Equality of opportunity and luck: Definitions and testable conditions, with an application to income in France

Journal of Public Economics

Volumn 93, Issue 11-12, 2009, Pages 1189-1207

  Lefranc, Arnaud ^a   Pistolesi, Nicolas ^b   Trannoy, Alain ^c  

^a UNIVERSITÉ DE CERGY PONTOISE   (France)

^b UMR 8184   (France)

^c Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique   (France)

Author keywords

Equality of opportunity; Income distribution; Luck; Stochastic dominance

Indexed keywords

EID: 70350393270     PISSN: 00472727     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jpubeco.2009.07.008     Document Type: Article

References (63)

1. Alesina A., and Angeletos G.-M. Fairness and redistribution. American Economic Review 4 (2005) 960-980
2. Alesina A., and Glaeser E. Fighting Poverty in the US and Europe: A World of Difference (2004), Oxford University Press, Oxford
3. Alesina A., and La Ferrara E. Preferences for redistribution in the land of opportunities. Journal of Public Economics 89 5-6 (2005) 897-931
4. Arneson R. Equality and equal opportunity of welfare. Philosophical Studies 56 (1989) 77-93
5. Arneson R. Liberalism, distributive subjectivism, and equal opportunity for welfare. Philosophy and Public Affairs 19 2 (1990) 158-194
6. Beach C., and Davidson R. Distribution-free statistical inference with Lorenz curves and income shares. Review of Economic Studies 50 4 (1983) 723-735
7. Ben-Porath E., Gilboa I., and Schmeidler D. On the measurement of inequality under uncertainty. Journal of Economic Theory 75 1 (1997) 194-204
8. Benabou R., and Ok E.A. Mobility as progressivity: ranking income processes according to equality of opportunity. NBER Working Papers 8431 (2001), National Bureau of Economic Research
9. Betts J., and Roemer J. Equalizing opportunity for racial and socioeconomic groups in the United States through educational finance reform. In: Woessmann L., and Peterson P. (Eds). Schools and the equal opportunity problem (2006), MIT Press
10. Birnbaum M., and Navarette J. Testing descriptive utility theories: violations of stochastic dominance and cumulative independence. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 17 (1998) 49-78
11. Bishop J.A., Formby J.P., and Thistle P.D. Convergence of the south and the non-south income distributions, 1969-1979. American Economic Review 82 1 (1992) 262-272
12. Blinder A.S. Wage discrimination: reduced form and structural estimates. Journal of Human Resources 8 (1973) 436-455
13. Bourguignon F., Ferreira F.H.G., and Menendez M. Inequality of opportunity in Brasil. Review of Income and Wealth 53 4 (2007) 585-618
14. Broome J. Weighing goods. Equality, Uncertainty and Time (1991), Blackwell, Oxford
15. Checchi D., and Peragine V. Regional disparities and inequality of opportunity: the case of Italy. IZA Discussion Papers 1874 (2005), Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA)
16. Checchi D., Ichino A., and Rustichini A. More equal but less mobile ? Education financing and intergenerational mobility in Italy and the US. Journal of Public Economics 74 (1999) 351-393
17. Cohen G.A. On the currency of egalitarian justice. Ethics (1989) 906-944
18. Corneo G., and Gruner H.P. Individual preferences for political redistribution. Journal of Public Economics 83 1 (2002) 83-107
19. Dardanoni V., and Forcina A. Inference for Lorenz curve orderings. Econometrics Journal 2 (1999) 49-75
20. Dardanoni V., Fields G., Roemer J., and Sanchez Puerta M. How demanding should equality of opportunity be, and how much have we achieved?. In: Morgan S.L., Grusky D., and Fields G. (Eds). Mobility and Inequality: Frontiers of Research in Sociology and Economics (2005), Stanford University Press, Stanford
21. Davidson R., and Duclos J.-Y. Statistical inference for stochastic dominance and for the measurement of poverty and inequality. Econometrica 6 (2000) 1435-1464
22. Diamond P.A. Cardinal welfare, individualistic ethics, and interpersonal comparison of utility: comment. Journal of Political Economy 5 (1967) 765-766
23. Dworkin R. What is equality. Part 1: Equality of welfare, Philosophy and Public Affairs vol. 10 (1981) 185-246
24. Dworkin R. What is equality. Part 2: Equality of ressources, Philosophy and Public Affairs vol. 10 (1981) 283-345
25. Fleurbaey M. Equal opportunity or equal social outcome. Economics and Philosophy 11 1 (1995) 25-56
26. Fleurbaey M. Egalitarian opportunities. Law and Philosophy 5 (2001) 499-530
27. Fleurbaey, M., 2006. Assessing risky social situations, mimeo.
28. Fleurbaey M. Fairness, Responsibility and Welfare (2008), Oxford University Press, Oxford
29. Fleurbaey M., and Maniquet F. Compensation and responsibility. In: Arrow K., Sen A., and Suzumura K. (Eds). Hanbdbook of Social Choice and Welfare vol. 2 (2007), North-Holland, Amsterdam chapter 21
30. Foster J., and Shorrocks A.F. Poverty orderings and welfare dominance. Social Choice and Welfare 5 (1988) 179-198
