"Divine stramonium": The rise and fall of smoking for asthma

Medical History

Volumn 54, Issue 2, 2010, Pages 171-194

  Jackson, Mark ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EXETER   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

PLANT MEDICINAL PRODUCT;

ARTICLE; ASTHMA; DATURA STRAMONIUM; HISTORY; HUMAN; INHALATIONAL DRUG ADMINISTRATION; PHYTOTHERAPY; SMOKING;

ADMINISTRATION, INHALATION; ASTHMA; DATURA STRAMONIUM; HISTORY, 17TH CENTURY; HISTORY, 18TH CENTURY; HISTORY, 19TH CENTURY; HISTORY, 20TH CENTURY; HISTORY, ANCIENT; HISTORY, MEDIEVAL; HUMANS; PHYTOTHERAPY; PLANT PREPARATIONS; SMOKING;

EID: 77950479742     PISSN: 00257273     EISSN: 09505571     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1017/S0025727300000235     Document Type: Article

References (103)

1. George D Painter (ed.), Marcel Proust: letters to his mother, London, Rider, 1956, pp. 124-7.
2. Matthew Hilton, Smoking in British popular culture 1800-2000, Manchester University Press, 2000, pp. 1-2.
3. For a broad discussion of the early history of tobacco consumption, see also Jordan Goodman, Tobacco in history: the cultures of dependence, London, Routledge, 1993
4. For accounts of smoking opium and cannabis, particularly during the nineteenth century, see Virginia Berridge, Opium and the people: opiate use and drug control policy in nineteenth and early twentieth century England, London, Free Association Books, 1999
5. James H Mills, Cannabis Britannica: empire, trade, and prohibition, Oxford University Press, 2003
6. Louise Foxcroft, The making of addiction: the 'use and abuse' of opium in nineteenth-century Britain, Aldershot, Ashgate, 2007
7. Stephen Lock, Lois Reynolds and E M Tansey (eds), Ashes to ashes: the history of smoking and health, Amsterdam, Rodopi, 1998
8. Rosemary Elliot, Women and smoking since 1890, New York and London, Routledge, 2008
9. Virginia Berridge, Marketing health: smoking and the discourse of public health in Britain, 1945-2000, Oxford University Press, 2007
10. Allan M Brandt, The cigarette century: the rise, fall and deadly persistence of the product that defined America, New York, Basic Books, 2007
11. Some detailed histories of smoking do refer, but only in passing, to the role of smoking in reducing stress
12. The broader health effects of tobacco are explored in R B Walker, 'Medical aspects of tobacco smoking and the anti-tobacco movement in Britain in the nineteenth century', Med. Hist., 1980, 24: 391-402.
13. Jay Grossman, 'The evolution of inhaler technology', Journal of Asthma, 1994, 31: 55-64
14. Noel Snell, 'Inhalation devices: a brief history', Respiratory Disease in Practice, summer 1995: 13-15
15. Jean-François Dessanges, 'A history of nebulization', Journal of Aerosol Medicine, 2001, 14: 65-71
16. Paula J Anderson, 'History of aerosol therapy: liquid nebulization to MDIs to DPIs', Respiratory Care, 2005, 50: 1139-50
17. Mark Sanders, 'Inhalation therapy: an historical review', Primary Care Respiratory Journal, 2007, 16: 71-81
18. P Ram Manohar, 'Smoking and Ayurvedic medicine in India', in Sander L Gilman and Zhou Xun (eds), Smoke: a global history of smoking, London, Reaktion Books, 2004, pp. 68-75.
19. B Ebbell (tr.), The Papyrus Ebers: the greatest Egyptian medical document, Copenhagen, Levin and Munksgaard, 1937, p. 67.
20. Robert Bree, A practical inquiry on disordered respiration; distinguishing convulsive asthma, its specific causes, and proper indications of cure, Birmingham, M Swinney, 1797, p. 375.
21. For more detailed discussion, see Mark Jackson, Asthma: the biography, Oxford University Press, 2009
