Rolling Out Anti-social Behaviour Families Projects in England and Scotland: Analysing the Rhetoric and Practice of Policy Transfer

Social Policy and Administration

Volumn 44, Issue 3, 2010, Pages 305-325

  Nixon, Judith ^a   Pawson, Hal ^a   Sosenko, Filip ^a  

^a SHEFFIELD HALLAM UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Anti social behaviour policy; Family Intervention Projects; Policy transfer; Sanctions

Indexed keywords

ANTISOCIAL BEHAVIOR; LEGISLATION; SOCIAL EXCLUSION; SOCIAL POLICY;

ENGLAND; SCOTLAND; UNITED KINGDOM;

EID: 77953795253     PISSN: 01445596     EISSN: 14679515     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-9515.2010.00715.x     Document Type: Article

References (60)

1. Bennett C J. Review article: what is policy convergence and what causes it? British Journal of Political Science 1991, 21:215-33.
2. Black J. Tales from the sin-bin. Roof 1997, 32-3. Jan/Feb
3. Blair T. Speech at the launch of the Respect Action Plan. 2006, http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/4600156.stm, BBC News. Available at: (accessed 20 September 2009
4. Burney E. Ruling out trouble: anti-social behaviour and housing management. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology 2000, 11(2):268-73.
5. Think Family: Improving the Life Chances of Families at Risk 2008, Cabinet Office, Families at Risk Review, London, Social Exclusion Taskforce
6. Davies H, Nutley S M, Smith P. What Works? Evidence-based Policy in Public Services 2000, Bristol, Policy Press
7. Youth Taskforce Action Plan 2008, http://www.respect.gov.uk/uploadedFiles/Members_site/Documents_and_images/Supportive_interventions/YFT_ActionPlan0145.pdf, Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF), London, DCSF, Available at:
8. Dillane J, Hill M, Bannister J, Scott S. Evaluation of the Dundee Families Project 2001, Glasgow, Dundee City Council, Scottish Executive, NCH Scotland
9. Dolowitz D, Marsh D. Who learns what from whom: a review of the policy transfer literature. Political Studies 1996, 44:343-57.
10. Donoghue J. Antisocial Behaviour Orders (ASBOs) in Britain: contextualizing risk and reflexive modernization. Sociology 2008, 42(2):337.
11. El Komy M, Bowen E, Hoon J, Steer C. Anti-social and Other Problem Behaviours among Young Children: Findings from the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children. 2008, http://www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs08/r283.pdf, London: Home Office Online Report 02/08. Available at:
12. Situating anti-social behaviour and respect: findings from an ESRC seminar series. 2009, http://www.law.leeds.ac.uk/esrcASB, ESRC, Available at: (or contact Anna Barker at:
13. Evans M, Davies J. Understanding policy transfer: a multi level, multi disciplinary perspective. Public Administration 1999, 77:361-85.
14. Farrington D, Codi J, Harnett L, Joliffe D, Soteriou N, Turner R, West D J. Criminal Careers and Life Success: New Findings from the Cambridge Study in Delinquent Development 2006, London, Home Office
15. Flint J. Housing and ethopolitics: constructing identities of active consumption and responsible communities. Economy and Society 2003, 32(3):611-29.
16. Offending Crime and Justice Survey 2005, Home Office, London, Home Office
17. Report into Anti-social Behaviour 2005, Home Affairs Select Committee, London, House of Commons
18. James O, Lodge M. The limitations of 'policy transfer' and 'lesson drawing' for public policy research. Political Studies Review 2003, 1:179-93.
19. Jones T, Newburn T. Policy convergence and crime control in the USA and UK: streams of influence and levels of impact. Criminology and Criminal Justice 2002, 2:173-203.
20. Jones T, Newburn T. The convergence of US and UK crime control policy: exploring substance and process. Criminal Justice and Political Cultures 2004, 123-51. Newburn T, Sparks R. eds, Cullompton, Willan Publishing.
21. Jones A, Pearce N, Quilars D. Evaluating the Shelter Inclusion Project: a floating support service for households accused of anti-social behaviour. Housing and Anti-social Behaviour: Theory, Policy and Practice 2006a, 179-97. Flint J, ed., Bristol, Policy Press.
22. Jones A, Pearce N, Quilars D. Addressing Anti-social Behaviour: An Independent Evaluation of Shelter Inclusion Project 2006b, London, Shelter
23. Keating M. Scottish Social Democracy: Progressive Ideas for Public Policy 2007, ed., Brussels, PIE Peter Lang
24. Macaskill M. Councils refuse to issue more ASBOs: Sunday Times. 2006, 21 May
25. Margo J, Stevens A. Make Me a Criminal: Preventing Youth Crime 2008, London, Institute for Public Policy Research
26. Morris K. Think Family: A Literature Review of Whole Family Approaches 2008, http://www.cabinetoffice.gov.uk/social_exclusion_task_force/families_at_risk/review_analysis.aspx, London, Cabinet Office, Available at:
27. Muncie J. Policy transfers and 'what works': some reflections on comparative youth justice. Youth Justice 2001, 1:27.
