The vertical integration of Lisbon and sustainable development strategies across the EU: How different governance architectures shape the European coherence of policy documents

Natural Resources Forum

Volumn 34, Issue 1, 2010, Pages 71-84

  Steurer, Reinhard ^a   Berger, Gerald ^b   Hametner, Markus ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND LIFE SCIENCES   (Austria)

^b UNIVERSITY OF VIENNA   (Austria)

Author keywords

EU sustainable development strategy; European coherence; Lisbon Strategy; National reform programmes; National sustainable development strategy; Structural indicators; Sustainable development indicators; Vertical integration

Indexed keywords

ECONOMIC POLICY; ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY; EUROPEAN UNION; GLOBAL ECONOMY; GOVERNANCE APPROACH; NATIONAL STRATEGY; OECD; POLICY MAKING; SOCIAL POLICY; SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT; UNITED NATIONS; VERTICAL INTEGRATION;

LISBOA [PORTUGAL]; LISBON; PORTUGAL;

EID: 77952902126     PISSN: 01650203     EISSN: 14778947     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1477-8947.2010.01272.x     Document Type: Article

References (56)

1. Berger G, Steurer R. The EU SDS process in the Member States: SDS coordinators, national progress reports and the open method of coordination. 2007, http://www.sd-network.eu/?k=quarterly%20reports&report_id=4, ESDN Quarterly Report March 2007, Vienna, ESDN, Available at:
2. Berger G, Zwirner W. The interfaces between the EU SDS and the Lisbon strategy: objectives, governance provisions, coordination and future developments. 2008, http://www.sd-network.eu/?k=quarterly%20reports, ESDN Quarterly Report December 2008, Vienna, ESDN, Available at:
3. Borrás S, Jacobsson K. The open method of co-ordination and new governance patterns in the EU. Journal of European Public Policy 2004, 11(2):185-208.
4. Borrás S, Radaelli C. The politics of governance architectures: Institutions, power, and public policy in the EU Lisbon Strategy. 2009, Paper presented at the workshop The Politics of Governance Architectures: Institutions, Power and Public Policy in the EU Lisbon Strategy, ECPR Joint Sessions, 14-19 April 2009, Lisbon/Portugal
5. Büchs M. How legitimate is the open method of co-ordination. Journal of Common Market Studies 2008, 46(4):765-786.
6. Domorenok E. The EU Lisbon agenda and cohesion policy: challenges for territorial governance. 2009, Paper presented at the workshop The Politics of Governance Architectures: Institutions, Power and Public Policy in the EU Lisbon Strategy, ECPR Joint Sessions, 14-19 April 2009, Lisbon/Portugal
7. National sustainable development strategies in the European Union: a first analysis by the European Commission. 2004, http://europe.eu.int/comm/sustainable/docs/sustainable_development_strategies.pdf, European Commission, Available at:
8. Common actions for growth and employment: The community Lisbon programme, (No. COM(2005) 330 final). 2005a, European Commission, Brussels, EC
9. Delivering on growth and jobs: a new integrated economic and employment co-ordination cycle in the EU, (SEC(2005) 193). 2005b, http://ec.europa.eu/growthandjobs/pdf/SEC2005_193_en.pdf, European Commission, Brussels, EC, Available at:
10. Growth and jobs: working together for Europe's future. A new start for the Lisbon strategy (No. COM(2005) 24). 2005c, European Commission, Brussels, EC
11. Integrated guidelines for growth and jobs (2005-08). 2005d, European Commission, Communication to the Spring European Council. Working together for growth and jobs, Luxembourg, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities
12. A year of delivery. 2006, European Commission, Communication from the Commission to the Spring European Council. Implementing the renewed Lisbon strategy for growth and jobs (No. COM(2006) 816 final), Brussels, EC
13. Progress report on the sustainable development strategy 2007 (No. COM(2007) 642 final). 2007a, European Commission, Brussels, Commission of the European Communities
