Labours in Vice or Virtue? Neo-liberalism, Sexual Commerce, and the Case of Indian Bar Dancing

Journal of Law and Society

Volumn 37, Issue 1, 2010, Pages 105-124

  Kotiswaran, Prabha ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 77953219978     PISSN: 0263323X     EISSN: 14676478     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-6478.2010.00497.x     Document Type: Note

References (102)

1. L. Singer, Erotic Welfare: Sexual Theory and Politics in the Age of Epidemic, eds. J. Butler and M. MacGrogan (1993).
2. B.G. Brents and K. Hausbeck, 'Marketing Sex: US Legal Brothels and Late Capitalist Consumption' (2007) 10 Sexualities 425-39, at 426; Brents and Sanders in this volume, pp. 40-60.
3. E. Bernstein, Temporarily Yours: Intimacy, Authenticity, and the Commerce of Sex (2007).
4. Brents and Hausbeck, op. cit., n. 2, pp. 433, 435.
5. Bernstein, op. cit., n. 3.
6. L. Agustín, 'Introduction to the Cultural Study of Commercial Sex' (2007) 10 Sexualities 403-7.
7. R. Hennessy, Profit and Pleasure: Sexual Identities in Late Capitalism (2000).
8. SNDT Women's University, Research Centre for Women's Studies and Forum Against Oppression of Women, Backgrounds and working conditions of women working as dancers in dance bars (2005) 31.
9. S. Mehta, Maximum City: Bombay Lost and Found (2004) 253.
10. id., p. 254.
11. id., p. 281.
12. F. Hariyanawala, '"I've seen politicians at dance bars"' Mid-Day, 17 April 2005, quoting Suketu Mehta.
13. Chandni Bar, directed by Madhur Bhandarkar, 28 September 2001.
14. SNDT, op. cit., n. 8, p. 26.
15. S. Ali, 'Mid Day's secret probe into dance bars' Mid-Day, 11 April 2005.
16. D. Bunsha, 'In step with the law' (2006) 23 Frontline available at .
17. SNDT, op. cit., n. 8, p. 26.
18. id., p. 31.
19. V. Kale, 'Securing and Safeguarding Rights of Stigmatised Through Social and Legal Action', paper presented at Workshop on Law and Social Movements, 26-27 June 2006, Bangalore, India.
20. 'Shall we dance?' Mid-Day, 10 May 2005.
21. Mehta, op. cit., n. 9, p. 271.
22. id., pp. 279-80.
23. SNDT, op. cit., n. 8, p. 6.
24. S. Devasia, 'Bar workers, music sales will also be hit' Mid-Day, 6 April 2005.
25. A. Birai and A. Holia, 'Mr. Patil, this is why we need dance bars' Mid-Day, 14 April 2005.
26. SNDT, op. cit., n. 8, p. 6.
27. id., p. 9.
28. F. Agnes, 'State Control and Sexual Morality - The Case of the Bar Dancers of Mumbai' in Enculturing Law: New Agendas for Legal Pedagogy, eds. M. John and S. Kakarala (2007) 161.
29. SNDT, op. cit., n. 8, p. 12.
30. C.S. Bhattacharya, 'Dressed up with no place to dance - Curtain drops on Mumbai bars but girls still lie in hope' Telegraph, 15 August 2005.
31. 'Show must go on, so saris drape skirts in Mumbai bars' Sunday Express, 21 July 2002; 'Bombay's barmaids stage protest' BBC News World Edition, 20 August 2004.
32. Mehta, op. cit., n. 9, p. 248.
33. Section 294 punishes anyone who performs any obscene act in any public place, or sings, recites or utters any obscene song, ballad or words, in or near any public place, with imprisonment for up to three months, or a fine, or both.
34. K.P. Babu, 'Cops protection for bars' Mid-Day, 9 April 2005; Agnes, op. cit., n. 29, p. 162; 'Dance bars, police raids and obscenity laws' Asian Age, 17 May 2005.
35. Agnes, id.
36. F. Agnes, 'Bar dancers and the issue of livelihood' Asian Age, 14 June 2005; 'Bar girls protest police harassment', Deccan Herald, 21 August 2004.
37. State of Maharashtra v. Joyce Zee alias Temiko (1973) ILR 1299 (Bom).; unreported judgment delivered by Justice Rege on 3 September 1984 in Criminal Application No. 782 of 1984; Sadhna v. State 1980 Cri L.T. 380 (Del); Narendra H. Khurana v. Commissioner of Police MANU/MH/0911/2003.
38. Y. Naik, 'Mumbai dance bar ban this week: R R Patil' Mid-Day, 13 April 2005.
39. Agnes, op. cit., n. 29, p. 162.
40. id., p. 163.
41. 'Bar raised for bar dancers' Kolkata Times of India, 29 July 2004, 10; A. Soondas, 'No cash & carry in Mumbai bars'' Telegraph, 29 July 2004, 1 and 6.
42. Devasia, op. cit., n. 25.
43. 'Maharashtra dance bars face the music' Indian Express, 31 March 2005.
44. '69% say YES to dance bars' Mid-Day, 16 April 2005.
45. D. Lokhande, 'Bar girls may get uniforms' Mid-Day, 22 May 2005.
46. SNDT Women's University, Research Centre for Women's Studies and Forum Against Oppression of Women, After the Ban: Women Working in Dance Bars (2006) 10.
47. id., p. 11.
48. id., p. 14.
49. id., p. 20.
50. id., p. 13.
