The double guilt of dueling: The stain of suicide in anti-dueling rhetoric in the early republic

Journal of the Early Republic

Volumn 29, Issue 3, 2009, Pages 383-410

  Bell, Richard ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND   (United States)

Author keywords

18th century U.S. history; 19th century U.S. history; Dueling; History; Social reformers; Suicide moral and ethical aspects

Indexed keywords

EID: 77958068833     PISSN: 02751275     EISSN: 15530620     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1353/jer.0.0088     Document Type: Review

References (88)

1. Letter from Robert Troup to Timothy Pickering, Mar. 31, 1828, Alexander Hamilton Papers, Library of Congress;
2. Harold G. Syrett, ed., The Papers of Alexander Hamilton, 27 vols. (New York, 1961-87), 27: 280;
3. Eliphalet Nott, A Discourse Delivered in the North Dutch Church, in the City of Albany (Albany, NY, 1804), 5.
4. Nancy Isenberg, Fallen Founder: The Life of Aaron Burr (New York, 2007).
5. J. Lee Shneidman and Conalee Levine-Shneidman, "Suicide or Murder? The Burr-Hamilton Duel," Journal of Psychohistory 8, no. 2 (1980), 159-82.
6. Evarts B. Greene, "The Code of Honor in Colonial and Revolutionary Times, with Special Reference to New England," Publications of the Colonial Society of Massachusetts 26 (1926), 367-88.
7. Samuel Spring, The Sixth Commandment Friendly to Virtue, Honor and Politeness: A Discourse, in Consequence of the Late Duel (Newburyport, MA, 1804), 15.
8. Thomas J. Carmody, "'Arise and Stand Forth': A Fantasy Theme Analysis of American Clergy and Their Calls for Social Action in the Nineteenth Century Anti-Dueling Movement, 1804-1856" (PhD dissertation, Regent University, 2004).
9. Donna T. Andrew, "The Code of Honour and Its Critics: The Opposition to Duelling in England, 1700-1850," Social History 5 (Oct. 1980), 409-34.
10. Lorna Ruth Wiedman, "Suicide in American Fiction, 1798-1909" (PhD dissertation, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 1995), 24;
11. Howard R. Lamar and Carolyn C. Cooper, eds., Voices of the New Republic: Connecticut Towns 1800-1832 (New Haven, CT, 2003), 302.
12. Thomas Day, The Suicide. A Dialogue Exhibited on the Stage at the Public Commencement of Yale-College (Litchfield, CT, 1797).
13. George W. Corner, ed., The Autobiography of Benjamin Rush, His "Travels through Life" Together with His Commonplace Book for 1789-1813 (Princeton, NJ, 1948), 188-89.
14. Keith Burgess-Jackson, "The Legal Status of Suicide in Early America: A Comparison with the English Experience," Wayne Law Review 29, no. 1 (1982), 57-87;
15. Thomas Jefferson, "The Memoir," in Memoir, Correspondence, and Miscellanies, from the Papers of Thomas Jefferson, ed. Thomas Jefferson Randolph (New York, 1830), 1: 125;
16. Benjamin Rush, An Enquiry into the Effects of Public Punishments Upon Criminals, and Upon Society (Philadelphia, 1787), 3-4.
17. Richard J. Bell, "Do Not Despair: The Cultural Significance of Suicide in America, 1780-1840" (PhD dissertation, Harvard University, 2006);
18. Rodney Hessinger, Seduced, Abandoned and Reborn: Visions of Youth in Middle-Class America, 1780-1850 (Philadelphia, 2005).
19. "Messieurs Hall and Sellers," Pennsylvania Gazette, Dec. 26, 1771.
20. Job R. Tyson, Brief Survey of the Great Extent and Evil Tendencies of the Lottery System as Existing in the United States (2nd ed., Philadelphia, 1833), 59-60.
21. Charles Royster, A Revolutionary People at War: The Continental Army and American Character, 1775-1783 (Chapel Hill, NC, 1977), 210.
22. W. J. Rorabaugh, "The Political Duel in the Early Republic: Burr v. Hamilton," Journal of the Early Republic 15 (Spring 1995), 1-23, quote 14.
23. Bruce C. Baird, "The Social Origins of Dueling in Virginia," in Lethal Imagination: Violence and Brutality in American History, ed. Michael A. Bellesiles (New York, 1999);
