Comparing the effectiveness of informal and formal institutions in sustainable common pool resources management in sub-saharan Africa

Conservation and Society

Volumn 7, Issue 3, 2009, Pages 153-164

  Yami, Mastewal ^a   Vogl, Christian ^a   Hauser, Michael ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND LIFE SCIENCES   (Austria)

Author keywords

Common pool resources; Formal; Informal; Institutions; Sub Saharan Africa

Indexed keywords

EID: 79951545572     PISSN: 09724923     EISSN: 09753133     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.4103/0972-4923.64731     Document Type: Review

References (127)

1. Agrawal, A. 2001. Common property institutions and sustainable governance of resources. World Development 29(10): 1649-1672.
2. Agrawal, A. 2003. Sustainable governance of common pool resources: Context, methods, and politics. Annual Review of Anthropology 32: 243-262.
3. Agrawal, A. and C. Gibson. 1999. Enchantment and disenchantment: The role of community in natural resource conservation. World Development 27(4): 629-649.
4. Agrawal, A. and E. Ostrom. 2001. Collective action, property rights, and decentralisation in resource use in India and Nepal. Politics and Society 29(4): 485-514.
5. Alemayehu, W. 2002. Opportunities, constraints and prospects of Ethiopian orthodox tewahido churches in conserving forest resources: The case of churches in South Gonder, Northern Ethiopia. MSc thesis. University of Agricultural Sciences. Sweden.
6. Alemayehu, W. 2007. Ethiopian church forests: Opportunities and challenges for restoration. Ph.D. dissertation, Wageningen University, the Netherlands.
7. Amoako-Atta, B. 1998. Preservation of sacred groves in Ghana: Esukawkaw forest reserve and its anweam sacred grove. South-South Co-operation programme on environmentally sound socio-economic development in the humid tropics. Working Article No. 26.
8. Andersson, K., C. Gibson and F. Lehoucq. 2004. The politics of decentralised natural resource governance. Political Science and Politics 37(3): 421-426.
9. Anoliefo, G., O. Isikhuemhen and N. Ochije. 2003. Environmental Implications of the erosion of cultural taboo practises in Awka-South local government area of Anambra State, Nigeria: Forests, trees, and water resource preservation. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 16: 281-296.
10. Antinori, C. and G. Rausser. 2003. Does community involvement matter? How collective choice affects forests in Mexico. Berkeley: Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics, UC Berkeley. Working Article Series 939.
11. Appiah, M., D. Blay, L. Damnyag, F. Dwomoh, A. Pappinen, and O. Luukkanen. 2009. Dependence on forest resources and tropical deforestation in Ghana. Environment, Development and Sustainability 11(3): 471-487.
12. Appiah-Opoku, S. 1999. Indigenous economic institutions and ecological knowledge: A Ghanian case study. The Environmentalist 19: 217-227.
13. Appiah-Opoku, S. and G. Mulamoottil. 1997. Indigenous institutions and environmental assessment: The case of Ghana. Environmental Management 21(2): 159-171.
14. Arnold, M. and I. Townson. 1998. Assessing the potential of forest product activities to contribute to rural incomes in Africa. Natural Resource Perspective No. 37. London: ODI Overseas Development Institute.
15. Average, C. and M. Desmond. 2007. The history of natural resource management in Zimbabwe: A chronicle of how sustainable resource management has remained an elusive concept. Journal of Sustainable Development in Africa 9(2): 102-115.
16. Azuela, A. 2006. Illegal logging and local democracy: Between communitarianism and legal fetishism. Ambient Soc 9(1).
17. Baland, J. and J. Plateau. 1996. Halting degradation of natural resources: Is there a role for rural communities? Oxford: Clarendon Press.
18. Banana, A., N. Vogt, J. Bahati and W. Gombya-Ssembajjwe. 2007. Decentralised governance and ecological health: Why local institutions fail to moderate deforestation in MPIGI district of Uganda. Scientifi c Research and Essays 2 (10): 434-445.
