Analysing classes of motion drive algorithms based on paired comparison techniques

Vehicle System Dynamics

Volumn 47, Issue 9, 2009, Pages 1075-1093

  Grant, Peter R ^a   Blommer, Mike ^b   Artz, Bruce ^b   Greenberg, Jeff ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

^b FORD RESEARCH LABORATORY   (United States)

Author keywords

Driver in the loop; Driving simulation; Motion cueing; Motion drive algorithm; Simulator motion

Indexed keywords

DRIVER-IN-THE-LOOP; DRIVING SIMULATION; MOTION CUEING; MOTION DRIVE ALGORITHM; SIMULATOR MOTION;

AUTOMOBILE DRIVERS; AUTOMOBILE SIMULATORS; COMMERCE; ERRORS; SIMULATORS; TUNING;

ALGORITHMS;

EID: 70449585100     PISSN: 00423114     EISSN: 17445159     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/00423110802450185     Document Type: Article

References (42)

1. T.W. Showalter and B.L. Parris, The effects of motion and g-seat cues on pilot simulator performance of three piloting tasks, NASA TP 1601, NASA, 1980.
2. J.A. Schroeder, Simulation motion effects on single axis compensatory tracking, Proceedings of theAIAA Flight Simulation Technologies Conference, No 93-3579, Monterey, CA, AIAA, August 1993.
3. R.S. Shirley and L.R.Young, Motion cues in man-vehicle control, IEEE Trans. Man Machine Syst. 9(4) (1968), pp. 121-128.
4. J. Greenberg, B. Artz, and L. Cathey, The effect of lateral motion cues during simulated driving, 2003 Driving Simulator Conference North America, Dearborn, MI, October 2003.
5. P.R. Grant, B.Yam, R. Hosman, and J.A. Schroeder, Effect of simulator motion on pilot behavior and perception, AIAA J. Aircraft 43(6) (2006), pp. 1914-1924.
6. L.D. Reid and M. Nahon, Flight simulation motion-base drive algorithms: Part 1 - developing and testing the equations, Rep 296, UTIAS, 1985.
7. L.D. Reid and P.R. Grant, Motion algorithm for large-displacement driving simulator, Transport. Res. Rec. (1403) (1993), pp. 98-106.
8. R. Romano, Non-linear optimal tilt coordination for washout algorithms,AIAA Paper 2003-5681, August 2003.
9. R.J. Telban and F.M. Cardullo, A nonlinear, human-centered approach to motion cueing with a neurocomputing solver, AIAA Paper 2002-4692, August 2002.
10. G. Reymond and A. Kemeny, Motion cueing in the renault driving simualtor, Vehicle Syst. Dyn. 34(4) (2000), pp. 249-259.
11. C.W. Schwarz, Two mitigation strategies for motion system limits in driving and flight simulators, IEEE Trans. Syst. Man Cyber. 37(4) (2007), pp. 562-568.
12. R.A. Hess and T. Malsbury, Closed-loop assessment of flight simulator fidelity, J. Guid. Control Dynam. 14(1) (1991), pp. 191-197.
13. R.A. Hess, T. Malsbury, and A. Atencio Jr, Flight simulator fidelity assessment in a rotorcraft lateral translation manuever, J, Guid. Control Dynam. 16(1) (1993), pp. 79-85.
14. J.A. Schroeder, Helicopter flight simulation motion requirements, NASA TP 1999-208766, NASA, 1996.
15. R.A. Hess, Unified theory for aircraft handling qualities and adverse aircraft-pilot coupling, J. Guid. Control Dynam. 20(6) (1997), 1141-1148.
16. Y. Zeyada and R.A. Hess, Modeling human pilot cue utilization with applications to simulator fidelity assessment, AIAA J. Aircraft 37(4) (2000), pp. 588-597.
17. R.J.A.W. Hosman, S. Advani, and N. Haeck, Integrated design of the motion cueing system for a wright flyer simulator, AIAA, J. Guid. Control Dynam. 28(1) (2005), pp. 43-52. (Pubitemid 40156667)
18. R.J.A.W. Hosman, Pilots perception and control of aircraft motions, Ph.D. thesis, Delft University ofTechnology, 1996. ISBN: 90-407-1384-7.
19. R. Hosman, P. Grant, and J. Schroeder, Pre and post pilot model analysis compared to experimental simulator results, AIAA Paper 2005-6303, San Francisco, August 2005.
20. S.R. Bussolari, L.R. Young, and A.T. Lee, The use of vestibular models for design and evaluation of flight simulator motion, AIAA Flight Simulation Technologies Conference and Exhibit Proceedings, August 1989. Paper No. 89-3274-CP, pp. 86-93.
