How to define and measure concordance between patients' preferences and medical treatments: A systematic review of approaches and recommendations for standardization

Patient Education and Counseling

Volumn 78, Issue 1, 2010, Pages 12-23

  Sepucha, Karen ^a   Ozanne, Elissa M ^a  

^a MASSACHUSETTS GENERAL HOSPITAL   (United States)

Author keywords

Decision making; Decisions; Measurement; Patient centered; Quality

Indexed keywords

CLINICAL TRIAL; COCHRANE LIBRARY; CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK; HUMAN; PARAMETERS OF MEASUREMENT AND ANALYSIS; PATIENT CARE; PATIENT DECISION MAKING; PATIENT PARTICIPATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SHORT SURVEY; STANDARDIZATION; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; TREATMENT PLANNING;

ALGORITHMS; CHOICE BEHAVIOR; DECISION MAKING; DECISION THEORY; HUMANS; PATIENT SATISFACTION; PATIENT-CENTERED CARE;

EID: 70549085782     PISSN: 07383991     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.pec.2009.05.011     Document Type: Short Survey

References (71)

1. Eddy D. Clinical decision making: from theory to practice. Anatomy of a decision. JAMA 263 3 (1990) 441-443
2. Tunis S. Reflections on science, judgment, and value in evidence-based decision making: a conversation with David Eddy. Health Aff (Millwood) 26 4 (2007) w500-w515
3. In: Hurtado M., Swift E., and Corrigan J. (Eds). Envisioning the National Health Care Quality Report (2001), National Academy Press, Washington, DC
4. Committee on Quality Health Care in America IoM. Crossing the quality chasm: a new health system for the 21st century (2001), National Academy Press, Washington, DC
5. AHRQ. National Healthcare Quality Report. Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, 2005:accessed on September 10, 2007 at http://www.ahrq.gov/qual/nhqr05/nhqr05.htm.
6. Schoen COR, Huynh PT, Doty M, Davis K, Zapert K, Peugh J. Primary care and health system performance: adults' experiences in five countries. Health Aff (Millwood) 2004;July-December;Suppl(Web Exclusives):W4-487-503.
7. Shaller D. Patient-centered care: what does it take? Picker Institute and Commonwealth Fund, 2007:accessed on September 10, 2007 at http://www.pickerinstitute.org/documents/PI%20Shaller%20Final%20Report.pdf.
8. Hammond J., Keeney R., and Raiffa H. Smart choices: a guide to making better decisions (1998), Harvard Business School Press, Cambridge
9. O'Connor A.M.T.P., Wells G.A., Elmslie T., Jolly E., Hollingworth G., McPherson R.B.H., Graham I., and Drake E. A decision aid for women considering hormone therapy after menopause: decision support framework and evaluation. Patient Educ Couns 33 Mar (3) (1998) 267-279
10. Ratliff A., Angell M., Dow R., Kuppermann M., Nease R.J., Fisher R., Fisher E.S., Redelmeier D.A., Faughnan M.E., Rimer B.K., Pauker S.P., Pauker S.G., and Sox H.C. What is a good decision?. Eff Clin Pract 2 4 (1999) 185-197
11. Kennedy A. On what basis should the effectiveness of decision aids be judged?. Health Expect 6 3 (2003) 255-268
12. Briss P., Rimer B., Reilley B., Coates R.C., Lee N.C., Mullen P., Corso P., Hutchinson A.B., Hiatt R., Kerner J., George P., White C., Gandhi N., Saraiya M., Breslow R., Isham G., Teutsch S.M., Hinman A.R., and Lawrence R. Promoting informed decisions about cancer screening in communities and healthcare systems. Am J Prev Med 26 1 (2004) 67-80
13. Sepucha K.R., Fowler F.J.J., and Mulley A.J. Policy support for patient-centered care: the need for measurable improvements in decision quality. Health Aff (Millwood) 7 October(Web exclusive supplement) (2004) VAR54-VAR62
14. Wennberg JE, Fisher ES, Skinner JS. Geography and the debate over Medicare reform. Health Aff (Millwood) 2002;Suppl Web Exclusives:W96-114.
15. Wennberg JE. Practice variations and health care reform: connecting the dots. Health Aff (Millwood) 2004;Suppl Web Exclusives:VAR140-4.
