The royal society, natural history and the peoples of the new world(s), 1660-1800

British Journal for the History of Science

Volumn 42, Issue 4, 2009, Pages 539-562

  Gascoigne, John ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES   (Australia)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ANTHROPOLOGY; ARTICLE; ETHNIC AND RACIAL GROUPS; ETHNOLOGY; EUROPE; HEALTH CARE ORGANIZATION; HISTORY; HUMAN; METHODOLOGY; UNITED KINGDOM; WESTERN HEMISPHERE;

AMERICAS; ANTHROPOLOGY; ENGLAND; ETHNOLOGY; EUROPE; HISTORY, 17TH CENTURY; HISTORY, 18TH CENTURY; HUMANS; NATURAL HISTORY; POPULATION GROUPS; SOCIETIES, SCIENTIFIC;

EID: 75949100850     PISSN: 00070874     EISSN: 1474001X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1017/S0007087409002210     Document Type: Article

References (160)

1. H. Lyons, The Royal Society 1660-1940: A History of Its Administration under Its Charters, Cambridge, 1944, 28.
2. P. H. Smith and P. Findlen, 'Commerce and the representation of nature in art and science', in Merchants and Marvels: Commerce, Science and Art in Early Modern Europe (ed. P. H. Smith and P. Findlen), New York, 2002, 1-25, 18;
3. and idem, 'Local herbs, global medicines: commerce, knowledge, and commodities in Spanish America', in ibid., 163-81, 165.
4. H. J. Cook, Matters of Exchange: Commerce, Medicine, and Science in the Dutch Golden Age, New Haven, 2007, 46.
5. G. Rees (ed.), The Oxford Francis Bacon, Vol. VI: Philosophical Studies c.1611-c.1619, Oxford, 1996, 99.
6. B. Shapiro, 'History and natural history in sixteenth- and seventeenth-century England: an essay on the relationship between humanism and science', in English Scientific Virtuosi in the 16th and 17th Centuries (ed. B. Shapiro and R. Frank), Los Angeles, 1979, 1-55, 7, 18.
7. J. Spedding, R. L. Ellis and D. D. Heath (eds), The Works of Francis Bacon, 14 vols., London, 1857-74, v, 152;
8. G. Rees (ed.), The Oxford Francis Bacon, Vol. XI: The Instauratio Magna, Part II, Novum Organum and Associated Texts, Oxford, 2004, 321.
9. Spedding, Ellis and Heath, op. cit. (6), ii, 348.
10. M. Kiernan (ed.), The Oxford Francis Bacon, Vol. IV: The Advancement of Learning, Oxford, 2000, 70, 71.
11. R. Drayton, 'Knowledge and empire', in The Oxford History of the British Empire, Vol. II: The Eighteenth Century (ed. P. Marshall), Oxford, 1998, 231-52, 233.
12. Rees, op. cit. (6), 479, 481.
13. D. Carey 'Compiling nature's history: travellers and travel narratives in the early Royal Society', Annals of Science (1997), 54, 269-92, 273.
14. On the background to this document see M. Hunter, 'Robert Boyle and the early Royal Society: a reciprocal exchange in the making of Baconian science', BJHS (2007), 40, 1-23.
15. R. Boyle, 'General heads ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1665-6), 1, 186-9, 188.
16. D. Carey, 'Locke, travel literature, and the natural history of man', Seventeenth Century (1986), 7, 259-80.
17. Carey, op. cit. (13), 269.
18. C. Withers, Geography, Science and Natural Identity: Scotland since 1520, Cambridge, 2001, 37-9.
19. S. Mendyk, 'Speculum Britanniae': Regional Study, Antiquarianism, and Science in Britain to 1700, Toronto, 1989, 165.
20. R. Knox, Historical Relation of the Island Ceylon, in the East Indies..., London, 1681, p. [i].
21. D. Preston and M. Preston, A Pirate of Exquisite Mind: The Life of William Dampier, Explorer, Naturalist and Buccaneer, London, 2005, 325.
22. On Woodward's work see C. Withers, 'Geography, natural history and the eighteenth-century enlightenment: putting the world in place', History Workshop Journal (1995), 39, 137-63, 144-5.
