Examining our assumptions - Have oversimplifications jeopardized our ability to design optimal fracture treatments?

Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Hydraulic Fracturing Technology Conference 2009

Volumn , Issue , 2009, Pages 172-222

  Vincent, M C ^a  

^a Insight Consulting   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

BOREHOLES; COAL DEPOSITS; FLOW OF FLUIDS; HYDRAULIC FRACTURING; METHANE; OIL FIELD EQUIPMENT; OIL WELLS; PETROLEUM RESERVOIRS; TIGHT GAS;

COMPLICATED GEOMETRY; CONDUCTIVITY DATA; FRACTURE GEOMETRIES; FRACTURE TREATMENT; PLANAR STRUCTURE; REAL-WORLD COMPLEXITY; SIMPLIFYING ASSUMPTIONS; VERTICAL FRACTURE;

FRACTURE;

EID: 70449587531     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Conference Proceeding    
DOI: 10.2118/119143-ms     Document Type: Conference Paper

References (82)

1. API, American Petroleum Institute, 1983. Recommended Practices for Testing Sand Used in Hydraulic Fracturing Operations, API RP 56, First edition March 1983, Second edition published December 1995.
2. Aud, W.W. et al (2001). Lateral Proppant Distribution: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly of Putting Frac Jobs Away. SPE paper 70132, SPED&E, March 2001, revised from SPE 56725.
3. Bagzis, J.M. (1989). Refracturing pays off in the Rangely field. World Oil Nov 1989 39-44.
4. Barree, R.D., et al.: Realistic Assessment of Proppant Pack Conductivity for Material Selection. SPE paper 84306 presented at the 2003 Annual Technical Conference, October 5-8.
5. Besler, M.R. et al, 2007: Improving Well Productivity and Profitability in the Bakken - A Summary of Our Experiences Drilling, Stimulating, and Operating Horizontal Wells. Paper SPE 110679 presented at the 2007 Annual Technical Conference, Anaheim, Nov. 11-14.
6. Blackwood, K. et al. 2008. Applying Science and Best Practices to Increase Production and Optimize Economics in a West Texas Gas Field - A Canyon Sand Case Study. Paper SPE 117538 presented at the 2008 SPE Eastern Regional Meeting, Pittsburgh, Oct. 11-15.
7. Boyer, C.M. II et al. 1986: Measurement of Coalbed Properties for Hydraulic Fracture Design and Methane Production. SPE paper 15258 presented at the 1986 Unconventional Gas Technology Symposium, Louisville, KY, May 18-21.
8. Branagan, P.T. et al 1996: Characterization of a Remotely Intersected Set of Hydraulic Fractures: Results of Intersection Well No. 1-B, GRI/DOE Multi-Site Project. SPE paper 36452 presented at the 1996 Annual Technical Conference, Denver, Oct 6-9.
9. Brannon, H.D. et al. 2004: Maximizing Fracture Conductivity with Partial Monolayers: Theoretical Curiosity or Highly Productive Reality? SPE paper 90698 presented as the 2004 Annual Technical Conference, Houston, Sept 26-29.
10. Burton, R.C. 1999. Use of Perforation-Tunnel Permeability to Assess Cased Hole Gravelpack Performance. Paper 59558, SPED&C 14 (4), Dec 1999, 235-239.
11. Cipolla, C.L., and Kyte, D.G. 1992: Infill Drilling in the Moxa Arch: A Case History of the Frontier Formation. SPE 24909 presented at the 1992 Annual Technology Conference, Washington D.C., Oct 4-7.
12. Cipolla, C.L., Meehan, D.N., Stevens, P.L. 1993: Hydraulic Fracture Performance in the Moxa Arch Frontier Formation, paper SPE 25918 presented at the 1993 Rocky Mountain Regional Meeting, Denver, Apr 26-28.
13. Cipolla, C.L. et al. 2008. The Relationship between Fracture Complexity, Reservoir Properties, and Fracture Treatment Design. Paper SPE 115769 presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference, Denver, Sep. 21-24.
14. Cinco-Ley, H. and Samaniego-V., F. 1981: "Transient Pressure Analysis for Fractured Wells," JPT (September, 1981) 1749.
15. Clawson, T. 2003: Production Enhancement in a Low Pressure CBM Reservoir - Apache Canyon Area. Presented at the IPAMS conference, Denver, April 16, 2003.
16. Cramer, D.D. 1995. The Evolution of Hydraulic Fracturing in the Almond Formation. Paper SPE 30480 presented at the Annual Technical Conference, Dallas, Oct 22-25.
