Measuring parties' ideological positions with manifesto data: A critical evaluation of the competing methods

Party Politics

Volumn 16, Issue 4, 2010, Pages 427-450

  Dinas, Elias ^a   Gemenis, Kostas ^b  

^a EUROPEAN UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE   (Italy)

^b KEELE UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Ideology; Left right; Party manifestos; Reliability; Validity

Indexed keywords

EID: 77954207870     PISSN: 13540688     EISSN: 14603683     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/1354068809343107     Document Type: Article

References (53)

1. Bartolini, Stefano and Peter Mair (1990) Identity, Competition, and Electoral Availability: the Stabilisation of European Electorates, 1885-1985. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
2. Benoit, Kenneth and Michael Laver (2007a) Estimating Party Policy Positions: Comparing Expert Surveys and Hand-Coded Content Analysis, Electoral Studies 26: 90-107.
3. Benoit, Kenneth and Michael Laver (2007b) Benchmarks for Text Analysis: a Response to Budge and Pennings, Electoral Studies 26: 130-5.
4. Bosco, Anna (2001) Four Actors in Search of a Role: the Southern European Communist Parties, in P. Nikiforos Diamandouros and Richard Gunther (eds) Parties, Politics, and Democracy in the New Southern Europe, pp. 329-87. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
5. Budge, Ian (1987) The Internal Analysis of Election Programmes, in Ian Budge, David Robertson and Derek J. Hearl (eds) Ideology, Strategy and Party Change, pp. 15-38. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
6. Budge, Ian (1994) A New Spatial Theory of Party Competition: Uncertainty, Ideology and Policy Equilibria Viewed Comparatively and Temporally, British Journal of Political Science 24: 443-67.
7. Budge, Ian (2000) Expert Opinions of Party Policy Positions: Uses and Limitations in Political Research, European Journal of Political Research 37: 103-13.
8. Budge, Ian (2001a) Validating Party Policy Placements, British Journal of Political Science 31: 210-23.
9. Budge, Ian (2001b) Validating the Manifesto Research Group Approach: Theoretical Assumptions and Empirical Confirmations, in Michael Laver (ed.) Estimating the Policy Position of Political Actors, pp. 50-65. London: Routledge.
10. Budge, Ian and Dennis Farlie (1983) Party Competition - Selective Emphasis or Direct Confrontation? An Alternative View with Data, in Hans Daalder and Peter Mair (eds) West European Party Systems: Continuity and Change, pp. 267-305. London: Sage.
11. Budge, Ian and Hans-Dieter Klingemann (2001) Finally! Comparative Over-time Mapping of Policy Movement, in Ian Budge, Hans-Dieter Klingemann, Andrea Volkens, Judith Bara and Eric Tanenbaum (eds) Mapping Policy Preferences: Estimates for Parties, Electors, and Governments, 1945-1998, pp. 19-50. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
12. Budge, Ian, Hans-Dieter Klingemann, Andrea Volkens, Judith Bara and Eric Tanenbaum (eds) (2001) Mapping Policy Preferences: Estimates for Parties, Electors, and Governments 1945-1998. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
13. Budge, Ian and Paul Pennings (2007) Do They Work? Validating Computerised Word Frequency Estimates Against Policy Series, Electoral Studies 26: 121-9.
14. Carmines, Edward G. and James A. Woods (2005) Validity Assessment, in Kimberly Kempf-Leonard (ed.) Encyclopedia of Social Measurement, vol. 3, pp. 933-7. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
15. Carrubba, Clifford J., Matthew Gabel, Lacey Murrah, Ryan Clough, Elizabeth Montgomery and Rebecca Schambach (2006) Off the Record: Unrecorded Legislative Votes, Selection Bias and Roll-Call Vote Analysis, British Journal of Political Science 36: 691-704.
16. Carter, Elisabeth (2005) The Extreme Right in Western Europe: Success or Failure? Manchester: Manchester University Press.
17. Clogg, Richard (1987) Parties and Elections in Greece: the Search for Legitimacy. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
18. Fitzmaurice, Garrett M., Nan M. Laird and James H. Ware (2004) Applied Longitudinal Analysis. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley and Sons.
19. Franzmann, Simon and André Kaiser (2006) Locating Political Parties in Policy Space: a Reanalysis of Party Manifesto Data, Party Politics 12: 163-88.
20. Gabel, Matthew J. and John D. Huber (2000) Putting Parties in Their Place: Inferring Party Left-Right Ideological Positions from Party Manifesto Data, American Journal of Political Science 44: 94-103.
21. Green, Donald P. and Bradley Palmquist (1990) Of Artifacts and Partisan Instability, American Journal of Political Science 34: 872-902.
22. Hanley, David (2008) Beyond the Nation State: Parties in the Era of European Integration. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
23. Heise, David R. (1969) Separating Reliability and Stability in Test-Retest Correlation, American Sociological Review 34: 93-101.
24. Huber, John D. and Ronald Inglehart (1995) Expert Interpretations of Party Space and Party Locations in 42 Societies, Party Politics 1: 73-111.
