Hydropower development and resettlement policy on China's Nu river

Journal of Contemporary China

Volumn 19, Issue 66, 2010, Pages 777-797

  Brown, Philip H ^a   Xu, Kevin ^a  

^a University of Connecticut   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ALTERNATIVE ENERGY; DAM CONSTRUCTION; DECISION MAKING; ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT; GOVERNANCE APPROACH; HYDROELECTRIC POWER; INFRASTRUCTURAL DEVELOPMENT; NATIONAL PLANNING; RESETTLEMENT POLICY;

CHINA; SALWEEN RIVER;

EID: 77955025925     PISSN: 10670564     EISSN: 14699400     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/10670564.2010.485409     Document Type: Article

References (60)

1. P. H. Brown, D. Magee and Y. Xu, 'Socioeconomic vulnerability in China's hydropower development', China Economic Review 19(4), (2008), pp. 614-627.
2. Desiree Tullos, 'Assessing the influence of environmental impact assessments on science and policy: an analysis of the Three Gorges Project', Journal of Environmental Management 90, (2009), pp. S208-S223.
3. Hereafter, 'Nujiang Prefecture'.
4. A. C. Mertha, China's Water Warriors: Citizen Action and Policy Change (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2008).
5. Prior to 1997, the Nu was believed to originate from melting ice on the 6,070-meter Jiregepa peak in the Tanggula mountain range in Tibet; see G. Huang, Lancang Jiang Nu Jiang chuan [Lancang River and Nu River Volume] (Baoding: Hebei University, 2004).
6. Tibet Bureau of Statistics, Tibet Statistical Year book 2007 (Beijing: China Statistical Publishing Company, 2007).
7. 2.
8. J. Wang, Q. Ming, P. Li and X. Peng, 'The exploitation of hydroelectric resources of Nu Jiang is the strategy to promote the protection of the world natural heritage', in Jiankun Feng and Yaohua He, eds, Nu Jiang, Lancangjiang, and Jinshajiang: Researches on the Exploitation of Hydropower Resources and the Protection of Environment (Beijing: Social Sciences Documents Publishing Company, 2005).
9. W. Lin and J. Zhang, 'The exploitation of hydropower resources of Nu Jiang: the national option against poverty', in Jiankun Feng and Yaohua He, eds, Nu Jiang, Lancangjiang, and Jinshajiang.
10. X. Xiang and X. Zhang, 'The hydropower resources of Nu Jiang, environment and development', in Jiankun Feng and Yaohua He, eds, Nu Jiang, Lancangjiang, and Jinshajiang.
11. G. Huang, Guanyu Nujiang Shuidian Kaifa De Zhengyi Jitu Liuyu Tongchou Guihua De Yi'an [Concerning the Highly Disputed General Plan Proposed to Develop Hydropower on the Nu River] (Kunming: Yunnan Academy of Social Sciences, 2003).
12. H. Luo, G. Bao and Z. Li, 'Analysis on the social and economic development and the factors about the exploitation of hydroelectric resources', in Jiankun Feng and Yaohua He, eds, Nu Jiang, Lancangjiang, and Jinshajiang. These terms refer to the status of animal species in the wild, with 'first degree' species in the greatest danger of extinction. These ratings were coined in the 'Wild Animals Protection Act' of 1989, and are updated annually by the State Council.
13. see Xinhua, People's Republic of China Wild Animals Protection Act (Xinhua.net, 30 August 2004), available at: http://news.xinhuanet.com/zhengfu/2004-08/30/content_1925402.htm (accessed 20 November 2008).
14. D. Magee and K. McDonald, 'Beyond Three Gorges: Nu River hydropower and energy decision politics in China', Asian Geographer, 25(1-2) (2009), pp. 39-60.
15. UNESCO, UNESCO World Heritage List: Three Parallel Rivers of Yunnan Protected Areas (UNESCO.org, 2008), available at: http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1083 (accessed 29 October 2008).
16. Mertha, China's Water Warriors.
17. There are two criteria for a region to be designated as a 'biodiversity hotspot'. Specifically, it must contain at least 1,500 species of vascular plants and it must have lost at least 70% of its original habitat; see Conservation International, Hotspots Science-Hotspots Defined (Conservation International, 2007), available at: http://www.biodiversityhotspots.org/xp/Hotspots/hotspotsScience/pages/hotspots_defined.aspx (accessed 19 November 2008).
18. Conservation International, Biodiversity Hotspot: Mountains of Southwest China (Conservation International, 2008), available at: http://www.biodiversityhotspots.org/xp/Hotspots/china/Pages/default.aspx (accessed 29 October 2008).
19. Yunnan Bureau of Statistics, Yunnan Statistical Yearbook 2007.
20. Tibet Bureau of Statistics, Tibet Statistical Yearbook 2007.
