Do primary care physicians have particular difficulty identifying late-life depression? A meta-analysis stratified by age

Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics

Volumn 79, Issue 5, 2010, Pages 285-294

  Mitchell, Alex J ^a,b   Rao, Sanjay ^a   Vaze, Amol ^a  

^a LEICESTER GENERAL HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

^b LEICESTER ROYAL INFIRMARY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Clinical judgement; Depressive disorder, diagnosis; Meta analysis, depression; Primary care; Sensitivity; Specificity

Indexed keywords

AGE DISTRIBUTION; AGED; ARTICLE; BAYES THEOREM; CLINICAL TRIAL; DEPRESSION; DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY; EMBASE; GENERAL PRACTITIONER; HUMAN; LATE LIFE DEPRESSION; MEDLINE; META ANALYSIS; PRIMARY MEDICAL CARE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW;

AGE FACTORS; AGED; AGED, 80 AND OVER; BAYES THEOREM; DEPRESSIVE DISORDER; DIAGNOSTIC ERRORS; HUMANS; PHYSICIANS, PRIMARY CARE;

EID: 77954290023     PISSN: 00333190     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1159/000318295     Document Type: Article

References (92)

1. Cooper-Patrick L, Crum RM, Ford DE: Characteristics of patients with major depression who received care in general medical and specialty mental health settings. Med Care 1994; 32:15-24.
2. Harman J, Crystal S, Walkup J, Olfson M: Trends in elderly patients' office visits for the treatment of depression according to physician specialty: 1985-1999. J Behav Health Ser v Res 2003; 30: 332-341.
3. Pincus HA, Tanielian TL, Marcus SC, Olfson M, Zarin DA, Thompson J, Zito JM: Prescribing trends in psychotropic medications: primary care, psychiatry, and other medical specia lities. JAMA 1998; 279: 52 6-531.
4. Unutzer J, Katon W, Russo J, Simon G, Bush T, Walker E, Lin E, Van Korff M, Ludman E: Patterns of care for depressed older adults in a large-staff model HMO. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry 1999; 7: 235-243.
5. Harman JS, Veazie PJ, Lyness JM: Primary care physician office visits for depression by older Americans. J Gen Int Med 2006; 21: 926-930.
6. Fischer LR, Wei F, Solberg LI, Rush WA, Heinrich RL: Treatment of elderly and other adult patients for depression in primary care. J Am Geriatr Soc 2003; 5 1: 155 4-15 62.
7. Berardi D, Menchetti M, De Ronchi D, Rucci P, Leggieri G, Ferrari G: Late-life depression in primary care: a nationwide Italian epide-miological survey. J Am Geriatr Soc 2002; 50: 77-83. (Pubitemid 34053026)
8. Mitchell AJ, Subramaniam H: Prognosis of depression in old age compared to middle age: a systematic review of comparative studies. Am J Psychiatry 2005; 16 2: 1588-16 01.
9. Unützer J, Katon W, Callahan CM, Williams JW Jr, Hunkeler E, Harpole L, Hoffing M, Della Penna RD, Noel PH, Lin EH, Tang L, Oishi S: Depression treatment in a sample of 1,801 depressed older adults in primary care. J Am Geriatr Soc 2003; 5 1: 505-514.
10. Beekman AT, Deeg DJ, Braam AW, Smit JH, Van Tilburg W: Consequences of major and minor depression in later life: a study of disability, well-being and service utilization. Psychol Med 1997; 27: 1397-1409.
11. Luber MP, Meyers BS, Williams-Russo PG, Hollenberg JP, DiDomenico TN, Charlson ME, Alexopoulos GS: Depression and service utilization in elderly primary care patients. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry 2001; 9: 1 6 9-176.
12. Menchetti M, Cevenini N, De Ronchi D, Quartesan R, Berardi D: Depression and frequent attendance in elderly primary care patients. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 2006; 28:119-124.
13. Crystal S, Sambamoorthi U, Walkup JT, Akincigil A: Diagnosis and treatment of depression in the elderly Medicare population: predictors, disparities, and trends. J Am Geriatr Soc 2003;51: 1718-1728.
14. Harman JS, Schulberg HC, Mulsant BH, Reynolds CF III: The effect of patient and visit characteristics on diagnosis of depression in primary care. J Fam Pract 2001; 50: 1068.
