How usual is usual care in pragmatic intervention studies in primary care? An overview of recent trials

British Journal of General Practice

Volumn 60, Issue 576, 2010, Pages

  Smelt, Antonia F H ^a   Van Der Week, Gerda M ^a   Blom, Jeanet W ^a   Gussekloo, Jacobijn ^a   Assendelft, Willem J J ^a  

^a LEIDEN UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Control groups; Family practice; Pragmatic trials; Primary care; Usual care

Indexed keywords

BEHAVIOR CHANGE; CAREGIVER; CLUSTER RANDOMISATION; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; MEDICAL RESEARCH; METHODOLOGY; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PATIENT CARE; PRIMARY MEDICAL CARE; RANDOMIZATION; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL; REVIEW; STUDY DESIGN;

CLUSTER ANALYSIS; CONTROL GROUPS; DELIVERY OF HEALTH CARE; HUMANS; PRIMARY HEALTH CARE; PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC;

EID: 78650461681     PISSN: 09601643     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3399/bjgp10X514819     Document Type: Review

References (93)

1. Roland M, Torgerson DJ. What are pragmatic trials? BMJ 1998; 316 (7127): 285.
2. Barkauskas VH, Lusk SL, Eakin BL. Selecting control interventions for clinical outcome studies. West J Nurs Res 2005; 27 (3): 346-363.
3. Campbell MK, Elbourne DR, Altman DG. CONSORT statement: extension to cluster randomised trials. BMJ 2004; 328 (7441): 702-708.
4. Moher D, Schulz KR Altman D. The CONSORT Statement: revised recommendations for improving the quality of reports of parallelgroup randomized trials 2001. Explore (NY) 2005; 1 (1): 40-45.
5. Zwarenstein M, Treweek S, Gagnier JJ, et al. Improving the reporting of pragmatic trials: an extension of the CONSORT statement. BMJ 2008; 337: a2390.
6. Eldridge S, Ashby D, Bennett C, et al. Internal and external validity of cluster randomised trials: systematic review of recent trials. BMJ 2008; 336 (7649): 876-880.
7. Puffer S, Torgerson D, Watson J. Evidence for risk of bias in cluster randomised trials: review of recent trials published in three general medical journals. BMJ 2003; 327 (7418): 785-789.
8. Mant D. The problem with usual care. BrJ Gen Pract 2008; 58 (556): 755-756.
9. Somerville S, Hay E, Lewis M, et al. Content and outcome of usual primary care for back pain: a systematic review. Br J Gen Pract 2008; 58 (556): 790-797, i-vi.
10. Gartlehner G, Hansen RA, Nissman D, et al. A simple and valid tool distinguished efficacy from effectiveness studies. J Clin Epidemiol 2006; 59 (10): 1040-1048.
11. Godwin M, Ruhland L, Casson I, et al. Pragmatic controlled clinical trials in primary care: the struggle between external and internal validity. BMCMed Res Methodol 2003; 3: 28.
12. Boivin JM, Poupon-Lemarquis L, Iraqi W, et al. A multifactorial strategy of pain management is associated with less pain in scheduled vaccination of children. A study realized by family practitioners in 239 children aged 4-12 years old. Fam Pract 2008; 25 (6): 423-429.
13. Community Pharmacy Medicines Management Project Evaluation Team. The MEDMAN study: a randomized controlled trial of community pharmacy-led medicines management for patients with coronary heart disease. Fam Pract 2007; 24 (2): 189-200.
14. Christensen KS, Toft T, Frostholm. L, et al. Screening for common mental disorders: who will benefit? Results from a randomised clinical trial. Fam Pract 2005; 22 (4): 428-434.
15. Coppin R, Wicke D, Little P. Managing earwax in primary care: efficacy of self-treatment using a bulb syringe. Br J Gen Pract 2008; 58 (546): 44-49.
16. Crilly M, Esmail A. Randomised controlled trial of a hypothyroid educational booklet to improve thyroxine adherence. Br J Gen Pract 2005; 55 (514): 362-368. (Pubitemid 40585210)
17. Daley A, Winter H, Grimmett C, et al. Feasibility of an exercise intervention for women with postnatal depression: a pilot randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract 2008; 58 (548): 178-183.