22. For an English version of Ibn Sarabīūn's work, see Luke Demaitre, 'Straws in the wind: Latin writings on asthma between Galen and Cardano', Allergy and Asthma Proceedings, 2002, 23: 59-93
23. Gerrit Bos (ed.), Maimonides: On asthma, Provo, Utah, Brigham Young University Press, 2002, p. 5.
24. For more detailed discussion of Cardano's approach, see Alan Wykes, Doctor Cardano: physician extraordinary, London, Muller, 1969
25. Charles L Dana, 'The story of a great consultation: Jerome Cardan goes to Edinburgh', Ann. Med. Hist., 1921, 13: 122-35.
26. John Baptista van Helmont, Oriatrike or, Physick refined, London, 1662
27. Thomas Willis, Pharmaceutice rationalis: or, The operations of medicines in humane bodies, Part II, London, 1679
28. John Floyer, A treatise of the asthma, London, Richard Wilkin, 1698
29. See, for example, the comments in Thomas Withers, A treatise on the asthma, London, G G J and J Robinson, 1786, pp. vii-viii.
30. William Cullen, First lines of the practice of physic, 4 vols, Edinburgh, 1784, vol. 3, pp. 390-410.
31. William Buchan, Domestic medicine, London, 1776, pp. 441-5.
32. Anon., Instant relief to the asthmatic, or those afflicted with shortness of breath, London, 1774, pp. 22-3, 28-30.
33. Philip Stern, Medical advice to the consumptive and asthmatic people of England, London, J Almon, 1767, p. 22.
34. For a similar pamphlet advertising his own "inhaler", see John Mudge, A radical and expeditious cure for a recent catarrhous cough, London, E Allen, 1778. On the inhalers themselves.
35. For a comparable discussion of the role of fumes and smoke in triggering asthma attacks
36. George Lipscomb, Observations on the history and cause of asthma, Birmingham, James Belcher, 1800, p. 99.
37. James Anderson, The conclusion of letters on the culture of silk, Madras, Joseph Martin, 1792
38. James Anderson, Letters, &c., Madras, Bone and Cooper, 1796.
39. Anon., 'Communications relative to the Datura Stramonium, or thorn-apple: as a cure or relief of asthma', Edinb. Med. Surg. J., 1812, 8: 364-7, at p. 365.
40. Alexander Marcet, 'On the medicinal properties of stramonium; with illustrative cases', Medico-Chirurg. Trans., 1816, 7: 546-75.
41. R T H Laennec, A treatise on the diseases of the chest and on mediate auscultation, 2nd ed., tr. John Forbes, London, T & G Underwood, 1827. The French first edition appeared as R T H Laennec, De l'auscultation médiate, Paris, J-A Brosson and J-S Chaudé, 1819.
42. F H Ramadge, Asthma, its species and complications, or Researches into the pathology of disordered respiration, London, 1835
43. quoted in Barry E Brenner, 'Where have we been? The history of acute asthma', in Barry E Brenner (ed.), Emergency asthma, New York, Marcel Dekker, 1999, pp. 1-31, at p. 7.
44. A T Thomson, 'Clinical remarks on a case of asthma', Lancet, 27 July 1839, ii: 645-9, at p. 647.
45. Armand Trousseau, Lectures on clinical medicine, tr. P Victor Bazire, London, [1861], 1868.
46. Henry Hyde Salter, On asthma: its pathology and treatment, London, John Churchill and Sons, 1860, pp. 161-204.
47. See also Idem, 'Spasmodic asthma', Lancet, 7 Jan. 1860, i: 12; idem.
48. 'On the treatment of the asthmatic paroxysm by full doses of alcohol', Lancet, 14 Nov. 1863, ii: 558-9.
49. Idem, 'On the treatment of asthma by belladonna', Lancet, 30 Jan. 1869, ii: 152-3.
50. Thomas Pridham, 'Observations on the treatment of asthma', Br. Med. J., 17 Nov. 1860, ii: 896-8.
51. G H Smith, 'On opium smoking among the Chinese', Lancet, 19 Feb. 1841-2, i: 707-10, quote at p. 710.
