Meta-analysis of short-term and long-term survival following repair versus replacement for ischemic mitral regurgitation

European Journal of Cardio-thoracic Surgery

Volumn 39, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 295-303

  Vassileva, Christina M ^a   Boley, Theresa ^a   Markwell, Stephen ^a   Hazelrigg, Stephen ^a  

^a SOUTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

Meta analysis; Mitral valve; Regurgitation; Surgery; Survival

Indexed keywords

ANNULOPLASTY; CORONARY ARTERY BYPASS GRAFT; DISEASE SEVERITY; HEART EJECTION FRACTION; HEART VENTRICLE FUNCTION; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; MEDLINE; META ANALYSIS; MITRAL VALVE REGURGITATION; MITRAL VALVE REPAIR; MITRAL VALVE REPLACEMENT; MORTALITY; POLITEF IMPLANT; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; SURVIVAL TIME; SUTURING METHOD; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; VALVULOPLASTY;

AGED; FEMALE; HEART VALVE PROSTHESIS; HEART VALVE PROSTHESIS IMPLANTATION; HUMANS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; MITRAL VALVE; MITRAL VALVE INSUFFICIENCY; MYOCARDIAL INFARCTION; SURVIVAL ANALYSIS; TREATMENT OUTCOME; VENTRICULAR FUNCTION;

EID: 78650352469     PISSN: 10107940     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ejcts.2010.06.034     Document Type: Review

References (71)

