The role of the financial services industry in the clean development mechanism: Involving private institutions in the carbon market

International Journal of Private Law

Volumn 4, Issue 1, 2011, Pages 32-53

  Weber, Rolf H ^a,b   Darbellay, Aline ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ZURICH   (Switzerland)

^b UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG   (Hong Kong)

Author keywords

Carbon certificates; Carbon fund; Carbon market; CDM; Clean development mechanism; Climate change; Financial services industry; Insurance

Indexed keywords

EID: 79251528552     PISSN: 17536235     EISSN: 17536243     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1504/IJPL.2011.037892     Document Type: Article

References (134)

1. Decision 2/CP.15 of the UNFCCC Report of the Conference of the Parties on its fifteenth session, held in Copenhagen from 7 to 19 December 2009, FCCC/CP/2009/11/Add.1 (30 March 2010) (Copenhagen Accord of 18 December 2009).
2. PointCarbon (2009) 'CDM market comment', CDM & JI Monitor, 23 December, Vol. 6, No. 26, p.2.
3. Garside, B. (2000) 'Carbon market growth to stall in 2010: report', in PointCarbon (Ed.): News, 20 January, Vol. 1.
4. Michaelowa, A. (2010) 'Copenhagen blues, the CDM in limbo', in PointCarbon (Ed): CDM & JI Monitor, 21 January, Vol. 7, No. 1.
5. Para 53 of Decision 2/CMP.5 of the UNFCCC Report of the Conference of the Parties serving as the meeting of the Parties to the Kyoto Protocol on its fifth session, held in Copenhagen from 7 to 19 December 2009, FCCC/KP/CMP/2009/21/Add.1 (30 March 2010) (Further guidance relating to the clean development mechanism).
6. Para 37 and 39(d) of further guidance relating to the clean development mechanism (n 5);.
7. PointCarbon, 'Developers win right of appeal at UN talks' (23 December 2009) in 6 CDM & JI Monitor, Issue 26, 1.
8. PointCarbon (2010) 'Gloomy investors mull Copenhagen fallout', CDM & JI Monitor, 21 January, Vol. 7, No. 1.
9. Tamiotti, L. et al. (2009) Trade and Climate Change, A Report by the United Nations Environment Programme and the World Trade Organization, p.90, WTO Publications, Geneva.
10. See further Michael Grubb and Karsten Neuhoff, 'Allocation and competitiveness in the EU emissions trading scheme: policy overview' (2006) Climate Policy Vol. 6, pp.7-8;.
11. see also Petitpierre-Sauvain, A. (2007) 'Les instruments économiques dans le protocole de Kyoto: l'instauration d'un marché des droits d'émission', Droit de l'environnement dans la Pratique (DEP), Vol. 87, pp.92-99.
12. Weimann, J. (2009) Klimapolitik im Zeitalter des Emissionshandels, pp.86-87 Wirtschaftswissenschaftliches Studium (WiST).
13. Carr, C. and Rosembuj, F. (2008) 'Flexible mechanisms for climate change compliance: emission offset purchases under the clean development mechanism', N.Y.U. Environmental Law Journal, Vol. 16, p.44.
14. de Sépibus, J. (2009) 'The environmental integrity of the CDM mechanism - a legal analysis of its institutional and procedural shortcomings', Working Paper No. 2009/24, May, NCCR Trade Regulation, p.4.
15. Art 12 of the Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (1998) (Kyoto Protocol);.
16. See Robert N. Stavins, 'A Meaningful U.S. Cap-and-Trade System to Address Climate Change' (2008) 32 HELR 293, 297.
17. Dutschke, M. and Michaelowa, A. (2006) 'Development assistance and the CDM - how to interpret 'financial additionality', Environment and Development Economics, Vol. 11, p.235.
18. Weber, R.H. and Darbellay, A. (2010) 'Regulation and financial intermediation in the Kyoto Protocol's clean development mechanism', GIELR, Vol. 22, pp.271-273.
19. Greiner, S. and Michaelowa, A. (2003) 'Defining investment additionality for CDM projects - practical approaches', Energy Policy, Vol. 31, pp.1007-1008;.