28. Nixon J, Hunter C, Parr S, Myers S, Whittle S, Sanderson D. Interim Evaluation of Rehabilitation Projects for Families at Risk of Losing Their Home as a Result of Anti-social Behaviour 2006a, London, ODPM
29. Nixon J, Hunter C, Parr S, Myers S, Whittle S, Sanderson D. Anti-Social Behaviour Intensive Family Support Projects: An Evaluation of Six Pioneering Projects 2006b, London, ODPM
30. Nixon J, Parr S, Sanderson D. The Longer-term Outcomes for Families Who Have Worked with Intensive Family Support Projects 2008, London, CLG
31. Parr S. Family Intervention Projects: a site of social work practice. British Journal of Social Work 2008, advance access version, published 23 April, doi:10.1093/bjsw/bcn057
32. Parr S, Nixon J. Rationalising Family Intervention Projects. ASBO Nation: The Criminalisation of Nuisance 2008, 161-75. Squires P, ed., Bristol, Policy Press.
33. Parr S, Nixon J. Family Intervention Projects: sites of resilience, resistance and domination. Subversive Citizens: Power, Agency and Resistance in Public Policy 2009, 101-17. Barnes M, Prior D. eds, Bristol, Policy Press.
34. Pawson H, Davidson E, Sosenko F, Flint J, Nixon J, Casey R, Sanderson D. Evaluation of Intensive Family Support Projects in Scotland 2009, Edinburgh, Scottish Government
35. Pierson C. Learning from Labor? Welfare policy transfer between Australia and Britain. Commonwealth and Comparative Politics 2003, 41(1):77-100.
36. Pollitt C. Public management: convergence the useful myth? Public Administration 2001, 79(4):933-47.
37. Respect Action Plan 2006a, http://www.homeoffice.gov.uk/documents/respect-action-plan, Respect Taskforce, London, Home Office, Available at:
38. Respect Family Intervention Projects. 2006b, http://www.respect.gov.uk/uploadedFiles/Members_site/Documents_and_images/Supportive_interventions/FIP_Respect_Projects_0026.pdf, Respect Taskforce, Available at:
39. Family Intervention Projects: A Toolkit for Local Practitioners. 2007, http://www.respect.gov.uk/uploadedFiles/Members_site/Documents_and_images/Supportive_interventions/FIP_RTFtoolkit_V1Jul07_0104.doc, Respect Taskforce, Available at:
40. Rose N. Community, citizenship and the Third Way. Citizenship and Cultural Policy 2001, 1-17. Merydyth DMinson J. eds, London, Sage.
41. Rose R. Lesson-drawing in Public Policy 1993, Chatham, NJ, Chatham House
42. Scott S. Tackling anti-social behaviour: an evaluation of the Dundee Families Project. Housing and Anti-social Behaviour: Theory, Policy and Practice 2006, 199-217. Flint J. ed., Bristol, Policy Press.
43. Housing and Anti-social Behaviour: The Way Ahead. 2000, http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2000/01/HousingAnti-Social/Q/Page/1, Scottish Executive, Available at:
44. Putting our Communities First 2003, Scottish Executive, Edinburgh, Scottish Executive
45. Antsocial Behaviour (Scotland) Act 2004 2004a, Scottish Executive, Edinburgh, Scottish Executive
46. Guidance on Antisocial Behaviour Strategies 2004b, Scottish Executive, Edinburgh, Scottish Executive
47. Standing up to Antisocial Behaviour. 2005, Scottish Executive, Statement by Jack McConnell, First Minister, Scottish Executive Press Release (21 February
48. Ministers pledge £2 million for troubled families. 2006, Scottish Executive, Statement by Cathy Jamieson, Justice Minister, Scottish Executive Press Release (12 April
49. Review of Antisocial Behaviour Strategy 2009a, Scottish Government, Edinburgh, Scottish Government
50. Promoting Positive Outcomes: Working Together to Prevent Antisocial Behaviour in Scotland 2009b, Scottish Government, Edinburgh, Scottish Government
51. Bringing Britain Together: A National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal 1999, Social Exclusion Unit, Cm 4045, London, Stationery Office
52. Squires P. The politics of anti-social behaviour. British Politics 2008, 3:300-23.
53. Squires P, Stephen D. Rethinking ASBOs. Critical Social Policy 2005, 25(4):517-28.
54. Stenson K, Edwards A. Policy transfer in local crime control: beyond naïve emulation. Criminal Justice and Political Cultures 2004, 209-33. Newburn T, Sparks R. eds, Cullompton, Willan Publishing.
55. Travis A. Straw calls for more anti-lout orders: Guardian. 2000, 26 June
56. Walker A, Kershaw C, Nicholas S. Crime in England and Wales 2005/06 2006, http://www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/hosb1206.pdf, London, Stationery Office, Available at:
57. Walters R, Woodward R. Punishing poor parents: respect, responsibility and parenting orders in Scotland. Youth Justice 2007, 7(5):5-17.
58. Wells P. New Labour and evidence-based policy making. People, Place and Policy Online 2007, 1(1):22-9.
59. White C, Warrener M, Reeves A, LaValle I. Family Intervention Projects: An Evaluation of Their Design, Set-up and Early Outcomes 2008, http://www.dcsf.gov.uk/research/data/uploadfiles/ACF44F.pdf, London, Department for Children, Schools and Families, Available at:
60. Wilson D, Sharp C, Patterson A. Young People and Crime: Findings from the 2005 Offending, Crime and Justice Survey 2006, London, Home Office