19. Bandstein, S. 2005. Donor approaches to the development of institutions-Formal and informal rules: A partial overview. UTV Working Articles no 4. Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (SIDA). Department for Evaluation and Internal Audit.
20. Barrow, E., J. Clarke, I. Grundy, K. Jones and Y. Tessema. 2002. Analysis of stakeholder power and responsibilities in community involvement in forest management in Eastern and Southern Africa. Forest and Social Perspectives in Conservation no. 9, International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources.
21. Barrow, E., K. Ruhombe, I. Nhantumbo, R. Oyono, and M. Savadogo. 2009. Customary practises and forest tenure reforms in Africa-status, issues and lessons. Washington: Rights and Resources Initiative.
22. Bass, S., B. Dalal-Clayton and J. Pretty. 2005. Participation in strategies for sustainable development. Environmental Planning Issues 7: 155.
23. Bazaara, N. 2003. Environmental governance in Africa: Decentralisation, politics, and environment in Uganda. Working Articles no 7. World Resources Institute.
24. Beck, T. and C. Nesmith. 2001. Building on poor people's capacities: The case of common property resources in India and West Africa. World Development 29(1): 119-133.
25. Becker, L. 2001. Seeing green in Mali's woods: Colonial legacy, forest use, and local control. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 91(3): 504-526.
26. Bedru, B. 2007. Economic valuation and management of common-pool resources: The case of exclosures in the highlands of Tigray, Northern Ethiopia. Ph.D. dissertation. Department Landbeheer en-Economie, Katholieke Universiteit, Leuven: Belgium.
27. Benin, S., S. Ehui and J. Pender. 2003. Policies for livestock development in the Ethiopian highlands. Environment, Development and Sustainability 5: 491-510.
28. Benjaminsen, T. 1997. Natural resource management, paradigm shifts, and the decentralisation reform in Mali. Human Ecology 25(1): 121-143.
29. Bereket, K. 2002. Land tenure and common pool resources in rural Ethiopia: A study based on fi fteen sites. African Development Bank 14(1): 113-149.
30. Berhanu, G. and S. Swinton. 2002. Sustainable management of private and communal lands in Northern Ethiopia. In Natural resources management in African agriculture: Understanding and improving current practises (eds. Barrett, C., F. Place and A. Aboud). Pp. 77-90. Cabi Publishing.
31. Berhanu, G., J. Pender and T. Girmay. 2004. Collective action for grazing land management in mixed crop-livestock systems in the highlands of Northern Ethiopia. Agricultural Systems 82(3): 273-290.
32. Bernard, R. 2006. Research methods in anthropology: Qualitative and quantitative approaches. USA: AltaMira Press.
33. Berry, L. and T. Andersen. 2004. Operationalizing GEF's new GEF OP 15 on sustainable land management within World Bank instruments Sub-Saharan Africa. Pp. 24.
34. Bhagwat, S. and C. Rutte. 2006. Sacred groves: Potential for biodiversity management. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 10: 519-552.
35. Boku, T. and B. Irwin. 2003. Traditional institutions, multiple stakeholders and modern perspectives in common property: Accompanying change within Borana pastoral systems. Securing the Commons No. 4.
36. Bongers, F., W. Alemayehu, F. Sterck, B. Tesfaye and T. Demel. 2006. Ecological restoration and church forests in Northern Ethiopia. Journal of the Drylands 1(1): 35-44.
37. Bremner, J. and F. Lu. 2006. Common property among indigenous peoples of the Ecuadorian Amazon. Conservation and Society 4(4): 499-521.
38. Brown, D. 1999. Principles and practise of forest co-management: Evidence from west-central Africa. European Union Tropical Forestry Article no 2. London, Belgium: European Commission, Brussels.
39. Bryan, T. 2004. Tragedy averted: The promise of collaboration. Society and Natural Resources 17: 881-896.
40. Byers, B., R. Cunliffe and A. Hudak. 2001. Linking the conservation of culture and nature: A case study of sacred forests in Zimbabwe. Human Ecology 29(2): 187-218.
