An economic assessment of the use of short-rotation coppice woody biomass to heat greenhouses in southern Canada

Biomass and Bioenergy

Volumn 35, Issue 1, 2011, Pages 374-384

  McKenney, Daniel W ^a   Yemshanov, Denys ^a   Fraleigh, Saul ^a   Allen, Darren ^a   Preto, Fernando ^b  

^a GREAT LAKES FORESTRY CENTRE   (Canada)

^b NATURAL RESOURCES CANADA   (Canada)

Author keywords

Bioeconomic model; Bioenergy crops; Biomass heating; Fossil fuel substitution; Short rotation coppice; Willow production

Indexed keywords

BIO-ECONOMIC MODEL; BIO-ENERGY; FOSSIL FUEL SUBSTITUTION; SHORT ROTATION COPPICE; WILLOW PRODUCTION;

BIOFUELS; BIOMASS; BOILERS; COMBUSTION; COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS; COSTS; CROPS; EARNINGS; FORESTRY; FOSSIL FUELS; GREENHOUSES; HEATING; INVESTMENTS; NATURAL GAS; ROTATION; SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS;

ECOLOGY;

BIOMASS; COPPICE; CROP PRODUCTION; CROP ROTATION; CROP YIELD; DECIDUOUS TREE; ECONOMIC ANALYSIS; FOSSIL FUEL; GREENHOUSE ECOSYSTEM; GROWTH RATE; HEATING; NATURAL GAS; SILVICULTURE;

CANADA; ONTARIO [CANADA];

SALIX;

EID: 78650541995     PISSN: 09619534     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.biombioe.2010.08.055     Document Type: Article

References (75)