16. Botwin M.D., Buss D.M., and Shackelford T.K. Personality and mate preferences: five factors in mate selection and marital satisfaction. J Pers 65 1 (1997) 107-136
17. Barry M.J., Fowler Jr. F.J., Mulley Jr. A.G., Henderson Jr. J.V., and Wennberg J.E. Patient reactions to a program designed to facilitate patient participation in treatment decisions for benign prostatic hyperplasia. Med Care 33 8 (1995) 771-782
18. Holmes-Rovner M., Kroll J., Rovner D.R., Schmitt N., Rothert M., Padonu G., and Talarczyk G. Patient decision support intervention: increased consistency with decision analytic models. Med Care 37 3 (1999) 270-284
19. O'Connor A.M., Wells G.A., Tugwell P., Laupacis A., Elmslie T., and Drake E. The effects of an 'explicit' values clarification exercise in a woman's decision aid regarding postmenopausal hormone therapy. Health Expect 2 1 (1999) 21-32
20. Elwyn G., O'Connor A., Stacey D., Volk R., Edwards A., Coulter A., Thomson R., Barratt A., Barry M., Bernstein S., Butow P., Clarke A., Entwistle V., Feldman-Stewart D., Holmes-Rovner M., Llewellyn-Thomas H., Moumjid N., Mulley A., Ruland C., Sepucha K., Sykes A., and Whelan T. Developing a quality criteria framework for patient decision aids: online international Delphi consensus process. BMJ 333 7565 (2006) 417
21. NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination. Undertaking Systematic Reviews of Research on Effectiveness: CRD's advice for carrying out or commissioning reviews. CRD Report 4 (2nd edition). York: University of York; 2001:accessed on June 14, 2006 at http://www.york.ac.uk/inst/crd/report4.htm.
22. In: Higgins J., and Green S. (Eds). Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions (version 4.2.6) (2006), Wiley, Chichester
23. Albert S.M., Murphy P.L., Del Bene M.L., and Rowland L.P. A prospective study of preferences and actual treatment choices in ALS. Neurology 53 2 (1999) 278-283
24. Ananian P., Houvenaeghel G., Protiere C., Rouanet P., Arnaud S., Moatti J.P., Tallet A., Braud A.C., and Julian-Reynier C. Determinants of patients' choice of reconstruction with mastectomy for primary breast cancer. Ann Surg Oncol 11 8 (2004) 762-771
25. Barrett P.H., Beck A., Schmid K., Fireman B., and Brown J.B. Treatment decisions about lumbar herniated disk in a shared decision-making program. Jt Comm J Qual Improv 28 5 (2002) 211-219
26. Beusterien K.M., Dziekan K., Flood E., Harding G., and Jordan J.C. Understanding patient preferences for HIV medications using adaptive conjoint analysis: feasibility assessment. Value Health 8 4 (2005) 453-461
27. Brundage M.D., Feldman-Stewart D., Cosby R., Gregg R., Dixon P., Youssef Y., Davies D., and Mackillop W.J. Phase I study of a decision aid for patients with locally advanced non-small-cell lung cancer. J Clin Oncol 19 5 (2001) 1326-1335
28. Carter W.B., Beach L.R., Inui T.S., Kirscht J.P., and Prodzinski J.C. Developing and testing a decision model for predicting influenza vaccination compliance. Health Serv Res 20 6 Pt 2 (1986) 897-932
29. Casarett D., Van Ness P.H., O'Leary J.R., and Fried T.R. Are patient preferences for life-sustaining treatment really a barrier to hospice enrollment for older adults with serious illness?. J Am Geriatr Soc 54 3 (2006) 472-478
30. Christensen-Szalanski J.J. Discount functions and the measurement of patients' values. Women's decisions during childbirth. Med Decis Making 4 1 (1984) 47-58
31. Clancy C.M., Cebul R.D., and Williams S.V. Guiding individual decisions: a randomized, controlled trial of decision analysis. Am J Med 84 2 (1988) 283-288
32. Danis M., Southerland L.I., Garrett J.M., Smith J.L., Hielema F., Pickard C.G., Egner D.M., and Patrick D.L. A prospective study of advance directives for life-sustaining care. N Engl J Med 324 13 (1991) 882-888
33. Denberg T.D., Melhado T.V., and Steiner J.F. Patient treatment preferences in localized prostate carcinoma: the influence of emotion, misconception, and anecdote. Cancer 107 3 (2006) 620-630