52. Anon., What opium feels like. By one who has tried it, (1870), John Burns Collection, Greater London Record Office.
53. Charles R Broadbent, A medical treatise on the causes and curability of consumption, laryngitis, chronic catarrh, and diseases of the air passages, Boston, Damrell and Welch, 1862, p. 48.
54. A W B Simpson, 'Quackery and contract law: the case of the Carbolic Smoke Ball', Journal of Legal Studies, 1985, 14: 345-89
55. Janice Dickin McGinnis, 'Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Company: influenza, quackery, and unilateral contract', Can. Bull. Med. Hist., 1988, 5: 121-41.
56. The full Court of Appeal judgement is given in Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Company, 1893, 1 QB 256.
57. For further examples of the range of medicated powders and cigarettes available, see Mark Sanders' collection at http://inhalatorium.com; National Library of Medicine, Breath of life, Washington, 1998.
58. On concerns about bronchial irritation and other side effects, see Sidney Martin, 'A clinical lecture on asthma and its treatment', Br. Med. J., 24 Dec. 1898, ii: 1861-3.
59. J B Berkart, On bronchial asthma: its pathology and treatment, London, Oxford University Press, 1911, pp. 97-8.
60. On the preference for oral tinctures of stramonium or belladonna, see C Theodore Williams, 'The value of inhalations in the treatment of lung disease', Br. Med. J., 29 Sept. 1888, ii: 700-6.
61. Walter Hayle Walshe, A practical treatise on the diseases of the lungs, London, James Walton, 1871, pp. 552-3.
62. E Symes Thompson, 'Notes of a lecture on hay-fever', Br. Med. J., 21 Jan. 1871, i: 58-60.
63. Céleste Albaret, Monsieur Proust, ed. Georges Belmont, London, Collins and Harvill Press, 1976, p. 63.
64. Henry Hyde Salter, On asthma: its pathology and treatment, 2nd ed., London, John Churchill and Sons, 1868, p. 2.
65. For a brief discussion of tobacco use in asthma during the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, see H Silvette, P S Larson, and H B Haag, 'Medical uses of tobacco, past and present', Virginia Medical Monthly, 1958, 85: 472-84
66. William Osler, The principles and practice of medicine, 4th ed., New York, D Appleton, 1901, p. 632.
67. Eric K Chu and Jeffrey M Drazen, 'Asthma: one hundred years of treatment and onward', Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., 2005, 171: 1202-8.
68. Stramonium was also recommended for the treatment of asthmatic children during the inter-war years: L A Reynolds and E M Tansey (eds), Childhood asthma and beyond, Wellcome Witnesses to Twentieth Century Medicine, vol. 11, London, Wellcome Trust Centre for the History of Medicine at UCL, 2001.
69. H Herxheimer, 'Atropine cigarettes in asthma and emphysema', Br. Med. J., 15 Aug. 1959, ii: 167-71, at p. 171.
70. See also Harold A Abramson, 'Therapy of asthma with reference to its psychodynamic pharmacology', Bull. N. Y. Acad. Med., 1949, 25: 345-63.
71. For further discussion, see Mark Jackson, Allergy: the history of a modern malady, London, Reaktion Books, 2006, pp. 27-55.
72. Arthur Hurst, 'An address on asthma', Lancet, 28 May 1921, i: 1113-17, at p. 1117.
73. Warren T Vaughan, Strange malady: the story of allergy, New York, Doubleday, Doran, 1941, pp. 179-80.
74. Doris J Rapp and A W Frankland, Allergies: questions and answers, London, Heinemann, 1976, pp. 34, 95; emphasis in original.
75. George W Bray, 'The treatment of asthma', Br. Med. J., 19 Jan. 1935, i: 119-21.
76. George W Bray, 'The treatment of asthma', Post-grad. Med. J., Oct. 1935, 11: 339-45.
77. Dharmendra, 'Asthma', Indian Med. Gaz., 1936, 1: 279-84.