18. Dennis CL, Hodnett E, Kenton L, et al. Effect of peer support on prevention of postnatal depression among high risk women: multisite randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2009; 338: a3064.
19. Farmer A, Wade A, Goyder E, et al. Impact of self monitoring of blood glucose in the management of patients with non-insulin treated diabetes: open parallel group randomised trial. BMJ 2007; 335 (7611): 132.
20. Gorgels WJ, Oude Voshaar RC, et al. Consequences of a benzodiazepine discontinuation programme in family practice on psychotropic medication prescription to the participants. Fam Pract 2007; 24 (5): 504-510.
21. Green J, Denham A, Ingram. J, et al. Treatment of menopausal symptoms by qualified herbal practitioners: a prospective, randomized controlled trial. Fam Pract 2007; 24 (5): 468-474.
22. Griffiths C, Motlib J, Azad A, et al. Randomised controlled trial of a layled self-management programme for Bangladeshi patients with chronic disease. Br J Gen Pract 2005; 55 (520): 831-837.
23. Gruffydd-Jones K, Hollinghurst S, Ward S, Taylor G. Targeted routine asthma care in general practice using telephone triage. Br J Gen Pract 2005; 55 (521): 918-923. (Pubitemid 41763120)
24. Hamilton W, Russell D, Stabb C, et al. The effect of patient selfcompletion agenda forms on prescribing and adherence in general practice: a randomized controlled trial. Fam Pract 2007; 24 (1): 77-83.
25. Hoefman E, van Weert HC, Reitsma JB, et al. Diagnostic yield of patient-activated loop recorders for detecting heart rhythm abnormalities in general practice: a randomised clinical trial. Fam Pract 2005; 22 (5): 478-484. (Pubitemid 41418764)
26. Holland R, Brooksby I, Lenaghan E, et al. Effectiveness of visits from Community pharmacists for patients with heart failure: HeartMed randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2007; 334 (7603): 1098.
27. Holland R, Lenaghan E, Harvey I, et al. Does home based medication review keep older people out of hospital? The HOMER randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2005; 330 (7486): 293.
28. Hunkeler EM, Katon W, Tang L, et al. Long term outcomes from the IMPACT randomised trial for depressed elderly patients in primary care. BMJ 2006; 332 (7536): 259-263.
29. Khunti K, Stone MA, Burden AC, et al. Randomised controlled trial of near-patient testing for glycated haemoglobin in people with type 2 diabetes mellitus. Br J Gen Pract 2006; 56 (528): 511-517.
30. Lawton BA, Rose SB, Raina EQ et al. Exercise on prescription for women aged 40-74 recruited through primary care: two year randomised controlled trial. Br J Sports Med 2009; 43 (2): 120-123.
31. Leong KC, Chen WS, Leong KW, et al. The use of text messaging to improve attendance in primary care: a randomized controlled trial. Fam Pract 2006; 23 (6): 699-705.
32. Liew SM, long SF, Lee VK, et al. Text messaging reminders to reduce non-attendance in chronic disease follow-up: a clinical trial. BrJ Gen Pract 2009; 59: 916-920.
33. Linschoten LR, van MM, Berger MY, et al. Supervised exercise therapy versus usual care for patellofemoral pain syndrome: an open label randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2009; 339: b4074.
34. Little P, Lewith G, Webley E, et al. Randomised controlled trial of Alexander technique lessons, exercise, and massage (ATEAM) for chronic and recurrent back pain. BMJ 2008; 337: a884.
35. Martins N, Monis P, Kelly PM. Food incentives to improve completion of tuberculosis treatment: randomised controlled trial in Dili, TimorLeste. BMJ 2009; 339: b4248.
36. McMahon L, Foran KM, Forrest SD, et al. Graduate mental health worker case management of depression in UK primary care: a pilot study. Br J Gen Pract 2007; 57 (544): 880-885.
37. McManus RJ, Mant J, Roalfe A, et al. Targets and self monitoring in hypertension: randomised controlled trial and cost effectiveness analysis. BMJ 2005; 331 (7515): 493.
