Privatising health care in China: Problems and reforms

Journal of Contemporary Asia

Volumn 40, Issue 1, 2010, Pages 63-81

  Tam, Waikeung ^a  

^a NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF SINGAPORE   (Singapore)

Author keywords

China; Health care; Privatisation; Public hospitals; Regulation

Indexed keywords

EID: 72049084538     PISSN: 00472336     EISSN: 17527554     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/00472330903270700     Document Type: Article

References (70)

1. An, Ran (2005) "Bingshan zhixia de yiyuan chanyelian" [Hospital Production Chain that is Under the Ice Mountain], Zhongguo xinwen zhoukan [China Newsweek], 26 September, pp. 23-7.
2. Bai, Jianfeng (2006) "Weishengbu buzhang Gao Qiang: gongli yiyuan yao gongyi buying zhuli" [Gao Qiang Minister of Health: Public Hospitals should Pursue Charity not Profit-making], Renmin ribao [People's Daily], 13 January, p. 5.
3. Bo, Jie (2006) "Feiyingli yiyuan zugei shangren shu yanzhong weigui" [Leasing of Not-for-profit Hospital to Businessmen Breached the Regulation], Shanghai zhengjuan bao [Shanghai Securities News], 22 November, http://finance.sina.com.cn/stock/t/20061122/00001055000.shtml (downloaded 3 April 2007).
4. Browne, A. (2005) "Health Crisis: Chinese Doctors Tell Patients to Pay Upfront, or No Treatment, " The Wall Street Journal, 5 December, p. A1.
5. Cai, J. (2005) "Patients Lose Eyes after Infection in Cataract Surgery, " South China Morning Post, 24 December, p. 5.
6. Cao, Haidong (2005) "Suqian yigai, wunian jibian" [Suqian's Health Care Reform Brought Five-year Radical Changes], Nanfang zhoumo [Southern Weekend], 21 July.
7. Chen, Dingrong and Chang Wei (2005) "Gongli yiyuan zaitong zhengfu boyi," [Public Hospitals are Maneuvering with the Government], Zhongguo weisheng [Chinese Health], 11, pp. 25-7.
8. Chen, Yong, Lu Dajun and An Dong (2005) "Weisheng jiandu tizhi gaige qianxing jiannan" [Difficulties of Promoting Health Care Regulatory Reform], Zhongguo weisheng [Chinese Health], 1, pp. 47-8.
9. China Central Television (2005a) "Daji feifa xingyi zhi yiyuan keshi chengbao neimu" [A Campaign Against Illegal Medical Practice: Inside Story of Contracting Clinical Departments to Outside Parties Within Public Hospitals], http://news.sina.com.cn/s/2005-10-18/10008041109.shtml, 18 October (downloaded 18 October 2005).
10. China Central Television (2005b) "Weiyisheng zijie yiliao heimu" [Quacks Exposed Illicit Medical Practices], http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2005-10-21/11218074828.shtml, 21 October (downloaded 22 October 2005).
11. China Central Television (2007) "Nanjing Qinhuaiqu shidian yigai xinzheng" [Nanjing Qinhuai District Implements Pilot Health Care Reform],http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2007-08-18/013513688279.shtml http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2007-08-18/013513688279.shtml, 18 August (downloaded 22 August 2007).
12. China Youth Daily (2005) "Yijia shuangmian dianxing yiyuan de jiepou" [An Analysis of a Typical Double-face Hospital], Zhongguo qingnian bao [China Youth Daily], 26 October, http://news. sina.com.cn/c/2005-10-26/04487265187s.shtml (downloaded 29 October 2005).
13. Chinese Business View (2006) "Gaige dengyu chuzu?" [Is Reform Equal to Contracting Out?], Huashang bao [Chinese Business View], 22 November, http://news.sina.com.cn/o/2006-11-22/063810564167s.shtml (downloaded 3 April 2007).
