Will Model-based Definition replace engineering drawings throughout the product lifecycle? A global perspective from aerospace industry

Computers in Industry

Volumn 61, Issue 5, 2010, Pages 497-508

  Quintana, Virgilio ^a   Rivest, Louis ^a   Pellerin, Robert ^b   Venne, Frédérick ^a   Kheddouci, Fawzi ^a  

^a ÉCOLE DE TECHNOLOGIE SUPÉRIEURE   (Canada)

^b ÉCOLE POLYTECHNIQUE DE MONTRÉAL   (Canada)

Author keywords

CAD; Engineering drawing; MBD; Model based Definition; Product lifecycle

Indexed keywords

3D MODELS; AEROSPACE COMPANY; CONFIGURATION MANAGEMENT; ENGINEERING DRAWING; GEOMETRIC INFORMATION; GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE; INSPECTION PROCESS; MODEL-BASED; PRODUCT QUALITY; PRODUCT-LIFE-CYCLE; TIME-TO-MARKET;

AEROSPACE INDUSTRY; BELT DRIVES; ENGINEERING; KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING; KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT; THREE DIMENSIONAL;

COMPUTER AIDED DESIGN;

EID: 77953286923     PISSN: 01663615     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.compind.2010.01.005     Document Type: Article

References (53)

