Is there an "abortion trauma syndrome"? Critiquing the evidence

Harvard Review of Psychiatry

Volumn 17, Issue 4, 2009, Pages 268-290

  Robinson, Gail Erlick ^a,f   Stotland, Nada L ^b   Russo, Nancy Felipe ^c   Lang, Joan A ^d   Occhiogrosso, Mallay ^e  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

^b RUSH MEDICAL COLLEGE   (United States)

^c ARIZONA STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^d SAINT LOUIS UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^e NEW YORK PRESBYTERIAN HOSPITAL   (United States)

^f TORONTO GENERAL HOSPITAL   (Canada)

Author keywords

Abortion; Abortion trauma; Depression; Mental health; Post abortion syndrome

Indexed keywords

ABORTION; ABORTION TRAUMA SYNDROME; CLINICAL EVALUATION; COMPARATIVE STUDY; EMPIRICISM; HEALTH SURVEY; HUMAN; INDUCED ABORTION; LAW; MEDICAL RECORD; MEDICAL RESEARCH; MENTAL DISEASE; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REGISTER; REVIEW; SEXUAL ABUSE; SOCIAL ATTITUDE; VIOLENCE;

ABORTION, INDUCED; EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE; FEMALE; GUILT; HUMANS; LIFE CHANGE EVENTS; MENTAL DISORDERS; PREGNANCY; PREGNANT WOMEN; RESEARCH DESIGN; STRESS DISORDERS, POST-TRAUMATIC; SYNDROME; WOMEN'S HEALTH;

EID: 68649116241     PISSN: 10673229     EISSN: 14657309     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/10673220903149119     Document Type: Review

References (76)