41. Campbell, B., A. Mandondo, N. Nemarundwe and B. Sithole. 2001. Challenges to proponents of common property resource systems: Despairing voices from the social forests of Zimbabwe. World Development 29(4): 589-600.
42. Carlsson, L. and F. Berkes. 2005. Co-management: Concepts and methodological implications. Journal of Environmental Management 75: 65-76.
43. Carruthers, B. 2007. Rules, institutions, and North's institutionalism: State and market in early modern England. European Management Review 4: 40-53.
44. Chakraborty, R. 2001. Stability and outcomes of common property institutions in forestry: Evidence from the Terai region of Nepal. Ecological Economics 36(2): 341-353.
45. Chisholm, N. 1998. Community-based natural resource management in Tigray, Northern Ethiopia. The World Bank/WBI's CBNRM Initiative.
46. Clover, J. 2003. Food security in Sub-Saharan Africa. African Security Review 12(1): 1-15.
47. Cocks, M., A. Dold and I. Grundy. 2001. Challenges facing a community structure to implement CBNRM in the eastern Cape, South Africa. African Studies Quarterly 5(3). http://web.africa.ufl .edu/asq/v5/v5i3a4. htm. Accessed on 23 June, 2008.
48. Colding, J. and C. Folke. 2001. Social taboos: 'Invisible' systems of local resource management and biological conservation. Ecological Application 11: 584-600.
49. Dietz, T., E. Ostrom and P. Stern. 2003. The struggle to govern the commons. Science 302: 1907-1912.
50. Dore, D. 2001. Transforming traditional institutions for sustainable natural resource management: History, narratives and evidence from Zimbabwe. African Quarterly 5(3). http://web.africa.ufl .edu/asq/v5/v5i3a1.htm, Accessed on 23 June, 2008.
51. Esenjoraf, A. 2004. A community-based conservation programme for the management and conservation of land resources in Lesotho. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Sociology of the Faculty of Humanities, University of the Free State Bloemfontein, Republic of South Africa. FAO. 1999. State of the world's forests. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations.
52. Farrington, J. and C. Boyd. 1997. Scaling up the participatory management of common pool resources. Development Policy Review 15: 371-391.
53. Feeny, D. 1988. The demand for and supply of institutional arrangements. In Rethinking institutional analysis and development (eds. Ostrom, V., D. Feeny and H. Picht). San Francisco: ICS Press.
54. Frost, P., B. Campbell, M. Luckert, M. Mutamba, A. Mandondo, and W.Kozanayi. 2007. In search of improved rural livelihoods in semi-Arid regions through local management of natural resources: Lessons from case studies in Zimbabwe. World Development 35(11): 1961-1974.
55. Zenebe, F. Alinyo, M. Ashenafi , A. Kassahun, T. Tessema, J. Zewdie, and B. Kifl u. 2007. Enabling equitable collective action and policy change for poverty reduction and improved natural resource management in Ethiopia and Uganda. AHI Working Article No. 25.
56. Gessesse, D. 2007. Forest decline in south central Ethiopia: Extent, history and process. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Physical Geography and Quaternary Geology, Stockholm: Stockholm University. Sweden.
57. Ghate, R. and H. Nagendra. 2005. Role of monitoring in institutional performance: Forest management in Maharashtra, India. Conservation and Society 3(2): 509-532.
58. Gibson, C., J. Williams and E. Ostrom. 2004. Local enforcement and better forests. World Development 33(2): 273-284.
59. Girma, A. 2005. Rehabilitation and sustainable use of degraded community forests in the Bale mountains of Ethiopia. Ph.D. dissertation, Faculty of Forest and Environmental Sciences, Albert-Ludwigs-University, Freiburg im Breisgau, Germany.
60. Girmay, T. 2006. Agriculture, resource management and institutions: A socio economic analysis of households in Tigray, Ethiopia. Ph.D. Dissertation, Wageningen University, Netherlands.
61. Haller, T. 2002b. The understanding of institutions and their link to resource management from a new institutionalism perspective. Working Article no 1, IP 6 Institutional Change and Livelihood Strategies.