51. D. Kennedy, Sexy Dressing Etc.: Essays on the Power and Politics of Cultural Identity (1993) 137.
52. SNDT, op. cit., n. 48, pp. 23-4.
53. On file with author, also available at (2006) 3 Bombay Cases Reporter 705.
54. Kale, op. cit., n. 20, p. 5.
55. Agnes, op. cit., n. 29, p. 170.
56. S. Rege, 'The hegemonic appropriation of sexuality: The case of the lavani performers of Maharashtra' in Social Reform, Sexuality and the State, ed. P. Uberoi (1996).
57. Mehta, op. cit., n. 9, p. 255.
58. id., p. 270.
59. id., p. 256.
60. P. Kotiswaran, Dangerous Sex, Invisible Labor and Other Stories of the Lumpen Proletariat: Rethinking the Regulation of Sex Work (2011, forthcoming).
61. Mehta, op. cit., n. 9, p. 317.
62. A. Thakraney, 'Spoilsport or Mr. Clean?' Mid-Day, 17 April 2005.
63. Lokhande, op. cit., n. 47.
64. Agnes, op. cit., n. 29, p. 164.
65. SNDT, op. cit., n. 8, p. 1.
66. F. Agnes, 'Fundamental freedom and bar dancers' Asian Age, 4 October 2005.
67. SNDT, op. cit., n. 8, p. 30.
68. 'Out of Tune', interview with Varsha Kale, president of the Bharatiya Bar Girls' Union conducted by J. Punwani, Times of India, Bangalore, 29 April 2005.
69. N.A. Bhuse, 'State may see huge boom in sex bars' Mid-Day, 13 June 2005.
70. 'Bar girls: Women a target again?' Cybernoon, official website of Afternoon Despatch & Courier, 7 June 2007.
71. SNDT, op. cit., n. 8, p. 35.
72. Mid-Day, op. cit., n. 46.
73. A. Mande, 'Men come here for recreation, not sex' Mid-Day, 14 April 2005.
74. Punwani, op. cit., n. 70.
75. Agnes, op. cit., n. 29, p. 164.
76. R. Oza, 'Showcasing India: Gender, Geography, and Globalization' (2001) 26 Signs 1067-95.
77. SNDT, op. cit., n. 8, p. 36.
78. Agnes, op. cit., n. 29, p. 174.
79. SNDT, op. cit., n. 8, p. 5.
80. F. Agnes, 'Mumbai's bar girls and the question of morality' Asian Age, 14 April 2007.
81. N. Rajan, 'Dance Bar Girls and the Feminist's Dilemma' Economic & Political Weekly, 10 February 2007, 471-4, at 472.
82. See, for example, S. Jeffreys, The Industrial Vagina: The Political Economy of the Global Sex Trade (2009).
83. S.K. Bhowmik, 'Making of a City' (reviewing A. Farooqui, Opium City: Making of Early Victorian Bombay) Economic & Political Weekly, 12 August 2006, 3506-7, at 3506.
84. K. Barry, The Prostitution of Sexuality: The Global Exploitation of Women (1995).
85. Kotiswaran, op. cit., n. 62.
86. S. Banerjee-Guha, 'Neoliberalising the "Urban": New Geographies of Power and Injustice in Indian Cities' Economic & Political Weekly, 30 May 2009, 95-107.
87. N. Gooptu, 'Neoliberal Subjectivity, Enterprise Culture and New Workplaces: Organised Retail and Shopping Malls in India' Economic & Political Weekly, 30 May 2009, 45-54.
88. K. Sanyal, Rethinking Capitalist Development: Primitive Accumulation, Governmentality and Post-Colonial Capitalism (2007).
89. J. Nair, 'From Devadasi Reform to SITA: Reforming Sex Work in Mysore State, 1892-1937' (1993) 1 National Law School J. 82-94; Rege, op. cit., n. 58.
90. L. Brown, 'Performance, Status and Hybridity in a Pakistani Red-Light District: The Cultural Production of the Courtesan' (2007) 10 Sexualities 409-23.
91. The Selling of Innocents, produced by S. Jacobovici, E. Halpern, and W. Cobban, directed by R. Gupta, 25 November 1996; 'Slavery in Our Time' New York Times, 22 January 2006, s. 4; Born into Brothels, produced and directed by Z. Briski and R. Kauffman, 8 December 2004.
92. J. Sengupta and J. Sinha, 'Battling AIDS in India' (2004) 3 McKinsey Q., available at .
93. National AIDS Control Organisation, 'Targeted Interventions for Core High Risk Groups Under NACP IIP (2007), available at: .
94. S. Shah, 'Producing the Spectacle of Kamathipura: The Politics of Red Light Visibility in Mumbai' (2006) 18 Cultural Dynamics 269-92; Kotiswaran, op. cit., n. 62.
95. Ali, op. cit., n. 15.
96. J. Halley, P. Kotiswaran, H. Shamir, and C. Thomas, 'From the International to the Local in Feminist Legal Responses to Rape, Prostitution/Sex Work, and Sex Trafficking: Four Studies in Contemporary Governance Feminism' (2006) 29 Harvard J. of Law & Gender 335-423.
97. A traditional Indian name based on the mythical story of a loyal Hindu wife.
98. Agnes, op. cit., n. 29, p. 166.
99. P. Chatterjee, The Politics of the Governed: Reflections on Popular Politics in Most of the World (2004).
100. SNDT, op. cit., n. 8, pp. 7-8.
101. P. Kotiswaran, 'Introduction' in Sex Work, ed. P. Kotiswaran (2010, forthcoming).
102. N. Gooptu, 'Economic Liberalisation, Work and Democracy' Economic & Political Weekly, 26 May 2007, 1922-33, at 1932.