A tiny membrane defending 'us' against 'them': Arabic internet debate about hymenorraphy in sunni islamic law

Culture, Health and Sexuality

Volumn 12, Issue 7, 2010, Pages 755-769

  Eich, Thomas ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TÜBINGEN   (Germany)

Author keywords

Hymen repair; Hymenorraphy; Sunni islam; Virginity

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CONFLICT; CULTURAL ANTHROPOLOGY; ETHNOLOGY; FEMALE; HUMAN; HYMEN; INTERNET; MIDDLE EAST; PERCEPTION; RELIGION; SEXUAL BEHAVIOR; SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY;

CULTURE; DISSENT AND DISPUTES; FEMALE; HUMANS; HYMEN; INTERNET; ISLAM; MIDDLE EAST; PREJUDICE; SEXUAL ABSTINENCE; SOCIAL PERCEPTION;

EID: 77955791579     PISSN: 13691058     EISSN: 14645351     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/13691051003746179     Document Type: Article

References (42)

1. (Abd al-(Az̄z, H. 2007. al-Jam̄(u tuwājihu h{dot below}arb al-zawāj al-(urf̄ [Everybody faces the war of customary marriage]. Al-Ahrām, April 16
2. Akhawat. 2007. Muft̄ Mis{dot below}r yuj̄z (amaliyāt tarq̄( ghashā' al-bakāra li-l-nisā' "li-ay sabab kāna" [The Mufti of Egypt allows hymenorraphy operations for women 'for whatever reason']. Mexat. http://www.mexat.com/vb/archive/index.php/t-245318.html
3. Al-Arabiyya. 2006. Murāhiqa Jazā'iriyya aqāmat (iddat (alaqāt ma(a shabān faransiȳn - mi'āt alfatayāt al-muslimāt f̄ Faransa yalja'unna li-,tarq̄( al-bakāra"qabla l-zawāj [An Algerian girl in puberty had several relations with French youngsters - Hundreds of Muslim girls in France have recourse to hymenorraphy before marriage]. January 1. Al-Arabiyya. http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/2006/01/08/20185.html
4. Al-Arabiyya. 2007a. Taklifatuhā tas{dot below}il li-10 ālāf Dirham raghma anna qawān̄n al-daula tu h{dot below}z{dot below}iruhā - Dubai... fatayāt (arabiyāt yalja'unna li-,tarq̄( al-bakāra"qubail zawājihinna [It costs up to10000 Dirham although the law of the state forbids it - Dubai... Arab girls have recourse to hymenorraphy shortly before their marriages]. February 2. Al-Arabiyya. http://www.alarabiya. net/articles/2007/02/02/31309.html
5. Al-Arabiyya. 2007b. Mushtara t{dot below}an an yakūn ijrā' al-(amaliyya bi-hadaf sitr al-fatāt - Muft̄ Mis{dot below}r yuj̄z (amaliyat tarq̄( ghashā' al-bakāra li-l-nisā',li-ay sabab kāna"[Under the condition that the operation aims at the covering (sitr) of the girlT{dot below}he Mufti of Egypt allows hymenorraphy for women 'for whatever reason']. February 14. Al-Arabiyya. http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/2007/02/14/31699.html
6. Al-Arabiyya. 2007c. Fuqahā' yu'ayyidūn bi-shart{dot below} faqdihā (adhriyatahā mujbaratan wa akharūn yarfud{dot below}ūnj{dot below}adal sa'ūd̄h{dot below}aula fatwā mis{dot below}riya bi-It{dot below}laq jawāz tarq̄( ghashā' al-bakāra"[Some scholars express support under the condition that she lost her virginity under duress and others rejectS{dot below}audi debate about the Egyptian fatwa allowing hymenorraphy]. February 17. Al-Arabiyya. http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/2007/02/17/31772.html
