Warm versus cold cardioplegia for heart surgery: a meta-analysis

European Journal of Cardio-thoracic Surgery

Volumn 37, Issue 4, 2010, Pages 912-919

  Fan, Ye ^a   Zhang, An Mei ^a   Xiao, Ying Bin ^a   Weng, Yu Guo ^b   Hetzer, Roland ^b  

^a THIRD MILITARY MEDICAL UNIVERSITY   (China)

^b DEUTSCHES HERZZENTRUM BERLIN   (Germany)

Author keywords

Cardioplegia; Heart; Meta analysis; Surgery

Indexed keywords

CREATINE KINASE; TROPONIN;

AORTA BALLOON; CARDIOPLEGIA; CLINICAL TRIAL; COLD CARDIOPLEGIA; CREATINE KINASE BLOOD LEVEL; FORWARD HEART FAILURE; HEART ATRIUM FIBRILLATION; HEART INDEX; HEART INFARCTION; HEART PROTECTION; HEART SURGERY; HUMAN; INFORMATION RETRIEVAL; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; META ANALYSIS; MORTALITY; POSTOPERATIVE PERIOD; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROTEIN SECRETION; REVIEW; STROKE; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; WARM CARDIOPLEGIA;

CARDIAC SURGICAL PROCEDURES; HEART ARREST, INDUCED; HOSPITAL MORTALITY; HUMANS; HYPOTHERMIA, INDUCED; MYOCARDIAL INFARCTION; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC; STROKE;

EID: 77949488380     PISSN: 10107940     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ejcts.2009.09.030     Document Type: Review

References (53)

