Meta-analysis of average and variability of time to extubation comparing isoflurane with desflurane or isoflurane with sevoflurane

Anesthesia and Analgesia

Volumn 110, Issue 5, 2010, Pages 1433-1439

  Agoliati, Andrew ^a   Dexter, Franklin ^b,c   Lok, Jason ^a   Masursky, Danielle ^a   Sarwar, Muhammad F ^a   Stuart, Sarah B ^a   Bayman, Emine O ^b,c   Epstein, Richard H ^d  

^a State University of New York Upstate Medical University: College of Medicine   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF IOWA   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF IOWA   (United States)

^d THOMAS JEFFERSON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

DESFLURANE; INHALATION ANESTHETIC AGENT; ISOFLURANE; SEVOFLURANE;

ANESTHESIA; ARTICLE; CLINICAL TRIAL; DRUG COST; EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE; EXTUBATION; HUMAN; INFORMATION SYSTEM; MEDLINE; META ANALYSIS; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW;

EID: 77951757993     PISSN: 00032999     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1213/ANE.0b013e3181d58052     Document Type: Article

References (77)

1. Dexter F, Bayman EO, Epstein RH. Statistical modeling of average and variability of time to extubation for meta-analysis comparing desflurane to sevoflurane. Anesth Analg 2010;110:570-580
2. Epstein RH, Dexter F, Ehrenfeld JM, Sandberg WS. Implications of event entry latency on anesthesia information management system decision support systems. Anesth Analg 2009;108:941-947
3. Ghouri AF, Bodner M, White PF. Recovery profile after desflurane-nitrous oxide versus isoflurane-nitrous oxide in outpatients. Anesthesiology 1991;74:419-424
4. Smiley RM, Ornstein E, Matteo RS, Pantuck EJ, Pantuck CB. Desflurane and isoflurane in surgical patients: comparison of emergence time. Anesthesiology 1991;74:425-428
5. Bennett JA, Lingaraju N, Horrow JC, McElrath T, Keykhah MM. Elderly patients recover more rapidly from desflurane than from isoflurane anesthesia. J Clin Anesth 1992;4:378-381
6. Frink EJ Jr, Malan TP, Atlas M, Dominguez LM, DiNardo JA, Brown BR Jr. Clinical comparison of sevoflurane and isoflurane in healthy patients. Anesth Analg 1992;74:241-245
7. Azad SS, Bartkowske RR, Witkowski TA, Marr AT, Lessin JB, Seltzer JL. A comparison of desflurane and isoflurane in prolonged surgery. J Clin Anesth 1993;5:122-128
8. Quinn AC, Newman PJ, Hall GM, Grounds RM. Sevoflurane anaesthesia for major intra-abdominal surgery. Anaesthesia 1994;49:567-571
9. Smith I, Taylor E, White PF. Comparison of tracheal extubation in patients deeply anesthetized with desflurane or isoflurane. Anesth Analg 1994;79:642-645
10. Campbell C, Nahrwold ML, Miller DD. Clinical comparison of sevoflurane and isoflurane when administered with nitrous oxide for surgical procedures of intermediate duration. Can J Anaesth 1995;42:884-890
11. Gambling DR, Sharma SK, White PF, Van Beveren T, Bala AS, Gouldson R. Use of sevoflurane during elective cesarean birth: a comparison with isoflurane and spinal anesthesia. Anesth Analg 1995;81:90-95
12. Loan PB, Mirakhur RK, Paxton LD, Gaston JH. Comparison of desflurane and isoflurane in anaesthesia for dental surgery. Br J Anaesth 1995;75:289-292
13. Campbell C, Andreen M, Battito MF, Camporesi EM, Goldberg ME, Grounds RM, Hobbhahn J, Lumb P, Murray JM, Solanki DR, Heard SO, Coriat P. A phase III, multicenter, open-label, randomized, comparative study evaluating the effect of sevoflurane versus isoflurane on the maintenance of anesthesia in adult ASA class I, II, and III inpatients. J Clin Anesth 1996;8:557-563
14. Gupta A, Kullander M, Ekberg K, Lennmarken C. Anaesthesia for day-care arthroscopy. A comparison between desflurane and isoflurane. Anaesthesia 1996;51:56-62
15. Loscar M, Allhoff T, Ott E, Conzen P, Peter K. Awakening from anesthesia and recovery of cognitive function after desflurane or isoflurane. Anaesthesist 1996;45:140-145
16. O'Hara DA, DeAngelis V, Lee H, Zedie N, Seuffert PA, Amory DW. The effects of sevoflurane and isoflurane on recovery from outpatient surgery. Pharmacotherapy 1996;16:446-452
