Britain's first live televised party leaders' debate: From the news cycle to the political information cycle1

Parliamentary Affairs

Volumn 64, Issue 1, 2011, Pages 24-44

  Chadwick, Andrew ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 78651307750     PISSN: 00312290     EISSN: 14602482     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/pa/gsq045     Document Type: Article

References (140)

1. Professor of Political Science and Co-Director of the New Political Communication Unit in the Department of Politics and International Relations at Royal Holloway, University of London: http://newpolcom.rhul.ac.uk. I would like to thank Ben O'Loughlin, the editors of Parliamentary Affairs, the participants-journalists, bloggers, party campaign staff, candidates, opinion pollsters, and scholars- who attended a 'Chatham House rules' seminar organized by Nick Anstead shortly after the 2010 election and the anonymous referees, for their helpful comments and suggestions. Responsibility for what follows, including any errors or shortcomings, is mine alone.
2. For the concept of assemblage see M. DeLanda, A New Philosophy of Society: Assemblage Theory and Social Complexity, Continuum, 2006.
3. See also R.K. Nielsen, 'The Labors of Internet-Assisted Activism: Overcommunication, Miscommunication, and Communicative Overload', Journal of Information Technology and Politics, 2009, 6, 267-80.
4. See for example J. Galtung and M.H. Ruge, 'The Structure of Foreign News: The Presentation of the Congo, Cuba, and Cyprus in Four Norwegian Newspapers', Journal of Peace Research, 1965, 2, 64-90;
5. H.J. Gans, Deciding What's News: A Study of CBS Evening News, NBC Nightly News, Newsweek, and Time, Pantheon, 1979;
6. P. Golding and P. Elliott, Making the News, Longman, 1979;
7. H. Molotch and M. Lester, 'News As Purposive Behaviour: On the Strategic Use of Routine Events, Accidents, and Scandals', American Sociological Review, 1974, 39, 101-12;
8. B. Roshco, Newsmaking, University of Chicago Press, 1975;
9. P. Schlesinger, Putting 'Reality' Together: BBC News, Constable, 1978;
10. G. Tuchman, Making News: A Study in the Construction of Reality, Free Press, 1978.
11. N. Davies, Flat Earth News: An Award-Winning Reporter Exposes Falsehood, Distortion and Propaganda in the Global Media, Chatto and Windus, 2008;
12. B. Kovach and T. Rosenstiel, Warp Speed: America in the Age of Mixed Media, Century Foundation Press, 1999;
13. H. Rosenberg and C.S. Feldman, No Time to Think: The Menace of Media Speed and the 24-Hour News Cycle, Continuum, 2008.
14. A. Bell, 'News Time', Time and Society, 1995, 4, 305-28;
15. P.J. Boczkowski and M. De Santos, 'When More Media Equals Less News: Patterns of Content Homogenization in Argentina's Leading Print and Online Newspapers', Political Communication, 2007, 24, 167-80;
16. see N. Davies, Political Communication, ibid., note 4;
17. J. Garcia Aviles, B. Leon, K. Sanders and J. Harrison, 'Journalists at Digital Television Newsrooms in Britain and Spain: Workflow and Multi-Skilling in a Competitive Environment', Journalism Studies, 2004, 5, 87-100;
18. A.S. Jones, Losing the News: The Future of the News That Feeds Democracy, Oxford University Press, 2009;
19. E. Klinenberg, 'Convergence: News Production in a Digital Age', Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 2005, 597, 48-64;
20. B. Kovach and T. Rosenstiel, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, ibid., note 4;
21. T.E. Patterson, 'Time and News: The Media's Limitations as an Instrument of Democracy', International Political Science Review, 1998, 19, 55-67;
22. J. Redden and T. Witshge, 'A New News Order? Online News Content Examined', in N. Fenton (ed.), New Media, Old News: Journalism and Democracy in the Digital Age, Sage, 2010, 171-86.
