David gordon and ha-maggid: Changing attitudes toward jewish nationalism, 1860-1882

Modern Judaism

Volumn 17, Issue 2, 1997, Pages 109-124

  Salmon, Yosef ^a  

^a BEN GURION UNIVERSITY OF THE NEGEV   (Israel)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 72749113220     PISSN: 02761114     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/mj/17.2.109     Document Type: Review

References (53)

1. L. Zitron's "Notes on the History of the Hebrew Press" (Hebrew), Ha-Olam, Nos. 10-12 (March 1912); Nos. 2, 4, 6, 8 (April-June 1912).
2. H. Toren, "Ha-Maggid and Its Editor" (Hebrew), Anack (1954), pp. 232-241.
3. I. Barzilai, 'Ha-Maggid and the Beginnings of the Nationalist Movement" (Hebrew), Btzaron 37 (1957-58), pp. 78-88.
4. Menuha Gilboa, (Jerusalem, 1992). (Henceforth referred to as Gilboa).
5. Benzion Dinur, Historical Writings (Jerusalem, 1972), p. 43, R 71.
6. Zitron, "Notes on die History," Ha-Olam, No. 12, p. 18
7. Barzilai, "Ha-Maggid and die Beginnings," pp. 86-88.
8. J. D. Klein, "The Jewish Question in die Reform Era Russian Press, 1855-65," Russian Review 39, No. 3 (1980).
9. Y. D. Frumkin, Havatzdet in Palestine
10. Y. Cohen-Tzedek, Ha-Mevasser in Galicia
11. Yehiel Michael, Pines in Russia. Gilboa (p. 120)
12. Shmuel Feiner, "Ha- Mifneh be Harachat Ha-Hassidut," Zion 51 (1986), pp. 167-210.
13. Ha-Maggid (1856), No. 3, p. 1
14. Ha-Maggid No. 35 (1862), pp. 279-280.
15. Mark Baker ("The Reassessment of Haskala Ideology in die Aftermadi of die 1863 Polish Revolt," Polin 5 [1990], p. 236)
16. M. Opalski and I. Bartal, Poles andjews, A Failed Brotherhood (Waldiam, Mass., 1992), pp. 2-11.
17. Ha-Maggid, No. 1 (1863), pp. 1-2
18. S. Bernfeld, "David Gordon" (Hebrew), Ha-Olam Nos. 23-24 (1926), pp. 449-450
19. G. Kressel, David Gordon-Mivhar Maamarav [David Gordon-Selected Articles] (Tel Aviv, 1942), pp. 8-9
20. Y. Klauser, Behitcorer 'Am [The Awakening of a People] (Jerusalem, 1962), p. 38.
21. Ha-Maggid No. 12 (1863), pp. 89-90
22. Barzilai, pp. 178-179, and Baker, p. 237.
23. Ha-Maggid No. 14 (1863), p. 105.
24. Ernest Laharanne, La nouve Ue question d'Orient: empires d"Egypte et d'Arabie; reconstitviion de la nationalite juive (1861).
25. Ha-Maggid No. 18, p. 137.
26. M. Sachs, Berlin; N. Adler, London; and A. Cohen, Paris.
27. D. Gordon, "On the Situation of the Jews and What They Underwent in the Last Year," Bikkurim2 (1865), p. 149-150.
28. Ha-Maggid No. 43 (1865), p. 337.
29. M. Meyer, "The Jewish Synods in Germany" (Hebrew), Mehkarim 3 (Haifa, 1975), pp. 239-274.
30. Ha-Levanonb, No. 34, p. 541
31. Ha-Maggid No. 51 (1868), p. 405.
32. Ha-Maggid No. 45 (1867), pp. 353-354
33. Meyer, "The Jewish Synods," p. 265.
34. Ha-Maggid Nos. 4-5 (1870).
35. Even Y. Kauman, who believes the main element of Jewish nationalism is the physical redemption of the Jewish people from exile and who, therefore, rejects the notion that Smolenskin and Hess were forerunners of Zionism, should have included Gordon in that category. However, for some reason he overlooked him. Zitron, however, in his Toledot Hibbat Ziyyon [A History of the Hibbat Ziyyon Movement], (Odessa, 1911), p. 73
36. Ha-Maggid No. 26 (1870), p. 204
37. David Gordon, "The Characteristics of the People of Israel," Ha-Maggid Nos. 8-11 (1871).
38. Gordon's reaction to the plan of Montefiore to establish a society similar to the Society for the Settlement of the Land of Israel. Ha- Maggidtio. 3 (1875). See also Barzilai, pp. 182-183.
39. M. Meyer, "The Great Debate on Anti-Semitism " Leo Baeck Institute Year Book 11 (1966), pp. 137-170
40. David Gordon, "On the Settlement of the Land," Ha-Maggid No. 26 (1880).
41. Ha-Maggid No. 35 (1880), pp. 295-296.
42. The Series of articles "On the Question of Agricultural Labor" (Hebrew), (1880), from No. 32 and on; No. 45, pp. 377-378
43. The Society to Propagate Haskalak No. 41 (1880), pp. 350-351.
44. S. Bernfeld, "David Gordon," Ha-Olam Nos. 20, 21, 22, 23-24 (1926).
45. Ha-Olam Nos. 23-24 (1926), p. 449.
46. In 1879 Ha-Maggid had rejected Ben-Yehuda's article "A Serious Question" (Hebrew), but published it in Ha-Maggid (1880) Nos. 35, (1881), pp. 321-322.
47. S. Bemfeld, Gilboa, p. 129.
48. The Jewish Problem, Nos. 21-29, No. 23, p. 186.
49. Jacob Toury, who traced the term, was not aware of Gordon's articles
50. J. Toury, "The Jewish Question: A Semantic Approach," Leo Baeck Institute Year Bookll (1966), p. 106, n. 88.
51. Zitron, "Notes on the History," No. 8, p. 12.
52. Ha-Maggid No. 36 (1881), p. 299.
53. "The Jewish Problem," No. 28, p. 229-231.