25. Hug, Simon and Tobias Schulz (2007) Left-Right Positions of Political Parties in Switzerland, Party Politics 13: 305-30.
26. Jacoby, William G. (1991) Data Theory and Dimensional Analysis, Quantitative Applications in the Social Sciences Series, no. 78. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
27. Kim, Heemin and Richard C. Fording (1998) Voter Ideology in Western Democracies, 1946-1989, European Journal of Political Research 33: 73-97.
28. King, Gary (1990) On Political Methodology, Political Analysis 2: 1-29.
29. Kleinnijenhuis, Jan and Paul Pennings (2001) Measurement of Party Positions on the Basis of Party Programmes, Media Coverage and Voter Perceptions, in Michael Laver (ed.) Estimating the Policy Position of Political Actors, pp. 162-82. London: Routledge.
30. Klingemann, Hans-Dieter (1995) Party Positions and Voter Orientations, in Hans-Dieter Klingemann and Dieter Fuch (eds) Citizens and the State, pp. 183-206. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
31. Klingemann, Hans-Dieter, Andrea Volkens, Judith Bara, Ian Budge and Michael D. McDonald (2007) Mapping Policy Preferences II: Estimates for Parties, Electors and Governments in Central and Eastern Europe, European Union and OECD, 1990-2003. New York: Oxford University Press.
32. Konstantinidis, Ioannis (2004) 'Metavoles sto periechomeno ton programmaton ton Hellinikon kommaton, 1974-2000: He axia tes prosarmostikotetas' [Policy Changes as Pictured in Greek Parties' Electoral Manifestos: the Value of Adaptability], Greek Political Science Review 12 (November): 105-39.
33. Laver, Michael (2001a) Why Should We Estimate the Policy Positions of Political Actors? in Michael Laver (ed.) Estimating the Policy Position of Political Actors, pp. 3-9. London: Routledge.
34. Laver, Michael (2001b) Position and Salience in the Politics of Political Parties, in Michael Laver (ed.) Estimating the Policy Position of Political Actors, pp. 66-75. London: Routledge.
35. Laver, Michael, Kenneth Benoit and John Garry (2003) Estimating the Policy Positions of Political Actors Using Words as Data, American Political Science Review 97: 311-31.
36. Laver, Michael and Ian Budge (1992) Measuring Policy Distances and Modelling Coalition Formation, in Michael Laver and Ian Budge (eds) Party Policy and Government Coalitions, pp. 15-40. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
37. Laver, Michael and Ben W. Hunt (1992) Policy and Party Competition. New York. Routledge.
38. Lubbers, Marcel (2001) Exclusionistic Electorates: Extreme Right-Wing Voting in Western Europe. Nijmegen: Center for Social Science Theory and Methodology.
39. Mair, Peter (2001) Searching for the Positions of Political Actors: a Review of Approaches and Critical Evaluation of Expert Surveys, in Michael Laver (ed.) Estimating the Policy Position of Political Actors, pp. 10-30. London: Routledge.
40. Marks, Gary (2007) Introduction: Triangulation and the Square-Root Law, Electoral Studies 26: 1-10.
41. McDonald, Michael P. (2005) Validity, Data Sources, in Kimberly Kempf-Leonard (ed.) Encyclopedia of Social Measurement, vol. 3, pp. 939-48. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
42. McDonald, MichaelD., Silvia M. Mendes and Myunghee Kim (2007) Cross-Temporal and Cross-National Comparisons of Party Left-Right Positions, Electoral Studies 26: 62-75.
43. Moschonas, Gerassimos (2002) In the Name of Social Democracy: the Great Transformation, 1945 to the Present. London: Verso.
44. Pelizzo, Ricardo (2003) Party Positions or Party Direction? An Analysis of Party Manifesto Data, West European Politics 26 (April): 67-89.
45. Pridham, Geoffrey and Susannah Verney (1991) The Coalitions of 1989-90 in Greece: Inter-Party Relations and Democratic Consolidation, West European Politics 14 (October): 42-69.
46. Ray, Leonard (1999) Measuring Party Orientations towards European Integration: Results from an Expert Survey, European Journal of Political Research 36: 283-306.
47. Robertson, David (1987) Britain, Australia, New Zealand and the United States, 1946-1981: an Initial Comparative Analysis, in Ian Budge, David Robertson and Derek J. Hearl (eds) Ideology, Strategy and Party Change, pp. 39-73. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
48. Spourdalakis, Michalis (1988) The Rise of the Greek Socialist Party. London: Routledge.
49. Steenbergen, Marco and Gary Marks (2007) Evaluating Expert Surveys, European Journal of Political Research 46: 347-66.
50. van der Brug, Wouter (2001) Analysing Party Dynamics by Taking Partially Overlapping Snapshots, in Michael Laver (ed.) Estimating the Policy Positions of Political Actors, pp. 115-32. London: Routledge.
51. Volkens, Andrea (2007) Strengths and Weaknesses of Approaches to Measuring Policy Positions of Parties, Electoral Studies 26: 108-20.
52. Warwick, Paul V. (2005) When Far Apart Becomes Too Far Apart: Evidence for a Threshold Effect in Coalition Formation, British Journal of Political Science 35: 383-401.
53. Wiley, David E. and James A. Wiley (1970) The Estimation of Measurement Error in Panel Data, American Sociological Review 35: 112-7.