20. Michaelowa, A. and Purohit, P. (2007) 'Additionality determination of Indian CDM projects, Can Indian CDM Project Developers outwit the CDM Executive Board?', Climate Strategies, Vol. 1;.
21. Michaelowa, A. (2009) 'Interpreting the additionality of CDM projects: changes in additionality definitions and regulatory practices over time', in Freestone, D. and Streck, C. (Eds): Legal Aspects of Carbon Trading, Kyoto, Copenhagen, and Beyond, pp.248-249; Oxford University Press, Oxford.
22. Tvinnereim, E., Røine, K., Heimdal, C. and PointCarbon (2009) 'Carbon 2009 - emission trading coming home', 17 March, Vol. 4.
23. http://cdmpipeline.org/cers.htm (accessed 9 November 2010).
24. Capoor, K. and Ambrosi, P. (2008) State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2008, Vol. 2, The World Bank, Washington D.C.
25. Derwent, H. (2009) 'Carbon markets need bankers', Environmental Finance, Vol. 10, No. 10, p.16.
26. Weber, R.H. and Iseli, T. (2008) Vertriebsträger im Finanzmarktrecht, p.11, Schulthess, Zurich.
27. Arshadi, N. and Karels, G.V. (1997) Modern Financial Intermediaries and Markets, p.27, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River.
28. Greenbaum, S.I. and Thakor, A.V. (2007) Contemporary Financial Intermediation, 2nd ed., p.42, Elsevier Inc., Oxford.
29. Weber and Darbellay (n 15) 275.
30. Hahn, R. (2009) 'Climate policy: separating fact from fantasy', HELR, Vol. 33, pp.557-564.
31. See Endres, A. and Ohl, C. (2005) 'Kyoto, Europe? - an economic evaluation of the European Emission Trading Directive', European Journal of Law and Economics, Vol. 19, No. 17, p.22.
32. Carr and Rosembuj (n 11) 47.
33. Tuerk, A et al. (2008) 'The role of land-based offsets in emissions trading systems: key design aspects and considerations for linking', Working Paper 2, Climate Strategies, August, p.1.
34. Humphrey, J. (2004) 'The clean development mechanism: how to increase benefits for developing countries', IDS Bulletin, Climate Change and Development, Vol. 35, p.84.
35. Sokona, Y. and Nanasta, D. (2000) 'The clean development mechanism: an African delusion?', Change, Vol. 8, p.8, Research and Policy Newsletter on Global Change from the Netherlands.
36. Munich Re, Cycle Management, Climate Neutrality, Kyoto Multi Risk Policy (2007) Topics, Issue 2, 35.
37. Capoor and Ambrosi (n 19) 5.
38. Para 43 of of the Decision 17/CP.7 of the UNFCCC Report of the Conference of the Parties on its Seventh Session, Held at Marrakesh from 29 October to 10 November 2001, FCCC/CP/2001/13/Add.2 (21 January 2002) (Marrakesh Accords); the Marrakesh Accords supplemented the Kyoto Protocol and are crucial for the implementation of the CDM.
39. See also Humphrey (n 29) 85.
40. Button, J. (2008) 'Carbon: commodity or currency? the case for an international carbon market based on the currency model', HELR, Vol. 32, pp.571-584.
41. UNEP Risoe Center, 'CDM/JI Overview', at http://cdmpipeline.org/overview. htm (accessed on 9 November 2010).
42. Zumbach, A. (2008) Trading Certified Emission Reductions, Legal Aspects from a European and Swiss Perspective, p.19, VDM Verlag Dr. Müller, Saarbrücken.
43. Netto, M. and Schmidt, K-U.B. (2005) 'CDM project cycle and the role of the UNFCCC Secretariat', in D. Freestone and C. Streck (Eds.): Legal Aspects of Implementing the Kyoto Protocol Mechanisms: Making Kyoto Work, p.180, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
44. Para 36 of the Marrakesh Accords (n 33).
45. Schneider, F. and Wagner, A.F. (2003) 'Tradable permits - ten key design issues', CESifo Forum, Vol. 15, p.18.
46. Capoor and Ambrosi (n 19) 4-5.
47. See, for instance, Michaelowa, A. and Müller, B. (2009) 'The clean development mechanism in the future climate change regime, summary for policymakers', Climate Strategies, 31 May, Vol. 3.
48. 2 emissions trading', Weber, R.H. (Ed.): Stromhandel, p.72, Schulthess, Zurich;.
