A large-scale survey of heterochrony in anuran cranial ossification patterns

Journal of Zoological Systematics and Evolutionary Research

Volumn 48, Issue 4, 2010, Pages 332-347

  Weisbecker, Vera ^a,b   Mitgutsch, Christian ^c  

^a FRIEDRICH SCHILLER UNIVERSITY JENA   (Germany)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE   (United Kingdom)

^c PALÄONTOLOGISCHES INSTITUT UND MUSEUM   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

Anura; Cranium; Event pairs; Heterochrony; Ossification

Indexed keywords

ALGORITHM; CRANIUM; DIACHRONISM; FROG; LIFE CYCLE; METAMORPHOSIS; PARSIMONY ANALYSIS; PHYLOGENETICS; TAXONOMY;

ANURA; PIPIDAE;

EID: 78649489726     PISSN: 09475745     EISSN: 14390469     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1439-0469.2010.00570.x     Document Type: Article

References (99)

1. Alberch P (1989) Development and evolution of amphibian metamorphosis. Fortschr Zool 35:163-173.
2. Alley KE (1990) Retrofitting larval neuromuscular circuits in the metamorphosing frog. J Neurobiol 21:1092-1107.
3. Altig R (1969) Notes on the ontogeny of the osseous cranium of Ascaphus truei. Herpetologica 25:59-62.
4. Banbury B, Maglia AM (2006) Skeletal development of the Mexican spadefoot, Spea multiplicata (Anura: Pelobatidae). J Morphol 267:803-821.
5. Beck CW, Slack JMW (2001) An amphibian with ambition: a new role for Xenopus in the 21st century. Genome Biol 2:1029.1-1029.5.
6. Bininda-Emonds ORP, Jeffery JE, Coates MI, Richardson MK (2002) From Haeckel to event-pairing: the evolution of developmental sequences. Theory Biosci 121:297-320.
7. Bininda-Emonds ORP, Jeffery JE, Richardson MK (2003) Inverting the hourglass: quantitative evidence against the phylotypic stage in vertebrate development. Proc R Soc Lond B 270:341-346.
8. Callery EM (2006) There's more than one frog in the pond: a survey of the Amphibia and their contributions to developmental biology. Seminars Cell Dev Biol 17:80-92.
9. Callery EM, Fang H, Elinson RP (2001) Frogs without polliwogs: evolution of anuran direct development. Bioessays 23:233-241.
10. Chipman AD (2002) Variation, plasticity and modularity in anuran development. Zoology 105:97-104.
11. Chipman AD, Haas A, Tchernov E, Khaner O (2000) Variation in anuran embryogenesis: differences in sequence and timing of early developmental events. J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol 288:352-365.
12. Davies M (1989) Ontogeny of bone and the role of heterochrony in the myobatrachine genera Uperoleia, Crinia, and Pseudophryne (Anura: Leptodactylidae: Myobatrachinae). J Morphol 200:269-300.
13. Deban SM, Olson WM (2002) Suction feeding by a tiny predatory tadpole. Nature 420:41-42.
14. Duellman WE, Trueb L (1994) Biology of Amphibians. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
15. Dunlap KD, Sanchiz B (1996) Temporal dissociation between the development of the cranial and appendicular skeletons in Bufo bufo (Amphibia: Bufonidae). J Herpetol 30:506-513.
16. Elinson RP (2001) Direct development: an alternative way to make a frog. Genesis 29:91-95.
17. Elinson RP, Fang H (1998) Secondary coverage of the yolk by the body wall in the direct developing frog, Eleutherodactylus coqui: an unusual process for amphibian embryos. Dev Genes Evol 208:457-466.
18. Emerson SB (1986) Heterochrony and frogs: the relationship of a life history trait to morphological form. Am Nat 127:167-183.
19. Erdmann K (1933) Zur Entwicklung des knöchernen Skelets von Triton und Rana unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Zeitfolge der Ossifikationen. Z Anat Entw Gesch 101:566-651.
20. Frost DR (2008) Amphibian Species of the World: An Online Reference. American Museum of Natural History, New York. Version 5.2 (15 July, 2008). Electronic Database accessible at
21. Frost DR, Grant T, Faivovich J, Bain RH, Haas A, Haddad CFB, De Sá RO, Channing A, Wilkinson M, Donnellan SC, Raxworthy CJ, Campbell JA, Blotto BL, Moler P, Drewes RC, Nussbaum RA, Lynch RA, Green DM, Wheeler WC (2006) The amphibian tree of life. Bull Am Mus Nat Hist 2006:1-371.
