Between tortured bodies and resurfacing bones: The politics of the dead in Zimbabwe

Journal of Material Culture

Volumn 15, Issue 4, 2010, Pages 423-448

  Fontein, Joost ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EDINBURGH   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

affective presence and properties of materials; bones and bodies; emotive materiality; Zimbabwe

Indexed keywords

BONE; MATERIAL CULTURE; POLITICAL VIOLENCE; POLITICS; POST-COLONIALISM; SOVEREIGNTY;

ZIMBABWE;

EID: 78650350952     PISSN: 13591835     EISSN: 14603586     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/1359183510383105     Document Type: Article

References (164)

1. AIDS-Free World (2009) Electing to rape: sexual terror in Mugabe's Zimbabwe, December.
2. Alexander J., McGregor J. and Ranger R. (2000) Violence and Memory. Oxford: James Currey.
3. Appadurai A. (1998) Dead certainty: ethnic violence in the era of globalization. Public Culture 10(2): 225-47.
4. Baines E. (2010) Spirits and social reconstruction after mass violence: rethinking transitional justice. African Affairs 109(436): 409-30.
5. BBC News (2007) Confessions of a Zimbabwe Torturer. Available at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/6275152.stm.
6. BBC News (2008a) Tracking down a massacre, 7 May.
7. BBC News (2008b) Death of a Zimbabwean activist, 23 May.
8. Bloch M. (1988) Death and the concept of the person. In: Cederroth Set al.(eds) On the Meaning of Death. Stockholm: AUU, 11-30.
9. Bourdillon MFC (1987) The Shona Peoples. Gweru: Mambo Press.
10. Brickhill J. (1995) Making peace with the past: war victims and the work of the Mafela trust. In: Bhebe N and Ranger T (eds) Soldiers in Zimbabwe's Liberation War. London: James Currey, 163-73.
11. Brown B. (2001) Thing theory. Critical Enquiry 28(1): 1-22.
12. Brown M. (2007) The fallen, the front and the finding: archaeology, human remains and the Great War. Archaeological Review from Cambridge 22(2): 53-68.
13. Catholic Commission for Justice and Peace (CCJP) (2007) Gukurahundi in Zimbabwe: A Report on the Disturbances in Matabeleland and the Midlands 1980-1988. London: Hurst.
14. Cox JL (1998) Rational Ancestors: Scientific Rationality and African Indigenous Religions. Cardiff: Cardiff Academic Press.
15. Cox JL (2005) The land crisis in Zimbabwe. Fieldwork in Religion 1(1): 35-48.
16. Daily News (2001a) MPs attack selection of national heroes, 2 March.
17. Daily News (2001b) We want to know where our loved ones are buried, Letters, 3 September.
18. Daily News (2001c) 56 war vets reburied, 25 October.
19. Daily News (2002) Political thugs to pay for murderous acts through mental illness, 27 April.
20. Daneel M. (as Mafuranhunzi Gumbo) (1995) Guerrilla Snuff. Harare: Baobab Books.
21. Daneel M. (1998) African Earthkeepers. Pretoria: Unisa Press.
22. Douglas M. (1966) Purity and Danger. London: Routledge.
23. Eppel S. (2001) Healing the Dead to Transform the Living: Exhumation and Reburial in Zimbabwe. Available at: http://www.icrc.org/themissi.nsf/32db2800384e72adc12569dd00505ac6/72889407ac24b246c1256b04004739f6/$FILE/healing%20the%20dead-%20calif%20conf%202001.rtf.
24. Eppel S. (2004) 'Gukurahundi': the need for truth and reparation. In: Raftopoulos B, Savage T (eds) Zimbabwe Injustice and Political Reconciliation. Harare: Weaver Press, 43-62.
25. Eppel S. (2009) A tale of three dinner plates: truth and the challenges of human rights research in Zimbabwe. Journal of Southern African Studies 35(4): 967-76.
26. Filippucci P. (forthcoming) Archaeology and memory on the Western Front. In: Boric D (ed.) Archaeology and Memory. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
27. Financial Gazette (2003) 'Green bombers' using rape as political weapon, 4 October.
28. Fontein J. (2006a) The Silence of Great Zimbabwe. London: UCL Press.
29. Fontein J. (2006b) Shared legacies of the war: spirit mediums and war veterans in southern Zimbabwe. Journal of Religion in Africa 36(2): 167-99.
30. Fontein J. (2009a) The Politics of the Dead: Living Heritage, Bones and Commemoration in Zimbabwe. Available at: http://www.theasa.org/publications/asaonline/articles/asaonline0102.pdf.
31. Fontein J. (2009b) Graves, ruins and belonging: towards an anthropology of proximity. Curl Lecture, Royal Anthropological Institute, British Museum, September.
