Hamilton, T. H. Henry, et al. 2008. Patterns of bat fatalities at wind energy facilities in North America. Journal of Wildlife Management 72:61-78.
3. (AWWI) American Wind and Wildlife Institute. 2010. Request for proposal: AWWI Research Initiative Wind Wildlife Research Information System. Contact: Dr. Judd A. Howell, Research Director. URL [accessed on 21 July 2010].
4. Bevanger, K., S. Clausen, E. Lie-Dahl, Ø. Flagstad, A. Follestad, J. O. Gjershaug, et al. 2008. Pre- and post-construction studies of conflicts between birds and wind turbines in coastal Norway. Progress Report 2008. NINA Report 409. 55 pp. URL [accessed on 10 January 2010].
5. (BPA) Bonneville Power Administration. 2010. BPA Statutes. Revised June. See "838i. Bonneville Power Administration fund." URL [accessed on 21 July 2010].
6. Breffle, W. S., and R. D. Rowe 2002. Comparing choice question formats for evaluating natural resource tradeoffs. Land Economics 78:298.
7. Bryce, R. 2009. Opinion: windmills are killing our birds. The Wall Street Journal. September 7, section: Commentary.
8. Carson, R., R. Mitchell, M. Hanemann, R. Kopp, S. Presser, and P. Ruud 2003. Contingent valuation and lost passive use: damages from the Exxon Valdez oil spill. Environmental and Resource Economics 25:257-286.
9. (CCC) County of Contra Costa. 2005. Final Environmental Impact Report: Buena Vista Wind Energy Project LP#022005. Community Development Department. April. URL [accessed on 21 July 2010].
10. st edition. Island Press, Washington, D.C.
11. Cole, S. G., and B. G. Kriström 2008. Annex 5: Discounting. In: REMEDE Toolkit (see Lipton et al. 2008). Umeå. URL [accessed on 20 September 2009].
12. Cole, S. G. 2010. "How much is enough?" Determining adequate levels of environmental compensation for wind power impacts using equivalency analysis: an illustrative & hypothetical case study of sea eagle impacts at the Smøla Wind Farm, Norway. Epsilon Open Archive Publishing, Swedish Agricultural University. URL [accessed on 28 May 2010].
13. Dunford, R. W., T. C. Ginn, and W. H. Desvousges 2004. The use of habitat equivalency analysis in natural resource damage assessments. Ecological Economics 48:49-70.
14. Dwyer, J. 2009. Personal communication with PhD Student, Department of Fisheries and Wildlife Sciences, Virginia Tech. October 11.
15. (EEI) Ecology and Environment, Inc. 2007. Montezuma Wind Project Final Environmental Impact Report. Prepared for Solano County Department of Resource Management. URL [accessed on 12 September 2009].
16. English, E. P., C. H. Peterson, and C. M. Voss 2009. Ecology and economics of restoration scaling, final report for Coastal Response Research Center, Appendix C. URL [accessed on 10 April 2010].
17. (FIMW) Federal Interagency Mitigation Working Group. 2002. National Wetlands Mitigation Action Plan. URL [accessed on 19 July 2010].
18. (GAO) Government Accounting Office. 2005. Wind power: impacts on wildlife and government responsibilities for regulating development and protecting wildlife. GAO-05-906 September 16. URL [accessed on 21 July 2010].
19. Helander, B., and T. Stjernberg 2003. Species action plan for the conservation of White-tailed Eagle. Birdlife International, Convention on the Conservation of European Wildlife and Natural Habitats. URL [accessed on 14 July 2009].
20. Helander, B., J. Axelsson, H. Borg, K. Holm, and A. Bignert 2009. Ingestion of lead from ammunition and lead concentrations in white-tailed sea eagles (Haliaeetus albicilla) in Sweden. Science of the Total Environment 407:5555-5563.
21. Hobbs, R. 2009. Looking for the silver lining: making the most of failure. Restoration Ecology 17:1-3.
22. (IEc) Industrial Economics, Inc. 2004. Final Lake Apopka Natural Resource Damage Assessment and Restoration Plan. Prepared for US Fish and Wildlife Service, June. URL [accessed on 20 September 2009].
23. Johansson, P. O. 1991. An introduction to modern welfare economics. Cambridge University Press, United Kingdom.
24. Jones, C. A., and K. A. Pease 1997. Restoration-based compensation measures in natural resource liability statutes. Contemporary Economic Policy 15:111-122.
25. Kiesecker, J. M., H. Copeland, A. Pocewicz, N. Nibbelink, B. McKenney, J. Dahlke, M. Halloran, and D. Stroud 2009. A framework for implementing biodiversity offsets: selecting sites and determining scale. Bioscience 59:77-84.
26. Kiesecker, J. M., H. Copeland, A. Pocewicz, and B. McKenney 2010. Development by design: blending landscape-level planning with the mitigation hierarchy. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 8:261-266.
27. Krone, O., T. Grunkorn, M. Gippert, and T. Durr 2008. White-tailed sea eagles and wind power plants in Germany-preliminary results. In Birds of Prey and Wind Farms. Documentation of an International Workshop in Berlin, 21-22 October (Editor H. Hötker). Germany. URL [accessed on 10 May 2010].
28. Kunz, T. H., E. B. Arnett, B. M. Cooper, W. P. Erickson, R. P. Larkin, T. Mabee, M. L. Morrison, M. D. Strickland, and J. M. Szewczak 2007. Assessing impacts of wind-energy development on nocturnally active birds and bats. Journal of Wildlife Management 71:2449-2486.