14. Chinese Health (2007) "Quanguo bacheng chengshi kaizhan shequ weisheng fuwu" [80% of Cities Nationwide have Implemented Community Health Services], Zhongguo weisheng [Chinese Health], 3, p. 70.
15. Development Research Centre of the State Council (2005) "Zhongguo yiliao weisheng tizhi gaige baogao" [Report on the Reform of China's Health Care System], Zhongguo fazhan pinglun [Commentary on China's Development], 7, March, pp. 1-144.
16. Ding, Zhulin (2007) "Shouzhi liangtiaoxian" [Separation of Revenue and Expenditure], Zhongguo weisheng [Chinese Health], 6, pp. 16-17.
17. Dong, Bishui (2005) "Yiyuan bushi shehui jiuzhu de zuihuo fangxian" [Hospital is Not the Last Resort of Social Relief], Zhongguo qingnian bao [China Youth Daily], 18 November, http://news.sina.com.cn/s/ 2005-11-18/05157469769s.shtml (downloaded 23 November 2005).
18. Du, Hailan (2005) "Weishengbu: daji feifa xingyi bulizhe jiangyao zhuijiu lingdao zeren" [Ministry of Health: Leaders who are Lax in Cracking Down Illegal Medical Practice will be Held Accountable], Fazhi ribao [Legal Daily], 28 December, http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2005-12-28/08157836670s.shtml (downloaded 5 February 2006)
19. Du, Lexun, Zhang Wenming and Wang Zemin (eds) (2006) Zhongguo yiliao weisheng fazhan baogao di er hao [The Development Report on China's Health No. 2], Beijing: Social Sciences Academic Press.
20. Feigenbaum, H., J. Henig and C. Hamnett (1998) Shrinking the State: The Political Underpinnings of Privatisation, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
21. French, H. (2006) "Wealth Grows, but Health Care Withers in China," The New York Times, 14 January, p. A1.
22. Gu, E. and J. Zhang (2006) "Health Care Regime Change in Urban China: Unmanaged Marketization and Reluctant Privatisation," Pacific Affairs, 79, 1, pp. 49-71.
23. Henderson, G. and M. Cohen (1984) The Chinese Hospital: A Socialist Work Unit, New Haven: Yale University Press.
24. Hu, Ling and Zhu Yuchen (2005) "Youyi de jianghu" [The World of Quacks], hongguo xinwen zhoukan [China Newsweek], 26 September, pp. 20-3.
25. Huang, Yong (2006) "Yigai diaocha, Suqian moshi" [Investigation of the Suqian Model of Health Care Reform], Zhongguo qingnian bao [China Youth Daily], 23 March, http://politics.people.com.cn/GB/ 14562/4228458.html (downloaded 23 March 2006).
26. Jiang, Bing and Yongquan Tian (2001) "The Development of Xiangya Hospital as a Model for Chinese Hospitals," The Yale-China Health Journal, 1, 1, pp. 47-60.
27. Jie, Wei (2005a) "Jiceng weisheng jiandu duiwu zhi guai xianxiang" [Some Strange Phenomena among Health Care Regulators at the Lower Administrative Levels], Zhongguo weisheng [Chinese Health], 9, p. 45.
28. Jie, Wei (2005b) "Guanzhu feifa xingyi xin dongxiang" [On the New Situation of Illicit Medical Practice], Zhongguo weisheng [Chinese Health], 12, p. 49.
29. Jinan Times (2006) "Ruci yiyuan gaige ying yansu chachu" [Illegal Hospital Reform should be Investigated Seriously], Jinan shibao [Jinan Times], 25 November 2006, http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2006- 11-25/032910591043s.shtml (downloaded 3 April 2007).