78. See also David Jack, 'Drug treatment of bronchial asthma 1948-95 - years of change', Int. Pharm. J., 1996, 10: 50-2.
79. See also the comments in Mass Observation Archive, TC 63, Box 3 File C Men S, 1 Sept. 1937. I am grateful to Rosemary Elliot for alerting me to this reference.
80. Gustavus A Peters, Louis E Prickman, Giles A Koelsche, and Haddon M Carryer, 'Smoking and asthma', Proceedings of the Staff Meetings of the Mayo Clinic, 1952, 27: 329-31
81. Anon., 'The tobacco habit', Br. Med. J., 16 Oct. 1943, ii: 502.
82. Anon., 'Smoking cures', Br. Med. J., 20 Feb. 1954, i: 471.
83. Anon., 'Menthol cigarettes', Br. Med. J., 17 Nov. 1956, ii: 1189.
84. See the articles and correspondence within the British-American Tobacco Company on Atrotabak, in the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, available online at http://legacy.library.ucsf.edu: 'Nicotine-free cigarettes from tobacco and Belladonna', Bates no. 1000025832.
85. Letter from D G Felton to Mr Anderson, dated 10 April 1963, Bates no. 106507887; letter from H D Anderson to D G Felton, dated 11 April 1963, Bates no. 103518668. I am grateful to Allan Brandt for alerting me to the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library.
86. 'Cigarettes as drug dispensers - health cigarettes', Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, Bates no. 100648851.
87. Bo Holmstedt and Olle Wallen, 'Drug administration by means of cigarettes', Archives Internationales de Pharmacodynamie et de Thérapie, 1959, 119: 275-93
88. The Poisons Rules, 1960, a copy of which is available in the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, Bates nos. 400517305-400517347.
89. See the entry on Greece in U.S. Department of Agriculture, 'Foreign Agriculture Circular', 1986, Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, Bates no. 89609583/9694.
90. M Robert Kaufman and Theodore Siek, 'Is "natural" always healthy?', J. Sch. Health, Aug. 1980, 50: 322-5.
91. See, for example, the evidence presented before the U.S. Food and Drug Administration in 1996, in 'Comments of Public Citizen, Inc. Regarding the FDA's proposal to regulate the sale and promotion of tobacco products to minors', Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, Bates no. 2048297052/7220.
92. D Charpin, J Orehek and J M Velardocchio, 'Bronchodilator effects of antiasthmatic cigarette smoke (Datura stramonium)', Thorax, 1979, 34: 259-61
93. H L Elliott and J L Reid, 'The clinical pharmacology of a herbal asthma cigarette', Br. J. Clin. Pharmacol., 1980, 10: 487-90.
94. 'Smoking and health', Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, Bates no. 87492752.
95. Virginia S Edwards, 'The quest of the cubebs', JAMA, 1968, 206: 133
96. A C Hardman, 'Abuse of belladonna alkaloids', Can. Med. Assoc. J., 1968, 98: 466.
97. J Robertson Unwin, 'Illicit drug use among Canadian youth: part II', Can. Med. Assoc. J., 1968, 98: 449-54.
98. Elizabeth A Harrison and D H Morgan, 'Abuse of herbal cigarettes containing stramonium', Br. Med. J., 13 Nov. 1976, ii: 1195.
99. A Ballantyne, P Lippiett, and J Park, 'Herbal cigarettes for kicks', Br. Med. J., 2 Dec. 1976, ii: 1539.
100. Ronald K Siegel, 'Herbal intoxication: psychoactive effects from herbal cigarettes, tea and capsules', JAMA, 1976, 236: 473-6
101. A H Barnett, F W Jones and E R Williams, 'Acute poisoning with Potter's Asthma Remedy', Br. Med. J., 24 Dec. 1977, ii: 1635.
102. R.G.H. Bethel, 'Abuse of asthma cigarettes', Br. Med. J., 30 Sept. 1978, ii: 959.
103. Kenneth R Chapman, 'Anticholinergic bronchodilators for adult obstructive airways disease', Am. J. Med., supplement 4A, 1991, 91: 13-16.