1. Follette D.M., Steed D.L., Foglia R.P., Fey K.H., and Buckberg G.D. Reduction on postischemic myocardial damage by maintaining arrest during initial reperfusion. Surg Forum 28 (1977) 281-283
2. Rosenkranz E.R., Buckberg G.D., Laks H., and Mulder D.G. Warm induction of cardioplegia with glutamate-enriched blood in coronary patients with cardiogenic shock who are dependent on inotropic drugs and intra-aortic balloon support: initial experience and operative strategy. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 86 (1983) 507-518
3. Ikonomidis J.S., Yau T.M., Weisel R.D., Hayashida N., Komeda M., Ivanov J., Carson S., Mohabeer M.K., and Mickle D.A.G. Warm blood cardioplegia: what happens when you turn it off?. Circulation 86 Suppl. 1 (1992) 103
4. Jadad A.R., Moore R.A., and Carroll D. Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary?. Control Clin Trials 17 (1996) 1-12
5. Higgins J.P., Thompson S.G., Deeks J.J., and Altman D.G. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ 327 (2003) 557-560
6. Yau T.M., Weisel R.D., Mickle D.A., Komeda M., Ivanov J., Carson S., Mohabeer M.K., and Tumiati L.C. Alternative techniques of cardioplegia. Circulation 86 5 Suppl. (1992) II377-II384
7. Lajos T.Z., Espersen C.C., Lajos P.S., Fiedler R.C., Bergsland J., and Joyce L.T. Comparison of cold versus warm cardioplegia. Crystalloid antegrade or retrograde blood?. Circulation 88 5 Pt 2 (1993) II344-II349
8. Yau T.M., Ikonomidis J.S., Weisel R.D., Mickle D.A., Hayashida N., Ivanov J., Carson S., Mohabeer M.K., and Tumiati L.C. Which techniques of cardioplegia prevent ischemia?. Ann Thorac Surg 56 5 (1993) 1020-1028
9. Ali I.M., and Kinley C.E. The safety of intermittent warm blood cardioplegia. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 8 10 (1994) 554-556
10. Rashid A., Fabri B.M., Jackson M., Desmond M.J., Grech E.D., Battistessa S.A., and Page R.D. A prospective randomised study of continuous warm versus intermittent cold blood cardioplegia for coronary artery surgery: preliminary report. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 8 5 (1994) 265-269
11. Martin T.D., Craver J.M., Gott J.P., Weintraub W.S., Ramsay J., Mora C.T., and Guyton R.A. Prospective, randomized trial of retrograde warm blood cardioplegia: myocardial benefit and neurologic threat. Ann Thorac Surg 57 2 (1994) 298-302
12. The Warm Heart Investigators. Randomised trial of normothermic versus hypothermic coronary bypass surgery. Lancet 1994;343(8897):559-63.
13. Yuan S.M., Zhu L.B., Li G.S., Liu M.H., Dong C., Yu Y.F., Wang D.Q., Li J.C., and Luo J. Myocardial protection of cold crystalloid and warm blood cardioplegia. A comparative study. Chin Med J (Engl) 107 7 (1994) 515-520
14. Pelletier L.C., Carrier M., Leclerc Y., Cartier R., Wesolowska E., and Solymoss B.C. Intermittent antegrade warm versus cold blood cardioplegia: a prospective, randomized study. Ann Thorac Surg 58 1 (1994) 41-48
15. Hayashida N., Ikonomidis J.S., Weisel R.D., Shirai T., Ivanov J., Carson S.M., Mohabeer M.K., Tumiati L.C., and Mickle D.A. The optimal cardioplegic temperature. Ann Thorac Surg 58 4 (1994) 961-971
16. Rashid A., Jackson M., Page R.D., Desmond M.J., and Fabri B.M. Continuous warm versus intermittent cold blood cardioplegia for coronary bypass surgery in patients with left ventricular dysfunction. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 9 8 (1995) 405-408
17. Anderson W.A., Berrizbeitia L.D., Ilkowski D.A., Cha R., Gu J., Fernandez J., Laub G.W., Adkins M.S., Chen C., and McGrath L.B. Normothermic retrograde cardioplegia is effective in patients with left ventricular hypertrophy. A prospective and randomized study. J Cardiovasc Surg (Torino) 36 1 (1995) 17-24
18. Hayashida N., Weisel R.D., Shirai T., Ikonomidis J.S., Ivanov J., Carson S.M., Mohabeer M.K., Tumiati L.C., and Mickle D.A. Tepid antegrade and retrograde cardioplegia. Ann Thorac Surg 59 3 (1995) 723-729
19. Maccherini M., Davoli G., Sani G., Rossi P., Giani S., Lisi G., Mazzesi G., and Toscano M. Warm heart surgery eliminates diaphragmatic paralysis. J Card Surg 10 3 (1995) 257-261