7. Ali, K. 2008. Progressive Muslims and Islamic jurisprudence: The necessity for critical engagement with marriage and divorce laws. In Progressive Muslims on justice, gender and pluralism, ed. O. Safi, 163-89. Oxford: Oneworld.
8. Al-Majlis al-Yaman̄. 2007. (Amaliyāt tarq̄( ghashā' al-bakāra li-l-nisā' [The hymenorraphy operation for women]. Parliament of Yemen. http://www.ye1.org/vb/archive/index.php/t-173958.html
9. Arvizu, S. 2004/5. The politics of bellydancing inCairo.Arab Studies Journal XII.2/XIII, no. 1: 159-87.
10. Bednarz, D. 2006. Iranian soap star swept up in video scandal. Spiegel Online International, November 30. Der Spiegel. http://www.spiegel.de/international/spiegel/0%2C1518%2C451449%2C00.html
11. Bentlage, B., and T. Eich. 2007. Hymen repair on the Arabic Internet. ISIM Review 19: 20-1.
12. Choe Choe, T. 2008. Like a virgin... again. New Straits Times, August 6.
13. Cindoglu, D. 2000. Virginity tests and artificial virginity in modern Turkish medicine. In Women and sexuality in Muslim societies, ed. P. Ilkkaracan, 215-28. Istanbul: Women for Women's Human Rights.
14. Dupret, B. 2001. Normality, responsibility, morality: Virginity and rape in an Egyptian legal context. Yearbook of the Sociology of Islam: Muslim Traditions and Modern Techniques of Power 3: 165-83.
15. Fad{dot below}lallāh, M.H{dot below}. n.d. Jurisprudence of medicine. Ayatollah Fa{dot below}dlallāh. http://english.bayynat.org.lb
16. Freund, C.P. 2003a. Look who's rocking the Kasbah: The revolutionary implications of Arab music videos. Reason Magazine, June. Reason. http://reason.com/archives/2003/06/01/look-whosrocking-the-casbah
17. Freund, C.P. 2003b. Weapons of singing destruction: The escalating storm over Arabic pop videos. Reason Magazine, October 29. Reason. http://reason.com/archives/2003/10/29/weapons-ofsinging-Destruction
18. Guma(a, A. 2007. Ratq ghashā' al-bakāra [Hymenorraphy]. April 5. Islamic Council. http://www.islamic-council.org
19. Hus{dot below}n̄,H{dot below}. 2007. (Ulamā' al-d̄n wa al-t{dot below}ibb yastankirūna fatwā tarq̄(... Ratq ghashā' al-bakāra yushajji( (alā ikhtilā t{dot below} al-ansāb wa intishār al-radh̄la [Scholars of religion and medicine refute the knitting fatwa... Hymenorraphy encourages the mixing of genealogies and the spread of vice]. Al-Tas{dot below}awwuf al-islām̄, March, 339: 46-8.
20. International Quranic Center. Muft̄ Mi_ sr yuj̄z (amaliyāt tarq̄( ghashā' al-bakāra li-l-nisā'. Ahl al-Quran - The International Quranic Center. http://www.ahl-alquran.com/arabic/show_news. php?main_id197
21. Jianyang, L., and G.J. Zhengzhou. 2005. Virginity haunts Chinese as more women undergo hymen repair surgery. Xinhua General News Service, March 31.
22. Kandela, P. 1996. Egypt's trade in hymen repair. Lancet 347: 1615.
23. Kobrin, S. 2005. Restoring virginity becomes risky business. Women's Enews, May 22. Womensenews. http://www.womensenews.org/article.cfm/dyn/aid/2304/context/archive
24. Mexat. 2007. Muft̄ yuj̄z (amaliyāt tarq̄( ghashā' al-bakāra [The Mufti allows hymenorraphy]. Mexat. http://www.mexat.com/vb/archive/index.php/t-245318.html
25. Miller, D., and D. Slater. 2000. The Internet. An ethnographic approach. Oxford and New York: Berg.
