A realistic assessment of the indicator potential of butterflies and other charismatic taxonomic groups

Conservation Biology

Volumn 23, Issue 5, 2009, Pages 1109-1116

  Fleishman, Erica ^a   Murphy, Dennis D ^b  

^a NATIONAL CENTER FOR ECOLOGICAL ANALYSIS AND SYNTHESIS   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF NEVADA   (United States)

Author keywords

Climate change; Indicator species; Land cover; Land use; Monitoring and assessment; Surrogate Species; Validation

Indexed keywords

ASSESSMENT METHOD; BIOINDICATOR; BUTTERFLY; CLIMATE CHANGE; ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT; ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; HABITAT CONSERVATION; LAND COVER; LAND USE; MODEL VALIDATION; SPECIES CONSERVATION; TAXONOMY;

ANIMAL; ARTICLE; BUTTERFLY; CLASSIFICATION; CLIMATE; ECOLOGY; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING;

ANIMALS; BUTTERFLIES; CLIMATE; ECOLOGY; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING;

ANIMALIA; PAPILIONOIDEA;

EID: 70349218134     PISSN: 08888892     EISSN: 15231739     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1523-1739.2009.01246.x     Document Type: Article

References (93)

1. Abensperg-Traun, M., G. W. Arnold, D. E. Steven, G. T. Smith, L. Atkins, J. J. Viveen, and M. Gutter. 1996. Biodiversity indicators in semi-arid, agricultural Western Australia. Pacific Conservation Biology 2 : 375 389.
2. Bachelard, P., and H. Descimon. 1999. Lycaena helle (Denis and Schiffermuller, 1775) from the Central Massif (France): an ecogeographical analysis (Lepidoptera: Lycaenidae). Linneana Belgica 17 : 23 41.
3. Batalden, R. V., K. Oberhauser, and A. T. Peterson. 2007. Ecological niches in sequential generations of eastern North American monarch butterflies (Lepidoptera: Danaidae): the ecology of migration and likely climate change implications. Environmental Entomology 36 : 1365 1373.
4. Beccaloni, G. W., and K. J. Gaston. 1995. Predicting the species richness of Neotropical forest butterflies: Ithomiinae (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) as indicators. Biological Conservation 71 : 77 86.
5. Bobo, K. S., M. Waltert, H. Fermon, J. Njokagbor, and M. Muhlenberg. 2006. From forest to farmland: butterfly diversity and habitat associations along a gradient of forest conversion in southwestern Cameroon. Journal of Insect Conservation 10 : 29 42. (Pubitemid 43118755)
6. Boersma, P. D. 2008. Penguins as marine sentinels. BioScience 58 : 597 607.
7. Boughton, D. A. 1999. Empirical evidence for complex source - sink dynamics with alternative states in a butterfly metapopulation. Ecology 80 : 2727 2739.
8. Bradley, B. A., and J. F. Mustard. 2006. Characterizing the landscape dynamics of an invasive plant and risk of invasion using remote sensing. Ecological Applications 16 : 1132 1147.
9. Brown, K. S., Jr. 1997. Diversity, disturbance and sustainable use of Neotropical forests: insects as indicators for conservation monitoring. Journal of Insect Conservation 1 : 25 42.
10. Brown, K. S., Jr., and A. V. L. Freitas. 2000. Atlantic forest butterflies: indicators for landscape conservation. Biotropica 32 : 934 956.
11. Brown, K. S., Jr., and A. V. L. Freitas. 2002. Butterfly communities of urban forest fragments in Campinas, Sao Paulo, Brazil: structure, instability, environmental correlates, and conservation. Journal of Insect Conservation 6 : 217 231.
12. Cleary, D. F. R. 2004. Assessing the use of butterflies as indicators of logging in Borneo at three taxonomic levels. Journal of Economic Entomology 97 : 429 435.