62. Hardin, G. 1968. The tragedy of the commons. Science 162: 1243-1248.
63. Haro, G., G. Doyo and J. McPeak. 2004. Linkages between community, environmental, and confl ict management: Experiences from northern Kenya. World Development 33(2): 285-299.
64. Hart, C. 1999. Doing a literature review: Releasing the social science research imagination. London: SAGE Publications Ltd.
65. Hart, C. 2001. Doing a literature search: A comprehensive guide for the social sciences. London: SAGE Publications Ltd.
66. Heltberg, R. 2002. Property rights and natural resource management in developing countries. Journal of Economic Surveys 16(2): 189-214.
67. Hira, A. and R. Hira. 2000. The new institutionalism: Contradictory notions of change. American Journal of Economics and Sociology 59(2): 267-282.
68. Hotimsky, S., R. Cobb and A. Bond. 2006. Contracts or scripts? A critical review of the application of institutional theories to the study of environmental change. Ecology and Society 11(1): 41.
69. Kamara, A., B. Swallow and M. Kirk. 2004. Policies, interventions and institutional change in pastoral resource management in Borana, Southern Ethiopia. Development Policy Review 22(4): 381-403.
70. Koku, E. and J. Gustafsson. 2003. Local institutions and natural resource management in the South Tongu District of Ghana: A case study. Sustainable Development 11: 17-35.
71. Lambin, E., H. Geist and E. Lepers. 2003. Dynamics of land-use and landcover change in tropical regions. Annual Review of Environmental Resources 28: 205-241.
72. Leach, M., R. Mearns and I. Scoones. 1997. Environmental entitlements: A framework for understanding the institutional dynamics of environmental change. IDS Discussion Article 359, Sussex.
73. Leach, M., R. Mearns and I. Scoones. 1999. Environmental entitlements: Dynamics and institutions in community-based natural resource management. World Development 7(2): 225-247.
74. Lovett, C., H. Quinn, G. Ockwell and R. Gregorowski. 2006. Two cultures and tragedy of the commons. African Journal of Ecology 44: 1-5.
75. Lund, C. 2006. Twilight institutions: An introduction. Development and Change 37(4): 673-684.
76. Makepe, P. 2006. The evolution of institutions and rules governing communal grazing lands in Botswana. Eastern Africa Social Science Research Review 22(1): 39-61.
77. Mansuri, G. and V. Rao. 2004. Community-based and-driven development: A critical review. The World Bank Research Observer 19(1): 1-39.
78. Maponga, R. and J. Muzirambi. 2007. Indigenous knowledge in conservation of forestry and land resources in Musana communal areas, Bindura. Journal of Sustainable Development in Africa 9(2): 1-14.
79. Marothia, D. 2003. Institutions for common pool resources. In: Institutional change in Indian agriculture (eds. Mruthyunjaya, S., P. Joshi and R. Saxena). Pp. 61-81. Delhi: Chandu Press.
80. Masangano, C., D. Kayambazinthu and L. Mwabumba. 2003. Confl icts over the Miombo Woodlands: The case of Blantyre, Lilongwe and Kasungu, in Malawi. In: Policies and governance structures in woodlands of Southern Africa (eds. Kowero, G., B. Campbell and U. Sumaila). Pp. 65-79. Centre for International Forestry Research.
81. McKean, M. 1992. Success on the commons: A comparative examination of institutions for common property resource management. Journal of Theoretical Politics 4(2): 256-268.
82. Menghestab, H. 2005. Weather patterns, food security and humanitarian response in sub-Saharan Africa. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 360: 2169-2182.
83. Mgumia, F. and G. Oba. 2003. Potential role of sacred groves in biodiversity conservation in Tanzania. Environmental Conservation 30: 259-265.
84. Muchena, F. and J. van der Bliek. 1997. Planning sustainable land management: Finding a balance between user needs and possibilities. ITC Journal 3(4): 229-234.
85. Nathan, I., J. Lund, Q. Gausset and S. Andersen. 2007. On the promises of devolution: Overcoming the constraints of natural resource management in a village in Tanzania. The Journal of Trans disciplinary Environmental Studies 6(1): 1-20.