23. See for example S. Barnett and I. Gaber, Westminster Tales: The 21st Century Crisis in British Political Journalism, Continuum, 2001;
24. P. Sellers, Cycles of Spin: Strategic Communication in the U.S. Congress, Cambridge University Press, 2010;
25. S. Young, 'Sky News Australia: The Impact of Local 24-hour News on Political Reporting in Australia', Journalism Studies, 2009, 10, 401-16.
26. S. Barnett and I. Gaber, ibid., note 6, pp. 42-6.
27. R. Davis, Typing Politics: The Role of Blogs in American Politics, Oxford University Press, 2009.
28. M. Messner and M.W. DiStaso, 'The Source Cycle: How Traditional Media and Weblogs Use Each Other as Sources', Journalism Studies, 2008, 9, 447-63.
29. S. Barnett and I. Gaber, Journalism Studies, ibid., note 6;
30. K. Callaghan and F. Schnell, 'Assessing the Democratic Debate: How the News Media Frame Elite Policy Discourse', Political Communication, 2001, 18, 183-212;
31. ibid..
32. N. Davies, note 4;
33. R. Davis, ibid., note 8;
34. H.J. Gans, ibid., note 3, pp. 116-46;
35. P. Golding and P. Elliott, ibid., note 3;
36. M. Messner and M.W. DiStaso, ibid., note 9;
37. H. Molotch and M. Lester, ibid., note 3;
38. T.E. Patterson, ibid., note 5;
39. B. Roshco, ibid., note 3;
40. P. Schlesinger, 'Newsmen and Their Time-Machine', British Journal of Sociology, 1977, 28, 336-50;
41. P. Schlesinger, ibid., note 3;
42. P. Sellers, British Journal of Sociology, ibid., note 6;
43. G. Tuchman, British Journal of Sociology, ibid., note 3;
44. S. Young, ibid. British Journal of Sociology, note 6. 11 ITV
45. Sky and BBC, 'Programme Format Agreed By All Parties 1st March 2010', ITV Website, 29 April 2010. http://www.itv.com/utils/cached/common/ ProgrammeFormat2.pdf.
46. K. Stacey and J. Pickard, 'Cameron Warns of 'Sluggish' TV Debate', Financial Times Website, 29 April 2010. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/ed6f0ab4-4860- 11df-9a5d-00144feab49a.html.
47. M. Sweney, 'Leaders' Debate: Nearly 700 Complain to OFCOM Over Treatment of Nick Clegg', Guardian Website, 13 May 2010. http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/ 2010/apr/28/leaders-debatecomplaints.
48. P. Wintour, 'Party Leaders Agree TV Election Debate Rules', Guardian Website, 29 April 2010. http://www.guardian.co.uk/tv-and-radio/2010/mar/03/tv- debates-party-leaders-politics.
49. BBC News Online, '8.4 Million Watch Final Prime Ministerial Debate', BBC News Website, 10 May 2010. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk-politics/election-2010/ 8653551.stm.
50. CoveritLive, CoveritLive.com Website, 19 May 2010. http://www. coveritlive.com.
51. ITV News, 'The Election Debates', ITV News Website, 15 April 2010. http://www.itv.com/electiondebate/; ITV News, ITV News at Ten, 15 April 2010.
52. M. Belam, 'General Election Debate: The Digital Experience', Martin Belam's Website, 15 April 2010. http://www.currybet.net/cbet-blog/2010/04/ general-election-debate-digital-experience.php;
53. N. Collins and H. Blake, 'Leaders' Debate Live Blog', Daily Telegraph Website, 15 April 2010. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/election-2010/7585859/ TV-Election-Debate-live.html;
54. N. Metcalfe, 'Leaders' Debate-As it Happened', MSN UK Website, 15 April 2010. http://msnuknews.spaces.live.com/Blog/cns!93FC6ECA7DF64076!17170.entry;
55. A. Sparrow, 'Leaders' Debate Live Blog', Guardian Website, 15 April 2010. http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/blog/2010/apr/15/leaders-debate-liveblog;
56. The Times, 'Leaders' Debate Live Blog', Times Website, 15 April 2010. http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/politics/article7098806.ece.