31. Gajdos T., and Maurin E. Unequal uncertainties and uncertain inequalities: an axiomatic approach. Journal of Economic Theory 116 1 (2004) 93-118
32. Goux, D., Maurin, E., 2003. On the evaluation of equality of opportunity for income: Axioms and evidence, mimeo CREST.
33. Grawe N. Lifecycle bias in estimates of intergenerational earnings persistence. Labour Economics 13 5 (2006) 551-570
34. Hammond P.J. Ex-ante and ex-post welfare optimality under uncertainty. Economica 48 191 (1981) 235-250
35. Jencks C., Smith M., Acland H., Bane M.J., Cohen D., Gintis H., Heyns B., and Michelson S. Inequality: A Reassessment of the Effect of Family and Schooling in America (1972), Basic Books, New York
36. Judd K.L. The law of large numbers with a continuum of iid random variables. Journal of Economic Theory 35 1 (1985) 19-25
37. Knight F.H. The Ethics of Competition and Other Essays (1935), Harper & Bros, New York
38. Kodde D.A., and Palm F.C. Wald criteria for jointly testing equality and inequality restrictions. Econometrica 54 5 (1986) 1243-1248
39. Le Grand J. Equity and Choice (1991), Harper Collins, London
40. Lefranc, A., Pistolesi, N., Trannoy, A., 2004. An equalization of opportunities for income acquisition in France?, mimeo THEMA.
41. Lefranc, A., Pistolesi, N., Trannoy, A., 2006. The link between inequality of opportunity for income acquisition and income inequality: the French example 1977-1993?, mimeo THEMA.
42. Lefranc A., Pistolesi N., and Trannoy A. Inequality of opportunities vs. inequality of outcomes: are western societies all alike ?. Review of Income and Wealth (2008) 513-543
43. Lippert-Rasmussen K. Egalitarianism, option luck and responsibility. Ethics 3 (2001) 548-579
44. Lippert-Rasmussen K. Justice and bad luck. In: Zalta E.N. (Ed). The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2005). http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2005/entries/justice-bad-luck/ http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2005/entries/justice -bad-luck/
45. Machina M. Expected utility analysis without the independence axiom. Econometrica 50 2 (1982) 277-324
46. Marshall G., Swift A., Routh D., and Burgoyne C. What is and what ought to be: popular beliefs about distributive justice in thirteen countries. European Sociological Review 4 (1999) 349-367
47. Nozick R. Anarchy, State and Utopia (1977), Basic Books
48. Oaxaca R. Male-female wage differentials in urban labor markets. International Economic Review 14 (1973) 693-709
49. O'Neill D., Sweetman O., and Van De Gaer D. Equiality of opportunity and kernel density estimation: an application to intergenerational mobility. Advances in Econometrics : A research Annual 14 (2000) 259-274
50. Rawls J. A Theory of Justice (1971), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
51. Roemer J. A pragmatic theory of responsibility for the egalitarian planner. Philosophy and Public Affairs 22 2 (1993) 146-166
52. Roemer J. Equality of Opportunity (1998), Harvard University Press, Cambridge
53. Roemer J., Aaberge R., Colombino U., Fritzell J., Jenkins S.P., Lefranc A., Marx I., Page M., Pommer E., Ruiz-Castillo J., San Segundo M.J., Tranaes T., Trannoy A., Wagner G., and Zubiri I. To what extent do fiscal regimes equalize opportunities for income acquisition among citizens?. Journal of Public Economics (2003) 539-565
54. Schuetz G., Ursprung H., and Woessman L. Education policy and equality of opportunity. CESifo working paper (1518) (2005)
55. Sen A. Commodities and Capabilities (1985), North-Holland, Amsterdam
56. Starmer C. Developments in non-expected utility theory: the hunt for a descriptive theory of choice under risk. Journal of Economic Literature 38 2 (2000) 332-382
57. Swift A. Justice, luck and the family : the intergenerational transmission of economic advantage from a normative perspective. In: Bowles S., Gintis H., and Osborne M. (Eds). Unequal Chances : Family Background and Economic Success (2005), Russel Sage Foundation and Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ 256-276 chapter 9
58. Vallentyne P. Self-ownership and equality: brute luck, gifts, universal dominance, and leximin. Ethics 107 2 (1997) 321-343
59. Vallentyne P. Brute luck, option luck and equality of initial opportunities. Ethics 112 (2002) 529-557
60. Vallet L.-A. Change in intergenerational class mobility in France from the 1970s to the 1990s and its explanation: an analysis following the CASMIN approach. In: Breen R. (Ed). Social Mobility in Europe (2004), Oxford University Press, Oxford 115-147
61. Van De Gaer, D., 1993. Equality of opportunity and investment in human capital, Ph.D dissertation, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven.
62. Van De Gaer D., Schokkaert E., and Martinez M. Three meanings of intergenerational mobility. Economica 272 (2001) 519-538
63. Wolak F.A. Testing inequality constraints in linear econometric models. Journal of Econometrics 41 (1989) 205-235