38. Muirhead PE, Butcher G, Rankin J, Munley A. The effect of a programme of organised and supervised peer support on the initiation and duration of breastfeeding: a randomised trial. Br J Gen Pract 2006; 56 (524): 191-197.
39. Nanchahal K, Townsend J, Letley L, et al. Weight-management interventions in primary care: a pilot randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract 2009; 59 (562): e157-e166.
40. Norg RJ, van de BK, Portegijs PJ, et al. The effectiveness of a treatment protocol for male lower urinary tract symptoms in general practice: a practical randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract 2006; 56 (533): 938-944.
41. Roberts L, Wilson S, Singh S, et al. Gut-directed hypnotherapy for irritable bowel syndrome: piloting a primary care-based randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract 2006; 56 (523): 115-121.
42. Schreuders B, van Oppen P, van Marwijk HW, et al. Frequent attenders in general practice: problem solving treatment provided by nurses. BMC Fam Pract 2005; 6: 42.
43. Schroeder K, Fahey T, Hollinghurst S, Peters TJ. Nurse-led adherence support in hypertension: a randomized controlled trial. Fam Pract 2005; 22 (2): 144-151.
44. Thomas KJ, MacPherson H, Thorpe L, et al. Randomised controlled trial of a short course of traditional acupuncture compared with usual care for persistent non-specific low back pain. BMJ 2006; 333 (7569): 623.
45. Thomsen JL, Parner ET, Karlsmose B, et al. Effect of preventive health screening on long-term primary health care utilization. A randomized controlled trial. Fam Pract 2005; 22 (3): 242-248.
46. Van Rijn RM, van Os AG, Kleinrensink GJ, et al. Supervised exercises for adults with acute lateral ankle sprain: a randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract 2007; 57 (543): 793-800.
47. Vicens C, Fiol F, Llobera J, et al. Withdrawal from long-term benzodiazepine use: randomised trial in family practice. Br J Gen Pract 2006; 56 (533): 958-963. (Pubitemid 44941795)
48. Wake M, Baur LA, Gemer B, et al. Outcomes and costs of primary care surveillance and intervention for overweight or obese children: the LEAP 2 randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2009; 339: b3308.
49. Williams KS, Assassa RP, Cooper NJ, et al. Clinical and cost-effectiveness of a new nurse-led continence service: a randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract 2005; 55 (518): 696-703.
50. Bebb C, Kendrick D, Coupland C, et al. A cluster randomised controlled trial of the effect of a treatment algorithm for hypertension in patients with type 2 diabetes. Br J Gen Pract 2007; 57 (535): 136-143.
51. Bellon JA, Rodriguez-Bayon A, de Dios LJ, Torres-Gonzalez F. Successful GP intervention with frequent attenders in primary care: randomised controlled trial. BrJ Gen Pract 2008; 58 (550): 324-330.
52. Cals JW, Butler CC, Hopstaken RM, et al. Effect of point of care testing for C reactive protein and training in communication skills on antibiotic use in lower respiratory tract infections: cluster randomised trial. BMJ 2009; 338: b1374.
53. Cullen W, Stanley J, Langton D, et al. Hepatitis C infection among injecting drug users in general practice: a cluster randomised controlled trial of clinical guidelines' implementation. Br J Gen Pract 2006; 56 (532): 848-856.
54. Davies MJ, Heller S, Skinner TC, et al. Effectiveness of the diabetes education and self management for ongoing and newly diagnosed (DESMOND) programme for people with newly diagnosed type 2 diabetes: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2008; 336 (7642): 491-195.
55. De Groot M, de Keijser J, Neeleman J, et al. Cognitive behaviour therapy to prevent complicated grief among relatives and spouses bereaved by suicide: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2007; 334 (7601): 994.