14. Strategic report on the renewed Lisbon strategy for growth and jobs: Launching the new cycle (2008-2010), COM (2007) 803 final. 2007b, http://ec.europa.eu/growthandjobs/pdf/european-dimension-200712-annual-progress-report/200712-annual-report_en.pdf, European Commission, Brussels, EC, Available at:
15. A European economic recovery plan. 2008, http://ec.europa.eu/growthandjobs/pdf/european-dimension-200812-annual-progress-report/200812-annual-report_en.pdf, European Commission, Communication from the Commission to the European Council, COM(2008) 800 final, Brussels, EC, Available at:
16. Mainstreaming sustainable development into EU policies: 2009 review of the European Union strategy for sustainable development, COM(2009) 400 final. 2009, http://ec.europa.eu/sustainable/docs/com_2009_400_en.pdf, European Commission, Brussels, EC, Available at:
17. Presidency conclusions - Lisbon European Council, 23-24 March 2000 (No. 100/1/00). 2000, European Council
18. Presidency conclusions - Gothenburg European Council 15-16 June 2001. 2001, European Council
19. Presidency conclusions - Brussels European Council, 22-23 March 2005 (No. 7619/1/05). 2005, European Council
20. Presidency conclusions - Brussels European Council, 23-24 March 2006 (No. 7775/1/06). 2006a, European Council
21. Review of the EU sustainable development strategy (EU SDS) - Renewed Strategy (No. 10917/06). 2006b, European Council
22. Presidency conclusions - Brussels European Council, 14 December 2007 (No. 16616/1/07, REV 1). 2008a, European Council
23. Presidency conclusions - Brussels European Council, 13-14 March 2008. 2008b, European Council
24. National reform programmes: bringing sSustainable development into the Lisbon process 2005, European Environmental Bureau, Brussels, EEB
25. Measuring progress towards a more sustainable Europe: 2007 monitoring report of the EU sustainable development strategy. 2007, http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/cache/ITY_OFFPUB/KS-77-07-115/EN/KS-77-07-115-EN.PDF, Eurostat, Brussels, Eurostat, Available at:
26. Heidenreich M, Bischoff G. The open method of co-ordination: a way to the Europeanization of social and employment policies? Journal of Common Market Studies 2008, 46(3):497-532.
27. Sustainable development strategies: a resource book. 2002, http://www.nssd.net/working/resource/, IIED, Compiled by Barry Dalal-Clayton and Stephen Bass for OECD and UNDP. Available at:
28. National strategies for sustainable development: new thinking and time for action 2002, http://www.nssd.net/index1.html, IIED, UNDP, UKDFID, New York: United Nations, Available at:
29. Kaiser R, Prange H. Missing the Lisbon target? Multi-level innovation and EU policy coordination. Journal of Public Policy 2005, 25(2):241-263.
30. Kok W. Facing the challenge: The Lisbon strategy for growth and employment. 2004, Report from the High Level Group chaired by Wim Kok. Brussels: European Communities
31. Liberatore A. The integration of sustainable development objectives into EU policymaking: Barriers and prospects. The politics of sustainable development: theory, policy and practice within the European Union 1997, 108-126. Baker SKousis MRichardson DYoung S. In, (Eds.), London, Routledge, pp.
32. Marks G, Hooghe L. Multi-level governance and European integration 2001, Lanham/MD, Rowman & Littlefield
33. Meadowcroft J. Nationale Pläne und Strategien zur nachhaltigen Entwicklung in Industrienationen. Umweltplanung im internationalen Vergleich: Strategien der Nachhaltigkeit 2000, 113-130. Jänicke MJörgens H. in, eds., Berlin, Springer, pp.
34. Strategies for sustainable development: practical guidance for development cooperation. 2001, http://www.nssd.net/pdf/gsuse.pdf, OECD-DAC, Paris, OECD, Available at:
35. Pierson C. Beyond the welfare state? The new political economy of welfare 1998, University Park, Penn State University Press
36. Pirgmaier E. Lisbon and sustainable development strategies in the EU: how does mutual recognition take place in practice. 2008, Findings from country studies on Austria, Sweden and the UK. Diploma Thesis, mimeo, Vienna