1. Schlamadinger B., Marland G. The Kyoto protocol: provisions and unresolved issues relevant to land-use change and forestry. Environmental Science and Policy 1998, 1:313-327.
2. Righelato R., Spracklen D.V. Carbon mitigation by biofuels or by saving and restoring forests?. Science 2007, 317:902.
3. Wright L.L., Hughes E.E. US carbon offset potential using biomass energy systems. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution 1993, 70:483-497.
4. Marland G., Schlamadinger B. Forests for carbon sequestration or fossil fuel substitution? A sensitivity analysis. Biomass and Bioenergy 1997, 13:389-397.
5. van Kooten G.C., Krcmar-Nozic E., Stennes B., van Gorkom R. Economics of fossil fuel substitution and wood product sinks when trees are planted to sequester carbon on agricultural lands in western Canada. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 1999, 29:1669-1678.
6. NRCan CanREN (Natural Resources Canada Canadian Renewable Energy Network). Biomass-fired district energy systems. Bioenergy series-5. Online publication. Available from: 2005 [accessed 05.05]. http://www.canren.gc.ca/prod_serv/index.asp%253FCaId%253D184%2526PgId%253D1091S.
7. Yemshanov D., McKenney D. Fast-growing poplar plantations as a bioenergy supply source for Canada. Biomass and Bioenergy 2008, 32:185-197.
8. Maker M.T. Wood-chip heating systems. A guide for institutional and industrial biomass installations 2004, Biomass Energy Resource Center, Montpelier, Vermont.
9. Ralevic P, Karau J, Smith T, Richardson J. IEA Bioenergy Task 31 Report, Canada; 2008.
10. Ontario Greenhouse Vegetable Growers (OGVG). 2005-2006 Statistics. Available from: [accessed 26.02.07]. http://www.ontariogreenhouse.com/folders/show/807.
11. TOGA (The Ontario Greenhouse Alliance). Greenhouses Grow Ontario. An economic impact study of the greenhouse industry in Ontario. The Ontario greenhouse alliance 2006. Available from: [accessed 26.02.07]. http://www.ontariogreenhouse.com/folders/show/807.
12. Layzell DB, Stephen J, Wood SM. Exploring the potential for biomass power in Ontario. A response to the OPA supply mix advice report. Biocap Canada Foundation; 2006.
13. Stephen J.D., Sokhansanj S., Bi X., Sowlati T., Kloeck T., Townley-Smith L., et al. Analysis of biomass feedstock availability and variability for the Peace River region of Alberta, Canada. Biosystems Engineering 2010, 105:103-111.
14. Picchi G, Gordon A, Thevathasan N. Feedstock to furnace: bioenergy systems for the Ontario greenhouse industry. IEA Task 30 Report; 2006. Available from [accessed 30.11]. http://www.shortrotationcrops.org/PDFs/FeedstocktoFurnaceCanada.pdf.
15. Kenney W.A., Gambles R.L., Zsuffa L. Economics and yields of energy plantation: status and potential 1991, Efficiency and Alternate Energy Technology Branch, Energy, Mines and Resources Canada, Ottawa, Ontario.
16. Richardson J. Forest bioenergy R&D in Canada. IEA Bioenergy Newsletter 1990, 2(2).
17. Karau J (comp.). Proceedings of the Canadian energy plantation workshop, Gananoque, Ontario, 2-4 May 1995. Ottawa: Natural Resources Canada, Canadian Forest Service; 1996.
18. Canadian Biomass Innovation Network. Available from: <>. http://www.cbin-rcib.gc.ca.
19. Christersson L., Forsse S.L., Zsuffa L. The role and significance of woody biomass plantations in Swedish agriculture. Forestry Chronicle 1993, 69:687-693.
20. Mitchell C.P. New cultural treatments and yield optimisation. Biomass and Bioenergy 1995, 9:11-34.
21. Volk TA, Abrahamson LP, White EH, Kopp RF, Nowak CA. Producing short rotation willow crops in the Northeastern United States. In: Proceedings of the second short-rotation woody crops operations working group conference. Portland, OR, 24-28, August 1998; 1999.
22. Keoleian G.A., Volk T.A. Renewable energy from willow biomass crops: life cycle energy, environmental and economic performance. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 2005, 24:385-406.
23. Heller M.C., Keoleian G.A., Volk T.A. Life cycle assessment of a willow bioenergy cropping system. Biomass and Bioenergy 2003, 25:147-165.
24. McKenney D.W., Yemshanov D., Fox G., Ramalal E. Using bioeconomic models to assess research priorities: a case study on afforestation as a carbon sequestration tool. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 2006, 36:886-900.
25. Boardman A.E., Greenburg D.H., Vining A.R., Weimer D.L. Cost-benefit analysis: concepts and practice 2001, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ.
26. @RISK @Risk advanced risk analysis for spreadsheets: professional edition, version 5.0 2007, Palisade Corporation, Newfield, NY.