86. Nemarundwe, N. 2003. Negotiating resource access: Institutional arrangements for woodlands and water use in southern Zimbabwe. Ph.D. dissertation, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala.
87. Ngwa, N. and L. Fonjong. 2003. Actors, options and the challenges of forest management in anglophone cameroon. Geo Journal 57: 95-111.
88. Nhantumbo, I., S. Norfolk and J. Pereira. 2003. Community based natural resources management in Mozambique: A theoretical or practical strategy for local sustainable development? The case study of Derre forest reserve. Research Articles no 10. Sustainable Livelihoods in Southern Africa.
89. Nkonya, E., J. Pender and E. Kato. 2008. Who knows, who cares? Determinants of enactment, awareness and compliance with community natural resource management bylaws in Uganda. Environment and Development Economics 13: 79-101.
90. North, D. 1990. Institutions, institutional change and economic performance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
91. Olowu, D. 2 001. Decentralisation policies and practises under structural adjustment and democratisation in Africa. United Nations Research Institute for Social Development Programme Article No. 4.
92. Ostrom, E. 1990. Governing the commons: The evolution of institutions for collective action. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
93. Ostrom, E. 1999. Social capital: A fad or a fundamental concept. In: Social capital: A multifaceted perspective (eds. Dasgupta, P. and I. Serageldin). Washington DC: World Bank.
94. Ouinsavi, C., N. Sokpon and O. Bada. 2005. Utilisation and traditional strategies of in situ conservation of iroko (Milicia excelsa Welw. C.C. Berg) in Benin. Forest Ecology and Management 207: 341-350.
95. Owubah, C., D. Le Master, J. Bowker and J. Lee. 2001. Forest tenure systems and sustainable forest management. Forest Ecology and Management 149: 253-264.
96. Pagdee, A., Y. Kim and P. Daugherty. 2006. What makes community forest management successful: A meta-study from community forests throughout the world. Society and Natural Resources 19: 33-52.
97. Pankhurst, A. 2001. Natural resource management institutions in post-confl ict situations: State and community forests in Yegof, South Wello, Ethiopia. Marena Research Project Working Article No. 6.
98. Platteau, J. 1992. Land reform and structural adjustment in Sub-Saharan Africa: Controversies and guidelines. FAO Economic and Social Development Article No. 107. FAO.
99. Pretty, J. 2003. Social capital and the collective management of resources. Science 302: 1912-1915.
100. Ribot, J. 2002. Democratic decentralisation of natural resources: Institutionalising popular participation. Washington, DC: World Resources Institute.
101. Ribot, J. 2003. Democratic decentralisation of natural resources: Institutional choice and discretionary power transfers in sub-saharan Africa. Public Administration and Development 23(1): 12.
102. Ribot, J. 2004b. Waiting for democracy: The politics of choice in natural resource management. Washington, DC: World Resources Institute.
103. Ribot, J., A. Chhatre and T. Lankina. 2008. Institutional choice and recognition in the formation and consolidation of local democracy representation, Equity and Environment. Working Article No. 35. World Resources Institute.
104. Rohde, F., M. Moleele, M. Mphale, N. Allsopp, R. Chanda, T. Hoffman, L. Magole, and E. Young. 2006. Dynamics of grazing policy and practise: Environmental and social impacts in three communal areas of southern Africa. Environmental Science and Policy 9: 302-316.
105. Rudd, M. 2000. Live long and prosper: Collective action, social capital and social vision. Ecological Economics 34(234): 131-144.
106. Sandelowski, M. and J. Barroso. 2007. Handbook for synthesising qualitative research. New York: Springer Publishing Company, Inc.
107. Sandler, T. 1992. Collective action: Theory and applications. Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
108. Sarfo-Mensah, P. and W. Oduro. 2007. Traditional natural resources management practises and biodiversity conservation in Ghana: A review of local concepts and issues on change and sustainability. Nota Di Lavoro 90. Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei.
109. Scherr, S. 1999. Soil degradation: A threat to developing-country food security by 2020. Food, agriculture, and the environment discussion article no 27. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.