23. Royal Society Archives, EL/M2/34, summaries of several letters from Cotton Mather to John Woodward and to Richard Waller, 1712-. A Philosophical Transactions article based on this correspondence ((1714-16), 29, 62-71) includes material by Mather on American Indian ethnology.
24. Joseph Levine, Dr Woodward's Shield: History, Science and Satire in Augustan England, Berkeley, 1997, 99; see also 73 on the correspondence with Mather.
25. John Woodward, Brief Instructions ..., London, 1698, 8-9.
26. [Review of] An Account ..., Philosophical Transactions (1695-7), 19, 426-433, 428-9.
27. Preston and Preston, op. cit. (18), 330, attribute this review to Hooke.
28. [Review of] An Account ..., Philosophical Transactions (1694), 18, 166-8, 167.
29. John Fryer, 'An abstract ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1698), 20, 338-48, 338.
30. Rees, op. cit. (6), 451.
31. Oldenburg to Sorbière, 3 January 1663/4, in A. Rupert Hall and M. Boas Hall (eds.), The Correspondence of Henry Oldenburg, 13 vols., Madison, WI and London, 1965-86, ii, 144.
32. Boyle to Oldenburg, 13 June 1666, in M. Hunter, A. Clericuzio and L. Principe (eds.), The Correspondence of Robert Boyle, 1636-1691, 6 vols., London, 1999-2000, iii, 171.
33. Carey, op. cit. (13), 259-80.
34. M. Boas Hall, Promoting Experimental Learning: Experiment and the Royal Society 1660-1727, Cambridge, 1991;
35. and P. Anstey, 'Experimental versus speculative natural philosophy', in The Science of Nature in the Seventeenth Century: Patterns of Change in Early Modern Natural Philosophy (ed. P. Anstey and J. Schuster), Dordrecht, 2005, 215-42, 220.
36. P. Fontes da Costa, 'The making of extraordinary facts: authentication of singularities of nature at the Royal Society of London in the first half of the eighteenth century', Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science (2002), 33, 265-88, 282.
37. For a recent affirmation of the importance of the Baconian programme in shaping the early Royal Society see W. T. Lynch, Solomon's Child: Method in the Early Royal Society of London, Stanford, 2001, which argues, at 233, that the 'Royal Society was a Baconian institution'.
38. P. Anstey, 'Locke, Bacon and natural history', Early Science and Medicine (2002), 7, 65-92, 85.
39. P. B. Wood, 'Methodology and apologetics: Thomas Sprat's History of the Royal Society', BJHS (1980), 13, 1-26.
40. Boyle to Oldenburg, 13 June 1666, in Hunter, Clericuzio and Principe, op. cit. (27), iii, 174.
41. Oldenburg to Hill?, 30 August 1671, with enclosure for an unknown Jesuit in Brazil, in Hall and Hall, op. cit. (26), viii, 236, 244.
42. Oldenburg to Hill?, op. cit. (35), 236.
43. 'Extracts of Three Letters ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1668), 3, 791-6, 794.
44. Oldenburg to Hotham, 7 March 1669-70, in Hall and Hall, op. cit. (26), vi, 535.
45. T. Birch, History of the Royal Society, 4 vols., London, 1756-7, iv, 165.
46. Royal Society Archives, RB/1/39/9 (Boyle Papers), fol. 49.
47. P. Dear, 'Totius in verba: rhetoric and authority in the early Royal Society', Isis (1985), 76, 144-61.
48. S. Shapin, A Social History of Truth: Civility and Science in Seventeenth-Century England, Chicago, 1994.
49. Dear, op. cit. (41), 156.
50. Fontes da Costa, op. cit. (30).
51. Carey, op. cit. (11), 286.
52. 'Inquiries for Suratte ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1666-7), 2, 415-22, 419.
53. M. Angelo De Guattini, 'Observations of some animals ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1677-8), 12, 977-8, 978.
54. T. Sprat, History of the Royal Society (ed. J. I. Cope and H. Whitmore Jones, St Louis, 1959), 158.
55. L. Daston, 'Marvelous facts and miraculous evidence in early modern Europe', in J. Chandler, A. I. Davidson and H. Harootunion, Questions of Evidence: Proof, Practice and Persuasion across the Discipline, Chicago, 1994, 243-89, 261.