17. Philip BK, Kallar SK, Bogetz MS, Scheller MS, Wetchler BV. A multicenter comparison of maintenance and recovery with sevoflurane or isoflurane for adult ambulatory anesthesia. The Sevoflurane Multicenter Ambulatory group. Anesth Analg 1996;83:314-319
18. Scholz J, Bischoff P, Szafarczyk W, Heetel S, Schulte J. Comparison of sevoflurane and isoflurane in ambulatory surgery. Results of a multicenter study. Anaesthesist 1996;45(suppl 1):S63-S70
19. Sloan MH, Conard PF, Karsunky PK, Gross JB. Sevoflurane versus isoflurane: induction and recovery characteristics with single-breath inhaled inductions of anesthesia. Anesth Analg 1996;82:528-532
20. Wolf AR, Lawson RA, Dryden CM, Davies FW. Recovery after desflurane anaesthesia in the infant: comparison with isoflurane. Br J Anaesth 1996;76:362-364
21. Cantillo J, Goldberg ME, Larijani GE, Vekeman D. Recovery parameters after sevoflurane and isoflurane anesthesia. Pharmacotherapy 1997;17:779-782
22. Goto T, Saito H, Shinkai M, Nakata Y, Ichinose F, Morita S. Xenon provides faster emergence from anesthesia than does nitrous oxide-sevoflurane or nitrous oxide-isoflurane. Anesthesiology 1997;86:1273-1278
23. Jakobsson J, Rane K, Ryberg G. Anaesthesia during laparoscopic gynaecological surgery: a comparison between desflurane and isoflurane. Eur J Anaesthesiol 1997;14:148-152
24. Juvin P, Servin F, Giraud O, Desmonts JM. Emergence of elderly patients from prolonged desflurane, isoflurane, or propofol anesthesia. Anesth Analg 1997;85:647-651
25. Wagner BK, O'Hara DA. Pharmacoeconomic analysis of sevoflurane versus isoflurane anesthesia in elective ambulatory surgery. Pharmacotherapy 1997;17:1006-1010
26. Alonso Chico A, Rodríguez Fraile JR, Pacheco Jiménez A, Faraco Favieres M, Gutiérrez Rodríguez M, Maroto Ramos E. Comparative study of recovery times and psychomotor function after anesthesia with desflurane or isoflurane. Rev Esp Anestesiol Reanim 1998;45:184-188
27. Ashworth J, Smith I. Comparison of desflurane with isoflurane or propofol in spontaneously breathing ambulatory patients. Anesth Analg 1998;87:312-318
28. Beaussier M, Deriaz H, Abdelahim Z, Aissa F, Lienhart A. Comparative effects of desflurane and isoflurane on recovery after long lasting anaesthesia. Can J Anaesth 1998;45:429-434
29. Boldt J, Jaun N, Kumle B, Heck M, Mund K. Economic considerations of the use of new anesthetics: a comparison of propofol, sevoflurane, desflurane, and isoflurane. Anesth Analg 1998;86:504-509
30. Canet J, Roigé J, Bandrés R, Campos JM, Chiveli MA, Campbell J. Comparison of the effect of desflurane with isoflurane in patients over 65 years of age: multicenter study. Rev Esp Anestesiol Reanim 1998;45:280-284
31. Caputo F, Ventura R. Rapidity of emergence from anesthesia with sevoflurane or isoflurane. Minerva Anestesiol 1998;64: 439-444
32. Chen TL, Yang SF, Chang HC, Tai YT, Li NL, Lin CJ. Comparison of hemodynamics and recovery of sevoflurane and isoflurane anesthesia in Chinese adult patients. Acta Anaesthesiol Sin 1998;36:31-36
33. Fredman B, Zohar E, Philipov A, Olsfanger D, Shalev M, Jedeikin R. The induction, maintenance, and recovery characteristics of spinal versus general anesthesia in elderly patients. J Clin Anesth 1998;10:623-630
34. Horn EP, Sessler DI, Standl T, Schroeder F, Bartz HJ, Schulte am Esch J. Non-thermoregulatory shivering in patients recovering from isoflurane or desflurane anesthesia. Anesthesiology 1998;89:878-886
35. Wilhelm W, Berner K, Grundmann U, Palz M, Larsen R. Desflurane or isoflurane for paediatric ENT anaesthesia. A comparison of intubating conditions and recovery profile. Anaesthesist 1998;47:975-978
36. Behne M, Wilke HJ, Lischke V. Recovery and pharmacokinetic parameters of desflurane, sevoflurane, and isoflurane in patients undergoing urologic procedures. J Clin Anesth 1999;11:460-465
37. Dupont J, Tavernier B, Ghosez Y, Durinck L, Thevenot A, Moktadir-Chalons N, Ruyffelaere-Moises L, Declerck N, Scherpereel P. Recovery after anaesthesia for pulmonary surgery: desflurane, sevoflurane and isoflurane. Br J Anaesth 1999;82: 355-359