110. Shyamsundar, P., E. Araral and S. Weeraratne. 2005. Devolution of resource rights, poverty, and natural resource management: A review. Environmental Economics Series Article no 104. The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development. USA: The World Bank.
111. Skoog, G. 2005. Supporting the development of institutions-Formal and informal rules: An evaluation theme, basic concepts. UTV Working Articles no 3. Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (SIDA). Department for Evaluation and Internal Audit.
112. Steins, N. and V. Edwards. 1998. Harbour resource management in Cowes, Isle of Wight: An analytical framework for multiple-use. Journal of Environmental Management 54(1): 67-81.
113. Steins, N. and V. Edwards. 1999. Platforms for collective action in multiple-use common-pool resources. Agriculture and Human Values 16: 241-255.
114. Stern, P., T. Dietz, N. Dolšak, E. Ostrom and S. Stonich. 2002. Knowledge and questions after 15 years of research. In: The drama of the commons (ed. National Resource Council). Pp. 445-489. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
115. Tefera, M., T. Demel, H. Hultén and Y. Yonas. 2005. The role of communitiesin closed area management in Ethiopia. Journal of Mountain Research and Development 25(1): 44-50.
116. Tilahun, A., K. Habtemariam, Z. Gete, S. Abebe, S. Kismu, T. Melese. 2007. Working with communities and building local institutions for sustainable land management in the Ethiopian highlands. Mountain Research and Development 27(1): 15-19.
117. Topp-Jorgensen, E., M. Poulsen, J. Lund and J. Massao. 2005. Communitybased monitoring of natural resource use and forest quality in Montane forests and Miombo Woodlands of Tanzania. Biodiversity Conservation 14: 2653-2677.
118. Turyahabwe, N., C. Geldenhuys, S. Watts and A. Banana. 2006. Technical and institutional capacity in local organisations to manage decentralised forest resources in Uganda. Southern African Forestry Journal 208: 63-78.
119. Tyynelä, T. and A. Niskanen. 2000. Communal management and social benefi ts of Woodland resources in Mukarakate, North-Eastern Zimbabwe. In: Forests, chiefs and peasants in Africa: Local management of natural resources in Tanzania, Zimbabwe and Mozambique (eds. Virtanen, P. and M. Nummelin). Pp. 65-85. Silva Carelica 34: University of Joensuu. UNRISD. 1994. Environmental degradation and social integration. Briefi ng Article No 3. United Nations Research Institute for Social Development (UNRISD). World Summit for Social Development.
120. Virtanen, P. 2002. The role of customary institutions in the conservation of biodiversity: Sacred forests in Mozambique. Environmental Values 11: 227-241.
121. Von Benda-Beckmann, F., K. Von Benda-Beckman and M.G. Wiber. 2006. The properties of property. In: Changing properties of property (eds. Von Benda-Beckmann, F., K. Von Benda-Beckman and M.G. Wiber). Pp. 1-39. New York /Oxford.
122. Wardell, D. and C. Lund. 2006. Governing Access to forests in northern Ghana: Micro-politics and the rents of non-enforcement. World Development 34(11): 1887-1906.
123. Watson, E. 2001. Inter institutional alliances and confl icts in natural resource management: Preliminary research fi ndings from Borana, Oromia Region, Ethiopia. Working Article No. 4. Marena Research Project.
124. Watson, E. 2003. Examining the potential of indigenous institutions for development: A perspective from Borana, Ethiopia. Development and Change 34(2): 287-309.
125. Williams, T. 1998. Multiple uses of common pool resources in semi-Arid West Africa: A survey of existing practises and options for sustainable resource management. London: Natural Resources Perspective No. 38.
126. Ylhäisi, J. 2006. Traditionally protected forests and sacred forests of Zigua and Gweno ethnic groups in Tanzania. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Geography Faculty of Science, Helsingin Yliopiston Maantieteen Laitoksen Julkaisuja, Finland.
127. Zelealem T. and N. Leader-Williams. 2005. Indigenous common property resource management in the central highlands of Ethiopia. Human Ecology 33(4): 539-563.