13. De Benedictis, J. A., D. L. Wagner, and J. B. Whitfield. 1990. Larval hosts of microlepidoptera of the San Bruno Mountains, California. Atala 16 : 14 18.
14. Dennis, R. L. H. 1993. Butterflies and climate change. Manchester University Press, Manchester, United Kingdom.
15. Dennis, R. L. H. 2004. Butterfly habitats, broad-scale biotope affiliations, and structural exploitation of vegetation at finer scales: the matrix revisited. Ecological Entomology 29 : 744 752.
16. Dennis, R. L. H., and T. H. Sparks. 2007. Climate signals are reflected in an 89 year series of British Lepidoptera records. European Journal of Entomology 104 : 763 767.
17. Ehrlich, P. R., and I. Hanski. 2004. On the wings of checkerspots. Oxford University Press, New York.
18. Erhardt, A. 1985. Diurnal lepidoptera, sensitive indicators of cultivated and abandoned grassland. Journal of Applied Ecology 22 : 849 862.
19. Feest, A. 2006. Establishing baseline indices for the quality of the biodiversity of restored habitats using a standardized sampling process. Restoration Ecology 14 : 112 122.
20. Fleishman, E., and R. Mac Nally. 2003. Distinguishing between signal and noise in faunal responses to environmental change. Global Ecology and Biogeography 12 : 395 402.
21. Fleishman, E., J. R. Thomson, R. Mac Nally, D. D. Murphy, and J. P. Fay. 2005. Using indicator species to predict species richness of multiple taxonomic groups. Conservation Biology 19 : 1125 1137.
22. Franzen, M., and T. Ranius. 2004. Occurrence patterns of butterflies (Rhopalocera) in semi-natural pastures in southeastern Sweden. Journal for Nature Conservation 12 : 121 135. (Pubitemid 39320316)
23. Garth, J. S., and J. W. Tilden. 1963. Yosemite butterflies: an ecological survey of the butterflies of the Yosemite sector of the Sierra Nevada, California. Journal of Research on the Lepidoptera 2 : 1 96.
24. Ghazoul, J. 2002. Impact of logging on the richness and diversity of forest butterflies in a tropical dry forest in Thailand. Biodiversity and Conservation 11 : 521 541.
25. Gordon, I., and M. Cobblah. 2000. Insects of the Muni-Pomadze Ramsar site. Biodiversity and Conservation 9 : 479 486.
26. Grill, A., B. Knoflach, D. F. R. Cleary, and V. Kati. 2005. Butterfly, spider, and plant communities in different land-use types in Sardinia, Italy. Biodiversity and Conservation 14 : 1281 1300.
27. Haddad, N. M., B. Hudgens, C. Damiani, K. Gross, D. Kuefler, and K. Pollock. 2008. Determining optimal population modeling for rare butterflies. Conservation Biology 22 : 929 940.
28. Hamer, K. C., J. K. Hill, L. A. Lace, and A. M. Langan. 1997. Ecological and biogeographical effects of forest disturbance on tropical butterflies of Sumba, Indonesia. Journal of Biogeography 24 : 67 75.
29. Hammond, P. C., and J. C. Miller. 1998. Comparison of the biodiversity of Lepidoptera within three forested ecosystems. Annals of the Entomological Society of America 91 : 323 328.
30. Hellmann, J. J. 2002. Butterflies as model systems for understanding and predicting climate change
31. Hellmann, J. J., S. L. Pelini, K. M. Prior, and J. D. K. Dzurisin. 2008. The response of two butterfly species to climatic variation at the edge of their range and the implications for poleward range shifts. Oecologia 157 : 583 592.
32. Hermy, M., and J. Cornelis. 2000. Towards a monitoring method and a number of multifaceted and hierarchical biodiversity indicators for urban and suburban parks. Landscape and Urban Planning 49 : 149 162.
33. Hess, G. R., R. A. Bartel, A. K. Leidner, K. M. Rosenfeld, M. J. Rubino, S. B. Snider, and T. H. Ricketts. 2006. Effectiveness of biodiversity indicators varies with extent, grain, and region. Biological Conservation 132 : 448 457.