1. Pellizzon G.G., Grines C.L., Cox D.A., Stuckey T., Tcheng J.E., Garcia E., Guagliumi G., Turco M., Lansky A.J., Griffin J.J., Cohen D.J., Aymong E., Mehran R., O'Neill W.W., Stone G.W. Importance of mitral regurgitation inpatients undergoing percutaneous coronary intervention for acute myocardial infarction: the Controlled Abciximab and Device Investigation to Lower Late Angioplasty Complications (CADILLAC) trial. J Am Coll Cardiol 2004, 43:1368-1374.
2. Bursi F., Enriquez-Sarano M., Nkomo V.T., Jacobsen S.J., Weston S.A., Meverden R.A., Roger V.L. Heart failure and death after myocardial infarction in the community: the emerging role of mitral regurgitation. Circulation 2005, 111:295-301.
3. Bursi F., Enriquez-Sarano M., Jacobsen S.J., Roger V.L. Mitral regurgitation after myocardial infarction: a review. Am J Med 2006, 119:103-112.
4. Ennezat P.V., Darchis J., Lamblin N., Tricot O., Elkohen M., Aumégeat V., Equine O., Dujardin X., Saadouni H., Le Tourneau T., de Groote P., Bauters C. Left ventricular remodeling is associated with the severity of mitral regurgitation after inaugural anterior myocardial infarction-optimal timing for echocardiographic imaging. Am Heart J 2008, 155:959-965. REVE Investigators.
5. Lamas G.A., Mitchell G.F., Flaker G.C., Smith S.C., Gersh B.J., Basta L., Moyé L., Braunwald E., Pfeffer M.A. Clinical significance of mitral regurgitation after acute myocardial infarction. Survival and Ventricular Enlargement Investigators. Circulation 1997, 96:827-833.
6. Tcheng J.E., Jackman J.D., Nelson C.L., Gardner L.H., Smith L.R., Rankin J.S., Califf R.M., Stack R.S. Outcome of patients sustaining acute ischemic mitral regurgitation during myocardial infarction. Ann Intern Med 1992, 117:18-24.
7. Lehmann K.G., Francis C.K., Dodge H.T. Mitral regurgitation in early myocardial infarction. Incidence, clinical detection, and prognostic implications. TIMI Study Group. Ann Intern Med 1992, 117:10-17. 349.
8. Grigioni F., Enriquez-Sarano M., Zehr K.J., Bailey K.R., Tajik A.J. Ischemic mitral regurgitation: long-term outcome and prognostic implications with quantitative Doppler assessment. Circulation 2001, 103:1759-1764.
9. Feinberg M.S., Schwammenthal E., Shlizerman L., Porter A., Hod H., Friemark D., Matezky S., Boyko V., Mandelzweig L., Vered Z., Behar S., Sagie A. Prognostic significance of mild mitral regurgitation by color Doppler echocardiography in acute myocardial infarction. Am J Cardiol 2000, 86:903-907.
10. Nesković A.N., Marinković J., Bojić M., Popović A.D. Early predictors of mitral regurgitation after acute myocardial infarction. Am J Cardiol 1999, 84:329-332. A8.
11. Barzilai B., Gessler C., Pérez J.E., Schaab C., Jaffe A.S. Significance of Doppler-detected mitral regurgitation in acute myocardial infarction. Am J Cardiol 1988, 61:220-223.
12. Golia G., Anselmi M., Rossi A., Cicoira M.A., Tinto M., Marino P., Zardini P. Relationship between mitral regurgitation and myocardial viability after acute myocardial infarction: their impact on prognosis. Int J Cardiol 2001, 78:81-90.
13. Alam M., Thorstrand C., Rosenhamer G. Mitral regurgitation following first-time acute myocardial infarction-early and late findings by Doppler echocardiography. Clin Cardiol 1993, 16:30-34.
14. Parmar M.K.B., Torri V., Stewart L. Extracting summary statistics to perform meta-analyses of the published literature for survival endpoints. Stat Med 1988, 17:2815-2834.
15. Williamson P.R., Smith C.T., Hutton J.L., Marson A.G. Aggregate data meta-analysis with time-to-event outcomes. Stat Med 2002, 21:3337-3351.
16. Borenstein M., Hedges L., Higgins J., Rothstein H. Comprehensive Meta-Analysis Version 2 2005, Biostat, Engelwood, NJ.
17. Higgins J.P.T., Thompson S.G. Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Stat Med 2002, 21:1539-1558.
18. Egger M., Davey Smith G., Schneider M., Minder C. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ 1997, 315:629-634.
19. Grossi E.A., Goldberg J.D., LaPietra A., Ye X., Zakow P., Sussman M., Delianides J., Culliford A.T., Esposito R.A., Ribakove G.H., Galloway A.C., Colvin S.B. Ischemic mitral valve reconstruction and replacement: comparison of long-term survival and complications. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2001, 122:1107-1124.