32. Fontein J. and Harries J. (2009) Report of the Bones Collective Workshop, 4-5 December 2008. Available at: www.san.ed.ac.uk/_data/assets/pdf_file/0013/29110/Final_Report.pdf.
33. Fry P. (1976) Spirits of Protest. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
34. Geary P. (1988) Sacred commodities: the circulation of medieval relics. In: Appadurai A (ed.) The Social Life of Things. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 169-91.
35. Gell A. (1998) Art and Agency: An Anthropological Theory. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
36. Globe & Mail (2008) Another violent loss for Zimbabwe's opposition, 24 May.
37. Grundy T. (2005) 'Mugabe Still Fears Chitepo's Legacy', Africa Reports: Zimbabwe Elections No 16, Institute for War and Peace Reporting, 17 March.
38. The Guardian (UK) (2008) Bodies pile up as Mugabe wages war on diamond miners, 11 December.
39. Harare Tribune (2009) Confessions of a Zimbabwe CIO ZANU-PF thug, 22 March.
40. Harries J. and Fontein J. (2010) The Matter of Bones. Unpublished manuscript.
41. Herald (2004a) Remains of liberation war fighter exhumed, 10 July.
42. Herald (2004b) State to probe discovery of mass graves, 16 July.
43. Herald (2008) Mutilated body found, 11 June.
44. Herald (2009) National healing begins, 15 June.
45. Hertz R. (1960) Death and the Right Hand. New York: Free Press.
46. Hove C. (1988) Bones. Harare: Baobab Press.
47. Hove C. (1996) Ancestors. London: Picador.
48. Human Rights Watch (HRW) (2008) 'Bullets for Each of You': State-Sponsored Violence since Zimbabwe's March 29 Elections. Available at: http://www.hrw.org/en/reports/2008/06/19/bullets-each-you.
49. Independent (2007a) Zimbabwe's terror: how I raped and tortured for Mugabe, 7 June.
50. Independent (2007b) Zimbabwe needs an apolitical National Heroes Commission, 13 August.
51. Independent (2009) Hurdles lie in wait for National healing process, 30 July.
52. Ingold T. (2007) Materials against materiality. Archaeological Dialogues 14(1): 1-16.
53. Integrated Regional Information Networks (IRIN) (2003) Zimbabwe: focus on rape as political weapon, 8 April.
54. Integrated Regional Information Networks (IRIN) (2009) Political violence growing in rural areas, 27 June.
55. Kriger N. (1992) Zimbabwe's Guerrilla War: Peasant Voices. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
56. Kriger N. (1995) The politics of creating national heroes. In: Bhebe N, Ranger T (eds) Soldiers in Zimbabwe's Liberation War. London: James Currey, 118-38.
57. Kü;chler S. (1999) The place of memory. In: Forty A, Kü;chler S (eds) The Art of Forgetting. Oxford: Berg, 53-72.
58. Lan D. (1985) Guns and Rain. London: James Currey.
59. Latour B. (1999) Pandora's Hope: An Essay on the Reality of Science Studies. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
60. Leach J. (2007) Differentiation and encompassment: a critique of Alfred Gell's theory of the abduction of creativity. In: Henare Aet al.(eds) Thinking through Things. London: Routledge, 167-88.
61. Linden I. (1980) The Catholic Church and the Struggle for Zimbabwe. London: Longman.
62. Livingston J. (2008) Disgust, bodily aesthetics and the ethic of being human in Botswana. Africa 78(2): 288-307.
63. Maalki L. (1995) Purity and Exile. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
64. McLaughlin J. (1996) On the Front Line: Catholic Missions in Zimbabwe's Liberation War. Harare: Baobab Books.
65. Masunungure E (ed.) (2009) Defying the Winds of Change: Zimbabwe's 2008 Elections. Harare: Weaver Press.
66. Mattheeuws C. (2008) Do crisps flavoured with chicken tikka have something in common with central-East Malagasy ancestral bodies? Unpublished paper, presented at the 'What lies beneath' conference, Edinburgh University, December.
67. Maxwell D. (1999) Christians and Chiefs in Zimbabwe: A Social History of the Hwesa People c.1870s-1990s. London: Edinburgh University Press.
68. Mbembe A. (2003) Necropolitics. Public Culture 15(1): 11-40.
69. Miller D. (2005) Materiality: an introduction. In: Miller D (ed.) Materiality. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
70. Nation (Kenya) (2007) Film reveals horror details of Ndebele massacre, 11 November.