49. Weber, R.H. (2008) 'Emissions trading', in Vogt, N.P., Stupp, E. and Dubs, D. (Eds.): Unternehmen - Transaktion - Recht, Liber Amicorum für Rolf Watter zum 50. Geburtstag, p.488, Dike Verlag AG, Zurich.
50. Boyle, G. et al. (2009) 'Transitioning from the CDM to a clean development fund', CCLR, Vol. 16, No. 1, p.17.
51. Lof, R.M. (2009) 'Addressing market failures in the CDM: a funding-based approach', CCLR, Vol. 25, No. 1, p.27.
52. Capoor and Ambrosi (n 19) 4-5.
53. Humphrey (n 29) 87.
54. Lütken, S.E. and Michaelowa, A. (2008) Corporate Strategies and the Clean Development Mechanism, Developing Country Financing for Developed Country Commitments?, p.7, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.
55. Zumbach (n 36) 29.
56. Wemaëre, M. (2007) 'Legal nature of Kyoto units', in W.T. Douma, L. Massai and M. Montini (Eds.): The Kyoto Protocol and Beyond, Legal and Policy Challenges of Climate Change, p.72, TMC Asser Press, The Hague.
57. See Weber, R.H. and Darbellay, A. (2009) 'Vers une évolution des marchés financiers au service de la protection de l'environnement', in R.T. Trindade, H. Peter and C. Bovet (Eds): Economie Environnement Ethique, de la Responsabilité Sociale et Sociétale, Liber Amicorum Anne Petitpierre-Sauvain, pp.404-405, Schulthess, Geneva.
58. Delimatsis, P. (2009) 'Financial innovation and climate change: the case of renewable energy certificates and the role of the GATS', World Trade Review, Vol. 8, pp.439-447.
59. Weber and Darbellay (n 15) 293.
60. Tuerk, A. and Sterk, W. (2008) 'Joining the dots', Environmental Finance, Vol. 10, No. 2, Supplement, p.34.
61. See further Weber (n 42) 484-486.
62. Orlando, Ehrat and Faccoli (n 42) 71;.
63. Tuerk and others (n 28) 8;.
64. Joëlle de Sépibus, 'Linking the EU Emissions Trading Scheme to JI, CDM and post-2012 International Offsets' (October 2008) nccr trade regulation, Working Paper No. 2008/18, 7-9;.
65. see further Erich Vranes, 'Climate Change and the WTO: EU Emission Trading and the WTO Disciplines on Trade in Goods, Services and Investment Protection' (2009) 43 Journal of World Trade 710, 721.
66. Streck, C. (2007) 'Marketing CERs: legal and contractual issues for sellers', W.T. Douma, L. Massai and M. Montini (Eds.): The Kyoto Protocol and Beyond, Legal and Policy Challenges of Climate Change, p.85, TMC Asser Press, The Hague.
67. Voluntary Carbon Standard, 'Voluntary Carbon Standard Program Guidelines', (18 November 2008) 10.
68. Michaelowa (n 16) 250.
69. Michaelowa (n 16) 249.
70. Zumbach (n 36) 31.
71. Humphrey (n 29) 86.
72. See Capoor and Ambrosi (n 19) 59;.
73. see further Rolf H. Weber and Brigitta Kratz, Elektrizitä tswirtschaftsrecht (Stämpfli Verlag AG, Bern 2005) 339-340;.
74. see also Jonathan Hill, Thomas Jennings and Evie Vanezi, 'The emissions trading market: risks and challenges' (March 2008) London: FSA Commodities Group, 13-14.
75. See the homepage of the UNFCCC CDM Bazaar at accessed 9 November 2010.
76. Marioni, R. (2007) 'Les mécanismes de flexibilité dans la pratique', Die Volkswirtschaft, Das Magazin für Wirtschaftspolitik, No. 9, p.18.
77. Marioni (n 64) 18.
78. See the homepage of Camco at accessed 9 November 2010.
79. See Kouchakji, K. and Cundy, C. (2009) 'Carbon firms report strong start to 2009', Environmental Finance, Vol. 10, No. 10, p.11.
80. Streck (n 56) 79.
81. See further in the electricity market, 'Meinhardt, M. and Schwibs, N. (2007) 'Standardisierte verträge im stromhandel - der EFET-rahmenvertrag', in R.H. Weber (Ed): Stromhandel, Schulthess, Zurich, pp.106-107.
82. Orlando, Ehrat and Faccoli (n 42) 73.
83. Streck (n 56) 79.
84. See in another context Delimatsis, P. (2007) 'GATS, financial services and trade in renewable energy certificates (RECs) - just another market-based solution to cope with the tragedy of the commons?, NCCR Trade Working Paper No. 2006/31, September, p.11.