37. Radulova E. On the emergence of light and heavy soft governance in the EU - The open method(s) of coordination. Dynamics and obstacles of EU governance 2006, De Bievre DNeuhold H. in, eds., Edward Elgar, Cheltenham
38. Radulova E. The construction of the EU's childcare policy through the open method of coordination: What we have learnt: Advances, pitfalls and remaining questions in OMC research. 2009, http://eiop.or.at/eiop/texte/2009-013a.htm, Kröger S. in, ed., European Integration online Papers (EIoP), Special Issue 1, 13, Art. 13. Available at:
39. Rametsteiner E, Pülzl H, Bauer A, Nussbaumer E, Weiss G, Hametner M, Tiroch M, Martinuzzi A. Analysis of national sets of indicators used in the national reform programmes and sustainable development strategies. 2007, Luxembourg, Eurostat & Office for Official Publications of the European Communities
40. Sánchez RS. The Europeanization effects of the Lisbon Strategy: The contribution of EU funding programmes. 2009, Paper presented at the workshop The Politics of Governance Architectures: Institutions, Power and Public Policy in the EU Lisbon Strategy, ECPR Joint Sessions, 14-19 April 2009, Lisbon/Portugal
41. Sapir A, Aghion P, Bertola G, Hellwig M, Pisani-Ferry J, Rosati D, Viñals J, Wallace H. An agenda for a growing Europe. The Sapir report 2004, Oxford, Oxford University Press
42. Steurer R, Berger G. Disentangling the double-track pursuit of sustainable development in the European Union: How Lisbon and sustainable development strategies run past each other. (personal communications)
43. Steurer R, Hametner M. How coherent are sustainable development strategies across Europe. Exploring the vertical integration of policy objectives and indicators (personal communications)
44. Steurer R, Hametner M, Berger G, Rametsteiner E. The governance of the Lisbon process: national reform programmes, structural indicators and sustainable development strategies. 2008, http://www.sd-network.eu/?k=quarterly%20reports&report_id=8, ESDN Quarterly Report March 2008, Vienna, ESDN, Available at:
45. Steurer R, Martinuzzi A. Towards new patterns of strategy formation in the public sector: first experiences with national strategies for sustainable development in Europe. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 2005, 23:455-472.
46. Steurer R, Martinuzzi A. Sustainable development strategies in Europe: taking stock 20 years after the Brundtland Report. European Environment (now Environmental Policy and Governance) Special Issue 2007, 17(3):147-214. eds.
47. Steurer R. From government strategies to strategic public management: an exploratory outlook on the pursuit of cross-sectoral policy integration. European Environment 2007, 17(3):201-214.
48. Steurer R. Strategies for sustainable development. Innovation in environmental policy? Integrating the environment for sustainability 2008, 93-113. Jordan ALenschow A. in, eds., London, Edward Elgar, pp.
49. Tharakan P K M. European social model under pressure. The World Economy 2003, 26(10):1417-1424.
50. Trubek D M, Mosher J S. Alternative approaches to governance in the EU: EU social policy and the European employment strategy. Journal of Common Market Studies 2003, 41(1):63-88.
51. Trubek D M, Trubek L D. Hard and soft law in the construction of social Europe: the role of the open method of co-ordination. European Law Journal 2005, 11(3):343-364.
52. Agenda 21 1992, UNCED, New York, United Nations
53. Guidance in preparing national sustainable development strategies: what are national sustainable development strategies. 2001, http://www.johannesburgsummit.org/web_pages/nsds_guidance_final_ghana.pdf, UNDESA, New York, UNDESA, Available at:
54. Programme for the further implementation of Agenda 21 1997, http://www.un.org/documents/ga/res/spec/aress19-2.htm, UNGASS, New York, UNGASS, Available at:
55. Our common future 1987, WCED, Oxford, Oxford University Press
56. Williams PM. Community strategies: mainstreaming sustainable development and strategic planning. Sustainable Development 2002, 10:197-205. In