20. Bonacchi M., Prifti E., Maiani M., Frati G., Nathan N.S., Leacche M. Mitral valve surgery simultaneous to coronary revascularization in patients with end-stage ischemic cardiomyopathy. Heart Vessels 2006, 21:20-27.
21. Calafiore A.M., Mauro M.D., Gallina S., Yassin I.M., Shaheen Y.A., Canosa C., Iacò A.L., Mazzei V. Surgical treatment of mitral valve regurgitation in dilated cardiomyopathy. Heart Surg Forum 2004, 7:21-25.
22. Gillinov A.M., Wierup P.N., Blackstone E.H., Bishay E.S., Cosgrove D.M., White J., Lytle B.W., McCarthy P.M. Is repair preferable to replacement for ischemic mitral regurgitation?. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2001, 122:1125-1141.
23. Hausmann H., Siniawski H., Hotz H., Hofmeister J., Chavez T., Schmidt G., Hetzer R. Mitral valve reconstruction and mitral valve replacement for ischemic mitral insufficiency. J Card Surg 1997, 12:8-14.
24. Hausmann H., Siniawski H., Hetzer R. Mitral valve reconstruction and replacement for ischemic mitral insufficiency: seven years' follow up. J Heart Valve Dis 1999, 8:536-542.
25. Cohn L.H., Rizzo R.J., Adams D.H., Couper G.S., Sullivan T.E., Collins J.J., Aranki S.F. The effect of pathophysiology on the surgical treatment of ischemic mitral regurgitation: operative and late risks of repair versus replacement. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 1995, 9:568-574.
26. Rankin J.S., Feneley M.P., Hickey M.S., Muhlbaier L.H., Wechsler A.S., Floyd R.D., Reves J.G., Skelton T.N., Califf R.M., Lowe J.E., Sabiston D.C. A clinical comparison of mitral valve repair versus valve replacement in ischemic mitral regurgitation. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1988, 95:165-177.
27. Kay G.L., Kay J.H., Zubiate P., Yokoyama T., Mendez M. Mitral valve repair for mitral regurgitation secondary to coronary artery disease. Circulation 1986, 74:I88-I98.
28. Oury J.H., Cleveland J.C., Duran C.G., Angell W.W. Ischemic mitral valve disease: classification and systemic approach to management. J Card Surg 1994, 9(2 Suppl.):262-273.
29. Magne J., Girerd N., Sénéchal M., Mathieu P., Dagenais F., Dumesnil J.G., Charbonneau E., Voisine P., Pibarot P. Mitral repair versus replacement for ischemic mitral regurgitation: comparison of short-term and long-term survival. Circulation 2009, 120:S104-S111.
30. Micovic S., Milacic P., Otasevic P., Tasic N., Boskovic S., Nezic D., Djukanovic B. Comparison of valve annuloplasty and replacement for ischemic mitral valve incompetence. Heart Surg Forum 2008, 11:E340-E345.
31. Milano C.A., Daneshmand M.A., Rankin J.S., Honeycutt E., Williams M.L., Swaminathan M., Linblad L., Shaw L.K., Glower D.D., Smith P.K. Survival prognosis and surgical management of ischemic mitral regurgitation. Ann Thorac Surg 2008, 86:735-744.
32. Ngaage D.L., Daly R.C., Rosales G., Sundt T.M., Dearani J.A., Mullany C.J., McGregor C.G., Orszulak T.A., Puga F.J., Schaff H.V. Mitral regurgitation surgery in heart failure due to ischemic cardiomyopathy: a 24-year experience. J Heart Valve Dis 2008, 17:251-259. [Discussion 259-60].
33. Silberman S., Oren A., Klutstein M.W., Deeb M., Asher E., Merin O., Fink D., Bitran D. Does mitral valve intervention have an impact on late survival in ischemic cardiomyopathy?. Isr Med Assoc J 2006, 8:17-20.
34. Al-Radi O.O., Austin P.C., Tu J.V., David T.E., Yau T.M. Mitral repair versus replacement for ischemic mitral regurgitation. Ann Thorac Surg 2005, 79:1260-1267. [Discussion 1260-7].
35. Mantovani V., Mariscalco G., Leva C., Blanzola C., Cattaneo P., Sala A. Long-term results of the surgical treatment of chronic ischemic mitral regurgitation: comparison of repair and prosthetic replacement. J Heart Valve Dis 2004, 13:421-428. [Discussion 428-9].
36. Reece T.B., Tribble C.G., Ellman P.I., Maxey T.S., Woodford R.L., Dimeling G.M., Wellons H.A., Crosby I.K., Kern J.A., Kron I.L. Mitral repair is superior to replacement when associated with coronary artery disease. Ann Surg 2004, 239:671-675. [Discussion 675-7].
37. Hickey M.S., Smith L.R., Muhlbaier L.H., Harrell F.E., Reves J.G., Hinohara T., Califf R.M., Pryor D.B., Rankin J.S. Current prognosis of ischemic mitral regurgitation. Implications for future management. Circulation 1988, 78:I51-I59.
38. Higgins J.P.T., Thompson S.G., Deeks J.J., Altman D.G. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analysis. BMJ 2003, 327:557-560.
