Narrative review: Should teaching of the respiratory physical examination be restricted only to signs with proven reliability and validity?

Journal of General Internal Medicine

Volumn 25, Issue 8, 2010, Pages 865-872

  Benbassat, Jochanan ^a   Baumal, Reuben ^b  

^a MYERS JDC BROOKDALE INSTITUTE   (Israel)

^b HOSPITAL FOR SICK CHILDREN   (Canada)

Author keywords

diagnostic accuracy; medical students; respiratory physical examination

Indexed keywords

CLINICAL FEATURE; CLINICAL PRACTICE; DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY; DISEASE SEVERITY; LABORATORY TEST; MEDICAL EDUCATION; MEDICAL STUDENT; NARRATIVE; PHYSICAL EXAMINATION; REPRODUCIBILITY; RESPIRATORY CARE; REVIEW; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; TEACHING; VALIDATION STUDY;

AUSCULTATION; DIAGNOSIS, DIFFERENTIAL; EDUCATION, MEDICAL; EDUCATION, MEDICAL, UNDERGRADUATE; HUMANS; LUNG DISEASES; PHYSICAL EXAMINATION; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; RESPIRATORY SOUNDS; RESPIRATORY SYSTEM; SCHOOLS, MEDICAL; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; STATISTICS AS TOPIC; STUDENTS, MEDICAL; TEACHING;

EID: 77954423510     PISSN: 08848734     EISSN: 15251497     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s11606-010-1327-8     Document Type: Review

References (69)