27. Volk T., Verwijist T., Tharakan P.J., Abrahamson L.P., White E.H. Growing fuel: a sustainability assessment of willow biomass crops. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 2004, 2:411-418.
28. Castellano P.J., Volk T.A., Herrington L.P. Estimates of technically available woody biomass feedstock from natural forests and willow biomass crops for two locations in New York State. Biomass and Bioenergy 2009, 33:393-406.
29. Tharakan P.J., Volk T.A., Abrahamson L.P., White E.H. Energy feedstock characteristics of willow and hybrid poplar clones at harvest age. Biomass and Bioenergy 2003, 25:571-580.
30. Labrecque M., Teodorescu T.I., Daigle S. Biomass productivity and wood energy of Salix species after 2 years growth in SRIC fertilized with wastewater sludge. Biomass and Bioenergy 1997, 12:409-417.
31. Labrecque M., Teodorescu T.I., Daigle S. Early performance and nutrition of two willow species in short-rotation intensive culture fertilized with wastewater sludge and impact on the soil characteristics. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 1998, 28:1621-1635.
32. Labrecque M., Teodorescu T.I. Influence of plantation site and wastewater sludge fertilization on the performance and foliar nutrient status of two willow species grown under SRIC in southern Quebec (Canada). Forest Ecology and Management 2001, 150:223-239.
33. Labrecque M., Teodorescu T.I. High biomass yield achieved by Salix clones in SRIC following two 3-year coppice rotations on abandoned farmland in southern Quebec, Canada. Biomass and Bioenergy 2003, 25:135-146.
34. Ericsson K., Rosenqvist H., Ganko E., Pisarek M., Nilssona L. An agro-economic analysis of willow cultivation in Poland. Biomass and Bioenergy 2006, 30:16-27.
35. Heaton R., Randerson P.F., Slater F.M. The economics of growing short rotation coppice in the uplands of mid-Wales and an economic comparison with sheep production. Biomass and Bioenergy 1999, 17:59-71.
36. Toivonen R.M., Tahvanainen L.J. Profitability of willow cultivation for energy production in Finland. Biomass and Bioenergy 1998, 15:27-37.
37. Rosenqvist H., Dawson M. Economics of willow growing in Northern Ireland. Biomass and Bioenergy 2005, 28:7-14.
38. Yemshanov D., McKenney D., Fraleigh S., D'Eon S. An integrated spatial assessment of the investment potential of three species in southern Ontario, Canada inclusive of carbon benefits. Forest Policy and Economics 2007, 10:48-59.
39. Yemshanov D., McKenney D.W., Hatton T., Fox G. Investment attractiveness of afforestation in Canada inclusive of carbon sequestration benefits. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics 2005, 307-323.
40. McKenney D.W., Yemshanov D., Fox G., Ramlal E. Cost estimates for carbon sequestration from fast growing poplar plantations in Canada. Forest Policy and Economics 2004, 345-358.
41. Abrahamson LP, Volk TA, Kopp RF, White EH, Ballard JL. Willow biomass producers handbook (Revised). Short-Rotation Woody Crops Program SUNY-ESF, Syracuse, NY. Available from: <>; 2002. http://www.esf.edu/willow/PUBLICATIONS/handbook/handbook.htm.
42. Bullard M.J., Mustill S.J., McMillan S.D., Nixon P.M.I., Carver P., Britt C.P. Yield improvements through modification of planting density and harvest frequency in short rotation coppice Salix spp. - 1. Yield response in two morphologically diverse varieties. Biomass and Bioenergy 2002, 22:15-25.
43. Samson R, Girouard P, Zan C, Mehdi B, Martin R, Henning J. The implications of growing short-rotation tree species for carbon sequestration in Canada. Final report for joint forest sector table/sinks table. Afforestation #5. National Climate Change Process Solicitation. No. 23103-8-0253/N. REAP Canada, Ste. Anne de Bellevue, QC; 1999.
44. Wilkinson J.M., Evans E.J., Bilsborrow P.E., Wright C., Hewison W.O., Pilbeam D.J. Yield of willow cultivars at different planting densities in a commercial short rotation coppice in the north of England. Biomass and Bioenergy 2007, 31:469-474.
45. Volk T.A., Abrahamson L.P., Nowak C.A., Smart L.B., Tharakan P.J., White E.H. The development of short-rotation willow in the northeastern United States for bioenergy and bioproducts, agroforestry and phytoremediation. Biomass and Bioenergy 2006, 30:715-727.
46. Mitchell C.P., Steven E.A., Watter M.P. Short-rotation forestry - operations, productivity and costs based on experience gained in the UK. Forest Ecology and Management 1999, 121:123-136.
47. OMAFRA. Provincial survey of custom farmwork charged in 2006. Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs. Factsheet 07-019. Available from: 2006 [accessed 24.11.07]. http://www.omafra.gov.on.ca/english/busdev/facts/07-019a.htm.