20. Jin X.Y., Gibson D.G., and Pepper J.R. Early changes in regional and global left ventricular function after aortic valve replacement. Comparison of crystalloid, cold blood, and warm blood cardioplegias. Circulation 92 9 Suppl. (1995) II155-II162
21. Pepper J.R., Mumby S., and Gutteridge J.M. Blood cardioplegia increases plasma iron overload and thiol levels during cardiopulmonary bypass. Ann Thorac Surg 60 6 (1995) 1735-1740
22. Isomura T., Hisatomi K., Sato T., Hayashida N., and Ohishi K. Interrupted warm blood cardioplegia for coronary artery bypass grafting. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 9 (1995) 133-138
23. Christakis G.T., Buth K.J., Weisel R.D., Rao V., Joy L., Fremes S.E., and Goldman B.S. Randomized study of right ventricular function with intermittent warm or cold cardioplegia. Ann Thorac Surg 61 1 (1996) 128-134
24. Landymore R., Murphy J.T., Hall R., and Islam M. Randomized trial comparing intermittent antegrade warm blood cardioplegia with multidose cold blood cardioplegia for coronary artery bypass. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 10 3 (1996) 179-184
25. Gozal Y., Glantz L., Luria M.H., Milgalter E., Shimon D., and Drenger B. Normothermic continuous blood cardioplegia improves electrophysiologic recovery after open heart surgery. Anesthesiology 84 6 (1996) 1298-1306
26. Engelman R.M., Pleet A.B., Rousou J.A., Flack III J.E., Deaton D.W., Gregory C.A., and Pekow P.S. What is the best perfusion temperature for coronary revascularization?. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 112 6 (1996) 1622-1632
27. Curtis J.J., Nawarawong W., Walls J.T., and Schmaltz R.A. Continuous warm blood cardioplegia: a randomized prospective clinical comparison. Int J Angiol 5 (1996) 212-218
28. Chello M., Mastroroberto P., Romano R., Ascione R., Pantaleo D., and De Amicis V. Complement and neutrophil activation during cardiopulmonary bypass: a randomized comparison of hypothermic and normothermic circulation. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 11 1 (1997) 162-168
29. Honkonen E.L., Kaukinen L., Pehkonen E.J., and Kaukinen S. Right ventricle is protected better by warm continuous than by cold intermittent retrograde blood cardioplegia in patients with obstructed right coronary artery. Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 45 4 (1997) 182-189
30. Bouchart F., Bessou J.P., Tabley A., Hecketsweiller B., Mouton-Schleifer D., Redonnet M., Arrignon J., and Soyer R. How to protect hypertrophied myocardium? A prospective clinical trial of three preservation techniques. Int J Artif Organs 20 (1997) 440-446
31. Fiore A.C., Swartz M.T., Nevett R., Vieth P.J., Magrath R.A., Sherrick A., and Barner H.B. Intermittent antegrade tepid versus cold blood cardioplegia in elective myocardial revascularization. Ann Thorac Surg 65 6 (1998) 1559-1564
32. Astorri E., Fiorina P., Grattagliano C., Medici D., Pinelli S., Albertini D., Pincolini S., Barboso G., and Albertini R. Cardiac troponin T to evaluate myocardial protection via intermittent cold blood or continuous warm blood cardioplegia in coronary artery bypass grafting. J Cardiovasc Surg (Torino) 39 6 (1998) 797-802
33. Jacquet L.M., Noirhomme P.H., Van Dyck M.J., El Khoury G.A., Matta A.J., Goenen M.J., and Dion R.A. Randomized trial of intermittent antegrade warm blood versus cold crystalloid cardioplegia. Ann Thorac Surg 67 2 (1999) 471-477
34. Simeone F., Biagioli B., Dolci A., Favilli R., Totaro P., Marullo A., Giomarelli P.P., and Toscano M. The diagnostic and prognostic value of cardiac troponin T in bypass surgery. J Cardiovasc Surg (Torino) 40 2 (1999) 211-216
35. Elwatidy A.M., Fadalah M.A., Bukhari E.A., Aljubair K.A., Syed A., Ashmeg A.K., and Alfagih M.R. Antegrade crystalloid cardioplegia versus antegrade/retrograde cold and tepid blood cardioplegia in CABG. Ann Thorac Surg 68 2 (1999) 447-453
36. Chocron S., Kaili D., Yan Y., Toubin G., Latini L., Clement F., Viel J.F., and Etievent J.P. Intermediate lukewarm (20 degrees) antegrade intermittent blood cardioplegia compared with cold and warm blood cardioplegia. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 119 3 (2000) 610-616