15. Shah S, Harris M: A survey of general practitioners' confidence in their management of elderly patients. Aust Fam Physician 1997; 26(suppl 1):S12-S17.
16. Mulsant BH, Ganguli M: Epidemiology and diagnosis of depression in late life. J Clin Psychiatry 1999; 60(suppl 20):9-15.
17. Simon GE, Goldberg D, Tiemens BG, Ustun TB: Outcomes of recognized and unrecognized depression in an international primary c a re s t udy. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 19 9 9; 21:97-105.
18. Klinkman MS, Coyne JC, Gallo S, Schwenk TL: False positives, false negatives, and the validity of the diagnosis of major depression in primary care. Arch Fam Med 1998; 7:451-461.
19. Iliffe S, Haines A, Gallivan S, Booroff A, Goldenberg E, Morgan P: Assessment of elderly people in general practice. 1. Social circumstances and mental state. Br J Gen Pract 1991; 41: 9-12.
20. Rost K, Zhang M, Fortney J, Smith J, Coyne J, Smith GR Jr: Persistently poor outcomes of undetected major depression in primary care. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 1998; 20:12-20.
21. Borowsky SJ, Rubenstein LV, Meredith LS, Camp P, Jackson-Triche M, Wells KB: Who is at risk of nondetection of mental health problems in primary care? J Gen Intern Med 2000; 15:381-388.
22. McCall L, Clarke D, Trauer T, Piterman L, Ling MY: Predictors of accuracy of recognition of emotional distress in general practice. Prim Care Community Psychiatry 2007; 12: 1-5.
23. Volkers A, Nuyen J, Verhaak P, Schellevis F: The problem of diagnosing major depression in elderly primary care patients. J Affect Dis-ord 2004; 82: 259-263.
24. Thompson C, Ostler K, Peveler RC, Baker N, Kinmonth A: Dimensional perspective on the recognition of depressive symptoms in primary care: the Hampshire Depression Project 3. Br J Psychiatry 2001; 179:317-323. (Pubitemid 32996040)
25. Cape J, Morris E, Adams N, Fairbairns A: Identification of psychological morbidity in older people in primary care by practice nurses. Aging Ment Health 2003; 7:446-451.
26. McCray LW, Bogner HR, Sammel MD, Gallo JJ: The role of patient personality in the identification of depression in older primary care patients. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 2007; 22: 1095-1100.
27. Da Canhota CM, Piterman L: Depressive disorders in elderly Chinese patients in Macau: a comparison of general practitioners' consultations with a depression screening scale. Aust NZJP sychiatry 2001; 25:336-344.
28. Irwig L, Macaskill P, Glasziou P, Fahey M: Meta-analytic methods for diagnostic test accuracy. J Clin Epidemiol 1995; 48:119-130.
29. Midgette AS, Stukel TA, Littenberg B: A meta-analytic method for summarising diagnostic test performance: receiver operating characteristic summary point estimates. Med Decis Making 1993; 13: 253-257.
30. Macaskill P, Glasziou P, Irwig L: Met a-ana lysis of diagnost ic tests; in A r m itage P, C olton T (eds): Encyclopedia of Biostatistics, ed 2. New York, Wiley, 2005.
31. Higgins JP, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, Altman DG: Measuring inconsistency in meta-anal-yses. BMJ 2003; 327:557-560.
32. McClish DK: Combining and comparing area estimates across studies or strata. Med Decis Making 1992; 12:274-279.
33. Mitchell AJ, Bird V, Rizzo M, Meader N: Diagnostic validity and added value of the geriatric depression scale for depression in primary care: a meta-analysis of GDS(30) and GDS(15). J Affect Disord 2009 [Epub ahead of print].
34. Bowers J, Jorm AF, Henderson S, Harris P: General practitioners' detection of depression and dementia in elderly patients. Med J Aust 1990; 153: 19 2-19 6.
35. Crawford MJ, Prince M, Menezes P, Mann AH: The recognition and treatment of depression in older people in primary care. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 1998; 13: 1 7 2-1 7 6.
36. O'Connor DW, Rosewarne R, Bruce A: Depression in primary care. 2. General prac-tioners' recognition of major depression in elderly patients. Int Psychogeriatr 2001; 13: 367-374.