22. Frost DR, Grant T, Faivovich J, Bain RH, Haas A, Haddad CFB, De Sa RO, Channing A, Wilkinson M, Donnellan SC, Raxworthy CJ, Campbell JA, Blotto BL, Moler P, Drewes RC, Nussbaum RA, Lynch RA, Green DM, Wheeler WC (2008) Is the amphibian tree of life really fatally flawed? Cladistics 24:385-395.
23. Gaudin AJ (1973) The development of the skull in the Pacific tree frog, Hyla regilla. Herpetologica 29:205-218.
24. Gaudin AJ (1978) The sequence of cranial ossification in the California toad, Bufo boreas (Amphibia, Anura, Bufonidae). J Herpetol 12:309-318.
25. Germain D, Laurin M (2009) Evolution of ossification sequences in salamanders and urodele origins assessed through event-pairing and new methods. Evol Dev 11:170-190.
26. Goswami A (2007) Cranial modularity and sequence heterochrony in mammals. Evol Dev 9:290-298.
27. Gould SJ (1977) Ontogeny and Phylogeny. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
28. Gurdon J, Hopwood N (2000) The introduction of Xenopus laevis into developmental biology: of empire, pregnancy testing and ribosomal genes. Int J Dev Biol 44:43-50.
29. Haas A (1999) Larval and metamorphic skeletal development in the fast-developing frog Pyxicephalus adspersus (Anura, Ranidae). Zoomorphology 119:23-35.
30. Haas A (2001) Mandibular arch musculature of anuran tadpoles, with comments on homologies of amphibian jaw muscles. J Morphol 247:1-33.
31. Haas A, Richards SJ (1998) Correlations of cranial morphology, ecology, and evolution in Australian suctorial tadpoles of the genera Litoria and Nyctimystes (Amphibia: Anura: Hylidae: Pelodryadinae). J Morphol 238:109-141.
32. Hall BK (2005) Bones and Cartilage: Developmental and Evolutionary Skeletal Biology. Elsevier Academic Press, London.
33. Hall JA, Larsen JH Jr (1998) Postembryonic ontogeny of the spadefoot toad, Scaphiopus intermontanus (Anura: Pelobatidae): skeletal morphology. J Morphol 238:179-244.
34. Hanken J (1992) Life history and morphological evolution. J Evol Biol 5:549-557.
35. Hanken J, Hall BK (1984) Variation and timing of the cranial ossification sequence of the oriental fire-bellied toad, Bombina orientalis (Amphibia: Discoglossidae). J Morphol 182:245-255.
36. Hanken J, Klymkowski MW, Summers CH, Seufert DW, Ingebrigtsen N (1992) Cranial ontogeny in the direct-developing frog, Eleutherodactylus coqui (Anura: Leptodactylidae), analyzed using whole-mount immunochemistry. J Morphol 211:95-118.
37. Hanken J, Jennings DH, Olsson L (1997) Mechanistic basis of life-history evolution in anuran amphibians: direct development. Am Zool 37:160-171.
38. Harris RN (1999) Tadpole evolution and maintenance. In: McDiarmid RW, Altig R (eds), Tadpoles: The Biology of Anuran Larvae. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 279-294.
39. Harrison LB, Larsson HCE (2008) Estimating evolution of temporal sequence changes: a practical approach to inferring ancestral developmental sequences and sequence heterochrony. Syst Biol 57:378-387.
40. Jeffery JE, Bininda-Emonds ORP, Coates MI, Richardson MK (2005) A new technique for identifying sequence heterochrony. Syst Biol 54:230-240.
41. Kälin J, Bernasconi A (1949) Ueber den Ossifikationsmodus bei Xenopus laevis. Rev Suisse Zool 56:359-364.
42. Kemp N, Hoyt JA (1969) Sequence of ossification in the skeleton of growing and metamorphosing tadpoles of Rana pipiens. J Morphol 129:415-444.
43. Kerney R, Meegaskumbura M, Manamendra-Arachchi K, Hanken J (2007) Cranial ontogeny in Philautus silus (Anura: Ranidae: Rhacophorinae) reveals few similarities with other direct-developing anurans. J Morphol 268:715-725.
44. Maddison WP, Maddison DR (2009) Mesquite: A Modular System for Evolutionary Analysis. Version 2.6
45. Maglia AM (2003) Skeletal development of Pelobates cultripes and a comparison of the osteogenesis of pelobatid frogs (Anura: Pelobatidae). Sci Pap Univ Kansas Nat Hist Mus 2003:1-13.
46. Maglia AM, Púgener LA (1998) Skeletal development and adult osteology of Bombina orientalis (Anura: Bombinatoridae). Herpetologica 54:344-363.