29. Kuvlesky, Jr., W. P., L. A. Brennan, M. I. Morrison, K. K. Boydston, B. M. Ballard, and F. C. Bryant 2007. Wind energy development and wildlife conservation: challenges and opportunities. Journal of Wildlife Management 71:2487-2498.
30. Langston, R. W., and J. D. Pullan 2003. Windfarms and birds: an analysis of the effects of wind farms on birds, and guidance on environmental criteria and site selection issues. By BirdLife International to the Council of Europe, Bern Convention. RSPB/Birdlife in the UK. URL [accessed on 10 September 2009].
31. Lipton, J., K. LeJeune, J. Calewaert, and E. Ozedemiroglu 2008. Toolkit for performing resource equivalency analysis to assess and scale environmental damage in the European Union. Produced by the Resource Equivalency Methods for Assessing Environmental Damage in the EU (REMEDE) Team. Funded by the Sixth Framework Programme of the EC. September. URL [accessed on 20 September 2009].
32. de Lucas, M., G. F. E. Janss, D. P. Whitfield, and M. Ferrer 2008. Collision fatality of raptors in wind farms does not depend on raptor abundance. Journal of Applied Ecology 45:1695-1703.
33. Maisonneuve, C. 2009. Email communication with wildlife biologist, Quebec Ministry of Natural Resources (MNR). October 30.
34. McKenney, B., and J. Kiesecker 2010. Policy development for biodiversity offsets: a review of offset frameworks. Environmental Management 45:165-176.
35. Mitchell, R., and R. T. Carson 1989. Using surveys to value public goods: the contingent valuation method. Resources for the Future, Washington, D.C.
36. Moilanen, A., A. J. A. V. Teeffelen, Y. Ben-Haim, and S. Ferrier 2008. How much compensation is enough? A framework for incorporating uncertainty and time discounting when calculating offset ratios for impacted habitat. Restoration Ecology 17:470-478.
37. (NOAA) National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. 1995. Habitat equivalency analysis: an overview. Originally published March 1995; updated 2001 and 2006. URL [accessed on 23 June 2010].
38. Ozdemiroglu, E., B. Kriström, S. Cole, P. Riera, and D. A. Borrego 2009. Environmental Liability Directive and the use of economics in compensation, offsets and habitat banking. Proceedings of UK Network for Environmental Economists. London, England, March.
39. Parsons, G. R., and A. K. Kang 2010. Compensatory restoration in a random utility model of recreation demand. Contemporary Economic Policy 28:453-463.
40. Smallwood, K. S. 2008. Mitigation in U.S. Wind Farms. In Birds of Prey and Wind Farms. Documentation of an International Workshop in Berlin, 21-22 October (Editor H. Hötker). Germany. URL [accessed on 10 May 2010].
41. Smallwood, K. S., and C. G. Thelander 2008. Bird mortality in the Altamont pass wind resource area, California. Journal of Wildlife Management 72:215-223.
42. Smallwood, K. S., C. G. Thelander, M. L. Morrison, and L. M. Rugge 2007. Burrowing owl mortality in the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area. Journal of Wildlife Management 71:1513-1524.
43. Solano Partners, Inc. 2009. Enabling progress: compensatory mitigation scenarios for wind energy projects in the U.S. Prepared for the American Wind and Wildlife Institute. September. URL [accessed on 19 July 2010].
44. Sperduto, M. B., S. P. Powers, and M. Donlan 2003. Scaling restoration to achieve quantitative enhancement of loon, seaduck, and other seabird populations. Marine Ecology Progress Series 264:221-232.
45. Swartzman, G. 1996. Resource modeling moves into the courtroom. Ecological Modeling 92:277-288.
46. Thur, S., and K. Barry 2006. The public's habitat preferences: an analysis: final summary report of the cross-habitat study focus groups. NOAA. January 24. URL [accessed on 28 June 2010].
47. Unsworth, R. E., and R. C. Bishop 1994. Assessing natural resource damages using environmental annuities. Ecological Economics 11:35-41.
48. (USCG) United Stated Coast Guard. 2006. Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund (OSLTF) funding for oil spills. NPFCPUB 16465.2. January. URL [accessed on 4 May 2010].
49. (USDOE) United States Department of Energy. 2010. Wind turbine interactions with birds, bats, and their habitats: a summary of research results and priority questions. Contract No. DE-AT01-07EE11218. Spring. URL [accessed on 28 June 2010].
50. Walker, D., M. McGrady, A. McCluskie, M. Madders, and D. R. A. McLeod 2005. Resident Golden Eagle ranging behaviour before and after construction of a windfarm in Argyll. Scottish Birds 25:24-40.
51. Wilkinson, J. B., J. M. McElfish, Jr, R. Kihslinger, R. Bendick, and B. McKenney 2009. The next generation of mitigation: linking current and future mitigation programs with state wildlife actions plans and other state and regional plans. Prepared by the Environmental Law Institute and The Nature Conservancy. August 4.
52. (WTGAC) Wind Turbine Guidelines Advisory Committee. 2010. Wind Turbine Guidelines Advisory Committee Recommendations. March 4. URL [accessed on 6 May 2010].
53. (WWEA) World Wind Energy Association. 2010. World wind energy report: 2009. March. URL [accessed on 21 July 2010].
54. Zafonte, M., and S. Hampton 2005. Lost bird-years: quantifying bird injuries in natural resource damage assessments for oil spills. Proceedings, 2005 International Oil Spill Conference. URL [accessed on 9 August 2010].
55. Zafonte, M., and S. Hampton 2007. Exploring welfare implications of resource equivalency analysis in natural resource damage assessments. Ecological Economics 61:134-145.