1. JR Hampton MJ Harrison JR Mitchell JS Prichard C Seymour 1975 Relative contributions of history-taking, physical examination, and laboratory investigation to diagnosis and management of medical outpatients Br Med J 2 486 9 10.1136/bmj.2.5969.486 1148666
2. BM Reilly 2003 Physical examination in the care of medical inpatients: an observational study Lancet 362 1100 05 10.1016/S0140-6736(03)14464-9 14550696 (Pubitemid 37222333)
3. IK Todd 2000 A thorough pulmonary exam and other myths Acad Med 75 50 1 10.1097/00001888-200001000-00011 10667875
4. A Halkin J Reichman M Schwaber O Paltiel M Brezis 1998 Likelihood ratios: getting diagnostic testing into perspective QJM 91 247 58 10.1093/qjmed/91.4. 247 9666947
5. CA Feddock 2007 The lost art of clinical skills Am J Med 120 374 378 10.1016/j.amjmed.2007.01.023 17398236 (Pubitemid 46483321)
6. P Bradding JB Cookson 1999 The dos and don'ts of examining the respiratory system: a survey of British Thoracic Society members J R Soc Med 92 632 4 10692885
7. S Mangione LZ Nieman 1999 Pulmonary auscultatory skills during training in internal medicine and family practice Am J Respir Crit Care Med 159 1119 24 10194155 (Pubitemid 29202545)
8. J Benbassat R Baumal SN Heyman M Brezis 2005 Viewpoint: suggestions for a shift in teaching clinical skills to medical students: the reflective clinical examination Acad Med 80 1121 6 10.1097/00001888-200512000-00012 16306285 (Pubitemid 44366109)
9. Morgan WL, Engel GL, eds. The Clinical Approach to the Patient. Philadelphia: WB Saunders Co; 1969: 197-204.
10. O Hargie D Dickson M Boohan K Hughes 1998 A survey of interviewing skills training in UK schools of medicine: present practices and prospective proposals Med Educ 32 25 34 10.1046/j.1365-2923.1998.00154.x 9624396 (Pubitemid 28184944)
11. DeGowin EL. Bedside diagnostic examination. 1st ed. New York: Macmillan Co; 1965.
12. LeBlond RF, Brown DD, DeGowin RL. DeGowin's diagnostic examination. 9th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill; 2009.
13. Kampmeier RH. Physical examination in health and disease. 2nd ed. Philadelphia: FA Davis Co; 1957.
14. AM Joshua DS Celermajer MR Stockler 2005 Beauty is in the eye of the examiner: reaching agreement about physical signs and their value Intern Med J 35 178 87 10.1111/j.1445-5994.2004.00795.x 15737139 (Pubitemid 40389016)
15. CJ Cook GB Smith 2004 Do textbooks of clinical examination contain information regarding the assessment of critically ill patients? Resuscitation 60 129 36 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2003.09.009 15036729 (Pubitemid 38230902)
16. KC Lee D Dunlop NC Dolan 1998 Do clinical breast examination skills improve during medical school? Acad Med 73 1013 9 10.1097/00001888-199809000- 00025 9759109
17. DL Sackett D Rennie 1992 The science of the art of the clinical examination JAMA 267 2650 2 10.1001/jama.267.19.2650 1573756
18. JP Metlay WN Kapoor MJ Fine 1997 Does this patient have community-acquired pneumonia? Diagnosing pneumonia by history and physical examination JAMA 278 1440 5 10.1001/jama.278.17.1440 9356004
19. McGee S. Evidence based physical diagnosis. 2nd ed. Philadelphia: WB Saunders Co; 2007.
20. AG Auld 1903 The roentgen rays in the diagnosis of pulmonary disease Lancet 162 341 2 10.1016/S0140-6736(01)34102-8
21. GL Horowitz HL Bleich 1981 PaperChase: a computer program to search the medical literature New Engl J Med 305 924 930 7024808
22. CM Fletcher 1952 The clinical diagnosis of pulmonary emphysema Proc R Soc Med 45 577 84 13003946
23. DA Pyke 1954 Finger clubbing Lancet 2 352 354 10.1016/S0140-6736(54) 92662-8
24. RS Schilling JP Hughes I Dingwall-Fordyce 1955 Disagreement between observers in an epidemiological study of respiratory disease Br Med J 1 65 8 10.1136/bmj.1.4905.65 13219343
25. HC Smyllie lM Blendis P Armitage 1965 Observer disagreement in physical signs of the respiratory system Lancet 2 412 3 10.1016/S0140-6736(65)90759-2 14346762
26. IC Schneider AE Anderson 1965 Correlation of clinical signs with ventilatory function in obstructive lung disease Ann Intern Med 62 477 85 14263096
27. JR Nairn M Turner-Warwick 1969 Breath sounds in Emphysema Brit J Dis Chest 63 29 37 10.1016/S0007-0971(69)80041-0 5772979