34. Dolan J.G., and Frisina S. Randomized controlled trial of a patient decision aid for colorectal cancer screening. Med Decis Making 22 2 (2002) 125-139
35. Dwight-Johnson M., Unutzer J., Sherbourne C., Tang L., and Wells K.B. Can quality improvement programs for depression in primary care address patient preferences for treatment?. Med Care 39 9 (2001) 934-944
36. Figueiredo M.I., Cullen J., Hwang Y.T., Rowland J.H., and Mandelblatt J.S. Breast cancer treatment in older women: does getting what you want improve your long-term body image and mental health?. J Clin Oncol 22 19 (2004) 4002-4009
37. Heckerling P.S., Verp M.S., and Hadro T.A. Preferences of pregnant women for amniocentesis or chorionic villus sampling for prenatal testing: comparison of patients' choices and those of a decision-analytic model. J Clin Epidemiol 47 11 (1994) 1215-1228
38. Hornberger J.C., Habraken H., and Bloch D.A. Minimum data needed on patient preferences for accurate, efficient medical decision making. Med Care 33 3 (1995) 297-310
39. Kakoko D.C., Astrom A.N., Lugoe W.L., and Lie G.T. Predicting intended use of voluntary HIV counselling and testing services among Tanzanian teachers using the theory of planned behaviour. Soc Sci Med 63 4 (2006) 991-999
40. Koedoot C.G., de Haan R.J., Stiggelbout A.M., Stalmeier P.F., de Graeff A., Bakker P.J., and de Haes J.C. Palliative chemotherapy or best supportive care? A prospective study explaining patients' treatment preference and choice. Br J Cancer 89 12 (2003) 2219-2226
41. Krumins P.E., Fihn S.D., and Kent D.L. Symptom severity and patients' values in the decision to perform a transurethral resection of the prostate. Med Decis Making 8 1 (1988) 1-8
42. Kuppermann M., Learman L.A., Gates E., Gregorich S.E., Nease Jr. R.F., Lewis J., and Washington A.E. Beyond race or ethnicity and socioeconomic status: predictors of prenatal testing for Down syndrome. Obstet Gynecol 107 5 (2006) 1087-1097
43. Lee M.A., Smith D.M., Fenn D.S., and Ganzini L. Do patients' treatment decisions match advance statements of their preferences?. J Clin Ethics 9 3 (1998) 258-262
44. Lerman C., Biesecker B., Benkendorf J.L., Kerner J., Gomez-Caminero A., Hughes C., and Reed M.M. Controlled trial of pretest education approaches to enhance informed decision-making for BRCA1 gene testing. J Natl Cancer Inst 89 2 (1997) 148-157
45. Lin P., Campbell D.G., Chaney E.F., Liu C.F., Heagerty P., Felker B.L., and Hedrick S.C. The influence of patient preference on depression treatment in primary care. Ann Behav Med 30 2 (2005) 164-173
46. Lin W.C., and Ball C. Factors affecting the decision of nursing students in Taiwan to be vaccinated against hepatitis B infection. J Adv Nurs 25 4 (1997) 709-718
47. Marteau T.M., Dormandy E., and Michie S. A measure of informed choice. Health Expect 4 2 (2001) 99-108
48. Minnis A.M., Shiboski S.C., and Padian N.S. Barrier contraceptive method acceptability and choice are not reliable indicators of use. Sex Transm Dis 30 7 (2003) 556-561
49. Molenaar S., Oort F., Sprangers M., Rutgers E., Luiten E., Mulder J., and de Haes H. Predictors of patients' choices for breast-conserving therapy or mastectomy: a prospective study. Br J Cancer 90 11 (2004) 2123-2130
50. Montgomery A.A., Fahey T., and Peters T.J. A factorial randomised controlled trial of decision analysis and an information video plus leaflet for newly diagnosed hypertensive patients. Br J Gen Pract 53 491 (2003) 446-453
51. Patrick D.L., Pearlman R.A., Starks H.E., Cain K.C., Cole W.G., and Uhlmann R.F. Validation of preferences for life-sustaining treatment: implications for advance care planning. Ann Intern Med 127 7 (1997) 509-517