17. Dedurin, A.V. et al 2006: Designing Hydraulic Fractures in Russian Oil and Gas Fields to Accommodate Non-Darcy and Multiphase Flow - Theory and Field Examples. SPE Paper 101821 presented at the 2006 Russian Oil and Gas Technical Conference, Moscow, Oct. 3-6.
18. Delaney, P.T. et al: Field Relations between Dikes and Joints: Emplacement Processes and Paleostress Analysis. Journal of Geophysical Research 91 (B5): 4920-4938.
19. Diamond, W.P. and Oyler, D.C.: Effects of Stimulation Treatments on Coalbeds and Surrounding Strata - Evidence from Underground Observations. Bureau of Mines, Report of Investigations 9083.
20. Economides, M.J et al: Unified Fracture Design, Orsa Press, Houston, May 2002.
21. Elsworth, D., and Fairhurst, C. (2006): Technical Report: Geo-Science and Geo-Engineering Research at DUSEL, prepared for the National Science Foundation, Oct. 9, 2006.
22. Ennis, B.K. 1989: Case History of Restimulations in Western Oklahoma. SPE 18861 presented at the 1989 SPE Production Operations Symposium, Oklahoma City, Mar. 13-14.
23. Fast, R.E. et al. 1992: Description and Analysis of Cored Hydraulic Fractures, Lost Hills Field, Kern County, California. SPE paper 24853 presented at the 1992 Annual Technical Conference, Washington DC Oct 4-7.
24. Finch, R.W. et al. 1996. Evolution of Completion and Fracture Stimulation Practices in the Jonah Field, Sublette County, WY. SPE paper 36734 presented at the 1996 Annual Technical Conference, Denver Oct 6-9.
25. Fisher, M.K. et al. 2002. Integrating Fracture Mapping Technologies to Optimize Stimulations. Paper SPE 77441 presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference, San Antonio, Sep. 29-Oct. 2.
26. Fleming, M.E. et al. 1992: Successful Refracturing in the North Westbrook Unit. Paper SPE 24011 presented at the 1992 Permian Basin Oil and Gas Recovery Conference, Midland, March 18-20.
27. Fredd, C.N. et al: 2001. Experimental Study of Fracture Conductivity for Water-Fracturing and Conventional Fracturing Applications. SPEJ(Sept 2001) 288-298. SPE 74138.
28. Gulrajani, S.N., Nolte, K.G. Romero, J. 2001: Evaluation of the M-Site B-Sand Fracture Experiments: Evolution of a Pressure Analysis Methodology. SPE paper 69206, SPEFE, Feb 2001.
29. Haas, M.R., McFall, K.S., Coates, J.-M.P., 1989. Technology Advances Unlock the Potential of the Tight Frontier Formation in the Moxa Arch. SPE 18962 presented at the 1989 Rocky Mountain Region Low Permeability Reservoirs Symposium, Denver March 6-8.
30. Hejl, K.A. 1992: High-Rate Refracturing: Optimization and Performance in a C02 Flood. SPE paper 24346 presented at the 1992 Rocky Mountain Regional Meeting, Casper, May 18-21.
31. Huckabee, P. et al 2005: Field Results: Effect of Proppant Strength and Sieve Distribution Upon Well Productivity. SPE paper 96559 presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference, Dallas, Oct 9-12.
32. Jeffrey, R.G. et al, 1998. Propped Fracture Geometry of Three Hydraulic Fractures in Sydney Basin Coal Seams. SPE paper 50061 presented at the 1998 Asia Pacific Oil and Gas Conference, Perth, Australia, Oct 12-14.
33. rd Annual Technical Conference, Houston, Oct 2-5.
34. Jordan, J.S. et al 2003: The Relationship between Net Pressure Development During Hydraulic Fracture Treatments and Productivity in Fruitland Coal Completions. SPE paper 84819 presented at the Eastern Regional Meeting, Pittsburgh, Sept 6-10.
35. JPT Online, March 2006: Techbits: Refracturing in Low-Permeability Reservoirs. SPE editorial summary of presentation by Devin Brown entitled "Refracturing in the Fruitland Coal" presented at ATW, San Antonio.
36. Lambert, S.W. et al. 1989: Warrior Basin Drilling, Stimulation Covered. OGJ, Nov 13, 1989, 87-92.
37. Lehman, L.V. et al. 1998: Desorption Enhancement in Fracture-Stimulated Coalbed Methane Wells. SPE paper 51063 presented at the 2998 Eastern Regional Conference, Pittsburgh, Nov 9-11.
38. McCabe, M.A. et al. 1999: Investigation of a New Fracturing Fluid and Conductivity Enhancement Technology on Coalbed Methane Production. SPE paper 52193 presented at the 1999 Mid-Continent Operations Symposium, Oklahoma City, Mar 28-31.
39. McDaniel, B.W. 1990: Hydraulic Fracturing Techniques Used for Stimulation of Coalbed Methane Wells. SPE paper 21292 presented at the 1990 Eastern Regional Meeting, Columbus OH, Oct 31-Nov 2.