30. Legal Daily (2005) "Anhui Suzhou yanqiu shijian baochu yishang hezuo jianguan ruanruo wuli" [Anhui Suzhou Eyeball Incident Exposed Ineffective Regulation Concerning Hospital-Business Co-operation], Fazhi ribao [Legal Daily], 28 December 2005, http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2005-12-28/08157836661s.shtml (downloaded 30 December 2005).
31. Liang, Wenjun (2006) "Hebei xianji gongli yuanli gaizhi mobu zhunmai" [Uncertain Reform of County-level Public Hospitals in Hebei Province], Zhonghua gongshang shibao [China Business Times], 29 May, http://finance.sina.com.cn/chanjing/b/20060529/02342603520.shtml (downloaded 29 March 2007).
32. Lieberthal, K. and M. Oksenberg (1988) Policy Making in China, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
33. Lin, Gang et al. (2005) "Yiyuan jiansi bujiu kejiu xingze, Qingdaoshi jijiu yiliao jiang tuixing wenzezhi" [Hospitals can be Prosecuted for Denying Treatment to Persons who are on the Verge of Death, Qingdao City Implements Responsibility System of Emergency Medical Treatment], Bandao dushibao [Peninsular Metropolitan News], 28 August, http://www.bandao.cn/news/showdetail.asp?id=123933 (downloaded 30 August 2005).
34. Liu, Huaining (2006) "Guangdong mouxie difang zhengfu jingyao yiyuan fanbu" [Some Local Governments in Guangdong Demand Financial Support from Hospitals], Yangcheng wanbao [Guangzhou Evening News], 4 January, http://www.ycwb.com/gb/content/2006-01/04/content_1049488. htm (downloaded 18 January 2006).
35. Liu, Junmin (2007) "Gongli yiyuan shouzhi liangtiaoxian hexing ma?" [Is it Feasible for Public Hospitals to be Completely Financed by the Government?], Zhongguo weisheng [Chinese Health], 3, pp. 42-6.
36. Liu, Xiao and Zhou Jianhong (2006) "Jiumu shijian huhuan wanshan shehui jiuzhu tixi" [The Incident of Saving Mother Calls for the Improvement of Social Relief System], Guangzhou ribao [Guangzhou Daily], 2 February, http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2006-02-02/11098115501s.shtml (downloaded 10 February 2006).
37. Maarse, H. (2006) "The Privatisation of Health Care in Europe: An Eight-Country Analysis," Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 31, 5, pp. 981-1014.
38. Ministry of Health (2007) Zhongguo weisheng tongji nianjian 2007 [China's Health Statistical Yearbook 2007], Beijing: Peking Union Medical College Press.
39. Ministry of Health (2008), Zhongguo weisheng tongji nianjian 2008 [China's Health Statistical Yearbook 2008], Beijing: Peking Union Medical College Press.
40. People's Net (2006) "Erqiannian: mai gongli yiyuan de chanquan gaige" [Year 2000: Sale of Public Hospitals and Property Reforms], http://finance.people.com.cn/GB/8215/71080/4906992.html, 11 October (downloaded 15 October 2006).
41. People's Net (2007) "Weishengbu tongbao shierjia yiliao jigou jiang keshi chuzu yishe yuanzhongyuan" [The Ministry of Health reports that 12 Health Care Institutions Leased their Clinical Departments to Outside Parties in order to Establish Covert Hospitals], http://gov.people.com.cn/GB/46737/ 5513625.html, 23 March (downloaded 23 March 2007).
42. Saltman, R. (2002) "Regulating Incentives: The Past and Present Role of the State in Health Care Systems," Social Science & Medicine, 54, pp. 1677-84.
43. Schamis, H. (2002) Re-forming the State: The Politics of Privatisation in Latin America and Europe, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