38. Chiu CL, Chan YK, Ong GS, Delilkan AE. A comparison of the maintenance and recovery characteristic of sevoflurane-nitrous oxide against isoflurane-nitrous oxide anaesthesia. Singapore Med J 2000;41:530-533
39. Juvin P, Vadam C, Malek L, Dupont H, Marmuse JP, Desmonts JM. Postoperative recovery after desflurane, propofol, or isoflurane anesthesia among morbidly obese patients: a prospective, randomized study. Anesth Analg 2000;91:714-719
40. Karlsen KL, Persson E, Wennberg E, Stenqvist O. Anaesthesia, recovery and postoperative nausea and vomiting after breast surgery. A comparison between desflurane, sevoflurane and isoflurane anaesthesia. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2000;44:489-493
41. Navarro EM. Desflurane-general anesthesia for cesarean section compared with isoflurane and epidural anesthesia. Anasthesiol Intensivmed Notfallmed Schmerzther 2000;35: 232-236
42. Pensado Castiñ eiras A, Rama Maceiras P, Molins Gauna N, Fiqueira Moure A, Vásquez Fidalgo A. Immediate anesthesia recovery and psychomotor function of patient after prolonged anesthesia with desflurane, sevoflurane or isoflurane. Rev Esp Anestesiol Reanim 2000;47:386-392
43. Solca M, Salvo I, Russo R, Fiori R, Veschi G. Anaesthesia with desflurane-nitrous oxide in elderly patients. Comparison with isoflurane-nitrous oxide. Minerva Anestesiol 2000;66:621-626
44. Torri G, Casati A. Cardiovascular homeostasis during inhalational general anesthesia: a clinical comparison between sevoflurane and isoflurane. On behalf of the Italian Research group on sevoflurane. J Clin Anesth 2000;12:117-122
45. Le Berre PY, Wodey E, Joly A, Carré P, Ecoffey C. Comparison of recovery after intermediate duration of anaesthesia with sevoflurane and isoflurane. Paediatr Anaesth 2001;11:443-448
46. Nagasaki G, Tanaka M, Nishikawa T. The recovery profile of baroreflex control of heart rate after isoflurane or sevoflurane anesthesia in humans. Anesth Analg 2001;93:1127-1131
47. Ozkose Z, Ercan B, Unal Y, Yardim S, Kaymaz M, Dogulu F, Pasaoglu A. Inhalation versus total intravenous anesthesia for lumbar disc herniation: comparison of hemodynamic effects, recovery characteristics, and cost. J Neurosurg Anesthesiol 2001;13:296-302
48. Fredman B, Sheffer O, Zohar E, Paruta I, Richter S, Jedeikin R, White PF. Fast-track eligibility of geriatric patients undergoing short urologic surgery procedures. Anesth Analg 2002;94:560-564
49. Gauthier A, Girard F, Boudreault D, Ruel M, Todorov A. Sevoflurane provides faster recovery and postoperative neurological assessment than isoflurane in long-duration neurosurgical cases. Anesth Analg 2002;95:1384-1388
50. Arar C, Kaya G, Karamanliog? lu B, Pamukçu Z, Turan N. Effects of sevoflurane, isoflurane and propofol infusions on post-operative recovery criteria in geriatric patients. J Int Med Res 2005;33:55-60
51. Pietrini D, Ciano F, Forte E, Tosi F, Zanghi F, Velardi F, DI Rocco C, Chiaretti A, Caresta E, Piastra M. Sevofluraneremifentanil vs isoflurane-remifentanil for the surgical correction of craniosynostosis in infants. Paediatr Anaesth 2005;15:653-662
52. Boisson-Bertrand D, Laxenaire MC, Mertes PM. Recovery after prolonged anaesthesia for acoustic neuroma surgery: desflurane versus isoflurane. Anaesth Intensive Care 2006;34:338-342
53. Sekimoto K, Nishikawa K, Ishizeki J, Kubo K, Saito S, Goto F. The effects of volatile anesthetics on intraoperative monitoring of myogenic motor-evoked potentials to transcranial electrical stimulation and on partial neuromuscular blockade during propofol/fentanyl/nitrous oxide anesthesia in humans. J Neurosurg Anesthesiol 2006;18:106-111
54. Mahajan VA, Ni Chonghaile M, Bokhari SA, Harte BH, Flynn NM, Laffey JG. Recovery of older patients undergoing ambulatory anaesthesia with isoflurane or sevoflurane. Eur J Anaesthesiol 2010;24:505-510
55. Meyer RR, Mü nster P, Werner C, Brambrink AM. Isoflurane is associated with a similar incidence of emergence agitation/delirium as sevoflurane in young children-a randomized controlled study. Paediatr Anaesth 2007;17: 56-60