40. McGuire, W. J., et al 1960: The Effect of Vertical Fractures on Well Productivity. SPE paper 1618-G, Journal of Petroleum Technology (October 1960) 12, pp. 72-74:
41. also in Trans., AIME (1960), 219.
42. Montgomery, K.T., Holditch, S.A., and Berthelot, J.M. 1990: Effect of Fracture Fluid Invasion on Cleanup Behavior and Pressure Buildup Analysis. Paper SPE 20643 presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference, New Orleans, Louisiana, Sep. 23-26.
43. Nelson, D.G. et al 1996: Optimizing Hydraulic Fracture Design in the Diatomite Formation, Lost Hills Field. SPE paper 36474 presented at the 1996 Annual Technical Conference, Denver, Oct 6-9.
44. Nolte, K.G., 1993: Discussion of Examination of a Cored Hydraulic Fracture in a Deep Gas Well. SPE 26302, SPEPF Aug 1993.
45. Nolte, K.G. and Economides, M.J., 1991: Fracture Design and Validation with Uncertainty and Model Limitations. SPE 18979, JPT Sep 1991, 1147:1155.
46. Palisch, T. et al. 2007: Determining Realistic Fracture Conductivity and Understanding its Impact on Well Performance - Theory and Field Examples. SPE paper 106301 presented at the 2007 Hydraulic Fracturing Technology Conference, College Station, TX, Jan 29-31.
47. Palisch, T. et al. 2008: Slickwater Fracturing - Food for Thought. SPE paper 115766 presented at the 2008 Annual Technical Conference, Denver, Sept 21-24.
48. Palisch, T. et al. 2009: How to Use and Misuse Proppant Crush Tests - Exposing the Top 10 Myths. SPE paper 119242 presented at the 2009 Hydraulic Fracturing Technology Conference, The Woodlands, TX, Jan 19-21.
49. Palmer, I.D. et al 1991: Measurement of Induced Fractures by Downhole TV Camera in Black Warrior Basin Coalbeds. SPE paper 20660, JPT March, 1991.
50. Palmer, I.D. 1992: Review of Coalbed Methane Well Stimulation. SPE paper 22395 presented at the 1992 International Meeting on Petroleum Engineering, Beijing, Mar 24-27.
51. Pollard, D.D and Fletcher, R.C. Fundamentals of Structural Geology, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
52. Pospisil, G. et al 1992: Results of a Large-Scale Refracture Stimulation Program, Kuparuk River Unit, Alaska. SPE paper 24857 presented at the 1992 SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Washington, D.C., Oct. 4-7.
53. Prats, M. 1961: Effect of Vertical Fractures on Reservoir Behavior-Incompressible Fluid Case. SPE paper 1575-G, SPE Journal (June 1961) 1, No. 1, pp. 105-118:
54. also in Trans., AIME (1961) 222.
55. Prism 2007: Interpreting Statistical Significance; The Prism Guide to Interpreting Statistical Results, http://graphpad.com/articles/interpret/ principles/statsig.htm
56. Rodvelt, G. et al. 2001. Multiseam Coal Stimulation Using Coiled-Tubing Fracturing and a Unique Bottomhole Packer Assembly. SPE paper 72380 presented at the 2001 Eastern Regional Meeting, Canton, OH, Oct. 17-19.
57. Rogers, Will. (1879-1935) Quotation from www.famousquotes.com, 2008.
58. Schubarth, S.K., Chabaud, R.A., Einhorn, R.B. 1994: Moxa Arch Frontier Formation Development Success Through Increased Fracture Conductivity. SPE 28610 presented at the 1994 Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, New Orleans Sep 25-28.
59. Schubarth, S.K., Chabaud, R.A., Penny, G.S. 1995: Moxa Arch Frontier Development Success Through Increased Fracture Conductivity - Part 2. SPE 30717 presented at the 1995 Annual Technical Conference, Dallas Oct 22-25.
60. Schubarth, S.K., Chabaud, R.A. 1998: Reservoir Description Techniques Improves Completion Economics in Moxa Arch Frontier Development Project. SPE 40037 presented at the 1998 Gas Technology Symposium, Calgary Mar 15-18.
61. Schubarth, S.K., Spivey, J.P., et al. 2006. Using Reservoir Modeling to Evaluate Stimulation Effectiveness in Multilayered "Tight" Gas Reservoirs: A Case History in the Pinedale Anticline Area. Paper SPE 100574 presented at the 2006 SPE Gas Technology Symposium, Calgary, May 15-17.
62. Sherman, J.B., and Holditch, S.A. 1991: "Effect of Injected Fracture Fluids and Operating Procedures on Ultimate Gas Recovery," paper SPE 21496 presented at the SPE Gas Technology Symposium, Houston, Texas, Jan. 23-25.