47. Maglia AM, Púgener LA, Trueb L (2001) Comparative development in anurans: using phylogeny to understand ontogeny. Am Zool 41:538-551.
48. Maxwell EE, Harrison LB (2009) Methods for the analysis of developmental sequence data. Evol Dev 11:109-119.
49. McNamara K (1997) Shapes of Time. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
50. Mitgutsch C, Piekarski N, Olsson L, Haas A (2008) Heterochronic shifts during early cranial neural crest cell migration in two ranid frogs. Acta Zool 89:69-78.
51. Mitgutsch C, Olsson L, Haas A (2009) Early embryogenesis in discoglossoid frogs: a study of heterochrony at different taxonomic levels. J Zool Syst Evol Res 47:248-257.
52. Moore MK, Townsend VR (2003) Intraspecific variation in cranial ossification in the tailed frog, Ascaphus truei. J Herpetol 37:714-717.
53. Moury JD, Hanken J (1995) Early cranial neural crest migration in the direct-developing frog, Eleutherodactylus coqui. Acta Anat 153:243-253.
54. Olsson L, Hanken J (1996) Cranial neural-crest migration and chondrogenetic fate in the oriental fire-bellied toad Bombina orientalis: defining the ancestral pattern of head development in anuran amphibians. J Morphol 229:105-120.
55. Olsson L, Falck P, Lopez K, Cobb J, Hanken J (2001) Cranial neural crest cells contribute to connective tissue in cranial muscles in the anuran amphibian, Bombina orientalis. Dev Biol 237:354-367.
56. Olsson L, Moury JD, Carl T, Håstad O, Hanken J (2002) Cranial neural crest-cell migration in the direct-developing frog, Eleutherodactylus coqui: molecular heterogeneity within and among migratory streams. Zoology 105:3-13.
57. Orton GL (1953) The systematics of vertebrate larvae. Syst Zool 2:63-75.
58. Perotti MG (2001) Skeletal development of Leptodactylus chaquensis (Anura: Leptodactylidae). Herpetologica 57:318-335.
59. Del Pino EM, Venegas-Ferrin M, Romero-Carvajal A, Montenegro-Larrea P, Sáenz-Ponce N, Moya IM, Alarcón I, Sudou N, Yamamoto S, Taira M (2007) A comparative analysis of frog early development. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104:11882-11888.
60. Púgener LA, Maglia AM (1997) Osteology and skeletal development of Discoglossus sardus (Anura: Discoglossidae). J Morphol 233:267-286.
61. R Development Core Team (2009) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. v. 2.9.1.
62. Reiss JO (2002) The phylogeny of amphibian metamorphosis. Zoology 105:85-96.
63. Richardson MK (1995) Heterochrony and the phylotypic period. Dev Biol 172:412-421.
64. Roček Z (2003) Larval development and evolutionary origin of the anuran skull. In: Heatwole H, Davis M (eds), Amphibian Biology Vol. 5: Osteology. Surrey Beatty & Sons, Chipping Norton 5.
65. Roček Z, Van Dijk E (2006) Patterns of larval development in Cretaceous pipid frogs. Acta Palaeontol Pol 51:111-126.
66. De Sá RO (1988) Chondrocranium and ossification sequence of Hyla lanciformis. J Morphol 195:345-355.
67. De Sá RO, Hill S (1998) Chondrocranial anatomy and skeletogenesis in Dendrobates auratus. J Herpetol 32:205-210.
68. De Sá RO, Trueb L (1991) Osteology, skeletal development, and chondrocranial structure of Hamptophryne boliviana (Anura: Microhylidae). J Morphol 209:311-330.
69. Sadaghiani B, Thiébaud C (1987) Neural crest development in the Xenopus laevis embryo, studied by interspecific transplantation and scanning electron microscopy. Dev Biol 124:91-110.
70. Sánchez-Villagra MR (2002) Comparative patterns of postcranial ontogeny in therian mammals: an analysis of relative timing of ossification events. J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol 294:264-273.
71. Sánchez-Villagra MR, Goswami A, Weisbecker V, Mock O, Kuratani S (2008) Conserved relative timing of cranial ossification patterns in early mammalian evolution. Evol Dev 10:519-530.
72. Schlosser G (2003) Mosaic evolution of neural development in anurans: acceleration of spinal cord development in the direct developing frog Eleutherodactylus coqui. Anat Embryol 206:215-227.
73. Schoch R (2002) The early formation of the skull in extant and Paleozoic amphibians. Paleobiology 28:278-296.