28. S Godfrey RHT Edwards EJM Campbell P Armitage EA Oppenheimer 1969 Repeatability of physical signs in airway obstruction Thorax 24 4 9 10.1136/thx.24.1.4 4884174
29. AB Bohadana R Peslin H Uffholtz 1978 Breath sounds in the clinical assessment of airflow obstruction Thorax 33 345 51 10.1136/thx.33.3.345 684671
30. TJ Williams D Ahmad WK Morgan 1981 A clinical and roentgenographic correlation of diaphragmatic movement Arch Intern Med 141 878 80 10.1001/archinte.141.7.878 7235806 (Pubitemid 11067027)
31. T Gjorup PM Bugge AM Jensen 1984 Interobserver variation in assessment of respiratory signs. Physicians' guesses as to interobserver variation Acta Med Scand 216 61 6
32. CD Mulrow BL Dolmatch ER Delong JR Feussner MC Benyunes JL Dietz SK Lucas ED Pisano LP Svetkey BD Volpp, et al. 1986 Observer variability in the pulmonary examination J Gen Intern Med 1 364 7 10.1007/BF02596418 3794835
33. MA Spiteri DG Cook SW Clarke 1988 Reliability of eliciting physical signs in examination of the chest Lancet 1 873 5 10.1016/S0140-6736(88)91613-3 2895374
34. A Purohit A Bohadana MC Kopferschmitt-Kubler L Mahr J Linder G Pauli 1997 Lung auscultation in airway challenge testing Respir Med 91 151 7 10.1016/S0954-6111(97)90051-2 9135854 (Pubitemid 27122665)
35. JC Osmer BK Cole 1966 The stethoscope and roentgenogram in acute pneumonia South Med J 59 75 7 5902759
36. C Bilgi RL Jones BJ Sproule 1977 Relation between pulsus paradoxus and pulmonary function in patients with chronic airways obstruction Can Med Assoc J 117 1389 92 589538
37. PD Stein PW Willis 3rd DL DeMets 1981 History and physical examination in acute pulmonary embolism in patients without preexisting cardiac or pulmonary disease Am J Cardiol 47 218 23 10.1016/0002-9149(81)90388-X 7468469 (Pubitemid 11184279)
38. P Diehr RW Wood J Bushyhead L Krueger B Wolcott RK Tompkins 1984 Prediction of pneumonia in outpatients with acute cough-a statistical approach J Chronic Dis 37 215 25 10.1016/0021-9681(84)90149-8 6699126
39. P Gennis J Gallagher C Falvo S Baker W Than 1989 Clinical criteria for the detection of pneumonia in adults: guidelines for ordering chest roentgenograms in the emergency department J Emerg Med 7 263 8 10.1016/0736-4679(89)90358-2 2745948 (Pubitemid 19147317)
40. S Bourke D Nunes F Stafford G Hurley I Graham 1989 Percussion of the chest re-visited: a comparison of the diagnostic value of ausculatory and conventional chest percussion Ir J Med Sci 158 82 4 10.1007/BF02942111 2753659
41. PS Heckerling TG Tape RS Wigton KK Hissong JB Leikin JP Ornato JL Cameron EM Racht 1990 Clinical prediction rule for pulmonary infiltrates Ann Intern Med 113 664 70 2221647
42. DG Kern SR Patel 1991 Auscultated forced expiratory time as a clinical and epidemiologic test of airway obstruction Chest 100 636 9 10.1378/chest.100.3.636 1889246
43. H Melbye B Straume U Aasebo K Dale 1992 Diagnosis of pneumonia in adults in general practice. Relative importance of typical symptoms and abnormal chest signs evaluated against a radiographic reference standard Scand J Prim Health Care 10 226 33 10.3109/02813439209014066 1410955
44. JR Guarino JC Guarino 1994 Auscultatory percussion: a simple method to detect pleural effusion J Gen Intern Med 9 71 4 10.1007/BF02600204 8164080
45. RP Baughman KL Gunther JA Buchsbaum EE Lower 1998 Prevalence of digital clubbing in bronchogenic carcinoma by a new digital index Clin Exp Rheumatol 16 21 6 9543557
46. IS Petersen A Aru V Skodt N Behrendt B Bols K Kiss K Simonsen 1999 Evaluation of pneumonia diagnosis in intensive care patients Scand J Infect Dis 31 299 303 10.1080/00365549950163617 10482061 (Pubitemid 29389240)
47. SE Straus FA McAlister DL Sackett JJ Deeks 2000 The accuracy of patient history, wheezing, and laryngeal measurements in diagnosing obstructive airway disease. CARE-COAD1 Group. Clinical Assessment of the Reliability of the Examination-Chronic Obstructive Airways Disease JAMA 283 1853 7 10.1001/jama.283.14.1853 10770147
48. DR Mehr EF Binder RL Kruse SC Zweig RW Madsen RB D'Agostino 2001 Clinical findings associated with radiographic neumonia in nursing home residents J Fam Pract 50 931 7 11711008