39. Shuhaiber J., Anderson R.J. Meta-analysis of clinical outcomes following surgical mitral valve repair or replacement. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2007, 31:267-275.
40. Gammie J.S., Sheng S., Griffith B.P., Peterson E.D., Rankin J.S., O'Brien S.M., Brown J.M. Trends in mitral valve surgery in the United States: results from the Society of Thoracic Surgeons Adult Cardiac Surgery Database. Ann Thorac Surg 2009, 87:1431-1437. [Discussion 1437-9].
41. Kulik A., Bédard P., Lam B.K., Rubens F.D., Hendry P.J., Masters R.G., Mesana T.G., Ruel M. Mechanical versus bioprosthetic valve replacement in middle-aged patients. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2006, 30:485-491.
42. Sidhu P., O'Kane H., Ali N., Gladstone D.J., Sarsam M.A., Campalani G., MacGowan S.W. Mechanical or bioprosthetic valves in the elderly: a 20-year comparison. Ann Thorac Surg 2001, 71:S257-S260.
43. Hammermeister K., Sethi G.K., Henderson W.G., Grover F.L., Oprian C., Rahimtoola S.H. Outcomes 15 years after valve replacement with a mechanical versus a bioprosthetic valve: final report of the veterans affairs randomized trial. J Am Coll Cardiol 2000, 36:1152-1158.
44. Asimakopoulos G., Edwards M.B., Brannan J., Taylor K.M. Survival and cause of death after mitral valve replacement in patients aged 80 years and over: collective results from the UK heart valve registry. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 1997, 11:922-928.
45. Grossi E.A., Galloway A.C., Miller J.S., Ribakove G.H., Culliford A.T., Esposito R., Delianides J., Buttenheim P.M., Baumann F.G., Spencer F.C., Colvin S.B. Valve repair versus replacement for mitral insufficiency: when is a mechanical valve still indicated?. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1998, 115:389-394. [Discussion 394-6].
46. Kawachi Y., Oe M., Asou T., Tominaga R., Tokunaga K. Comparative study between valve repair and replacement for mitral pure regurgitation-early and late postoperative results. Jpn Circ J 1991, 55:443-452.
47. Ren J.F., Aksut S., Lighty G.W., Vigilante G.J., Sink J.D., Segal B.L., Hargrove W.C. Mitral valve repair is superior to valve replacement for the early preservation of cardiac function: relation of ventricular geometry to function. Am Heart J 1996, 131:974-981.
48. Okita Y., Miki S., Ueda Y., Tahata T., Sakai T., Matsuyama K. Comparative evaluation of left ventricular performance after mitral valve repair or valve replacement with or without chordal preservation. J Heart Valve Dis 1993, 2:159-166. comment 148-9.
49. Sand M.E., Naftel D.C., Blackstone E.H., Kirklin J.W., Karp R.B. A comparison of repair and replacement for mitral valve incompetence. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1987, 94:208-219.
50. Perier P., Deloche A., Chauvaud S., Fabiani J.N., Rossant P., Bessou J.P., Relland J., Bourezak H., Gomez F., Blondeau P., Dallaines C., Carpentier A. Comparative evaluation of mitral valve repair and replacement with Starr, Björk, and porcine valve prostheses. Circulation 1984, 70:I187-I192.
51. Tischler M.D., Cooper K.A., Rowen M., LeWinter M.M. Mitral valve replacement versus mitral valve repair. A Doppler and quantitative stress echocardiographic study. Circulation 1994, 89:132-137.
52. Galloway A.C., Colvin S.B., Baumann F.G., Grossi E.A., Ribakove G.H., Harty S., Spencer F.C. A comparison of mitral valve reconstruction with mitral valve replacement: intermediate-term results. Ann Thorac Surg 1989, 47:655-662.
53. McGee E.C., Gillinov A.M., Blackstone E.H., Rajeswaran J., Cohen G., Najam F., Shiota T., Sabik J.F., Lytle B.W., McCarthy P.M., Cosgrove D.M. Recurrent mitral regurgitation after annuloplasty for functional ischemic mitral regurgitation. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2004, 128:916-924.
54. Gillinov A.M., Cosgrove D.M., Blackstone E.H., Diaz R., Arnold J.H., Lytle B.W., Smedira N.G., Sabik J.F., McCarthy P.M., Loop F.D. Durability of mitral valve repair for degenerative disease. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1998, 116:734-743.
55. Gillinov A.M., Tantiwongkosri K., Blackstone E.H., Houghtaling P.L., Nowicki E.R., Sabik J.F., Johnston D.R., Svensson L.G., Mihaljevic T. Is prosthetic annuloplasty necessary for durable mitral valve repair?. Ann Thorac Surg 2009, 88:76-82.