57. These data are from the Royal Holloway New Political Communication Unit/Linguamatics real-time text mining project, co-directed by Ben O'Loughlin and Linguamatics, and funded by the UK Technology Strategy Board. See B. O'Loughlin, 'TV Debate: Initial Twitter Analysis Shows Level of Support for Party Leaders and Winners by Topic', New Political Communication Unit Website, 20 April 2010. http://newpolcom.rhul.ac.uk/npcu-blog/2010/4/20/tv-debate-initia- twitter-analysisshows-level-of-support-fo.html.
58. N. Anstead and B. O'Loughlin, The Emerging Viewertariat: Explaining Twitter Responses to Nick Griffin's Appearance on BBC Question Time: University of East Anglia School of Political, Social and International Studies Working Paper, University of East Anglia, 2010.
59. N. Robinson, 'Queasy Feeling', Nick Robinson's Newslog, 15 April 2010. http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/nickrobinson/2010/04/queasy-feeling.html.
60. Google Replay Search, 'Google Replay Real-Time Search Archive for 'krishgm', Google Replay Search, 19 May 2010. http://www.google.co.uk/search?q= krishgm&hl=en&prmd=u&source=lnms&ei=SuTzS6uNNYmM0gTL4dWWDQ& sa=X&oi=mode-link&ct=mode&ved=0CAwQ-AU&&tbs=mbl:1,mbl-hs: 1271286000,mbl-he:1271372399.
61. S. Davies, 'UK Journalists on Twitter Update', Stedavies.com, 13 May 2010. http://stedavies.com/2009/10/uk-journalists-on-twitter-update/.
62. H. Kwak, C. Lee, H. Park and S. Moon, 'What is Twitter, a Social Network or a News Media?', Proceedings of the 19th International World Wide Web (WWW) Conference, 2010, 19, 591-600;
63. S. Ye and F. Wu, 'Measuring Message Propagation and Social Influence on Twitter.com', Paper to The Second International Conference on Social Informatics (SocInfo'10), 30 August 2010. http://sites.google.com/site/yeshao/mj.pdf.
64. E. Weaver, 'QCon Presentation', Evan Weaver's Website, 30 April 2010. http://blog.evanweaver.com/articles/2009/03/13/qcon-presentation/.
65. The Labour Party, 'The Leaders' Debate', Labour Party Website, 16 April 2010. http://www2.labour.org.uk/the-leaders-debate.
66. M. Belam, 'General Election Debate: The Digital Experience', Martin Belam's Website, 15 April 2010. http://www.currybet.net/cbet-blog/2010/04/ general-election-debate-digital-experience.php.
67. Facebook, 'Facebook Democracy UK Page', Facebook Website, 15 April 2010. http://www.facebook.com/democracyuk.
68. A. Sparrow, 'Leaders' Debate Live Blog', The Guardian Website, 15 April 2010. http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/blog/2010/apr/15/leaders-debate-live- blog.
69. J. Gibson, 'Note to Lib Dem HQ. We can see what you're doing to our tracker and @bruntonspall can stop it. You're barred! http://bit.ly/bU4UVQ', Twitter.com/janinegibson, 15 April 2010. http://twitter.com/janinegibson/status/ 12243055856.
70. A. Chung, 'Clegg Up: Lib Dem Leader Wins TV Debate', Sky News Website, 16 April 2010. http://news.sky.com/skynews/Home/Politics/Sky-News-Instant-Leaders- Debate-Poll-With-Fizzback-Panel-Texts-Feedback-For-Faster-Results/Article/ 201004315603598?f=rss.
71. Sky News, 'Sky News to Capture Instant Reaction to Leaders' Debates via Text Polling', Sky News Website, 16 April 2010. http://www.skypressoffice.co.uk/ SkyNews/Resources/showarticle.asp?id=2952.