34. Hill, J. K., L. A. Lace, and W. M. T. Banham. 1995. Effects of selective logging on tropical forest butterflies on Buru, Indonesia. Journal of Applied Ecology 32 : 754 760.
35. Holl, K. D. 1995. Nectar resources and their influence on butterfly communities on reclaimed coal surface mines. Restoration Ecology 3 : 76 85.
36. Holl, K. D. 1996. The effect of coal surface mine reclamation on diurnal lepidopteran conservation. Journal of Applied Ecology 33 : 225 236.
37. Horner-Devine, M. C., G. C. Daily, P. R. Ehrlich, and C. L. Boggs. 2003. Countryside biogeography of tropical butterflies. Conservation Biology 17 : 168 177.
38. Hunter, M. L., Jr. 1993. Natural fire regimes as spatial models for managing boreal forests. Biological Conservation 65 : 115 120.
39. Kerr, J. T., A. Sugar, and L. Packer. 2000. Indicator taxa, rapid biodiversity assessment, and nestedness in an endangered ecosystem. Conservation Biology 14 : 1726 1734.
40. Kleintjes, P. K., B. F. Jacobs, and S. M. Fettig. 2004. Initial response of butterflies to an overstory reduction and slash mulching treatment of a degraded pinon-juniper woodland. Restoration Ecology 12 : 231 238.
41. Kremen, C. 1992. Assessing the indicator properties of species assemblages for natural areas monitoring. Ecological Applications 2 : 203 216.
42. Kremen, C., et al. 2008. Aligning conservation priorities across taxa in Madagascar with high-resolution planning tools. Science 320 : 222 226.
43. Kula, E., and M. Kralicek. 1995. Occurrence of melanism with butterflies in polluted area Decinsky Sneznik. Lesnictvi 41 : 257 264.
44. LaDeau, S. L., A. M. Kilpatrick, and P. P. Mara. 2007. West Nile virus emergence and large-scale declines of North American bird populations. Nature 447 : 710 713.
45. Landres, P. B., J. Verner, and J. W. Thomas. 1988. Ecological uses of vertebrate indicator species: a critique. Conservation Biology 2 : 316 328.
46. Lawton, J. H., et al. 1998. Biodiversity inventories, indicator taxa and effects of habitat modification in tropical forest. Nature 391 : 72 76.
47. Lewinsohn, T. M., A. V. L. Freitas, and P. I. Prado. 2005. Conservation of terrestrial invertebrates and their habitats in Brazil. Conservation Biology 19 : 640 645.
48. Lindenmayer, D. B., C. R. Margules, and D. B. Botkin. 2000. Indicators of biodiversity for ecologically sustainable forest management. Conservation Biology 14 : 941 950.
49. Lomov, B., D. A. Keith, D. R. Britton, and D. F. Hochuli. 2006. Are butterflies and moths useful indicators for restoration monitoring? A pilot study in Sydney's Cumberland Plain Woodland. Ecological Management and Restoration 7 : 204 210.
50. Lu, S.-S., and M. J. Samways. 2002. Behavioural ecology of the Karkloof blue butterfly Orachrysops ariadne (Lepidoptera: Lycaenidae) relevant to its conservation. African Entomology 10 : 137 147.
51. McLaughlin, J. F., J. J. Hellmann, C. L. Boggs, and P. R. Ehrlich. 2002. Climate change hastens population extinctions. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 99 : 6070 6074.
52. Macmynowski, D. P., T. L. Root, G. Ballard, and G. R. Geupel. 2007. Changes in spring arrival of Nearctic-Neotropical migrants attributed to multiscalar climate. Global Change Biology 13 : 2239 2251.
53. Mac Nally, R., and E. Fleishman. 2002. Using 'indicator' species to model species richness: model development and predictions. Ecological Applications 12 : 79 92.