56. Czer L.S., Maurer G., Trento A., DeRobertis M., Nessim S., Blanche C., Kass R.M., Chaux A., Matloff J.M. Comparative efficacy of ring and suture annuloplasty for ischemic mitral regurgitation. Circulation 1992, 86:II46-52.
57. Lillehei C.W., Levy M.J., Bonnabeau R.C. Mitral valve replacement with preservation of papillary muscles and chordae tendinae. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1964, 47:532-543.
58. Reardon M.J., David T.E. Mitral valve replacement with preservation of the subvalvular apparatus. Curr Opin Cardiol 1999, 14:104-110.
59. Rao C., Hart J., Chow A., Siannis F., Tsalafouta P., Murtuza B., Darzi A., Wells F.C., Athanasiou T. Does preservation of the sub-valvular apparatus during mitral valve replacement affect long-term survival and quality of life? A microsimulation study. J Cardiothorac Surg 2008, 3:17.
60. Taşdemir O., Katircioĝlu F., Catav Z., Tezcaner T., Kural T., Zorlutuna Y., Bayazit K. Clinical results of mitral valve replacement with and without preservation of the posterior mitral valve leaflet and subvalvular apparatus. J Cardiovasc Surg (Torino) 1991, 32:509-515.
61. Yun K.L., Sintek C.F., Miller D.C., Schuyler G.T., Fletcher A.D., Pfeffer T.A., Kochamba G.S., Khonsari S., Zile M.R. Randomized trial of partial versus complete chordal preservation methods of mitral valve replacement: A preliminary report. Circulation 1999, 100:II90-II94.
62. Yun K.L., Sintek C.F., Miller D.C., Pfeffer T.A., Kochamba G.S., Khonsari S., Zile M.R. Randomized trial comparing partial versus complete chordal-sparing mitral valve replacement: effects on left ventricular volume and function. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2002, 123:707-714.
63. Come P.C., Riley M.F., Weintraub R.M., Wei J.Y., Markis J.E., Lorell B.H., Grossman W. Dynamic left ventricular outflow tract obstruction when the anterior leaflet is retained at prosthetic mitral valve replacement. Ann Thorac Surg 1987, 43:561-563.
64. Grossi E.A., Bizekis C.S., LaPietra A., Derivaux C.C., Galloway A.C., Ribakove G.H., Culliford A.T., Esposito R.A., Delianides J., Colvin S.B. Late results of isolated mitral annuloplasty for " functional" ischemic mitral insufficiency. J Card Surg 2001, 16:328-332.
65. Tahta S.A., Oury J.H., Maxwell J.M., Hiro S.P., Duran C.M. Outcome after mitral valve repair for functional ischemic mitral regurgitation. J Heart Valve Dis 2002, 11:11-18. [Discussion 18-9].
66. Magne J., Pibarot P., Dumesnil J.G., Sénéchal M. Continued global left ventricular remodeling is not the sole mechanism responsible for the late recurrence of ischemic mitral regurgitation after restrictive annuloplasty. J Am Soc Echocardiogr 2009, 22:1256-1264.
67. Kuwahara E., Otsuji Y., Iguro Y., Ueno T., Zhu F., Mizukami N., Kubota K., Nakashiki K., Yuasa T., Yu B., Uemura T., Takasaki K., Miyata M., Hamasaki S., Kisanuki A., Levine R.A., Sakata R., Tei C. Mechanism of recurrent/persistent ischemic/functional mitral regurgitation in the chronic phase after surgical annuloplasty: importance of augmented posterior leaflet tethering. Circulation 2006, 114:I529-I534.
68. Kongsaerepong V., Shiota M., Gillinov A.M., Song J.M., Fukuda S., McCarthy P.M., Williams T., Savage R., Daimon M., Thomas J.D., Shiota T. Echocardiographic predictors of successful versus unsuccessful mitral valve repair in ischemic mitral regurgitation. Am J Cardiol 2006, 98:504-508.
69. Onorati F., Rubino A.S., Marturano D., Pasceri E., Santarpino G., Zinzi S., Mascaro G., Renzulli A. Midterm clinical and echocardiographic results and predictors of mitral regurgitation recurrence following restrictive annuloplasty for ischemic cardiomyopathy. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2009, 138:654-662.
70. Roshanali F., Mandegar M.H., Yousefnia M.A., Rayatzadeh H., Alaeddini F. A prospective study of predicting factors in ischemic mitral regurgitation recurrence after ring annuloplasty. Ann Thorac Surg 2007, 84:745-749.
71. Magne J., Pibarot P., Dagenais F., Hachicha Z., Dumesnil J.G., Sénéchal M. Preoperative posterior leaflet angle accurately predicts outcome after restrictive mitral valve annuloplasty for ischemic mitral regurgitation. Circulation 2007, 115:782-791.