56. 'Extracts of three letters ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1668), 3, 791-6, 795.
57. C. Clarke, 'An account of the very tall men ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1767), 57, 75-9.
58. The credibility of such claims about the existence of Patagonian giants was much discussed among naturalists, and Buffon devoted a section of his 'Additions à l'article qui a pour titre, Variétés dans l'espèce humaine' to the issue. He was sceptical about the existence of real giants, though he was willing to believe the sort of claim made by Clarke that some Patagonians were nine feet tall. G. Buffon Histoire Naturelle, Générale et Particulière, Supplément, Vol. IV, Paris, 1777, 525.
59. J. Maxwell and J. Harris, 'An account of the Cape of Good Hope', Philosophical Transactions (1706-7), 25, 2423-34, 2426.
60. R. McCauseland, 'Particulars relative to the nature and customs of the Indians of North-America', Philosophical Transactions (1786), 76, 229-35, 230.
61. Carey, op. cit. (11), 273.
62. 'Directions for Sea-Men ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1665-6), 1, 140-3, 140-1.
63. Sprat, op. cit. (48), 86.
64. R. Illiffe, 'Foreign bodies: travel, empire and the early Royal Society of London, Part II. "The land of experimental knowledge'", Canadian Journal of History (1999), 34, 24-50, 40.
65. R. Stearns, Science in the British Colonies of America, Urbana, IL, 1970.
66. S. Parrish, American Curiosity: Cultures of Natural History in the Colonial British Atlantic World, Chapel Hill, 2006, 315.
67. Lyons, op. cit. (1), 28.
68. Oldenburg to Winthrop, 13 October 1667, in Hall and Hall, op. cit. (26), iii, 525.
69. Winthrop to Oldenburg, 4 October 1669, in Hall and Hall, op. cit. (26), vi, 255.
70. Oldenburg to Norwood, 24 October 1666, in Hall and Hall, op. cit. (26), iii, 276.
71. M. Hunter, Science and Society in Restoration England, Cambridge, 1981, 36.
72. Birch, op. cit. (39), i, 457, 3 August 1664.
73. Oldenburg to Boyle, 13 March 1666; Boyle to Oldenburg, 19 March 1666, in Hunter, Clericuzio and Principe, op. cit. (27), iii, 109, 117.
74. L. de Bougainville, A Voyage Round the World. Performed by Order of the His Most Christian Majesty, in the Years 1766, 1767, 1768, and 1769 (tr. from the French by J. Reinhold Forster), London, 1772, p. viii.
75. Royal Society Archives, Misc MS3/20, East India Court of Directors to the Royal Society, 19 November 1778.
76. R. I. Ruggles, 'Governor Samuel Wegg, intelligent layman of the Royal Society, 1753-1802', Notes and Records of the Royal Society (1978), 32, 181-99.
77. Stearns, op. cit. (58), 705, 707.
78. Birch, op. cit. (39), ii, 92.
79. J. McClelland, Science Reorganized: Scientific Societies in the Eighteenth Century, New York, 1985, 303-4.
80. J. Reinhold Forster, 'A Letter ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1772), 62, 54-9, 56.
81. Birch, op. cit. (39), ii, 314.
82. C. Reilly, 'A catalogue of Jesuitica in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 1665-1715', Archivum Historicum Societatis Jesu (1958), 27, 339-62.
83. Sprat, op. cit. (48), 373.
84. P. Clain, Father Le Gobien, 'An extract of two letters from the missionary Jesuits ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1708-9), 22, 189-99.
85. M. Hunter, 'The cabinet institutionalised: the Royal Society's "Repository" and its background', in The Origins of Museums: The Cabinet of Curiosities in Sixteenth- and Seventeenth-Century Europe (ed. O. Impey and A. MacGregor), Oxford, 1985, 159-68, 159.
86. K. Arnold, Cabinets for the Curious: Looking back at Early English Museums, Aldershot, 2006, 2.
87. Arnold, op. cit. (79), 110.
88. N. Grew, Musaeum Regalis Societatis, or a Catalogue and Description of the Natural and Artificial Rarities Belonging to the Royal Society and Preserved at Gresham College ..., London, 1694, 365-72, 56, 205, 222.