37. Pond CD, Mant A, Bridges-Webb C, Purcell C, Eyland EA, Hewitt H, Saunders NA: Recognition of depression in the elderly: a comparison of general practitioner opinions and the geriatric depression scale. J Fam Pract 199 0; 7: 190-194.
38. Turrina C, Caruso R, Este R, Lucchi F, Faz-zari G, Dewey ME, Ermentini A: Affective disorders among elderly general practice patients: a two-phase survey in Brescia, Italy. Br J Psychiatry 1994; 16 5: 533-537.
39. Van Marwijk HWJ, de Bock GH, Hermans J, Mulder JD, Springer MP: Prevalence of depression and clues to focus diagnosis: a study among Dutch general practice patients 65+ years of age. Scand J Prim Health Care 1996; 14: 142-147.
40. Memel DS, Kirwan JR, Sharp DJ, Hehir M: General practitioners miss disability and anxiety as well as depression in t heir patients with osteoarthritis. Br J Gen Pract 2000; 50: 645-648.
41. McCusker J, Karp E, Yaffe MJ, Cole M, Bel-lavance F: Determining detection of depression in the elderly by primary care physicians: chart review or questionnaire? Prim Care Psychiatry 1996; 2:217-221.
42. Mullan E, Katona P, D'Ath P, Katona C: Detection and management of depression in elderly primary care attenders. II. Detection and fitness for treatment: a case record study. Fa m Pract 1994; 11: 267-270.
43. Pond CD, Mant A, Kehoe L, Hewitt H, Bro-daty H: General practitioner diagnosis of depression and dementia in the elderly: can academic detailing make a difference? Fam Pract 1994; 11:141-147.
44. Watts SC, Bhutani GE, Stout IH, Ducker GM, Cleator PJ, McGarry J, Day M: Mental health in older adult recipients of primary care services: is depression the key issue? Identification, treatment and the general practitioner. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 2002; 17:427-437.
45. Rabinowitz J, Shayevitz D, Hornik T, et al.: Primary care physicians' detection of psychological distress among elderly patients. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry 2005; 13: 773-78 0.
46. Aragones E, Pinol JL, Labad A: The overdi-agnosis of depression in non-depressed patients in primar y care. Fam Pract 20 06; 23: 363-368.
47. Christensen KS, Toft T, Frostholm L, Ornbol E, Fink P, Olesen F: The FIP Study: a randomised, controlled trial of screening and recognition of psychiatric disorders. Br J Gen Pract 20 03; 53: 758-763.
48. Henkel V, Mergl R, Kohnen R, Maier W, Möller HJ, Hegerl U: Identifying depression in primary care: a comparison of different methods in a prospective cohort study. BMJ 2003; 326:200-201.
49. Klinkman MS, Coyne JC, Gallo S, Schwenk TL: False positives, false negatives, and the validity of the diagnosis of major depression in primary care. Arch Fam Med 1998; 7:451-461.
50. Tiemens BG, VonKorff M, Lin EH: Diagnosis of depression by primary care physicians versus a structured diagnostic interview: understanding discordance. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 1999; 21:87-96.
51. Chung H, Teresi J, Guarnaccia P, Meyers BS, Holmes D, Bobrowitz T, Eimicke JP, Ferran E Jr: Depressive symptoms and psychiatric distress in low income Asian and Latino primary care patients: prevalence and recognition. Community Ment Health J 2003; 39: 33-46.
52. Kahn LS, Halbreich U, Bloom MS, Bidani R, Rich E, Hershey CO: Screening for mental illness in primary care clinics. Int J Psychiatry Med 2004; 34: 345-362.
53. Kendrick T, King F, Albertella L , Smith P: GP treatment decisions for patients with depression: an observational study. Br J Gen Pract 2005; 55: 280-286.
54. Robbins JM, Kirmayer LJ, Cathébras P, Yaffe MJ, Dworkind M: Physician characteristics and the recognition of depression and anxiety in primary care. Med Care 1994; 32:795-812.
55. Schmaling KB, Hernandez DV: Detection of depression among low-income Mexican Americans in primary care. J Health Care Poor Underserved 2005; 16:780-790.