54. Mac Nally, R., A. F. Bennett, and G. Horrocks. 2000. Forecasting the impacts of habitat fragmentation. Evaluation of species-specific predictions of the impact of habitat fragmentation on birds in the box-ironbark forests of central Victoria, Australia. Biological Conservation 95 : 7 29.
55. Maes, D., D. Bauwens, L. De Bruyn, A. Anselin, G. Vermeersch, W. Van Landuyt, G. De Knijf, and M. Gilbert. 2005. Species richness coincidence: conservation strategies based on predictive modelling. Biodiversity and Conservation 14 : 1345 1364.
56. Mas, A. H., and T. V. Dietsch. 2004. Linking shade coffee certification to biodiversity conservation: butterflies and birds in Chiapas, Mexico. Ecological Applications 14 : 642 654.
57. Meir, E., S. Andelman, and H. P. Possingham. 2004. Does conservation-planning matter in a dynamic and uncertain world? Ecology Letters 7 : 615 622.
58. Merrill, R. M., D. Gutiérrez, O. T. Lewis, J. Gutiérrez, S. B. Díes, and R. J. Wilson. 2008. Combined effects of climate and biotic interactions on the elevational range of a phytophagous insect. Journal of Animal Ecology 77 : 145 155.
59. Morrison, M. L., and L. S. Hall. 2002. Standard terminology: toward a common language to advance ecological understanding and application
60. Mouquet, N., V. Belrose, J. A. Thomas, G. W. Elmes, R. T. Clarke, and M. E. Hochberg. 2005. Conserving community modules: a case study of the endangered lycaenid butterfly Maculinea alcon. Ecology 86 : 3160 3173.
61. Murphy, D. D., and B. A. Wilcox. 1986. Butterfly diversity in natural habitat fragments: a test of the validity of vertebrate-based management
62. Myers, N., R. A. Mittermeier, C. G. Mittermeier, G. A. B. daFonesca, and J. Kent. 2000. Biodiversity hotspots for conservation priorities. Nature 403 : 853 858.
63. Nel, J. 1992. On the ecological plasticity and the biology of some Lepidoptera (Rhopalocera) of the southwest Mediterranean area of France. Linneana Belgica 13 : 287 338.
64. Niemela, J., and B. Baur. 1998. Threatened species in a vanishing habitat: plants and invertebrates in calcareous grasslands in the Swiss Jura mountains. Biodiversity and Conservation 7 : 1407 1416.
65. Noss, R. F. 1990. Indicators for monitoring biodiversity: a hierarchical approach. Conservation Biology 4 : 355 364.
66. Nummelin, M., and S. Kaitala. 2004. Do species dominance indices indicate rain forest disturbance by logging? Biotropica 36 : 628 632.
67. Parmesan, C. 2003. Butterflies as bioindicators for climate change effects
68. Pearson, D. L., and S. S. Carroll. 1998. Global patterns of species richness: spatial models for conservation planning using bioindicator and precipitation data. Conservation Biology 12 : 809 821.
69. Poyry, J., M. Luoto, J. Paukkunen, J. Pykala, K. Raatikainen, and M. Kuussaari. 2006. Different responses of plants and herbivore insects to a gradient of vegetation height: an indicator of the vertebrate grazing intensity and successional age. Oikos 115 : 401 412.
70. Ricketts, T. H., E. Dinerstein, D. M. Olson, and C. Loucks. 1999. Who's where in North America? Patterns of species richness and the utility of indicator taxa for conservation. BioScience 49 : 369 381.
71. Ricketts, T. H., G. C. Daily, and P. R. Ehrlich. 2002. Does butterfly diversity predict moth diversity? Testing a popular indicator taxon at local scales. Biological Conservation 103 : 361 370.
72. Ross, G. N. 1976. An ecological study of the butterflies of the Sierra de Tuxtla in Veracruz Mexico. Journal of Research on the Lepidoptera 15 : 225 240.
73. Rowland, M. M., M. J. Wisdom, L. H. Suring, and C. W. Meinke. 2006. Greater sage-grouse as an umbrella specie for sagebrush-associated vertebrates. Biological Conservation 129 : 323 335.