44. Sun, Chen (2007) "Gongli yiyuan zhengfu bokuan shi wudidong" [Government Financial Backing to Public Hospitals is an Unfathomable Hole], Zhongguo jingji shibao [China's Economic Times], 3 April, http://finance.people.com.cn/GB/1045/5555668.html (downloaded 23 April 2007).
45. Sun, Cheng (2006) "Tianjin diyi yiyuan shexian chuzu chengbao keshi" [Tianjin First Hospital Contracted its Clinical Department to Outside Parties], Jinwan bao [Tonight News], 17 October, http://news. sina.com.cn/c/h/2006-10-17/145111260977.shtml (downloaded 3 April 2007).
46. Sun, Fuhai (2005) "Shandong Heze yigai huichao kaoyan zhengfu shichang bawo nengli" [Reversal of Health Reform in Shandong Heze Tested the Capacity of the Government to Manage the Market], Gongren ribao [Workers' Daily], 24 October, http://politics.people.com.cn/GB/14562/3795052 (downloaded 7 November 2005).
47. Tian, Yi and Yang Zhenglian (2007) "Xiangzhen weishengyuan gaizhi huichao: cong chanquan paimai dao chongxin guigong" [Reversal of the Reform of Township and Village Hospitals: From Ownership Sales to Reversion to the Public Sector], Diyi caijing bao [China Business News], 1 August, http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2007-08-01/032013567397.shtml (downloaded 11 August 2007).
48. Walle, N. (1989) "Privatisation in Developing Countries: A Review of the Issues," World Development, 17, 5, pp. 601-15.
49. Wang, Gang (2005) "Putian youyi de jiazu zhuanqi" [The Story of Quacks in Putian], Zhongguo xinwen zhoukan [China Newsweek], 26 September, p. 30.
50. Wang, Ganlin (2006) "Henan gongli yiyuan gufen gaizhi: weishengju yu difang zhengfu boyi" [Stockholding Reforms of Henan Public Hospitals: Struggle between Health Bureaus and Local Governments], Fazhi zaobao [China Legal News], 8 October, http://news.sina.com.cn/c/h/2006-10-08/115411180613.shtml (downloaded 28 March 2007).
51. Wei, Mingyan (2006) "Weishengbu bianzhi zuo zhongda diaozheng, xin weisheng jianduju jiang ducha daan" [The Ministry of Health Makes Important Change to its Establishment, and the New Health Supervisory Administration will be in Charge of Important Offences], Xinjingbao [Beijing News], 23 March, http://politics.people.com.cn/GB/1027/4228064.html (downloaded 23 March 2006).
52. Whyte, M.K. and W. Parish. (1984) Urban Life in Contemporary China, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
53. Wong, L. (1994) "Privatization of Social Welfare in Post-Mao China," Asian Survey, 34, 4, pp. 307-25.
54. Workers' Daily (2005) "Feizhi keshi chengbao fagaiwei: yiliao shouru jinyu geren shouru guagou" [State Development Reform Commission: Abolish Departmental Contracting, Prohibit the Linkage of Individual Income with Revenue from Medical Services], Gongren ribao [Workers' Daily], 19 December, http://society.people.com.cn/GB/41158/3952452 (downloaded 23 December 2005).
55. Xiang Wei (2005) "Wuqian mingong bingsi Beijing tongren yiyuan shuizhize" ("Who Should Bear the Responsibility for the Death of an Indigent Migrant Laborer at Beijing Tongren Hospital?"), Huaxia shibao [China Times], 28 December 2005, http://news.sina.com.cn/s/p/2005-12-28/10548714845.shtml (downloaded 29 December 2005).
56. Xie, Maoming (2006) "Weisheng juzhang zenneng jian yiyuan yuanzhang" [How Can a Deputy Director of Health Bureau Currently Hold the Post of a Hospital's Director], Xinjingbao [Beijing News], 3 January, http://news.sina.com.cn/o/2006-01-03/03087880491s.shtml (downloaded 5 February 2006).