71. Navaro-Yashin Y. (2009) Affective spaces, melancholic objects: ruination and the production of anthropological knowledge. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 15(1): 1-18.
72. Nehandaradio.com (2009) Dabengwa wants 'unqualified apology', 12 August.
73. New York Times (1984) Zimbabwe discovers 4000 in mass graves, 7 March.
74. New Zimbabwe (2004) Independence war mass graves unearthed in Zimbabwe, 8 July.
75. New Zimbabwe (2008) Hackers target Herald website, 12 May.
76. newzimbabwe.com (2008) MDC activist's decomposed body found, 2 June.
77. Niehus I. (2007) Death before dying. Journal of Southern African Studies 33(4): 845-60.
78. Primorac R. (2007) The poetics of state terror in twenty-first-century Zimbabwe. Interventions 6(3): 434-50.
79. Radio VOP (2009a) Tsvangirai calls for inclusive process to choose heroes, 12 August.
80. Radio VOP (2009b) Headman in hot soup with ZANU PF, 13 August.
81. Radio VOP (2010) Hunter finds activist's remains, 6 January.
82. radiovop.com (2009a) Soldiers beat resident for playing anti-Mugabe ringing tune, 17 August.
83. radiovop.com (2009b) MDC-T activist murdered in fresh political violence, 31 August.
84. radiovop.com (2010a) ZANU PF sets up torture bases, 25 January.
85. radiovop.com (2010b) Masvingo villagers get a hiding for attending MDC-T Rally, 7 February.
86. radiovop.com (2010c) Zanu PF Youth Militia forces villagers to join party, 12 March.
87. Ranger T. (1967) Revolt in Southern Rhodesia 1896-7. London: Heineman.
88. Ranger T. (1985) Peasant Consciousness and Guerrilla War in Zimbabwe. London: James Currey.
89. Ranger T. (1999) Voices from the Rocks. Oxford: James Currey.
90. Ranger T. (2004) Nationalist historiography, patriotic history and the history of the nation: the struggle over the past in Zimbabwe. Journal of Southern African Studies 30(2): 215-34.
91. Rowlands M. (1999) Remembering to forget: sublimation as sacrifice in war memorials. In: Forty A, Kü;chler S (eds) The Art of Forgetting. Oxford: Berg, 129-46.
92. Scott M. (2005) Hybridity, vacuity, and blockage: visions of chaos from anthropological theory, Island Melanesia and Central Africa. Comparative Studies of Society and History 47(1): 190-216.
93. Shoko T. (2006) 'My bones shall rise again': war veterans, spirits and land reform in Zimbabwe. Leiden: African Studies Centre, ASC Working Paper no. 68.
94. Solidarity Peace Trust (SPT) (2008a) Punishing Dissent, Silencing Citizens: The Zimbabwe Elections 2008. Available at: http://www.solidaritypeacetrust.org/133/punishing-dissent-silencing-citizens/.
95. Solidarity Peace Trust (SPT) (2008b) Desperately Seeking Sanity: What Prospects for a New Beginning in Zimbabwe? Available at: http://www.solidaritypeacetrust.org/326/desperately-seeking-sanity/.
96. SW Radio Africa (2005) Mass graves from Gukurahundi era located in Matabeleland, 19 October.
97. SW Radio Africa (2007) Abducted journalist found dead, 4 April.
98. SW Radio Africa (2008a) ZANU PF militia blocking access to dead MDC activists in centenary, 14 May.
99. SW Radio Africa (2008b) Zanu PF thugs disrupt MDC funeral in Harare, 22 May.
100. SW Radio Africa (2008c) State agents want to dig up Tonderai Ndira's body, 29 May.
101. swradioafrica.com (2009a) Victims of diamond massacre buried in Chitungwiza mass graves, 19 May.
102. swradioafrica.com (2009b) Gov. dedicates three days to national healing, 21 July.
103. swradioafrica.com (2009c) Another MDC activist murdered, 7 September.
104. swradioafrica.com (2009d) Nkala denies contributing to Gukurahundi, wants Mugabe prosecuted, 18 December.
105. swradioafrica.com (2010) ZimRights forced to abandon photo exhibition after launch, 25 March.
106. Taylor C. (1999) Sacrifice as Terror. New York: Berg.
107. The Standard (1997) Matabele slaughter: CCJP report exposé, 4-10 May.
108. The Standard (2006) Msika speaks out on Gukurahundi, 15 October.
109. The Standard (2007a) Gukurahundi fears split Zanu, 29 April.
110. The Standard (2007b) Police bar memorial service, 12 August.
111. The Standard (2008) Corpses rot as ZANU PF terror moves a gear up, 3 May.
112. The Standard (2009a) Parties clash at hero's funeral, 11 July.
113. The Standard (2009b) GNU crafts bill to 'guide national healing', 18 July.
114. The Standard (2009c) Broaden selection of national heroes, 8 August.
115. The Standard (2009d) Sunday view: state's celebration of denial: political uses of national healing, 8 August.