24. Robert Baldick, The Duel: A History of Duelling (New York 1965).
25. Joanne B. Freeman, "Dueling as Politics: Reinterpreting the Burr-Hamilton Duel," William and Mary Quarterly 53, no. 2 (1996), 289-318.
26. Jeannette M. Hussey, The Code Duello in America (Washington, DC, 1980), 5.
27. "Dueling!" Claypoole's Daily Advertiser, June 12, 1800.
28. Bertram Wyatt-Brown, Southern Honor: Ethics and Behavior in the Old South (New York, 1982);
29. Kenneth S. Greenberg, Honor & Slavery: Lies, Duels, Noses, Masks, Dressing as a Woman, Gifts, Strangers, Humanitarianism, Death, Slave Rebellions, the Proslavery Argument, Baseball, Hunting, and Gambling in the Old South (Princeton, NJ, 1996);
30. Dickson D. Bruce, Violence and Culture in the Antebellum South (Austin, TX, 1979);
31. Nicholas Proctor, Bathed in Blood: Hunting and Mastery in the Old South (Charlottesville, VA, 2002);
32. Steven M. Stowe, "The Touchiness of the Gentleman Planter: The Sense of Esteem and Continuity in the Antebellum South," Psychohistory Review 8 (Winter 1979), 6-15.
33. Anthony E. Simpson, "Dandelions on the Field of Honor: Dueling, the Middle Classes, and the Law in 19th Century England," Criminal Justice History 9 (1988), 105-10.
34. A. W. Patterson, The Code Duello: With Special Reference to the State of Virginia (Richmond, VA, 1927).
35. Wayne C. Minnick, "A Case Study in Persuasive Effect: Lyman Beecher on Duelling," Speech Monographs 38, no. 4 (1971), 262-76.
36. William Oliver Stevens, Pistols at Ten Paces: The Story of the Code of Honor in America (Boston, 1940), 71.
37. C. A. Hartwell Wells, "The End of the Affair? Anti-Dueling Laws and Social Norms in Antebellum America," Vanderbilt Law Review 54, no. 4 (2001), 1805-47.
38. Bradley A. Johnson, "'A Succinct and Formal Violence': The Function of the Duel in Southern Fiction, 1825-1950" (PhD dissertation, University of Connecticut, 2001), 29-30.
39. Joanne B. Freeman, Affairs of Honor: National Politics in the New Republic (New Haven, CT, 2002), xxiii.
40. Steven M. Stowe, Intimacy and Power in the Old South: Rituals in the Lives of the Planters (Baltimore, 1987), 45.
41. Charles H. Hoover, "The Criminality, Cowardice, and Cure of Dueling," American National Preacher 12, no. 5 (1838), 65-80.
42. Dick Steward, Duels and the Roots of Violence in Missouri (Columbia, MO, 2000), 79-99.
43. "From the Patron of Industry," Independent Chronicle and Boston Patriot, Sept. 12, 1821;
44. "Editor," Middlesex Gazette, July 16, 1826.
45. Jack K. Williams, Dueling in the Old South: Vignettes of Social History (College Station, TX, 1980), 60.
46. Thomas Gamble, Annals of Savannah: Savannah Duels and Duellists 1733-1877 (Savannah, GA, 1923), 185.
47. To the Honorable Speaker, and the Other Members of the House of Representatives of the State of South-Carolina (Charleston, SC, 1804), 1;
48. Frederick Beasley, A Sermon Upon Duelling: Delivered to the Senior Class in the University of Pennsylvania, on the Sunday before Their Commencement (Philadelphia, 1822), 8.
49. Mason L. Weems, God's Revenge against Duelling, or, the Duellists Looking Glass. (2nd ed., Philadelphia, 1821), 15-16, 25.
50. Abiel Abbot, Self Preservation. A Sermon Preached before the Ancient and Honorable Artillery Company, in Boston, June 7, 1802 (Boston, 1802), 9-10;
51. Timothy Dwight, The Folly, Guilt, and Mischiefs of Duelling: A Sermon, Preached in the College Chapel at New Haven (Hartford, CT, 1805), 17;
52. Frederick Beasley, A Sermon on Duelling: Delivered in Christ-Church, Baltimore, April 28, 1811 (Baltimore, 1811), 25.
53. Samuel Barrett, Thou Shalt Not Kill: A Sermon Preached in the Twelfth Congregational Church, Boston, March 4, 1838 (Boston, 1838), 15.
54. Walter C. Colton, Remarks on Duelling (New York, 1828), 47.
55. Joseph Sewall, He That Would Keep God's Commandments Must Renounce the Society of Evil Doers (Boston, 1728);