21. M. Yu and N. Zhang, 'Dong Fang Rui Shi' Linzhi Fazhan Xunsu, Jiang Cheng Wei Xizang Jingji Qiangdi' ['"Switzerland in the East" Linzhi develops rapidly, becoming an economic stronghold of Tibet'], China Daily, (12 November 2008), available at: http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/hqgj/2008-11/12/content_7196561.htm (accessed 29 November 2008).
22. P. Wang, 'Perspective of small hydro development in Linzhi area and counter measures', Northwest Hydropower 2, (2003), pp. 49-50.
23. Yunnan Bureau of Statistics, Yunnan Statistical Yearbook 2007.
24. The Central Government of China first designated a total of 592 counties as 'National Key Poverty Counties' in 1986, which the goal of concentrating financial resources to combat poverty in the poorest regions of China. The list of counties was updated in 1994. Yunnan has a total of 73 'National Key Poverty Counties', the largest number among all provinces in China; see State Council Leading Group Office of Poverty Alleviation and Development, Guo Jia Zhong Dian Fu Chi Pin Kun Xian de Que Ding [The Designation of National Key Poverty Counties for Subsidies] (The State Council Leading Group Office of Poverty Alleviation and Development, 3 March 2006), available at: http://www.cpad.gov.cn/data/2006/0303/article_270.htm (accessed 19 November 2008).
25. Nujiang Prefecture National Land Resources Bureau, Qiang Hua Fa Zhi Xuan Chuan Jiao Yu Ying Zao Liang Hao Gong Zuo Qi Fen-Nujiang Zhou Guo Tu Zi Yuan Fa Zhi Xuan Chuan Jiao Yu Gong Zuo Ji Shi [Strengthen the Propaganda of Legal Education, Establishing Good Working Environment-Nujiang Prefecture National Land Resources Propaganda and Education Work Summary], (2008), available at: http://nj.yndlr.gov.cn/xw/new_0243532.html (accessed 30 October 2008).
26. Yunnan Bureau of Statistics, Yunnan Statistical Yearbook 2007.
27. Y. Liu, 'Yunnan Nujiang: 60 Yi Zi Jin Tou Ru Shui Dian Chan Ye' ['Yunnan Nujiang: 6 billion yuan invested in the hydropower industry'], China Economic Times, (14 January 2008), available at: http://city.finance.sina.com.cn/ city/2008-01-14/95433.html (accessed 29 October 2008).
28. Yunnan Bureau of Statistics, Yunnan Statistical Yearbook 2007.
29. Yunnan Bureau of Statistics, Yunnan Statistical Yearbook 2004 (Beijing: China Statistical Publishing Company, 2004)
30. Yunnan Bureau of Statistics, Yunnan Statistical Yearbook 2007.
31. Yunnan Bureau of Statistics, Yunnan Statistical Yearbook 2004
32. Yunnan Bureau of Statistics, Yunnan Statistical Yearbook 2007., By contrast, agriculture and services accounted for 11.35% and 29.02% of GDP in Nujiang Prefecture, respectively
33. Y. Yang, 'A study of Baoshan economy structures', Journal of Baoshan Teachers' College 25(6), (2006), pp. 25-26.
34. H. Cao and P. Zhang, 'Jing Ji: Nu Jiang Bao Wei Zhan Hou Mian de Min Jian Li Liang' ['Economics: civil power behind the protective war for the Nujiang'], Economics, (24 May 2004), available at: http://finance.sina.com. cn/g/20040524/1237774903.shtml (accessed 5 November 2008)., Initial plans for the cascade were developed by the Beijing Investigation and Design Institute and the East China Investigation and Design Institute
35. P. Zhou, 'Liuku Shui Dian Zhan Jie Pai' ['Inauguration of Liuku Hydroelectric Station'], Yunnan Daily, (19 July 2003), available at: http://www.yn.xinhuanet.com/newscenter/200307/19/content_724446.htm (accessed 30 September 2008).
36. 'Nujiang 13 Ji Shui Ba Reng Yao Shang Ma Ku Qu Yi Min An Zhi Cheng Jiao Dian' ['Nujiang 13 dams will go ahead, dam area immigrants become a focus'], Beijing News, (25 November 2003), available at: http://news. thebeijingnews.com/0547/2003/1125/002@1436.htm (accessed 30 September 2008).
37. H. Chen, 'Nujiang Shui Dian Kai Fa "Da Tiao Zheng" Fang An Wei He Ru Ci Shen Mi' ['Why is the Nujiang hydroelectricity development adjustment so mysterious?'], China Economic Times, (21 June 2006), available at: http://business.sohu.com/20060621/n243856858.shtml (accessed 30 September 2008).
38. 'Nujiang Shui Dian Wan Cheng Huan Ping Shen Cha' ['Nujiang hydroelectricity development passes environmental assessment'], Wenweipo, (11 January 2006), available at: http://www.cyol.net/cydgn/content/2006-03/30/content_1347396.htm (accessed 30 September 2008).
39. J. Shi, Nujiang Liuku Saige Dian Zhan Lie Ru 'Shi Yi Wi' Zhong Dian Xiang Mu [Nujiang Liuku and Sai Hydroelectric Stations Listed in the 'Tenth Five Year Plan' Major Project] (Pan Pearl River Delta Cooperation Information Net, 2008), available at: http://yunnan.pprd.org.cn/fzgh/wngh/200803/t20080325_41112.htm (accessed 30 September 2008).