72. E. Levine, 'Distinguishing Television: The Changing Meanings of Television Liveness', Media, Culture and Society, 2008, 30, 393-409;
73. E. Ytreberg, 'Extended Liveness and Eventfulness in Multi-Platform Reality Formats', New Media and Society, 2009, 11, 467-85.
74. N. Couldry, 'Playing for Celebrity: Big Brother as Ritual Event', Television and New Media, 2002, 3, 283-93, p. 286.
75. ITV News, 'The Election Debates', ITV News Website, 15 April 2010. http://www.itv.com/electiondebate/.
76. S. Herbst, Numbered Voices: How Opinion Polling Has Shaped American Politics, University of Chicago Press, 1993.
77. W.L. Bennett, 'Constructing Publics and Their Opinions', Political Communication, 1994, 10, 101-20.
78. L. Kuenssberg, 'Twitpic Photo', Twitpic.com, 18 May 2010. http://twitpic.com/1ftuyd.
79. P. Rogers, 'Finally, the Leaders' Debate', The Times Election Blog, 30 April 2010. http://timesonline.typepad.com/election10/2010/04/finally-the- leaders-debate.html.
80. T. Montgomerie, 'Twitpic photo', Twitpic.com, 18 May 2010. http://twitpic.com/1jgg15.
81. P. Rogers, 'Finally, the Leaders' Debate', The Times Election Blog, 30 April 2010. http://timesonline.typepad.com/election10/2010/04/finally-the- leaders-debate.html.
82. L. Kuenssberg, 'Twitpic Photo', 18 May 2010. Twitpic.com, http://twitpic.com/1ftuyd.
83. J.N. Cappella and K.H. Jamieson, Spiral of Cynicism: The Press and the Public Good, Oxford University Press, 1997;
84. F. Esser, C. Reinemann and F. David, 'Spin Doctors in the United States, Great Britain, and Germany: Metacommunication About Media Manipulation', Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics, 2001, 6, 16-45;
85. T.E. Patterson, Out of Order, Knopf, 1993.
86. J. Stanyer, The Creation of Political News: Television and British Party Political Conferences, Sussex Academic Press, 2001.
87. ITV News, ITV News at Ten, 15 April 2010.
88. Ipsos MORI, 'The Leaders' Debates: Immediate Public Reaction-Clegg Wins the First Round', Ipsos MORI Website, 20 April 2010. http://www.ipsos-mori.com/ Assets/Docs/News/ipsos-mori-publicreaction-to-leaders-debate.pdf.
89. YouGov, 'Instant Reactions: The Great Debate', YouGov Website, 15 April 2010. http://today.yougov.co.uk/politics/instant-reactions-great-debate.
90. ComRes, 'ITV News Instant Poll Results 15 April 2010', ComRes Website, 16 April 2010. http://www.comres.co.uk/page184332236.aspx.
91. Populus, 'Post Debate Poll-April 15 2010', Populus Website, 20 April 2010. http://www.populuslimited.com/the-times-post-debate-poll-april-15-2010- 150410.html.
92. Angus Reid Public Opinion, 'Angus Reid Real Time Reporting: First Debate', Angus Reid Public Opinion Website, 15 April 2010. http://www. angusreidelections.co.uk/2010/04/debate/.
93. ITV News, ITV News at Ten, 15 April 2010.
94. G. Gibbon, 'What the Post-Debate Reaction Polls Tell Us', Channel 4 News Website, 4 May 2010. http://blogs.channel4.com/snowblog/2010/04/30/what-the- post-debate-reaction-polls-tell-us.