37. Bical O.M., Fromes Y., Paumier D., Gaillard D., Foiret J.C., and Trivin F. Does warm antegrade intermittent blood cardioplegia really protect the heart during coronary surgery?. Cardiovasc Surg 9 2 (2001) 188-193
38. Ascione R., Williams S., Lloyd C.T., Sundaramoorthi T., Pitsis A.A., and Angelini G.D. Reduced postoperative blood loss and transfusion requirement after beating-heart coronary operations: a prospective randomized study. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 121 4 (2001) 689-696
39. Franke U.F., Korsch S., Wittwer T., Albes J.M., Wippermann J., Kaluza M., Rahmanian P.B., and Wahlers T. Intermittent antegrade warm myocardial protection compared to intermittent cold blood cardioplegia in elective coronary surgery-do we have to change?. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 23 3 (2003) 341-346
40. Ferreira R., Fraga C., Carrasquedo F., Hourquebie H., Grana D., and Milei J. Comparison between warm blood and crystalloid cardioplegia during open heart surgery. Int J Cardiol 90 2-3 (2003) 253-260
41. Chello M., Mastroroberto P., Patti G., D'Ambrosio A., and Di Sciascio G. Covino E. Intermittent warm blood cardioplegia induces the expression of heat shock protein-72 by ischemic myocardial preconditioning. Cardiovasc Surg 11 5 (2003) 367-374
42. Sirlak M., Eryilmaz S., Yazicioǧlu L., Kiziltepe U., Inan M.B., Taşöz R., Aral A., and Akalin H. Conduction disturbances in coronary artery bypass surgery. Int J Cardiol 92 1 (2003) 43-48
43. Baron O., Roussel J.C., Delaroche O., Péron S., and Duveau D. Prospective clinical and biological comparison of three blood cardioplegia techniques in low-risk CABG patients: better is worse than good enough. Cardiovasc Surg 11 6 (2003) 489-495
44. Sirvinskas E., Nasvytis L., Raliene L., Vaskelyte J., Toleikis A., and Trumbeckaite S. Myocardial protective effect of warm blood, tepid blood, and cold crystalloid cardioplegia in coronary artery bypass grafting surgery. Croat Med J 46 6 (2005) 879-888
45. Dar M.I. Cold crystalloid versus warm blood cardioplegia for coronary artery bypass surgery. Ann Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 11 6 (2005) 382-385
46. Barassi A., Merlini G., Finazzi S., Pallotti F., Mantovani V., Sala A., and d'Eril G.M. Comparison of three strategies for myocardial protection during coronary artery bypass graft surgery based on markers of cardiac damage. Clin Biochem 38 6 (2005) 504-508
47. Fremes S.E., Weisel R.D., Mickle D.A., Ivanov J., Madonik M.M., Seawright S.J., Houle S., McLaughlin P.R., and Baird R.J. Myocardial metabolism and ventricular function following cold potassium cardioplegia. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 89 (1985) 531-546
48. Buckberg G.D., Brazier J.R., Nelson R.L., Goldstein S.M., McConnell D.H., and Cooper N. Studies on the effects of hypothermia on regional myocardial blood flow and metabolism during cardiopulmonary bypass. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 73 (1977) 87-94
49. Kirklin J., and Barrat-Boyes B. Myocardial management during cardiac surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass. In: Kirklin J., and Barrat-Boyes B. (Eds). Cardiac surgery (1993), Churchill Livingstone, New York, NY 129-166
50. Teoh K.H., Christakis G.T., Weisel R.D., Fremes S.E., Mickle D.A., Romaschin A.D., Harding R.S., Ivanov J., Madonik M.M., and Ross I.M. Accelerated myocardial metabolic recovery with terminal warm blood cardioplegia. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 91 (1986) 888-895
51. Mallidi H.R., Sever J., Tamariz M., Singh S., Hanayama N., Christakis G.T., Bhatnagar G., Cutrara C.A., Goldman B.S., and Fremes S.E. The short-term and long-term effects of warm or tepid cardioplegia. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 125 3 (2003) 711-720
52. Lichtenstein S.V., Ashe K.A., El Dalati H., Cusimano R.J., Panos A., and Slutsky A.S. Warm heart surgery. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 101 (1991) 269-274
53. Guru V., Omura J., Alghamdi A.A., Weisel R., and Fremes S.E. Is blood superior to crystalloid cardioplegia? A meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. Circulation 114 1 Suppl. (2006) I331-I338