57. Xie, Peiyue (2005), "Zhifa weihe yanbuzheng mingbushun" [Why is Law Enforcement So Difficult?], Zhongguo weisheng [Chinese Health], 1, p. 50.
58. Xinhua Net (2004) "Shenzhen: Yiyuan jiansi bujiu jiangbei chufa sanqian yuan yishang" [Shenzhen: Hospitals will be Fined More than 3,000 yuan if they Deny Treatment to Persons who are on the Verge of Death], http://news.xinhuanet.com/newscenter/2004-09/21/content_2001003.htm, 21 September (downloaded 25 September 2004).
59. Xinhua Net (2005), "Anhui Suzhou huanzhe beizhai yanqiu diaocha: maoyi gongsi baoban shoushu" [An Investigation of the Removal of Eyeballs of Patients in Anhui Suzhou: Trading Company Contracted to Carry Out Surgery], http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2005-12-22/21597792289s.shtml, 22 December 2005 (downloaded 28 December 2005).
60. Xinhua Net (2007), "Guangdong xiangzhen weishengyuan jiangyou caizheng quane bokuan" [Guangdong's Township and Village Hospitals will be Completely Financed by the Provincial Budget], http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2007-07-25/174213526238.shtml, 25 July (downloaded 11 August 2007).
61. Xu, Jie (2007) "Xiangzhen weishengyuan gongyouzhi mingcun shiwang" [Is Public Ownership of Township and Village Hospitals Dead?], Zhongguo weisheng [Chinese Health], 7, pp. 40-2.
62. Xu, Lishan (2006) "Daqi jumin de waizhuyi: shequ yiyuan jingxiang chengbao keshi changkai" [Seeking to Take Advantage of Citizens: A Community Hospital Contracted Out its Clinical Department], Shichang bao [Market News], 29 March, p. 4.
63. Yan, Li (2004) "Gaizhi buneng gaidiao yiyuan tianzhi" [Reform Cannot Take Away Hospitals' Holy Duty], Shidaichao [Times Current], 22, http://www.people.com.cn/GB/paper83/13543/1212898.html (downloaded 21 May 2006).
64. Ye, Yiwen (2006) "Fang Tingyu pouxi yiyuan jiansi bujiu" [Fang Tingyu Analyzes Why Hospitals do Not Save Patients who are on the Verge of Death], Jiankang shibao [Health Times], 13 March, p. 2.
65. Zhan, Chuhang (2007) "Weisheng jiandu zhiyue rengzai jiceng" [Weaknesses of Health Care Supervision Remain at the Lower Administrative Level], Zhongguo weisheng [Chinese Health], 5, p. 85.
66. Zhang, Yi and Huang Sujuan (2004) "Qianfei yiliao zhizhi jiuzhu baozhang ruanlei" [Outstanding Medical Fees Highlight Weaknesses in Medical Relief Protection], Jiangnan shibao [Southern Jiangsu Times], 21 August, http://www.people.com.cn/GB/paper447/12753/1146014.html (downloaded 20 April 2006).
67. Zheng, Xueqian and K. Liu (2005) "Waibao keshi: shigu duofa diduan" [Medical Conflicts and Malpractices Happened Frequently in Contracted Clinical Departments], Zhongguo weisheng [Chinese Health], 7, pp. 23-5.
68. Zheng, Y. (2002) "State Rebuilding, Popular Protest and Collective Action in China," Japanese Journal of Political Science, 3, 1, pp. 45-70.
69. Zhong, Ang (2005) "Heze yigai mitu: gongli yiyuan bannian quan maiguang yigeyue you shouhui" [Heze Health Reform Lost Way: Sale of Public Hospitals within Half a Year but Taking Back within One Month], Jingji guancha bao [The Economic Observer], 29 October, http://finance.sina.com.cn/chanjing/b/ 20051029/11222077469.shtml (downloaded 29 October 2005).
70. Zuo, Qinglin (2007) "Weishengbu diaoyan gongli yiyuan gaizhi"[Ministry of Health Investigates Reform of Public Hospitals], Ershiyi shiji jingji baodao [21st Century Business Herald], 12 April.