95. BBC2, Newsnight, 15 April 2010.
96. J. Chapman, 'Is This Really the End of Two-Party Politics?', Daily Mail, 19 April 2010;
97. T.N. Dunn, 'It's Lib Dems in Front', Sun, 19 April 2010;
98. A. Grice, 'Clegg's Popularity Soars on Two Fronts; Lib Dem Leader's Stock Rises with Voters, While Mandelson Concedes Possibility of a Coalition', Guardian, 19 April 2010;
99. J. Lyons and J. Beattie, 'Crush Clegg: Desperate Tories Fightback Panic', Daily Mirror, 19 April 2010;
100. A. Pierce, 'Who's to Blame for Cameron's TV Nightmare?', Daily Mail, 19 April 2010;
101. A. Porter, C. Hope and R. Prince, 'Cameron Thinks Positive to Counter Threat From Clegg', Daily Telegraph, 19 April 2010;
102. The Daily Star, 'Rivals Do an Add Lib', Daily Star, 19 April 2010;
103. R. Watson and S. Coates, 'Rivals Set Their Sights on 'Churchill' Clegg', Times, 19 April 2010;
104. N. Watt and P. Wintour, 'Conservatives: Tories Not for Turning Despite Lib Dem Surge, Says Cameron', Guardian, 19 April 2010;
105. D. Yelland, 'The Rise of Clegg Could Lock Murdoch and the Media Elite Out of UK politics', Guardian, 19 April 2010.
106. BBC Radio 4, 'Today', Today Programme Archive Website, 17 April 2010. http://news.bbc.co.uk/today/hi/today/newsid-8624000/8624275.stm.
107. F. Luntz, 'U.S. Pollster Uses Instant Response Method to Rate Politicians Debate', Sun Website, 16 April 2010. http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/ election2010/2934852/US-pollster-uses-Instant-Response-method-to-rate- politicians-debate.html.
108. Conservative Home, 'Conservative Home: Friday 16th April 2010', Conservative Home Website, 16 April 2010. http://conservativehome.blogs.com/ frontpage/2010/04/friday-16th-april-2010.html;
109. G. Fawkes, 'Clegg: Winning Here!', Guido Fawkes Website, 17 May 2010. http://order-order.com/2010/04/16/clegg-winning-here/;
110. Labourlist, 'Election 2010', Labourlist Website, 17 May 2010. http://www.labourlist.org/topics/Election2010/;
111. Left Foot Forward, Left Foot Forward Website, 17 May2010. http://www.leftfootforward.org/page/13;
112. Liberal Democrat Voice, 'Monthly Archives: April 2010', Liberal Democrat Voice Website, 17 May 2010. http://www.libdemvoice.org/date/2010/04.
113. YouTube, 'Search: UK Election', YouTube Website, 4 May 2010. http://www.youtube.com/results?search-query=uk+election&aq=f.
114. Twapperkeeper, 'Twitter Hashtag Archives for #ukelection, #ge2010, and #ge10', Twapperkeeper.com,14 May 2010. http://twapperkeeper.com/allnotebooks. php.
115. Channel 4 News, 'Channel 4 News FactCheck on Twitter', Twitter.com/FactCheck, 12 May 2010. http://twitter.com/FactCheck.
116. T. Young, 'Tonight's Polls: Lib Dem Surge Holds Up', Daily Telegraph Website, 19 April 2010. http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/tobyyoung/100035455/ tonights-polls-lib-dem-surge-holds-up.
117. T.N. Dunn, 'It's Lib Dems in Front', Sun, 19 April 2010.
118. BBC Radio 4, 'Today', Today Programme Archive Website, 20 April 2010. http://news.bbc.co.uk/today/hi/today/newsid-8628000/8628896.stm.
119. We Got Rage Against the Machine to Number 1. We Got Rage Against the Machine to #1, We Can Get the Lib Dems into Office Facebook Group, 7 May 2010. http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=113749985304255.
120. T. Helm and A. Asthana, 'Nick Clegg Appeals to Youth Vote and Liberal Democrats Maintain Poll Surge', Guardian Website, 18 April 2010. http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2010/apr/18/election-liberal-democrat-surge- nick-clegg.
121. T. Shipman, 'Nick Clegg's Nazi Slur on Britain', Daily Mail Website, 22 April 2010. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/election/article-1267921/GENERAL- ELECTION-2010-Nick-Clegg-Nazi-slur-Britain.html.