74. Schoch R (2006) Skull ontogeny: developmental patterns of fishes conserved across major tetrapod clades. Evol Dev 8:524-536.
75. Schoch R, Carroll RL (2003) Ontogenetic evidence for the Paleozoic ancestry of salamanders. Evol Dev 5:314-324.
76. Schoch R, Fröbisch NB (2006) Metamorphosis and neoteny: alternative pathways in an extinct amphibian clade. Evolution 60:1467-1475.
77. Sheil CA (1999) Osteology and skeletal development of Pyxicephalus adspersus (Anura: Ranidae: Raninae). J Morphol 240:49-75.
78. Sheil CA, Alamillo H (2005) Osteology and skeletal development of Phyllomedusa vaillanti (Anura: Hylidae: Phyllomedusinae) and a comparison of this arboreal species with a terrestrial member of the genus. J Morphol 265:343-368.
79. Smirnov SV (1990) Evidence of neoteny: a paedomorphic morphology and retarded development in Bombina orientalis (Anura, Discoglossidae). Zool Anz 225:324-332.
80. Smirnov SV (1994) Postmaturation skull development in Xenopus laevis (Anura; Pipidae): late-appearing bones and their bearing on the pipid ancestral morphology. Russ J Herpetol 1:21-29.
81. Smirnov SV (1995) Extra bones in the Pelobates skull as evidence of the paedomorphic origin of the anurans. Zh Obshch Biol 56:317-328.
82. Smirnov SV (1997) Additional dermal ossifications in the anuran skull: morphological novelties or archaic elements? Russ J Herpetol 1:21-29.
83. Smith KK (1997) Comparative patterns of craniofacial development in eutherian and metatherian mammals. Evolution 51:1663-1678.
84. Stokely PS, List JC (1954) The progress of ossification in the skull of the cricketfrog Pseudacris nigrita triseriata. Copeia 1954:211-217.
85. Thibaudeau G, Altig R (1999) Endotrophic anurans: development and evolution. In: McDiarmid RW, Altig R (eds), Tadpoles: The Biology of Anuran Larvae. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 170-188.
86. Trueb L (1970) Evolutionary relationships of casque-headed tree frogs with co-ossified skulls (family Hylidae). Univ Kansas Publ Mus Nat Hist 18:547-716.
87. Trueb L (1985) A summary of osteocranial development in anurans with notes on the sequence of cranial ossification in Rhinophrynus dorsalis (Anura: Pipoidea: Rhinophrynidae). S Afr J Sci 81:181-185.
88. Trueb L (1993) Patterns of cranial diversity among the Lissamphibia. In: Hanken J, Hall BK (eds), The Skull Vol. 2, Patterns of Structural and Systematic Diversity. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, London, pp. 2.
89. Trueb L, Alberch P (1985) Miniaturisation and the anuran skull: a case study of heterochrony. In: Duncker HR, Fleischer G (eds), Functional Morphology of the Vertebrates. Gustav Fischer, New York, pp. 113-121.
90. Trueb L, Hanken J (1992) Skeletal development of Xenopus laevis (Anura: Pipidae). J Morphol 214:1-41.
91. Trueb L, Púgener LA, Maglia AM (2000) Ontogeny of the bizarre: an osteological description of Pipa pipa (Anura: Pipidae), with an account of skeletal development in the species. J Morphol 243:75-104.
92. Velhagen WA (1997) Analyzing developmental sequences using sequence units. Syst Biol 46:204-210.
93. Wake TA, Wake DB, Wake MH (1983) The ossification sequence of Aneides lugubris, with comments on heterochrony. J Herpetol 17:10-22.
94. Weisbecker V, Goswami A, Wroe S, Sánchez-Villagra MR (2008) Ossification heterochrony in the therian postcranial skeleton and the marsupial-placental dichotomy. Evolution 62:2027-2041.
95. Wiens JJ (1989) Ontogeny of the skeleton of Spea bombifrons (Anura: Pelobatidae). J Morphol 202:29-51.
96. Wiens JJ (2007) Review of "The amphibian tree of life" by Frost et al. Q Rev Biol 82:55-56.
97. Wild ER (1997) Description of the adult skeleton and developmental osteology of the hyperossified horned frog, Ceratophrys cornuta (Anura: Leptodactylidae). J Morphol 232:169-206.
98. Wild ER (1999) Description of the chondrocranium and osteogenesis of the Chacoan burrowing frog, Chacophrys pierotti (Anura: Leptodactylidae). J Morphol 242:229-246.
99. Yeh J (2002) The evolution of development: two portraits of skull ossification in pipoid frogs. Evolution 56:2484-2498.