89. E. Hooper-Greenhill, Museums and the Shaping of Knowledge, London, 1992, 158.
90. D. Collett, 'An empire of things - exotische Objekte in "Musaeum" der Royal Society', WerkstattGeschichte (2006), 43, 5-21, 20.
91. Lyons, op. cit. (1), 49.
92. L. Jardine, 'Paper monuments and learned societies: Hooke's Royal Society Repository', in Enlightening the British: Knowledge, Discovery and the Museum in the Eighteenth Century (ed. R. G. W. Anderson et al.), London, 2004, 49-54, 50.
93. D. Miller, '"Into the valley of darkness": reflections on the Royal Society in the eighteenth century', History of Science (1989), 27, 155-66, 161.
94. Oldenburg to Winthrop, 26 March 1670, in Hall and Hall, op. cit. (26), vi, 594. Grew's catalogue, at 370, duly records 'Several sorts of Indian Money, called Wampampeage'.
95. D. Stimson, Scientists and Amateurs: A History of the Royal Society, New York, 1968, 154.
96. Birch, op. cit. (39), ii, 495.
97. Birch, op. cit. (39), iv, 226-7.
98. Oldenburg to Hevelius, 13 June 1677, in Hall and Hall, op. cit. (26), xiii, 299.
99. Birch, op. cit. (39), iv, 493.
100. J. Steele, 'Account of a musical instrument ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1775), 65, 67-71, 72-8.
101. J. Cope, 'Some considerations ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1735-6), 131-5, 131.
102. Birch, op. cit. (39), iv, 504.
103. Philosophical Transactions (1666-7), 2, 415-22, 417, 420.
104. 'An account of a sort of sugar ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1685), 15, 988;
105. P. Dudley, 'An account of the method of making sugar ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1720-1), 31, 27-8.
106. Birch, op. cit. (39), iv, 520.
107. R. Southwell, 'The method the Indians in Virginia and Carolina use ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1686), 16, 532-3.
108. J. Reinhold Forster, 'A letter ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1772), 62, 54-9, 57.
109. Father Papin, 'A letter ... upon the mechanic arts and physick of the Indians', Philosophical Transactions (1713), 28, 225-30, 225.
110. W. Sherard, 'The way of making several China varnishes', Philosophical Transactions (1700-1), 22, 525-6.
111. Birch, op. cit. (39), iv, 520;
112. Philosophical Transactions (1775), 65, 91-3, 93.
113. Cook, op. cit. (3), 414.
114. Birch, op. cit. (39), ii, 75.
115. T. Glover, 'An account of Virginia ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1676), 11, 623-36, 634, 624.
116. J. Chaplin, Subject Matter: Technology, the Body, and Science on the Anglo-American Frontier, 1500-1676, Cambridge, MA, 2001, 197-8.
117. H. Sloane, 'An Account ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1698), 20, 390-2, 390.
118. Royal Society Archives, RBO/18/45, Doctor Mortimer's account of the ... proposals for printing a geographical and historical account of China, Read 7 June 1733, fol. 278.
119. Stearns, op. cit. (58), 697.
120. 'A narrative ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1674), 9, 197-208, 200.
121. Kiernan, op. cit. (8), 82.
122. Rees, op. cit. (4), 105.
123. Rees, op. cit. (6), 157.
124. Rees, op. cit. (6), 39.
125. Rees, op. cit. (6), 457.
126. M. Purver, The Royal Society: Concept and Creation, London, 1967, 35.
127. Oldenburg to Harpur, 22 May 1668, in Hall and Hall, op. cit. (26), iv, 422.
128. Oldenburg to Sir John Finch, 10 April 1666, in Hall and Hall, op. cit. (26), iii, 86;
129. Philosophical Transactions (1666), 1, 186.
130. Boyle to Oldenburg, 13 June 1666, in Hunter, Clericuzio and Principe, op. cit. (27), iii, 171.
131. P. Anstey and M. Hunter, 'Robert Boyle's "Designe about natural history'", Early Science and Medicine (2008), 13, 83-126, 107.