52. Pritchard R.S., Fisher E.S., Teno J.M., Sharp S.M., Reding D.J., Knaus W.A., Wennberg J.E., and Lynn J. Influence of patient preferences and local health system characteristics on the place of death. SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Risks and Outcomes of Treatment. J Am Geriatr Soc 46 10 (1998) 1242-1250
53. Reynolds R.F., Obermeyer C.M., Walker A.M., and Guilbert D. The role of treatment intentions and concerns about side effects in women's decision to discontinue postmenopausal hormone therapy. Maturitas 43 3 (2002) 183-194
54. Rimer B.K., Conaway M.R., Lyna P.R., Rakowski W., Woods-Powell C.T., Tessaro I., Yarnall K.S., and Barber L.T. Cancer screening practices among women in a community health center population. Am J Prev Med 12 5 (1996) 351-357
55. Rothert M.L., Holmes-Rovner M., Rovner D., Kroll J., Breer L., Talarczyk G., Schmidt N., Pedona G., and Willis C. An educational intervention as decision support for menopausal women. Res Nurs Health 20 5 (1997) 377-387
56. Schapira M.M., Gilligan M.A., McAuliffe T.L., and Nattinger A.B. Menopausal hormone therapy decisions: insights from a multi-attribute model. Patient Educ Couns 52 1 (2004) 89-95
57. Sepucha K., Ozanne E., Silvia K., Partridge A., and Mulley Jr. A.G. An approach to measuring the quality of breast cancer decisions. Patient Educ Couns 65 2 (2007) 261-269
58. Shorten A., Shorten B., Keogh J., West S., and Morris J. Making choices for childbirth: a randomized controlled trial of a decision-aid for informed birth after cesarean. Birth: Issues Perinat Care 32 4 (2005) 252-261
59. Srebnik D.S., and Russo J. Consistency of psychiatric crisis care with advance directive instructions. Psychiatr Serv 58 9 (2007) 1157-1163
60. Stanton A.L., Estes M.A., Estes N.C., Cameron C.L., Danoff-Burg S., and Irving L.M. Treatment decision making and adjustment to breast cancer: a longitudinal study. J Consult Clin Psychol 66 2 (1998) 313-322
61. Temple W.J., Russell M.L., Parsons L.L., Huber S.M., Jones C.A., Bankes J., and Eliasziw M. Conservation surgery for breast cancer as the preferred choice: a prospective analysis. J Clin Oncol 24 21 (2006) 3367-3373
62. Teno J.M., Fisher E., Hamel M.B., Wu A.W., Murphy D.J., Wenger N.S., Lynn J., and Harrell F. Decision-making and outcomes of prolonged ICU stays in seriously ill patients. J Am Geriatr Soc 48 5 (2000) S70-S74
63. van den Berg M., Timmermans D.R., Ten Kate L.P., van Vugt J.M., and van der Wal G. Informed decision making in the context of prenatal screening. Patient Educ Couns (2005)
64. van Tol-Geerdink J.J., Stalmeier P.F., van Lin E.N., Schimmel E.C., Huizenga H., van Daal W.A., and Leer J.W. Do patients with localized prostate cancer treatment really want more aggressive treatment?. J Clin Oncol 24 28 (2006) 4581-4586
65. Vuorma S., Rissanen P., Aalto A.M., Kujansuu E., Hurskainen R., and Teperi J. Factors predicting choice of treatment for menorrhagia in gynaecology outpatient clinics. Soc Sci Med 56 8 (2003) 1653-1660
66. Wall E.M. Development of a decision aid for women choosing a method of birth control. J Fam Pract 21 5 (1985) 351-355
67. Way B.B. Relationships between patient, family, and significant other disposition preferences in psychiatric emergency services and the clinical symptom ratings and disposition decisions of psychiatrists. Psychiatr Rehabil J 29 2 (2005) 132-137
68. Wroe A.L. Intentional and unintentional non adherence: a study of decision making. J Behav Med 25 4 (2002) 355-372
69. Frosch D., Kaplan R., and Felitti V. The evaluation of two methods to facilitate shared decision-making for men considering the prostate-specific antigen test. J Gen Intern Med 16 6 (2001) 391-398
70. Peele P., Siminoff L., Xu Y., and Ravdin P. Decreased use of adjuvant breast cancer therapy in a randomized controlled trial of a decision aid with individualized risk information. Med Decis Making 25 3 (2005) 301-307
71. Kravitz R.L., and Melnikow J. Engaging patients in medical decision making. BMJ 323 7313 (2001) 584-585