40. Field visits by the authors in June 2008 confirmed that roads and other support infrastructure for the Luiku dam had indeed begun. Brown et al. ('Socioeconomic vulnerability in China's hydropower development') report that site work was evident at Songta, Maji, Yabiluo, and Saige as well as Liuku in 2005.
41. Notably, there were already 48 small hydropower stations, each with below 25 MW in power generation, built on the confluence of the Nu and various tributaries in Nujiang Prefecture by 2002. The total installed capacity of these dams is 43,231 KW per year (Xiang and Zhang, 'The hydropower resources of Nu Jiang'), yet it is unclear how dams along the main stem might affect hydropower production in these stations.
42. Y. He and J. Feng, 'Ke Xue Fa Zhan Yu Nujiang Shui Dian Kai Fa' ['Scientific development and Nujiang hydropower exploitation'], Zhongguo Nengyuan Wang [China Energy Network], (2004), available at: http://www. china5e.com/news/water/200410/200410140036.html (accessed 30 September 2008).
43. G. Wu, 'On the protection and exploitation of Nu Jiang', in Jiankun Feng and Yaohua He, eds, Nu Jiang, Lancangjiang, and Jinshajiang.
44. Luo et al., 'Analysis on the social and economic development and the factors about the exploitation of hydroelectric resources'.
45. J. Wang, G. Yu and S. Li, 'The enlightenment on the exploitation of hydropower resources of Nu Jiang from the development of American dam economy', in Jiankun Feng and Yaohua He, eds, Nu Jiang, Lancangjiang, and Jinshajiang.
46. Central Government of the PRC, Regulations on Land Acquisition Compensation and Resettlement of Migrants for Construction of Large and Medium Scale Water Conservancy and Hydropower Project (Central Government of the PRC Net, 2006), available at: http://www.gov.cn/zwgk/2006-08/13/content_360853.htm (accessed 3 October 2008).
47. Magee and McDonald, 'Beyond Three Gorges'.
48. Wu, 'On the protection and exploitation of Nu Jiang'.
49. Yunnan Bureau of Statistics, Yunnan Statistical Yearbook 2007.
50. He and Feng, 'Ke Xue Fa Zhan Yu Nujiang Shui Dian Kai Fa'.
51. NDRC, Report from the Fact-finding Mission by a National Development and Reform Commission Survey Team to Nujiang Basin Region, (2003).
52. D. Lou, 'Shui Li Bu Zhang Wang Shuicheng Shou Ci Biao Tai Yi Zhi Mang Mu Kai Fa Nujiang Shui Dian' ['Minister Wang Shuicheng admits for the first time that blind development of Nujiang Hydropower should be stopped'], Economic Observer, (23 April 2005), available at: www.elc.gov.cn/1/sinanews/show.asp?url=FinanceNews/g/20050423/15441544606.shtml (accessed 29 November 2008).
53. Like many villages in China, Xiaoshaba consists of several 'natural villages'. The natural villages that will be affected by the Liuku Dam are called 'Group One', 'Group Two', and 'Group Three'., The authors gratefully acknowledge the Goldfarb Center for Civic Affairs and Public Engagement for underwriting the data collection, One mu is just under 1/6 acre., At the time of the survey, US$1= RMB 6.8 at official exchange rates
54. Green SOS, 'Liuku Zhen Xiaoshaba Xinnongcun Quan Ti Cun Min Yi Jian Shu' ['Opinions letter by all villagers of the new village of Xiaoshaba, Liuku Township'], Green Reporter Salon, (2008), available at: http://www.greensos.cn/?action_viewnews_itemid_11378.html (accessed 2 October 2008).
55. Despite the lack of official announcements, rumors about the levels of compensation were circulating throughout the villages during our site visits: compensation for inundation land was rumored to be RMB 17,000 for dry land and RMB 27,000 for paddy land, and the lump-sum resettlement payment was rumored to be between RMB 10,000 and RMB 40,000 per person
56. Yunnan Bureau of Statistics, Yunnan Statistical Yearbook 2007
57. Green Home, Nu Jiang Bai Ming Qian Zai Yi Min Fang Tan Lu (Green Home, 2006), available at: http://www.nujiang.ngo.cn/Themes/Interviews/ (accessed 2 October 2008).
58. Liuku Zhen Xiaoshaba New Village All Villager Suggestion Letter, (2007), available at: http://www.greensos.cn/?action_viewnews_itemid_11378.html (accessed 16 October 2008).
59. Brown et al., 'Socioeconomic vulnerability in China's hydropower development'.
60. J. Shi, 'Wen calls halt to Yunnan dam plan; Premier orders further environmental checks', South China Morning Post (Hong Kong), (21 May 2009).