21. L. Guo, F. Cardullo, R.J. Telban, J.A. Houck, and L.C. Kelly, The results of a simulator study to determine the effects on pilot performance of two different motion cueing algorithms and various delays, compensated and uncompensated, AIAA Paper 2003-5676, August 2003. Presented at AIAA Modeling and Simulation Technologies Conference.
22. E.L. Groen, M.H. Smaili, and R.J.A.W. Hosman, Perception model analysis of flight simulator motion for a decrab maneuver, AIAA J. Aircraft 44(2) (2007), 427-435.
23. J.B. Sinacori, The determination of some requirements for a helicopter flight research simulator facility, NASA CP 152066, NASA, 1977.
24. P.R. Grant, B. Artz, M. Blommer, L. Cathey, and J. Greenberg, A paired comparison study of simulator motion drive algorithms, DSC2002, Paris, France, September 2002.
25. R.S. Bray, Cockpit motion requirements for simulation studies of critical stability and control problems, Contract Report RTOP 501-20-103, NASA, 1973.
26. R.J.A.W. Hosman, J.C. van der Vaart, and G.A.J. Van de Moesdijk, Optimalization and evaluation of linear motion filters, Memorandum M-326, Delft University of Technology, Deptartment of Aerospace Engineering, 1979.
27. H.R. Jex, R.E. Magaleno, and W.F. Jewell, Effects on target tracking of motion simulator drive-logic filters, Technical Report AFAMRL-TR-80-134, Air Force Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory, August 1981.
28. L.D. Reid and M. Nahon, Response of airline pilots to variations in flight simulator motion algorithms, AIAA J. Aircraft 25(7) (1988), pp. 639-646.
29. J. Tajima, K. Maruyama, and N.Yuhara, Driving task adaptive motion-cueing algorithm for driving simulator, Driving Simulation Conference, DSC Asia/Pacific 06, Tsukuba, Japan, May/June 2006.
30. M. Brenger-Koch, S. Briest, and M. Vollrath, Do you feel the difference? a motion assessment study, Driving Simulation Conference, DSC Asia/Pacific 06, Tsukuba, Japan, May/June 2006.
31. N. Kuge, M. Kubota, and K. Itoh, A study on a motion algorithm based on a driver-centered approach, Driving Simulation Conference, DSC02, Paris, France, September 2002.
32. S. Nordmark, H. Jansson, M. Lidstrom, and G. Palmkvist, A moving base driving simulator with wide angle visual system, TRB Conference Session on Simulation and Instrumentation for the 80s 64th Annual Meeting, Washington, DC, January 1985.
33. P.R. Grant, M. Blommer, L. Cathey, B. Artz, and J. Greenberg, Analyzing classes of motion drive algorithms based on paired comparison techniques, DSC2003, ISSN 1546-5071, Dearborn, Michigan, October 2003.
34. G.L. Greig, Masking of motion cues by random motion: comparison of human performance with a signal detection model, UTIAS Report 313, Toronto, 1988.
35. P.R. Grant and L.D. Reid, Motion washout filter tuning: rules and requirements, AIAA J. Aircraft 34(2) (1997), pp. 145-151.
36. L. Cathey, B. Artz, J. Greenberg, M. Blommer, and P. Grant, Characterization of the visual display system used in the ford virttex driving simulator, Proceedings of Image 2003, Scottsdale, Arizona, July 2003.
37. P.R. Grant, B.A. Artz, J.A. Greenberg, and L.W. Cathey, Motion characteristics of the virttex motion system, 1st Human Centered Transportation Simulation Conference, Iowa City, Iowa, USA, September 2001. Driving Simulation Conference, 2001.
38. E. Bakker, H.B. Pacejka, and L. Linder, A new tire model with an application in vehicle dynamics studies, SAE Paper 890087, 1989.
39. J.E. Bernard and C.L. Clover, Tire modeling for low-speed and high-speed calculations, SAE Paper 950311, 1995.
40. B.A. Artz, L.W. Cathey, R.E. Curry, P.R. Grant, and J. A. Greenberg, Using the Ford driving simulator to develop metrics for on-center steering feel, Driving Simulation Conference 1999 (DSC99), Paris, France, September 1999.
41. H.A. David, The Method of Paired Comparisons, Oxford University Press, NewYork, NY, 1988.
42. B.J.Winer, D.R. Brown, and K.M.Michels, Statistical Principles in Experimental Design,McGrawHill, Boston, MA, 1991.