122. P. Oborne, 'Dirty Tricks of the REAL Nasty Party', Daily Mail Website, 22 April 2010. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-1267912/General-Election- 2010-Liberal-Democrats-dirty-tricks-realnasty-party.html.
123. J. Slack, 'How the LibDems Would Release 60,000 Convicts', Daily Mail Website, 21 April 2010. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-1267658/ General-Election-2010-How-Lib-Dems-release-60-000-convicts.html.
124. R. Waghorne, 'The LibDems are a Party Full of Shadow Lobbyists', Daily Mail Website, 21 April 2010. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-1267633/ GENERAL-ELECTION-2010-The-Lib-Dems-party-shadow-lobbyists.html.
125. R. Winnett and J. Swaine, 'Nick Clegg, the Lib Dem Donors and Payments into his Private Account; Exclusive Donor Cash Mystery', Daily Telegraph, 22 April 2010.
126. BBC2, Newsnight, 21 April 2010.
127. Twapperkeeper, 'Twitter Hashtag Archive for #nickcleggsfault', Twapperkeeper.com, 14 May 2010.http://twapperkeeper.com/allnotebooks.php.
128. E. Davis, 'Extraordinary. Twitter parodies undercut media attacks on Clegg (#nickcleggsfault).Telegraph ends up defending itself. http://bit.ly/dmd6eA', Twitter.com/EvanHD, 22 April 2010. http://twitter.com/ EvanHD/status/12633467781.
129. R. Cellan-Jones, 'It's All Nick Clegg's Fault', BBC News Online, 23 April 2010. http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thereporters/rorycellanjones/2010/04/its-all- nick-cleggs-fault.html.
130. Ultimately this is a matter of identifying the point at which it became clear that the Telegraph's story began to look insecure. During the second debate, Sky News's chair, Adam Boulton, injected a supplementary question to Clegg on expenses. This was controversial because it appeared to break the format rules, but the substance of Boulton's question had very little impact on the course of the debate or its aftermath. By that point the context had already shifted in response to the rapid contestation of the Telegraph's line earlier in the day by both professional journalists and online activists, combined with the Lib Dems' crucial decision to publish Clegg's expenses documentation shortly before the debate.
131. Libdemvoice, 'Sky News Debate: Nick Clegg Opening Statement', YouTube Website, 22 April 2010. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5EFnJ-pQ2hI&feature= youtu.be&a;
132. M. Pack, 'I liked a YouTubevideo-Sky News Debate: Nick Clegg opening statement. http://youtu.be/5EFnJ-pQ2hI?a',Twitter.com/markpack, 22 April 2010. http://twitter.com/markpack/status/12661723684.
133. K. Maguire, 'So bad for the Cons spinner Paul Stephenson's trying to brief hacks in the Bristol centre while debate's on. Poor form', Twitter.com/Kevin-Maguire, 22 April 2010. http://twitter.com/Kevin-Maguire/ status/12658132770.
134. J.D. Bolter and R. Grusin, Remediation: Understanding New Media, MIT Press, 1999.
135. T. Rosenstiel, 'Political Polling and the New Media Culture: a Case of More Being Less', Public Opinion Quarterly, 2005, 69, 698-715.
136. P.J. Boczkowski and M. De Santos, 'When More Media Equals Less News: Patterns of Content Homogenization in Argentina's Leading Print and Online Newspapers', Political Communication, 2007, 24, 167-80;
137. see N. Davies, Political Communication, ibid., note 4;
138. A.S. Jones, Political Communication, ibid., note 5;
139. E. Klinenberg, Political Communication, ibid, note 5;
140. C. Paterson, 'News Agency Dominance in International News on the Internet', in D. Skinner, J. Compton and M. Gasher (eds), Converging Media, Diverging Politics: A Political Economy of News in the United States and Canada, Lexington, 2005, 145-64.