56. Shiels C, Gabbay M, Dowrick C, Hulbert C: Depression in men attending a rural general practice: factors associated with prevalence of depressive symptoms and diagnosis. Br J Psychiatry 2004; 18 5: 239-244.
57. Balestrieri M, Carta MG, Leonetti S, Sebas-tiani G, Starace F, Bellantuono C: Recognition of depression and appropriateness of antidepressant treatment in Italian primary care. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 2004; 39:171-176.
58. Gerber PD, Barrett J, Barrett J, Manheimer E, Whiting R, Smith R: Recognition of depression by internists in primary care: a comparison of internists and 'gold standard' psychiatric assessments. J Gen Intern Med 1989; 4:7-13.
59. Becker SM: Detection of somatisation and depression in primary care in Saudi Arabia. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 2004; 39: 962-966.
60. Seller RH, Blascovich J, Lenkei E: Influence of stereotypes in the diagnosis of depression by family practice residents. J Fam Pract 1981; 12:849-854.
61. Rosenberg E, Lussier MT, Beaudoin C, Kir-mayer LJ, Dufort GG: Determinants of the diagnosis of psychological problems by pri-mar y c a re physicia ns in pat ients with norma l GHQ-28 scores. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 2002; 24:322-327.
62. Ostler K, Thompson C, Kinmonth Al, Peve-ler RC, Stevens L, Stevens A: Influence of socio-economic deprivation on the prevalence and outcome of depression in primary care: the Hampshire Depression Project. Br J Psychiatry 2001; 178:12-17.
63. Wittchen HU, Hofler M, Meister W: Prevalence and recognition of depressive syndromes in German primary care settings: poorly recognized and treated? Int Clin Psy-chopharmacol 2001; 16:121-135.
64. Lyness JM, Cox C, Curry J, Conwell Y, King DA, Caine ED: Older age and the underreporting of depressive symptoms. J Am Geri-atr Soc 1995; 43:216-221.
65. Gallo JJ, Rabins PV, Anthony JC: Sadness in older persons: 13-year follow-up of a community sample in Baltimore. Psychol Med 1999; 29: 341-350.
66. Lebowitz BD, Pearson JL, Schneider LS, Reynolds CF III, Alexopoulos GS, Bruce ML, Conwell Y, Katz IR, Meyers BS, Morrison MF, Mossey J, Niederehe G, Parmelee P: Diagnosis and treatment of depression in late life: consensus statement update. JAMA 1997; 278: 11 8 6-119 0.
67. Lyness JM, Bruce ML, Koenig HG, Parmelee PA, Schulz R, Lawton MP, Reynolds CF III: Depression and medical illness in late life: report of a symposium. J Am Geriatr Soc 1996; 44: 198-2 03.
68. Gallo JJ, Ryan SD, Ford DE: Attitudes, knowledge, and behavior of family physicians regarding depression in late life. Arch Fam Med 1999; 8:249-256.
69. Ani C, Bazargan M, Hindman D, Bell D, Fa-rooq MA, Akhanjee L, Yemofio F, Baker R, Rodriguez M: Depression symptomatology and diagnosis: discordance between patients and physicians in primary care settings. BMC Fam Pract 2008; 9: 1.
70. Pfaff JJ, Almeida OP: A cross-sectional analysis of factors that influence the detection of depression in older primary care patients. Aust NZ J Psychiatry 2005; 39: 262-265.
71. Tai-Seale M, Bramson R, Drukker D, Hur-wicz ML, Ory M, Tai-Seale T, Street R Jr, Cook MA: Understanding primary care physicians' propensity to assess elderly patients for depression using interaction and survey data. Med Care 2005; 43:1217-1224.
72. Tai-Seale M, McGuire T, Colenda C, Rosen D, Cook MA: Two-minute mental health care for elderly patients: inside primary care visits. J Am Geriatr Soc 2007; 55: 19 03-1911.
73. Adelman RD, Greene MG, Friedmann E, Cook MA: Discussion of depression in follow-up medical visits with older patients. J Am Geriatr Soc 2008; 56: 16-2 2.
74. Schneider G, Kruse A, Nehen HG, Senf W, Heuft G: The prevalence and differential diagnosis of subclinical depressive syndromes in inpatients 60 years and older. Psychother Psychosom 200 0; 69: 251-260.
75. Wilson A, McDonald P: Comparison of patient questionnaire, medical record, and audio tape in assessment of health promotion in general practice consultations. BMJ 1994; 309:1483-1485.