85. Mehling, M. (2009) 'Global carbon market institutions, an assessment of governance challenges and functions in the carbon market', Climate Strategies, July, p.20.
86. Derwent (n 20) 16.
87. Watanabe, H. (2009) 'Helping the panda escape the bear', Environmental Finance, Vol. 10, No. 7, Supplement, p.32.
88. Nordseth, M., Buen, J. and Lokshall, E. (2007) 'CER market dynamics', in G. Hodes and S. Kamel (Eds): Equal Exchange: Determining a Fair Price for Carbon, p.11, UNEP RISOE Centre, Roskilde.
89. Mehling (n 73) 18-19.
90. Nordseth, Buen and Lokshall (n 76) 18.
91. Capoor and Ambrosi (n 19) 20.
92. Kouchakji, K. (2008) 'A recession-proof market?', Environmental Finance, Vol. 10, No. 2, Supplement, p.10.
93. Speckman, J. (2009) 'Counting on Copenhagen', Environmental Finance, Vol. 10, No. 7, Supplement, p.5.
94. Speckman (n 81) 5.
95. Cundy, C. and Kouchakji, K. (2008) 'Good news, and bad, for CDM', Environmental Finance, Vol. 10, No. 1, p.9.
96. Mehling (n 73) 18.
97. Nordseth, Buen and Lokshall (n 76) 12-13.
98. Capoor and Ambrosi (n 19) 65.
99. See further Mehling (n 73) 18.
100. PointCarbon (2009) 'EB appoints 9 new auditors for CDM projects', CDM & JI Monitor, 1 April, Vol. 6, No. 7, p.2.
101. Tung, C. (2009) 'Carbon law and practice in China', D. Freestone and C. Streck (Eds): Legal Aspects of Carbon Trading, Kyoto, Copenhagen, and Beyond, p.498, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
102. Cundy, C. (2009) 'Competitive markets', Environmental Finance, Vol. 10, No. 8, p.22.
103. Cundy (n 90) 23 (statement of Christopher Morris).
104. PointCarbon (2009) 'Nordpool launches CER spot contract', Carbon Market Europe, 6 November, Vol. 8, No. 44, p.6.
105. Carr and Rosembuj (n 11) 55.
106. Carr and Rosembuj (n 11) 55.
107. Zumbach (n 36) 26.
108. Twidale, S. (2009) 'Several companies are offering insurance to the carbon market, but uptake has been slow', in PointCarbon (Ed.): Special Report: Insurance, November, p.30.
109. See Zumbach (n 36) 26.
110. PointCarbon (2009) 'CER buyers try to "wriggle free" from deals', 18 March, CDM & JI Monitor, Vol. 6, No. 6, p.1.
111. Streck (n 56) 79.
112. Capoor and Ambrosi (n 19) 3, 20.
113. 'Swiss Re launches Kyoto-related insurance' (13 June 2006) Canadian Underwriter.
114. Munich Re (n 31) 30.
115. http://www.carbonre.eu (accessed on 9 November 2010).
116. Twidale (n 96) 32.
117. See Capoor, K. and Ambrosi, P. (2007) State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2007, p.35, The World Bank, Washington D.C..
118. See Twidale (n 96) 31-32.
119. Ali, P.A.U. and Yano, K. (2004) 'Eco-finance, the legal design and regulation of market-based environmental instruments', D. Bodansky and D. Freestone (Eds): International Environmental Law and Policy Series, Vol. 67, p.61, Kluwer Law International, The Hague.
120. Weber and Darbellay (n 15) 297.
121. Lof (n 44) 25-27.
122. Carr and Rosembuj (n 11) 53.
123. Freestone, D. (2005) 'The UN framework convention on climate change, the Kyoto Protocol, and the Kyoto Mechanisms', in D. Freestone and C. Streck (Eds.): Legal Aspects of Implementing the Kyoto Protocol Mechanisms: Making Kyoto Work, p.18, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
124. Ali and Yano (n 107) 63.
125. See the homepage of the Climate Cent Foundation at accessed 9 November 2010.
126. Marioni (n 64) 17-18.
127. Tung (n 89) 505.
128. Tung (n 89) 498.
129. Tung (n 89) 500.
130. Lof (n 44) 27.
131. Wilder, M. and Fitz-Gerald, L. (2009) 'Carbon contracting', in D. Freestone and C. Streck (Eds): Legal Aspects of Carbon Trading, Kyoto, Copenhagen, and Beyond, p.307, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
132. Humphrey (n 29) 86.
133. Derwent (n 20) 16.
134. See Speckman (n 81) 5.