56. Downs M, Turner S, Bryans M, et al. Effectiveness of educational interventions in improving detection and management of dementia in primary care: cluster randomised controlled study. BMJ 2006; 332 (7543): 692-696.
57. Fitzmaurice DA, Hobbs FD, Jowett S, et al. Screening versus routine practice in detection of atrial fibrillation in patients aged 65 or over: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2007; 335 (7616): 383.
58. Francis NA, Butler CC, Hood K, et al. Effect of using an interactive booklet about childhood respiratory tract infections in primary care consultations on reconsulting and antibiotic prescribing: a cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2009; 339: b2885.
59. Harmsen H, Bemsen R, Meeuwesen L, et al. The effect of educational intervention on intercultural communication: results of a randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract 2005; 55 (514): 343-350. (Pubitemid 40585207)
60. Hayward AQ Harling R, Wetten S, et al. Effectiveness of an influenza vaccine programme for care home staff to prevent death, morbidity, and health service use among residents: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2006; 333 (7581): 1241.
61. Hoddinott P, Britten J, Prescott GJ, et al. Effectiveness of policy to provide breastfeeding groups (BIG) for pregnant and breastfeeding mothers in primary care: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2009; 338: a3026.
62. Hogg W, Lemelin J, Graham. ID, et al. Improving prevention in primary care: evaluating the effectiveness of outreach facilitation. Fam Pract 2008; 25 (1): 40-18.
63. Janssen PG, Gorter KJ, Stolk RP, Rutten GE. Randomised controlled trial of intensive multifactorial treatment for cardiovascular risk in patients with screen-detected type 2 diabetes: 1-year data from the ADDITION Netherlands study. Br J Gen Pract 2009; 59 (558): 43-18.
64. Jellema P, van der Windt DA, van der Horst HE, et al. Should treatment of (sub)acute low back pain be aimed at psychosocial prognostic factors? Cluster randomised clinical trial in general practice. BMJ 2005; 331 (7508): 84.
65. Kerse N, Peri K, Robinson E, et al. Does a functional activity programme improve function, quality of life, and falls for residents in long term care? Cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2008; 337: a1445.
66. Lester H, Freemantle N, Wilson S, et al. Cluster randomised controlled trial of the effectiveness of primary care mental health workers. Br J Gen Pract 2007; 57 (536): 196-203.
67. Lester H, Birchwood M, Freemantle N, et al. REDIRECT: duster randomised controlled trial of GP training in first-episode psychosis. Br J Gen Pract 2009; 59 (563): e183-e190.
68. Lo Fo WS, Wester F, Mol SS, Lagro-Janssen TL. Increased awareness of intimate partner abuse after training: a randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract 2006; 56 (525): 249-257.
69. MacArthur C, Jolly K, Ingram L, et al. Antenatal peer support workers and initiation of breast feeding: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2009; 338: b131.
70. McNulty CA, Thomas M, Bowen J, et al Interactive workshops increase chlamydia testing in primary aire - a controlled study. Fam Pract 2008; 25 (4): 279-286.
71. McNulty CA, Thomas M, Bowen J, et al. Improving the appropriateness of laboratory submissions for urinalysis from general practice. Fam Pract 2008; 25 (4): 272-278.
72. Middleton JE McKinley RK, Gillies CL. Effect of patient completed agenda forms and doctors' education about the agenda on the outcome of consultations: randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2006; 332 (7552): 1238-1242.
73. Midlöv P, Bondesson A, Eriksson T, et al. Effects of educational outreach visits on prescribing of benzodiazepines and antipsychotic drugs to elderly patients in primary health care in southern Sweden. Fam Pract 2006; 23 (1): 60-64. (Pubitemid 43174687)