49. F Bokhari S Brakenridge K Nagy R Roberts R Smith K Joseph G An D Wiley J Barrett 2002 Prospective evaluation of the sensitivity of physical examination in chest trauma J Trauma 53 1135 8 10.1097/00005373-200212000-00017 12478040
50. D Lichtenstein I Goldstein E Mourgeon P Cluzel P Grenier JJ Rouby 2004 Comparative diagnostic performances of auscultation, chest radiography, and lung ultrasonography in acute respiratory distress syndrome Anesthesiology 100 9 15 10.1097/00000542-200401000-00006 14695718 (Pubitemid 38031648)
51. E Garcia-Pachon I Padilla-Navas 2006 Frequency of Hoover's sign in stable patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease Int J Clin Pract 60 514 7 10.1111/j.1368-5031.2006.00850.x 16700846
52. WT O'Brien DA Rohweder GE Lattin JA Thornton JP Dutton DL Ebert-Long MD Duncan 2006 Clinical indicators of radiographic findings in patients with suspected community-acquired pneumonia: who needs a chest x-ray? J Am Coll Radiol 3 703 6 10.1016/j.jacr.2006.02.007 17412152 (Pubitemid 44280050)
53. BR Nolt R Gonzales J Maselli E Aagaard CA Camargo JP Metlay 2007 Vital-sign abnormalities as predictors of pneumonia in adults with acute cough illness Am J Emerg Med 25 631 6 10.1016/j.ajem.2006.11.031 17606087 (Pubitemid 46990697)
54. PF Saldias TD Cabrera LI de Solminihac AP Hernandez GA Gederlini FA Diaz 2007 Predictive value of history and physical examination for the diagnosis of community-acquired pneumonia in adults Rev Med Chil 135 143 150
55. EN Pardee CJ Martin EH Morgan 1976 A test odf the practical value of estimating breath sound intensity Chest 70 341 344 10.1378/chest.70.3.341 954460
56. AB Bohadana FT Coimbra JR Santiago 1986 Detection of lung abnormalities by auscultatory percussion: a comparative study with conventional percussion Respiration 50 218 25 10.1159/000194929 3797828
57. DK King 1989 Wheezing on maximal forced exhalation in the diagnosis of atypical asthma Ann Intern Med 110 451 55 2645821
58. DR Holleman DL Simel JS Goldberg 1993 Diagnosis of obstructive airways disease from the clinical examination J Gen Intern Med 8 63 8 10.1007/BF02599985 8441077
59. RG Badgett DJ Tanaka DK Hunt MJ Jelley LE Feinberg JF Steiner TL Petty 1994 The clinical evaluation for diagnosing obstructive airways disease in high-risk patients Chest 106 1427 31 10.1378/chest.106.5.1427 7956395
60. JE Wipf BA Lipsky JV Hirschmann EJ Boyko J Takasugi RL Peugeot CL Davis 1999 Diagnosing pneumonia by physical examination: relevant or relic? Arch Intern Med 159 1082 7 10.1001/archinte.159.10.1082 10335685 (Pubitemid 29230860)
61. S Kalantri R Joshi T Lokhande A Singh M Morgan JM Colford M Pai 2007 Accuracy and reliability of physical signs in the diagnosis of pleural effusion Respir Med 101 431 8 10.1016/j.rmed.2006.07.014 16965906 (Pubitemid 46196338)
62. PM Bossuyt JB Reitsma DE Bruns CA Gatsonis PP Glaziou LM Irwig D Moher D Rennie HCV De Vet JG Lijmer 2003 The STARD statement for reporting studies of diagnostic accuracy: explanations and elaboration Ann Intern Med 138 w1 w12 12513067
63. DL Simmel D Rennie PM Bossuyt 2008 The STARD statement for reporting diagnostic accuracy studies: application to the history and physical examination J Gen Intern Med 23 768 74 10.1007/s11606-008-0583-3
64. JR Landis GG Koch 1977 The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data Biometrics 33 159 174 10.2307/2529310 843571
65. DB King JA Dickinson MR Boulton C Toumpas 2006 Clinical skills textbooks fail evidence-based examination ACP J Club 144 A10 1 16388550
66. JM Vukanovic-Criley S Criley CM Warde JR Boker L Guevara-Matheus WH Churchill WP Nelson JM Criley 2006 Competency in cardiac examination skills in medical students, trainees, physicians and faculty Arch Intern Med 166 610 616 10.1001/archinte.166.6.610 16567598
67. SG Mukkamala C Gennings RP Wenzel 2008 R = 20: bias in the reporting of respiratory rates Am J Emerg Med 26 237 9 18272111
68. MW Weber S Usen A Palmer S Jaffar EK Mulholland 1997 Predictors of hypoxaemia in hospital admissions with acute lower respiratory tract infection in a developing country Arch Dis Child 76 310 4 10.1136/adc.76.4.310 9166021
69. W Mower C Sachs E Nicklin, et al. 1997 Pulse oximetry as a fifth vital sign Pediatrics 99 681 6 10.1542/peds.99.5.681 9113944