56. Kaygusuz K, Yildirim A, Kol IO, Gursoy S, Mimaroglu C. Hypotensive anaesthesia with remifentanil combined with desflurane or isoflurane in tympanoplasty or endoscopic sinus surgery: a randomised, controlled trial. J Laryngol Otol 2008;122:691-695
57. Ali Z, Prabhakar H, Bithal P, Dash H. Bispectral index-guided administration of anesthesia for transsphenoidal resection of pituitary tumors: a comparison of 3 anesthetic techniques. J Neurosurg Anesthesiol 2009;21:10-15
58. Singh D, Rath G, Dash H, Bithal P. Sevoflurane provides better recovery as compared with isoflurane in children undergoing spinal surgery. J Neurosurg Anesthesiol 2009;21:202-206
59. Dexter F, Macario A, Manberg PJ, Lubarsky DA. Computer simulation to determine how rapid anesthetic recovery protocols to decrease the time for emergence or increase the phase I post anesthesia care unit bypass rate affect staffing of an ambulatory surgery center. Anesth Analg 1999;88: 1053-1063
60. Macario A, Dexter F. Effect of compensation and patient scheduling on operating room labor costs. AORN J 2000;71:860-869
61. Abouleish AE, Dexter F, Whitten CW, Zavaleta JR, Prough DS. Quantifying net staffing costs due to longer-thanaverage surgical case durations. Anesthesiology 2004;100: 403-412
62. McIntosh C, Dexter F, Epstein RH. Impact of service-specific staffing, case scheduling, turnovers, and first-case starts on anesthesia group and operating room productivity: tutorial using data from an Australian hospital. Anesth Analg 2006;103:1499-1516
63. Dexter F, Epstein RH. Typical savings from each minute reduction in tardy first case of the day starts. Anesth Analg 2009;108:1262-1267
64. McKay RE, Large MJ, Balea MC, McKay WR. Airway reflexes return more rapidly after desflurane anesthesia than after sevoflurane anesthesia. Anesth Analg 2005;100:697-700
65. Higgins JP, White IR, Anzures-Cabrera J. Meta-analysis of skewed data: combining results reported on log-transformed or raw scales. Stat Med 2008;27:6072-6092
66. Whitehead A. Meta-Analysis of Controlled Clinical Trials. West Sussex, England: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, 2002:50, 59, 60, 80-4, 89, 91-6, 205-206
67. Spiegelhalter, D, Thomas A, Best N, Lunn D. WinBUGS User Manual Version 1.4. Cambridge, UK: MRC Biostatistics Unit, 2002
68. Clopper CJ, Pearson ES. The use of confidence or fiducial limits illustrated in the case of the binomial. Biometrika 1934;26:404-413
69. Hahn GJ, Meeker WQ. Statistical Intervals. A Guide for Practitioners. New York: Wiley, 1991:82- 4, 100-105
70. Eger EI II, Shafer SL. Tutorial: context-sensitive decrement times for inhaled anesthetics. Anesth Analg 2005;101:688-696
71. Nordmann GR, Read JA, Sale SM, Stoddart PA, Wolf AR. Emergence and recovery in children after desflurane and isoflurane anaesthesia: effect of anaesthetic duration. Br J Anaesth 2006;96:779-785
72. Youngs EJ, Shafer SL. Pharmacokinetic parameters relevant to recovery from opioids. Anesthesiology 1994;81:833-842
73. Dexter F, Coffin S, Tinker JH. Decreases in anesthesiacontrolled time cannot permit one additional surgical operation to be scheduled during the workday. Anesth Analg 1995;81:1263-1268
74. Dexter F, Tinker JH. Comparisons between desflurane and isoflurane or propofol on time to following commands and time to discharge: a meta-analysis. Anesthesiology 1995;83: 77-82
75. Dexter F. Regional anesthesia does not significantly change surgical time versus general anesthesia-a meta-analysis of randomized studies. Reg Anesth Pain Med 1998;23:439-444
76. Apfelbaum JL, Grasela TH, Hug CC Jr, McLeskey CH, Nahrwold ML, Roizen MF, Stanley TH, Thisted RA, Walawander CA, White PF. The initial clinical experience of 1819 physicians in maintaining anesthesia with propofol: characteristics associated with prolonged time to awakening. Anesth Analg 1993;77:S10-4
77. Macario A, Dexter F, Lubarsky DA. Meta-analysis of trials comparing postoperative recovery after anesthesia with sevoflurane or desflurane. Am J Health System Pharm 2005;62:63-68