26. Peteet, J.M. 2002. Nationalism and sexuality in Palestine. In Social constructions of nationalism in the Middle East, ed. F. Müge Göçek, 141-66. Albany: SUNY Press.
27. Qut{dot below}b, H. 2007. I(ādat ghashā' al-bakāra... li-l-Ih{dot below}tifāl bi-(̄d al-zawāj! [Restoring the hymen... for the marriage celebrations!]. al-Liwā' al-islām̄, February 15.
28. Rif(at, H. 2007. Yumazziq shaq̄qatahu bi-l-sikk̄n bi-sabab zawājihā (urfiyan min (āmil [He chops his sister into pieces with a knife because she had a customary marriage with a worker]. Al-Mas{dot below}r̄ al-yaum, April 2.
29. Rispler-Haim, V. 2007. The Muslim surgeon and contemporary ethical dilemmas surrounding the restoration of virginity. HAWWA: Journal of Women in the Middle East and the Islamic World 5, nos. 2-3: 324-49.
30. Roberts, H. 2006. Reconstructing virginity in Guatemala. Lancet 367: 1227f.
31. Rūm̄, A. al-. 2007. Li-l-walad: Hal tatazawwaj fatāt lail? [Asking boys: Would you marry a 'girl of the night'?] Rūz al-Yū sif, April 27.
32. Sālih{dot below}, S. 2007. Tarq̄( ghashā' al-bakāra yaftah{dot below} bāb al-tauba... wa laisa al-fāh{dot below}isha [Hymenorraphy opens the door to repentence... and not to shamelessness]. Rūz al-Yū sif, February 16.
33. Sciolino, E., and S. Mekhennet. 2008. In Europe, debate over Islam and virginity. New York Times, June 11.
34. Shalab̄, A. 2007. Shurt{dot below}̄ yaqtul shaq̄qatahu al-armila bi-l-sikk̄n. Al-Mas{dot below}r̄ al-yaum, May 12.
35. Shalhoub-Kevorkian, N. 2005. Imposition of virginity testing: A life-saver or a license to kill? Social Science & Medicine 60: 1187-96.
36. Sharf, B.F. 1999. Beyond netiquette. The ethics of doing naturalistic discourse research on the Internet. In Doing Internet research: Critical issues and methods for examining the Net, ed. S. Jones, 243-56. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
37. Singerman, D., and B. Ibrahim. 2001. The costs of marriage in Egypt: A hidden dimension in the new Arab demography. In The new Arab family, ed. N.S. Hopkins, 80-116. Cairo and New York: AUC Press.
38. Tam̄m̄, I. al-. 1995. Ratq ghashā' al-bakāra min manz{dot below}ūr islām̄ [Hymenorraphy from an Islamic point of view]. In ar-Ru'ya al-islām̄ya li-ba( d{dot below} al-mumārasā t al- _ tibbiya [An Islamic view on some medical acts], ed. (Abd al-Rah{dot below}mān al-(Awad{dot below}̄ et al., 2nd ed., 562-76. Kuwait: Islamic Organization of Medical Sciences.
39. Vincent, L. 2006. Virginity testing in South Africa: Re-traditioning the postcolony. Culture, Health & Sexuality 8, no. 1: 17-30.
40. Walters, J. 2006. Like a virgin.... The Times, February 27.
41. Wehbi, S. 2002. 'Women with nothing to lose': Marriageability and women's perceptions of rape and consent in contemporary Beirut. Women's Studies International Forum 25, no. 3: 287-300.
42. Yās̄n, M.N. 1995. Ratq ghashā' al-bakāra f̄ m̄zān al-maqās{dot below}id al-shar(̄ya [Hymenorraphy in the scales of the goals of the Sharia]. In ar-Ru'ya al-islām̄ya li-ba(d{dot below} al-mumārasāt al-t{dot below}ibbiya [An Islamic view on some medical acts], ed. (Abd al-Rah{dot below}mān al-(Awa d{dot below}̄ et al., 2nd ed., 577-625. Kuwait: Islamic Organization of Medical Sciences.