76. Stange KC, Zyzanski SJ, Smith TF, Kelly R, Langa DM, Flocke SA, Jaén CR: How valid are medical records and patient questionnaires for physician profiling and health services research? A comparison with direct observation of patient visits. Med Care 1998; 36: 851-867.
77. Williams JW Jr, Pignone M, Ramirez G, Perez Stellato C: Identifying depression in primary care: a literature synthesis of case-finding instruments. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 2002; 24:225-237.
78. Kessler D, Bennewith O, Lewis G, Sharp D: Detection of depression and anxiety in primary care: follow-up study. BMJ 2002; 325: 1016-1017.
79. Jackson JL, Passamonti M, Kroenke K: Outcome and impact of mental disorders in primary care at 5 years. Psychosom Med 2007; 69:270-276.
80. Callahan CM, Hendrie HC, Dittus RS, Bra-ter DC, Hui SL, Tierney WM: Improving treatment of late life depression in primary care: a randomized clinical trial. J Am Geri-atr Soc 1994; 42: 839-846.
81. Volkers A, Nuyen J, Verhaak P, Schellevis F: The problem of diagnosing major depression in elderly primary care patients. J Affect Dis-ord 2004; 82: 259-263.
82. Rojas-Fernandez C, Thomas VS, Carver D, Tonks R: Suboptimal use of antidepressants in the elderly: a population-based study in Nova Scot ia. Clin Ther 1999; 21: 1937-1950.
83. Callahan CM, Hendrie HC, Dittus RS, Bra-ter DC, Hui SL, Tierney WM: Improving treatment of late life depression in primary care: a randomized clinical trial. J Am Geri-atr Soc 1994; 42: 839-846.
84. Whooley MA, Stone B, Soghikian K: Randomized trial of case-finding for depression in elderly primary care patients. J Gen Intern Med 200 0; 15: 293-30 0.
85. Rubenstein LZ, Alessi CA, Josephson KR, Trinidad Hoyl M, Harker JO, Pietruszka FM: A randomized trial of a screening, case finding, and referral system for older veterans in primary care. J Am Geriatr Soc 2007; 55:16 6-174.
86. Lattanzio F, Di Bari M, Sgadari A, Baccini M, Ercolani S, Rengo F, Senin U, Bernabei R, Marchionni N, Cherubini A, Depression in the Aged Female National Evaluation Study Group: Improving the diagnostic accuracy of depression in older persons: the Depression in the Aged Female National Evaluation cluster randomized trial. J Am Geriatr Soc 2009; 57: 588-593.
87. Fava GA, Nicoletta Sonino N: Psychosomatic assessment. Psychother Psychosom 2009; 78:333-341.
88. Bartels SJ, Coakley EH, Zubritsky C, Ware JH, Miles KM, Areán PA, Chen H, Oslin DW, Llorente MD, Costantino G, Quijano L, McIntyre JS, Linkins KW, Oxman TE, Maxwell J, Levkoff SE, PRISM-E Investigators: Improving access to geriatric mental health services: a randomized trial comparing treatment engagement with integrated versus enhanced referral care for depression, anxiety, and at-risk alcohol use. Am J Psychiatry 2004; 161:1455-1462.
89. Chew-Graham CA, Lovell K, Roberts C, Baldwin R, Morley M, Burns A, Richards D, Burroughs H: A randomised controlled trial to test the feasibility of a collaborative care model for the management of depression in older people. Br J Gen Pract 20 07; 57: 364-370.
90. Unützer J, Katon W, Callahan CM, Williams JW Jr, Hunkeler E, Harpole L, Hoffing M, Della Penna RD, Noël PH, Lin EH, Areán PA, Hegel MT, Tang L, Belin TR, Oishi S, Langston C, IMPACT Investigators: Improving mood-promoting access to collaborative treatment: collaborative care management of late-life depression in the primary care setting-a randomized controlled trial. JAMA 2002; 288:2836-2845.
91. Bruce ML, Ten Have TR, Reynolds CF 3rd, Katz II, Schulberg HC, Mulsant BH, Brown GK, McAvay GJ, Pearson JL, Alexopoulos GS: Reducing suicidal ideation and depressive symptoms in depressed older primary care patients: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA 2003; 291:1081-1091.
92. Cole MG, McCusker J, El ie M, Dendu k ur i N, Latimer E, Belzile E: Systematic detection and multidisciplinary care of depression in older medical inpatients: a randomized trial. CMAJ 2006; 174:3 8-4 4.