48. Lowthe-Thomas S.C., Slater F.M., Randerson P.F. Reducing the establishment costs of short rotation willow coppice (SRC) - a trial of a novel layflat planting system at an upland site in mid-Wales. Biomass and Bioenergy 2010, 34:677-686.
49. Savoie P. Mechanization of willow harvesting. Canadian biomass innovation network, tid8 31 third annual workshop. Presented November 20, 2007, Montréal, Quebec, Canada; 2007.
50. Pitcher K., Hilton B., Lundberg H. The ARBRE project. Progress achieved. Biomass and Bioenergy 1998, 15:213-218.
51. Graham R.L., Liu W., Downing M., Noon C.E., Daly M., Moore A. The effect of location and facility demand on the marginal cost of delivered woodchips from energy crops: a case study of the state of Tennessee. Biomass and Bioenergy 1997, 13:117-123.
52. Preto F. Personal communication. CanmetENERGY, Ottawa, Ontario: Natural Resources Canada.
53. Orosz D. Economic discussion: biomass in greenhouse operations. Farm credit Canada, bioenergy in greenhouse workshop. Presented February 8, 2006 at the bioenergy for greenhouses workshop in Leamington, Ontario. Available from: 2007 [accessed 01.03.07]. http://www.ontariogreenhouse.com/folders/show/1338.
54. Chau J., Sowlati T., Sokhansanj S., Preto F., Melin S., Bi X. Techno-economic analysis of wood biomass boilers for the greenhouse industry. Applied Energy 2009, 86:364-371.
55. NRCan Buyer's guide to small commercial biomass combustion systems 2000, Natural Resources Canada's Renewable and Electrical Energy Division.
56. Jenkins B.M., Baxter L.L., Miles T.R. Combustion properties of biomass. Fuel Processing Technology 1998, 54:17-46.
57. Statistics Canada Energy statistics handbook. Third quarter 2009. Catalogue no. 57-601-X 2010.
58. Canada Plan Service. Greenhouse heating requirements. Canada Plan Service, Plan 6701. Available from: 2000 [accessed 28.01.07]. http://www.cps.gov.on.ca/english/plans/E6000/6701/M-6701L.pdf.
59. McKenney D.W., Pedlar J.H., Papadopol P., Hutchinson M.F. The development of 1901-2000 historical monthly climate models for Canada and the United States. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 2006, 138:69-81.
60. Papadopoulos A.P. Growing greenhouse tomatoes in soil and soiless media 1991, Agriculture Canada Publication 1865/E.
61. Samson R, Chen Y. Short rotation forestry and the water problem. In: Karau J. Proceedings of the Canadian energy plantation workshop in Gananoque, Ontario, May 2-4; 1995.
62. Prasad S.B. Biomass-fired steam power cogeneration system: a theoretical study. Energy Conversion Management 1995, 36:65-77.
63. Girouard P, Lowe R, Samson R. Economics of small commercial wood chip combustion systems in eastern Canada. Resource efficient agricultural production (REAP), Canada. Research report; 1997.
64. Henderson-Sellers B., Henderson-Sellers A. Sensitivity evaluation of environmental models using fractional factorial experimentation. Ecological Modelling 1996, 86:291-295.
65. Schwartzman G.L., Kaluzny S.P. Ecological simulation primer 1987, Macmillan, New York.
66. Silberberg E. The structure of economics: a mathematical analysis 1990, McGraw-Hill, New York. 2nd ed.
67. Raneses A., Hanson K., Shapouri H. Economic impacts from shifting cropland use from food to fuel. Biomass and Bioenergy 1998, 15:417-422.
68. Helby P., Rosenqvist H., Roos A. Retreat from Salix-Swedish experience with energy crops in the 1990s. Biomass and Bioenergy 2006, 30:422-427.
69. ArborVitae Environmental Services Ltd. Evaluation of Tax Incentives that Promote Afforestation and Fast Growing Tree Plantations. NRCan-04-0923. Available from: 2004 [accessed 22.02.09]. http://cfs.nrcan.gc.ca/subsite/afforestation/reportsummaries/.
70. Savvanidou E., Zervas E., Tsagarakis K.P. Public acceptance of biofuels. Energy Policy 2010, 38:3482-3488.
71. Volney W.J.A., Alfaro R.I., Bothwell P., Hogg E.H., Hopkin A., Laflamme G., et al. A framework for poplar plantation risk assessments. Unasylva 2005, 221:20-25.
72. Hubbes M, Lin D. Canker diseases that limit the establishment of energy plantations. In: Karau J. (Comp.). Proceedings of the Canadian energy plantation workshop. Gananoque, Ontario. May 2-4; 1995. p. 127-130.
73. Hopkin AA, Cheliak W. Pest problems on immature poplar and willow in Ontario and their potential threat to plantations. In: Karau J. (Comp.). Proceedings of the Canadian energy plantation workshop. Gananoque, Ontario. May 2-4; 1995. p. 113-126.
74. Ramlal E., Yemshanov D., Fox G., McKenney D.W. A bioeconomic model of afforestation in southern Ontario: integration of fiber, carbon and municipal biosolids values. Journal of Environmental Management 2009, 90:1833-1843.
75. Okkonen L., Suhonen N. Business models of heat entrepreneurship in Finland. Energy Policy 2010, 38:3443-3452.