132. R. Sargent, 'Learning from experience', in Robert Boyle Reconsidered (ed. M. Hunter), Cambridge, 1994, 57-78, 58.
133. H. Kames, The Gentleman Farmer, 4th edn, Edinburgh, 1798, 1 (first published 1776).
134. W. Wales, 'Journal of a voyage ... ', Philosophical Transactions, 1770, 100-36, 127.
135. See M. Feingold, 'Mathematicians and naturalists: Sir Isaac Newton and the Royal Society', in Isaac Newton's Natural Philosophy (ed. J. Z. Buchwald and I. Bernard Cohen), Cambridge, MA, 2001, 77-102, 77.
136. Feingold, op. cit. (125), 97.
137. Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge, Perceval Collection, MS 215, Charles Blagden to Joseph Banks (27 December 1783). On this conflict see J. Gascoigne, Joseph Banks and the English Enlightenment: Useful Knowledge and Polite Culture, Cambridge, 1994, 62-6;
138. J. L. Heilbron, 'A mathematicians' mutiny, with morals', in World Changes: Thomas Kuhn and the Nature of Science (ed. Paul Horwich), Cambridge, MA, 1993, 81-129.
139. On the rising prestige of natural history in the late eighteenth century see W. P. Jones, 'The vogue of natural history in England, 1750-1770', Annals of Science (1937), 2, 345-52;
140. T. L. Hankins, Science and the Enlightenment, Cambridge, 1985, 169;
141. Mendyk, op. cit. (16), 243.
142. J. Reinhold Forster, 'A letter ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1772), 62, 58.
143. P. Wood, 'The science of man', in Cultures of Natural History (ed. N. Jardine, J. A. Secord and E. C. Spary), Cambridge, 1996, 197-210.
144. A. Rusnock, 'Correspondence networks and the Royal Society', BJHS (1999), 32, 155-69, 157.
145. R. Bernasconi, Concepts of Race in the Eighteenth Century, Vol. I: Bernier, Linnaeus and Maupertuis, Bristol, 2001, pp. xi-xii.
146. 'An extract of a letter of Mr. Lister's ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1675), 10, 399-400, 400.
147. Royal Society Archives, RB/1/39/10, 'An Account of Virginia', fol. 132.
148. M. Govier, 'The Royal Society, slavery and the island of Jamaica: 1660-1700', Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London (1999), 53, 203-17, 215.
149. Stearns, op. cit. (58), 545.
150. J. Mitchell, 'An essay ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1744-5), 43, 102-50, 131.
151. J. Bate, 'An account ... ', Philosophical Transactions (1759-60), 51, 175-8, 177-8.
152. J. Gascoigne, 'Blumenbach, Banks, and the beginnings of anthropology at Göttingen', in Göttingen and the Development of the Natural Sciences (ed. N. Rupke), Göttingen, 2002, 86-98.
153. M. Berman, '"Hegemony" and the amateur tradition in British science', Journal of Social History (1974-5), 8, 30-43.
154. J. Lyon, and P. R. Sloan, From Natural History to the History of Nature: Readings from Buffon and His Critics, Notre Dame, 1981, 121;
155. P. Sloan, 'Natural History, 1670-1802', in Companion to the History of Science (ed. R. C. Olby, G. N. Cantor, J. R. R. Christie and M. J. S. Hodge), London, 1996, 295-313;
156. P. Sloan, 'Natural History', in The Cambridge History of Eighteenth-Century Philosophy (ed. K. Haakonssen), 2 vols., Cambridge, 2006, ii, 903-38.
157. P. Wood, 'The science of man', in Cultures of Natural History (ed. N. Jardine, J. A. Secord and E. C. Spary), Cambridge, 1996, 197-210;
158. D. Outram, 'New spaces in natural history', in ibid., 249-65;
159. G. Stocking, 'French anthropology in 1800', in Race, Culture and Evolution (ed. G. Stocking), Chicago, 1982, 13-41;
160. J. Gascoigne, 'The Pacific and the German Enlightenment', in The Anthropology of the Enlightenment (ed. L. Wolff and M. Cipolloni), Stanford, 2007, 141-71.