74. Morrell CJ, Slade P, Warner R, et al. Clinical effectiveness of health visitor training in psychologically informed approaches for depression in postnatal women: pragmatic cluster randomised trial in primary care. BMJ 2009; 338: a3045.
75. Murphy AW, Cupples ME, Smith SM, et al. Effect of tailored practice and patient care plans on secondary prevention of heart disease in general practice: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2009; 339: b4220.
76. Nijs KA, de Graaf Q Kok FJ, van Staveren WA. Effect of family style mealtimes on quality of life, physical performance, and body weight of nursing home residents: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2006; 332 (7551): 1180-1184.
77. Qureshi NN, Hatcher J, Chaturvedi N, Jafar TH. Effect of general practitioner education on adherence to antihypertensive drugs: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2007; 335 (7628): 1030.
78. Sackley CM, van den Berg ME, Lett K, et al. Effects of a physiotherapy and occupational therapy intervention on mobility and activity in care home residents: a cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2009; 339: b3123.
79. Slade M, Gask L, Leese M, et al. Failure to improve appropriateness of referrals to adult community mental health services - lessons from a multi-site cluster randomized controlled trial. Fam Pract 2008; 25 (3): 181-190. (Pubitemid 351965937)
80. Sandergaard J, Hansen DG, Aarslev P, Munck AP. A multifaceted intervention according to the Audit Project Odense method improved secondary prevention of ischemic heart disease: a randomised controlled trial. Fam Pract 2006; 23 (2): 198-202.
81. Van Bruggen BR, Goiter KJ, Stalk RP, et al. Implementation of locally adapted guidelines on type 2 diabetes. Fam Pract 2008; 25 (6): 430-437.
82. Van Marwijk HW, Ader H, de Haan M, Beekman A. Primary care management of major depression in patients aged ≥55 years: outcome of a randomised clinical trial. BrJ Gen Pract 2008; 58 (555): 680-611.
83. Vass M, Avlund K, Siersma V, Hendriksen C. A feasible model for prevention of functional decline in older home-dwelling people - the GP role. A municipality-randomized intervention trial. Fam Pract 2009; 26 (1): 56-64.
84. Wilkes S, Murdoch A, Steen N, et al. Open Access Tubal aSsessment for the initial management of infertility in general practice (the OATS trial): a pragmatic cluster randomised controlled trial. Br J Gen Pract 2009; 59 (562): 329-335.
85. Fransen GA, van Marrewijk CJ, Mujakovic S, et al. Pragmatic trials in primary care. Methodological challenges and solutions demonstrated by the DIAMOND study. BMC Med Res Methodol 2007; 7: 16.
86. Degenholtz HB, Parker LS, Reynolds CF, Trial design and informed consent for a clinic-based study with a treatment as usual control arm. Ethics Behav 2002; 12 (1): 43-62.
87. Staines GL, McKendrick K, Perils T, et al. Sequential assignment and treatment-as-usual. Alternatives to standard experimental designs in field studies of treatment efficacy. Eval Rev 1999; 23 (1): 47-76.
88. NIH program on Clinical Research Policy Analysis and Coordination. Meeting proceedings. Considering usual medical care in clinical trial design: scientific and ethical issues. Bethesda, MD: 14-15 November 2005.
89. NIH Rockville. Meeting summary. Treatment as usual: measurement, design and ethics. Rockville, MD: 4-5 November 2002.
90. Edwards SJ, Braunholtz DA, Lilford RJ, Stevens AJ. Ethical issues in the design and conduct of cluster randomised controlled trials. BMJ 1999; 318 (7195): 1407-1409.
91. Huibers MJ, Bleijenberg G, Beurskens AJ, et al. An alternative trial design to overcome validity and recruitment problems in primary care research. Fam Pract 2004; 21 (2): 213-218. (Pubitemid 38489407)
92. Macpherson H. Pragmatic clinical trials. Complement Ther Med 2004; 12 (2-3): 136-140.
93. Schellings R, Kessels AG, Ter RG, Kleijnen J, et al. Members of research ethics committees accepted a modification of the randomized consent design. J Clin Epidemiol 2005; 58 (6): 589-594.