63. Smith, M.B. et al. 1982. Fracture Width-Design vs. Measurement. SPE paper 10965 presented at the 1982 Annual Fall Technical Conference, New Orleans, Sept. 26-29.
64. Smith, M.B. et al. 2004. An Investigation of Non-Darcy Flow Effects on Hydraulic Fractured Oil and Gas Well Performance. SPE paper 90864 presented at the 2004 Annual Technical Conference, Houston, Sept 26-29.
65. Soliman, M.Y., and Hunt, J.L. 1985: Effect of Fracturing Fluid and Its Cleanup on Well Performance. Paper SPE 14514 presented at the 1985 SPE Eastern Regional Meeting, Morgantown, West Virginia, Nov. 6-8.
66. Stim-Lab Proppant Conductivity and Fluid Damage Consortia, 1986-2007. Duncan, OK.
67. Stutz, H.L. et al. 2002. Calibrating Coal Bed Methane Fracture Geometry in the Helper Utah Field Using Treatment Well Tiltmeters. SPE paper 77443 presented at the 2002 Annual Technical Conference, San Antonio, Sep 29-Oct 2.
68. Talley, G.R. et al. 1999: Field Application of After-Closure Analysis of Fracture Calibration Tests. SPE paper 52220, presented at the 1999 Mid-Continent Operations Symposium, Mar 28-31.
69. Vincent, M.C. 2002: Proving It - A Review of 80 Published Field Studies Demonstrating the Importance of Increased Fracture Conductivity. SPE paper 77675 presented at the 2002 Annual Technical Conference, San Antonio, Sep 29-Oct 2.
70. Vincent, M.C. 2006: Refracs: Where do they work and why? SPE Applied Technology Workshop, Tight Gas Completions. Keystone, CO, Dec 5-7.
71. Vincent, M.C. et al 2007: Field Trial Design and Analyses of Production Data from a Tight Gas Reservoir: Detailed Production Comparisons form the Pinedale Anticline. SPE paper 106151 presented at the 2007 Hydraulic Fracturing Technology Conference, College Station, TX Jan 29-31.
72. Vincent, M.C. and Huckabee, P. 2007: Using Field Results to Guide Proppant Selection in the Pinedale Anticline. SPE paper 108991 presented at the 2007 Rocky Mountain Oil and Gas Technology Symposium, Denver, April 16-18.
73. Voneiff, G.W., Hopkins, C.W., Hill, D.G. 1997: Calculating Benefits of Advanced Stimulation Technologies. SPE 37934 presented at the 1997 Hydrocarbon Economics and Evaluation Symposium, Dallas March 16-18.
74. Warpinski, N.R. et al: Hydraulic Fracture Behavior at a Geologic Formation Interface: Pre-mineback Report. Contract No. EY-76-C-04-0789, DOE OSTI ID 6620463 (Oct, 1978).
75. Warpinski, N.R., L. D. Tyler, W. C. Vollendorf and D. A. Northrop, "Direct Observation of a Sand-Propped Hydraulic Fracture," Sandia National Laboratories Report, SAND81-0225, May 1981.
76. Warpinski, N.R. et al, 1981: Formation Interface Fracturing Experiment: An in-situ Investigation of Hydraulic Fracture Behavior near a Material Property Interface. Final Report, Contract No. AC04-76DP00789, DOE OSTI ID 60247 Sandia SAND81-0938 (Jun, 1981).
77. N. R. Warpinski, 1983. Investigation of the Accuracy and Reliability of In Situ Stress Measurements Using Hydraulic Fracturing in Perforated, Cased Holes. Proceedings, 24th U.S. Symposium on Rock Mechanics, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX, pp. 773-786, June 20-22, 1983.
78. Warpinski, N.R. and Teufel, L.W. 1987. Influence of Geologic Discontinuities on Hydraulic Fracture Propagation. JPT 39: Feb 1987: 209-220. SPE 13224.
79. Warpinski, N.R. et al. 1993: Examination of a Cored Hydraulic Fracture in a Deep Gas Well. SPE 22876, SPEPF Aug 1993, 150-158.
80. Warpinski, N.R. et al. 2005. Comparison of Single- and Dual-Array Microseismic Mapping Techniques in the Barnett Shale. Paper SPE 95568 presented at the Annual Technical Conference, Dallas, Oct. 9-12.
81. Warpinski, N.R. et al. 2008. Stimulating Unconventional Reservoirs: Maximizing Network Growth while Optimizing Fracture Conductivity. Paper SPE 114173 presented at the SPE Unconventional Reservoirs Conference, Keystone, CO, Feb. 10-12.
82. Wright, C.A. et al. 1997: Wellbore-to-Fracture Communication Problems Pose Challenges in California Diatomite Horizontal Wells. Paper SPE 38632 presented at the 1997 Annual Technical Conference, San Antonio, Oct 5-8.