1. T.E. French, C.L. Svensen, Mechanical Drawing, 7th ed. rev. and enl, 1968, p. 1.
2. French T.E., Svenson C.L., Helsel J.D., and Urbanick B. Mechanical Drawing: CAD-Communications. 11th ed. (1990), McGraw-Hill, New York, NY pp. 26
3. Bourguignon D., Cani M.P., and Drettakis G. Drawing for illustration and annotation in 3D. Computer Graphics Forum 20 3 (2001) 114-122
4. French T.E., and Vierck C.J. The Fundamentals of Engineering Drawing and Graphic Technology. 3rd ed. (1972), McGraw-Hill, New York, NY pp. 15
5. Chen K.-Z., Feng X.-A., and Ding L. Intelligent approaches for generating assembly drawings from 3-D computer models of mechanical products. Computer Aided Design 34 5 (2002) 347-355
6. Lin Y.J., and Colello M. Exploring the transitional impacts of a 2D to 3D design environment for the development of torque converters. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 23 5-6 (2004) 389-398
7. Staubu C. A paperless approach to managing major projects. Power Engineering 111 5 (2007) 42-46
8. Hudspeth M. Transitioning from 2D to 3D: the benefits of switching to 3D far outweigh what 2D offers. Cadalyst 23 9 (2006) 39-41
9. Lamit L. Moving from 2D to 3D CAD for Engineering Design: Challenges and Opportunities (2007), BookSurge Publishing pp. 5
10. McMahon C., and Browne J. CADCAM: Principles, Practice and Manufacturing Management. 2nd ed. (1998), Addison-Wesley, Harlow, England pp. 175
11. ASME, American Society of Mechanical Engineers. Digital Product Definition Data Practices vol. ASME Y14.41-2003 (2003), American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York pp. viii, 91
12. Haight B. New ASME standard for CAD. Automotive Industries AI 183 10 (2003)
13. Dassault-Systèmes, Toyota Motorsport Uses Automotive Industry PLM Solution from Dassault Systèmes for 2004 F1 Season, http://www.3ds.com/news-events/press-room/release/203/1/, 2004 (visited on September 3rd, 2009).
14. Sharma K.J., and Bowonder B. The making of Boeing 777: a case study in concurrent engineering. International Journal of Manufacturing Technology and Management 6 3-4 (2004) 254-264
15. K. Versprille, Model-based Definition for the Masses, Collaborative Product Development Associates, 2008, http://store.connectpress.com/product42.html.
16. Conover J.S., and Zeid I. Development of a prototype for transfer of drawing annotations into the ASME Y14.41 standard. International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, IMECE2006-Computers and Information in Engineering (2006), American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Chicago, IL, United States pp. 8
17. Boeing, Quality Assurance Standard for Digital Product Definition at Boeing Suppliers, 2007, http://www.boeing.com/companyoffices/doingbiz/supplier/D6-51991.pdf (visited on September 3rd, 2009).
18. Siemens, NX Overview, 2007, http://www.plm.automation.siemens.com (visited on September 3rd, 2009).
19. N. Crawford, Increase Solid Model Value with 3D GD&T, 2006, http://bennett-eng.com/Pages/About%20GD%26T.html (visited on September 3rd, 2009).
20. Korneffel D. Dimensions, tolerances, and more right on the model [digital 3D model documentation]. Machine Design International 76 17 (2004) 70-72
21. SASIG, Strategic Automotive Product Data Standards Industry Group, 3D Annotated Model Standard, vol. JAMAEIC042, Japan, 2008, p. 53, http://www.aiag.org/.
22. Subrahmanian E., Rachuri S., Fenves S.J., Foufou S., and Sriram R.D. Product lifecycle management support: a challenge in supporting product design and manufacturing in a networked economy. International Journal of Product Lifecycle Management 1 1 (2005) 4-25
23. Price A.M. Virtual Product Development Case Study of the T-45 Horizontal Stabilator vol. 4 (1998), AIAA, Reston, VA, USA/Long Beach, CA, USA pp. 3041-3051
24. Vezzetti E. Product lifecycle data sharing and visualisation: Web-based approaches. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 41 5-6 (2009) 613-630
25. J. MacKrell, E. Miller, Product Visualization Across the Extended Enterprise, 2005, http://www.cimmetry.com/documents/CIMdata_Feb2005.pdf (visited on August 3rd, 2008).
26. Carvajal A. Quantitative comparison between the use of 3D vs 2D visualization tools to present building design proposals to non-spatial skilled end users. Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference on Information Visualisation (2005), Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Inc, London, United Kingdom 291-296
27. Emerald Group Publishing Limited. Messier-Dowty's move to model based definition. Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology Journal 78 6 (2006)
28. S. Knoche, Embrace Model Based Definition, Quality Magazine, 2006, http://www.qualitymag.com/Articles/Supplement/08b4a4342ac8c010VgnVCM100000f932a8c0____ (visited on September 3rd, 2009).
29. Schoonmaker S.J. The CAD Guidebook: A Basic Manual for Understanding and Improving Computer-aided Design (2003), Marcel Dekker, New York
30. ASME, American Society of Mechanical Engineers. Decimal Inch Drawing Sheet Size and Format vol. ASMEY14.1-2005 (2005), American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York pp. vii, 14
31. F. Venne, Capture des annotations au sein de la maquette numérique en developpement des produits aéronautiques, Master's Thesis, École de technologie supérieure, 2009, pp. 137.
32. Cabel J. Transposer les tolérances et annotations du 2D vers le 3D. École de technologie supérieure (2008), Montréal, Canada pp. 39
33. R. Pedauque, Document: Form, Sign and Medium, as Reformulated for Electronic Documents, 2003, http://archivesic.ccsd.cnrs.fr/docs/00/06/22/28/PDF/sic_00000594.pdf (visited on September 3rd, 2009).
34. FAA, Federal Aviation Administration. Type Certification, Order 8110.4C (2007), Federal Aviation Administration pp. 257
35. FAA, Federal Aviation Administration. Use of Electronic Technology and Storage of Data, Order 8000.79 (2002), Federal Aviation Administration pp. 2
36. ISO Organisation Internationale de Normalisation. Technical Product Documentation-Vocabulary, Terms Relating to Technical Drawings: General and Types of Drawings vol. ISO10209-1 (1992), Organisation Internationale de Normalisation, Genève, Suisse pp. 7
37. G. Adamczewski, Concept de Document, 2006, http://urfist.enc.sorbonne.fr/sciences/stage2/2007_Urfist_Stag2_Seance1_diapos.pdf_%5BFj9Gha%5D.pdf (visited on August 3rd, 2008).
38. Giesecke F.E., and Paige D. Technical Drawing. 12th ed. (2003), Prentice Hall/Pearson Education, Upper Saddle River, NJ pp. 3
39. Ding L., Davies D., and McMahon C.A. The integration of lightweight representation and annotation for collaborative design representation. Research in Engineering Design 19 4 (2009) 223-238
40. Manjula P., Ball A., and Ding L. Strategies for the curation of CAD engineering models. The International Journal of Digital Curation 4 1 (2009) 84-97
41. LOTAR, LOng Term Archiving and Retrieval of digital technical product documentation such as 3D, CAD and PDM data (LOTAR), ASD-STAN and ProSTEP iViP Association, 2002.
42. ISO, Organisation Internationale de Normalisation. Systèmes de transfert des informations et données spatiales. Système ouvert d'archivage d'information: modèle de référence vol. ISO14721 (2003), Organisation Internationale de Normalisation, Genève, Suisse pp. 140
43. ISO, International Organization for Standardization Industrial Automation Systems and Integration-Product Data Representation and Exchange, vol. ISO 10303:1994, International Organization for Standardization, Genève, Suisse, 1994.
44. PDES, Product Data Exchange using STEP, Long Term Data Retention (LTDR) Pilot, 2005, http://pdesinc.aticorp.org/long_term_data_retention_pilot.html (visited on September 3rd, 2009).
45. SAE, Society of Automotive Engineers. A Process Standard for the Storage, Retrieval and Use of Three-dimensional Type Design Data: ARP 9034 (2003), Society of Automotive Engineers, Warrendale, Penns pp. 33
46. VDA, Verband der Automobilindustrie, Long-Term Archiving (LTA) of digital product data, which are not based on technical drawings, Recommendation 4958, Verband der Automobilindustrie, 2005.
47. J. Wirtz, J. Haenisch, K. Bengtsson, A. Pettersen, G. Wahl, MIMER a joint project between EADS, EPM and Norwegian Ministry of Defence, 2006, http://conferences.esa.int/pde2006/presentations/pde2006_pettersen_mimer.ppt (visited on September 3rd, 2009).
48. Ball A., Patel M., McMahon C., Green S., Clarkson J., and Culley S. A grand challenge: immortal information and through-life knowledge management (KIM). International Journal of Digital Curation 1 1 (2008)
49. C.R. Arms, C. Fleischhauer, Digital Formats for Library of Congress Collections-Factors To Consider When Choosing Digital Formats, 2003, p. 20, http://www.media-matters.net/docs/resources/Videotape%20Reformatting/DigForm_Intro_v04%5B1%5D.pdf (visited on September 3rd, 2009).
50. Ball A., Ding L., and Patel M. Lightweight formats for product model data exchange and preservation. Proceedings of PV2007: Ensuring the Long-Term Preservation and Value Adding to Scientific and Technical Data. Oberpfaffenhofen/Munich, Germany (2007) 1
51. Bouikni N., Rivest L., and Desrochers A. A multiple views management system for concurrent engineering and PLM. Concurrent Engineering Research and Applications 16 1 (2008) 61-72
52. Chu C.-H., Cheng C.-Y., and Wu C.-W. Applications of the Web-based collaborative visualization in distributed product development. Computers in Industry 57 3 (2006) 272-282
53. Huang G.Q. Web-based support for collaborative product design review. Computers in Industry 48 1 (2002) 71-88