116. The Standard (2009e) Gukurahundi victims confront Nkomo, 28 November.
117. The Standard (2010a) Ziyapa Moyo's family blasts ZANU PF, 6 February.
118. The Standard (2010b) High drama as ngozi fears grip Gokwe, 6 March.
119. The Standard (2010c) The wage of torture is torture, 20 March.
120. The Sunday Mail (2008a) Mt Darwin's killing fields, 13 January.
121. The Sunday Mail (2008b) Mysterious deaths rock Kanyemba, 3 June.
122. The Sunday Times (UK) (2001a) Mugabe eats supper with spirit of dead rival, 12 August.
123. The Sunday Times (UK) (2001b) Paranoid Mugabe dines with a ghost, 2 September.
124. The Sunday Tribune (2008) Family forced to rush burial of murdered MDC leader, 20 April.
125. The Times (UK) (2008) Victims of Zimbabwean diamond crackdown to be dumped in mass grave, 13 December.
126. thezimbabwetimes.com (2009) Dabengwa says Mugabe must apologise, 12 May.
127. UN Wire (2003) Rapes linked to groups tied to Ruling ZANU PF Party, 21 March.
128. Venis S. (2003) The interview: Shari Eppel. The Lancet 361 (9354): 354.
129. Vera I. (1993) Nehanda. Harare: Baobab Press.
130. Verdery K. (1999) The Political Lives of Dead Bodies. New York: Columbia University Press.
131. VOA News (2007) Zimbabwe security forces disrupt opposition memorial service, 13 August.
132. Werbner R. (1991) Tears of the Dead. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
133. Werbner R. (1998) Smoke from the barrel of a gun. In: Werbner R (ed.) Memory and the Post-colony: African Anthropology and the Critique of Power. London: Zed Books, 71-102.
134. Williams H. (2004) Death warmed up: the agency of bodies and bones in early Anglo-Saxon cremation rites. Journal of Material Culture 9(3): 263-91.
135. ZBC News (2008) Efforts to locate 2nd Chimurenga mass graves continuing, 12 January.
136. Zimbabwe Human Rights (ZHR) NGO Forum (2009) Taking Transitional Justice to the People, Outreach Report. Harare: ZHR NGO Forum.
137. Zimbabwe Independent (2000) Evidence of 'dirty war' lies far below, 29 September.
138. Zimbabwe Times (2009) Leaders to launch national healing Friday, 22 July.
139. Zimbabwe Today (2008) The revenge of the dead, 13 March.
140. Zimbabwean (2007a) MDC names real heroes, 9 August.
141. Zimbabwean (2007b) ZANU PF forcibly buries murambatsvina victim as police disrupt solidarity service, 18 September.
142. Zimbabwean (2008a) Two more MDC activists callously murdered, 19 May.
143. Zimbabwean (2008b) Taking transitional justice to the people, 13 August.
144. Zimbabwean (2009a) 'I need forgiveness' - Biggie Chitoro, 6 May.
145. Zimbabwean (2009b) Headman cleanses torture base, 22 July.
146. Zimbabwean (2009c) Tsvangirai wants Gukurahundi probe, 25 July.
147. Zimbabwean (2009d) Amnesty is way to national healing: Gono, 7 August.
148. Zimbabwean (2009e) Merchants of violence regroup, 28 August.
149. Zimbabwean (2010a) War vets dig up Great Zimbabwe Ruins, 14 February.
150. Zimbabwean (2010b) National healing elusive, as torture bases re-emerge, 16 February.
151. zimbabwejournalists.com (2008a) Another Brutal Murder of an MDC Hero. Available at: http://zimbabwejournalists.com/story.php?art_id=4069&cat=4.
152. zimbabwejournalists.com (2008b) MDC Activist Ndira Buried as Another Body Is Found in Goromonzi. Available at: http://zimbabwejournalists.com/story.php?art_id=4192&cat=1.
153. zimbabwemetro.com (2008a) Gukurahundi memorial website launched, 30 May.
154. zimbabwemetro.com (2008b) CIO hid MDC activist's corpse, 23 July.
155. zimbabwetimes.com (2008) Ndira's mutilated body found in mortuary, 24 May.
156. zimbabwetimes.com (2009a) Hero's acre must be closed, 16 August.
157. zimbabwetimes.com (2009b) Mugabe must restore dignity to burial, 6 November.
158. zimdaily.com (2007) Zimbabwe: ZESA Engineers recover three bodies from Kariba Dam, 12 April; alsowww.thechiefbaboon.com/forums/showthread.php?t=6482.
159. zimeye.org (2010) MDC activist was murdered by police, 5 February.
160. zimnetradio.com (2009) Redefine hero status conferment - MDC, 7 August.
161. zimonline.co.za (2007) Moyo says Gukurahundi Bill ready by September, 16 May.
162. zimonline.co.za (2009) Zim healing process flawed, 24 July.
163. ZW News (2009a) Push to classify Gukurahundi as genocide, 8 June.
164. ZW News (2009b) Gukurahundi graves are 'war crime sites', 18 July.