74. Schmiegelow, F. K. A., D. P. Stepnisky, C. A. Stambaugh, and M. Koivula. 2006. Reconciling salvage logging of boreal forests with a natural-disturbance model. Conservation Biology 20 : 971 983.
75. Schulze, C. H., et al. 2004. Biodiversity indicator groups of tropical land-use systems: comparing plants, birds, and insects. Ecological Applications 14 : 1321 1333.
76. Scott, J. A. 1986. The butterflies of North America. Stanford University Press, Stanford, California.
77. Scott, J. M., B. Csuti, J. D. Jacobi, and J. E. Estes. 1987. Species richness. BioScience 37 : 782 788.
78. Singer, M. C. 1983. Determinants of multiple host use by a phytophagous insect population. Evolution 37 : 389 403.
79. Skorka, P., J. Settele, and M. Woyciechowski. 2007. Effects of management cessation on grassland butterflies in southern Poland. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment 121 : 319 324.
80. Sparks, T. H., and T. J. Yates. 1997. The effect of spring temperature on the appearance dates of British butterflies 1883-1993. Ecography 20 : 368 374.
81. Stewart, D. A. B., and M. J. Samways. 1998. Conserving dragonfly (Odonata) assemblages relative to river dynamics in an African savanna game reserve. Conservation Biology 12 : 683 692.
82. Swengel, A. B., and S. R. Swengel. 1997. Co-occurrence of prairie and barrens butterflies: applications to ecosystem conservation. Journal of Insect Conservation 1 : 131 144.
83. Swengel, S. R., and A. B. Swengel. 1999. Correlations in abundance of grassland songbirds and prairie butterflies. Biological Conservation 90 : 1 11.
84. Thiele, V. 2000. To the knowledge of the Lepidoptera-fauna of different types of river valley in Mecklenburg-West Pomerania (Lep.). Entomologische Nachrichten und Berichte 44 : 137 144.
85. Thomas, J. A. 2005. Monitoring change in the abundance and distribution of insects using butterflies and other indicator groups. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 360 : 339 357.
86. Uehara-Prado, M., K. S. Brown Jr., L. Freitas, and A. Victor. 2007. Species richness, composition and abundance of fruit-feeding butterflies in the Brazilian Atlantic Forest: comparison between a fragmented and a continuous landscape. Global Ecology and Biogeography 16 : 43 54.
87. van Swaay, C., M. Warren, and G. Lois. 2006. Biotope use and trends of European butterflies. Journal of Insect Conservation 10 : 189 209.
88. Vessby, K., B. Soderstrom, A. Glimskar, and B. Svensson. 2002. Species-richness correlations of six different taxa in Swedish seminatural grasslands. Conservation Biology 16 : 430 439.
89. Viejo, J. L., M. G. De Viedma, and E. Martinez Falero. 1989. The importance of woodlands in the conservation of butterflies (Lepidoptera: Papilionoidea and Hesperioidea) in the center of the Iberian Peninsula. Biological Conservation 48 : 101 114.
90. Wallis DeVries, M. F., and I. Raemakers. 2001. Does extensive grazing benefit butterflies in coastal dunes? Restoration Ecology 9 : 179 188.
91. Weiss, S. B., D. D. Murphy, P. R. Ehrlich, and C. F. Metzler. 1993 Adult emergency phenology in checkerspot butterflies: the effects of macroclimate, topography, and population history. Oecologia 96 : 261 270.
92. Wiens, J. A., G. D. Hayward, R. S. Holthausen, and M. J. Wisdom. 2008. Using surrogate species and groups for conservation planning and management. BioScience 58 : 241 252.
93. Williams, P. H., and K. J. Gaston. 1998. Biodiversity indicators: graphical techniques, smoothing and searching for what makes relationships work. Ecography 21 : 551 556.