56. Benjamin Colman, Death and the Grave without Any Order. A Sermon Preached July 7, 1728. Being the Lord's-Day after a Tragical Duel (Boston, 1728);
57. "For the Western Star," Western Star (Stockbridge, MA), July 30, 1793.
58. Samuel Low, A Discourse on Duelling: Preached on Sunday, March 4, 1810, at the Capitol in the City of Washington (Richmond, VA, 1811), 18.
59. Harold G. Syrett and Jean G. Cooke, eds., Interview in Weehawken: The Burr-Hamilton Duel as Told in the Original Documents (Middletown, CT, 1960); 151,
60. "Remarks," The Bee (Hudson, NY), Aug. 14, 1804;
61. "Northampton; Tuesday, August 21, 1804," Republican Spy (Hudson, NY), Aug. 21, 1804;
62. Hezekiah Woodruff, The Danger of Ambition . . . Death of General Alexander Hamilton (Albany, NY, 1804), 20-21.
63. "New-York, July 31, 1807," New-York Gazette & General Advertiser, July 31, 1807.
64. "On the Duty of Refusing to Par Take the Production of Slave-Labor," The Liberator, Jan. 25, 1834,
65. "No Headline," Baltimore Patriot & Mercantile Advertiser, July 14, 1831, 4.
66. "Mr. Ansel; Glover; Postmaster; Paper; Mill; Village; Alstead; Attempts," New-Hampshire Sentinel, Feb. 11, 1836.
67. John Black, A Sermon on National Righteousness and Sin Delivered in the First Presbyterian Church, Pittsburgh, April 3, 1827 (Pittsburgh, PA, 1827), 1, 9.
68. "Remarks on Duelling," Weekly Recorder (Chillicothe, OH), Sept. 25, 1817.
69. Posthumus, Observations on the South Carolina Memorial Upon the Subject of Duelling: In a Letter to a Friend (1805).
70. William Ladd, A Letter to Aaron Burr on the Barbarous Origin: The Criminal Nature and the Baneful Effects of Duels (New York, 1804), 14;
71. An Essay on Duelling (New York, 1830), 13;
72. Henry Ware, The Law of Honor: A Discourse, Occasioned by the Recent Duel in Washington; Delivered March 4, 1838 (Cambridge, MA, 1838), 15-16;
73. M. A. H. Niles, The Sin of Duelling; A Sermon Preached at Marblehead, April 5, 1838 (Newburyport, MA, 1838), 16;
74. Isaac Worcester, A Discourse Occasioned by the Recent Duel at Washington, Delivered at Littleton, N.H., April 12, 1838 (Concord, NH, 1838), 8.
75. Lyman Beecher, Remedy for Duelling; A Sermon Delivered before the Presbytery of Long Island, at Aquebogue, April 16, 1806 (Boston, 1806), 14.
76. "Irish Suicide," Poulson's American Daily Advertiser (Philadelphia), May 4, 1811.
77. J. R. McDowell, Henry Wallace; or the Victim of Lottery Gambling. A Moral Tale. By a Friend to American Youth (New York, 1832), 62.
78. Nina Baym, Woman's Fiction: A Guide to Novels by and About Women in America, 1820-1870 (Ithaca, NY, 1979), 26.
79. John Bachman, Sermon on Duelling (1842), 12.
80. The Murder of Jonathan Cilley (Washington, DC, 1844).
81. Robert J. Breckinridge, The Immorality of the Traffic, Manufacture, and Use of Ardent Spirits as a Drink; and the Duty of Christians (Baltimore, 1834), 16.
82. Thomas Posage Hunt, Death by Measure; or, Poisons, and Their Effects, Found in Intoxicating Liquors (Philadelphia, 1846).
83. W. W. Patton, Duty of Christians to Suppress Duelling: A Sermon Preached on the Annual Fast, April 4, 1844, at South Boston (Boston, 1844), 8.
84. William H. Barnwell, The Impiety and Absurdity of Duelling: A Sermon Preached in St. Peters' Church, Charleston, on the 9th Day of June, 1844 (Charleston, SC, 1844), 6;
85. Alexander MacKay, The Western World (Philadelphia, 1849), 142-43;
86. James M. MacDonald, A Mourning Land. A Sermon Occasioned by the Late Duel at Washington between Jonathan Cilley, and William J. Graves (New London, CT, 1838), 11.
87. J. D. Strong, A Plea against Dueling: A Discourse Delivered in the Presbyterian Church, at Oakland, California, Sunday, September 25th, 1859 (San Francisco, CA,1859).
88. Edward L. Ayers, Vengeance and Justice: Crime and Punishment in the 19th Century American South (New York, 1984), 270-71.