1. World Health Organization. The world health report 2005 - make every mother and child count. Geneva: WHO, 2005: chapter 3.
2. Guttmacher Institute. New York/Washington: 2005. http://www.agi-usa.org
3. Council on Scientific Affairs, American Medical Association. Induced termination of pregnancy before and after Roe v. Wade. Trends in the mortality and morbidity of women. JAMA 1992;268:3231-3239
4. Adler NF, Adler NE, David HP, et al. Psychological responses after abortion. Science 1990;248:41-43
5. Adler NE, David HP, Major BN, Roth S, Russo NF, Wyatt G. Psychological factors in abortion. A review. Am Psychol 1992;47:1194-1204
6. Dagg PK. The psychological sequelae of therapeutic abortion denied and completed. Am J Psychiatry 1991;148:578-585
7. Posavac E, Miller T. Some problems caused by not having a conceptual foundation for health research: an illustration from studies of the psychological effects of abortion. Psychol Health 1990;5:13-23.
8. Stotland NL. The myth of the abortion trauma syndrome. JAMA 1992;268:2078-2079
9. Rue VM. Postabortion trauma: controversy, diagnosis and treatment. Stratham, NH: Institute for Pregnancy Loss, 1998.
10. David HP, Rasmussen NK, Holst E. Postpartum and postabortion psychotic reactions. Fam Plann Perspect 1981:13:88-92.
11. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 4th ed., text rev. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, 2000.
12. Medical Students for Life. http://www.ms4l.org
13. Royal College of Psychiatrists. Position statement on women's mental health in relation to induced abortion. 2008. http://extras.timesonline.co.uk/ abortion.pdf
14. South Dakota Task Force to Study Abortion. Report of the task force submitted to the governor and legislature of South Dakota. Pierre, SD: SDTFSA, 2000.
15. Franz W, Reardon D. Differential impact of abortion on adolescents and adults. Adolescence 1992;27:161-172
16. Coleman PK, Maxey CD, Rue VM, Coyle CT. Associations between voluntary and involuntary forms of perinatal loss and child maltreatment among low-income mothers. Acta Paediatr 2005;94:1476-1483
17. Williams JM, Watts FN, MacLeod C, Mathews A. Cognitive psychology and emotional disorder. Chichester, UK: Wiley, 2005.
18. Women reveal reasons for their late abortions. ScienceDaily 2007(7 May). http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/05/ 070506163225.htm
19. Dietz PM, Spitz AM, Anda RF, et al. Unintended pregnancy among adult women exposed to abuse or household dysfunction during their childhood. JAMA 1999;282:1359-1364
20. Steinberg JR, Russo NF. Abortion and anxiety: what's the relationship? Soc Sci Med 2008;67:238-252
21. Russo NF, Denious JE. Violence in the lives of women having abortions: implications for public policy and practice. Prof Psychol Res Pr 2001;32:142-150 (Pubitemid 33250913)
22. Felton GM, Parsons MA, Hassell JS. Health behaviour and related factors in adolescents with a history of abortion and never-pregnant adolescents. Health Care Women Int 1998;19:37-47.
23. Fergusson DM., Horwood LJ, Ridder EM. Abortion in young women and subsequent mental health. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 2006;47:116-124
24. Bailey PE, Bruno ZV, Bezerra MF, Queiroz CM, Chen-Mok M. Adolescent pregnancy 1 year later: the effect of abortion vs. motherhood in Northeast Brazil. J Adolesc Health 2001;29:223-232 (Pubitemid 32755800)
25. Glander SS, Moore ML, Michiellutte R, Parsons LH. The prevalence of domestic violence among women seeking abortion. Obstet Gynecol 1998;91:1002-1006 (Pubitemid 28246940)
26. Gazmararian JA, Adams MM, Saltzman LE, et al. The relationship between pregnancy intendedness and physical violence in mothers of newborns. Obstet Gynecol 1995;85:1031-1038
27. Wyatt GE, Guthrie D, Notgrass CM. Differential effects of women's child sexual abuse and subsequent sexual revictimization. J Consult Clin Psychol 1992;58:758-767
28. Gilchrist AC, Hannaford PC, Frank P, Kay CR. Termination of pregnancy and psychiatric morbidity. Br J Psychiatry 1995:167:243-248
29. Cozzarelli C, Major B. The effects of anti-abortion demonstrators and pro-choice escorts on women's psychological responses to abortion. J Soc Clin Psychol 1994;13:404-427
30. Cozzarelli C, Major B, Karrasch A, Fuegen K. Women's experiences of and reactions to anti-abortion picketing. Basic Appl Soc Psych 2000;22:265-275
31. Major B, Gramzow RH. Abortion as stigma: cognitive and emotional implications of concealment. J Pers Soc Psychol 1999;77:735-745
32. Mueller P, Major B. Self-blame, self-efficacy and adjustment to abortion. J Pers Soc Psychol 1989;57:1059-1068
33. Lagakos SW. The challenge of subgroup analyses - reporting without distorting. N Engl J Med 2006;354:1667-1669
34. Gissler M, Hemminki E, Lonnqvist J. Suicides after pregnancy in Finland, 1987-1994; register linkage study. BMJ 1996;313:1431-1434
35. Gissler M, Hemminki E. Pregnancy-related violent deaths. Scand J Public Health 1999;27:54-55
36. Gissler M, Berg C, Bouvier-Colle MH, Buekens P. Pregnancy-associated mortality after birth, spontaneous abortion or induced abortion in Finland, 1987-2000. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2004;190:422-427
37. Reardon DC, Ney PG, Scheuren F, Cougle J, Coleman PK, Strahan TW. Deaths associated with pregnancy outcome: a record linkage study of low income women. South Med J 2002;95:834-841 (Pubitemid 34858017)
38. Coleman PK, Reardon DC, Rue VM, Cougle J. State-funded abortions versus deliveries: a comparison of outpatient mental health claims over 4 years. Am J Orthopsychiatry 2002:72:141-152 (Pubitemid 36885641)
39. Reardon DC, Cougle JR, Rue VM, Shuping MW, Coleman PK, Ney PG. Psychiatric admissions of low-income women following abortion and childbirth. CMAJ 2003:168:1253-1256
40. Reardon DC, Coleman PK. Relative treatment rates for sleep disorders and sleep disturbances following abortion and childbirth: a prospective record-based study. Sleep 2006:29:105-106
41. Cougle JR, Reardon DC, Coleman PK. Generalized anxiety following unintended pregnancies resolved through childbirth and abortion: a cohort study of the 1995 National Survey of Family Growth. J Anxiety Disord 2005;19:137-142
42. Reardon DC, Cougle JR. Depression and unintended pregnancy in the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth: a cohort study. BMJ 2002;321:151-152
43. Cougle JR, Reardon DC, Coleman PK. Depression associated with abortion and childbirth: a long term analysis of the NLSY cohort. Med Sci Monit 2003;9:105-112
44. Rue VM, Coleman PK, Rue JJ, Reardon DC. Induced abortion and traumatic stress: a preliminary comparison of American and Russian women. Med Sci Monit 2004;10:SR5-16.
45. Coleman PK, Reardon DC, Cougle J. The quality of the caregiving environment and child developmental outcomes associated with maternal history of abortion using the NLSY data. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 2002;43:743-757 (Pubitemid 36939255)
46. Coleman PK, Reardon DC, Rue VM, Cougle J. A history of induced abortion in relation to substance use during subsequent pregnancies carried to term. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2002;187:1673-1678 (Pubitemid 36026706)
47. Coleman PK, Reardon DC, Cougle JR. Substance use among pregnant women in the context of previous reproductive loss and desire for current pregnancy. Brit J Health Psychol 2005;10:255-268
48. Reardon DC. Abortion decisions and the duty to screen: clinical, ethical and legal implications of predictive risk factors of post-abortion maladjustment. J Contemp Health Law Policy 2003;20:33-114.
49. Reardon DC, Strahan TW, Thorp JM Jr, Shuping MW. Deaths associated with abortion compared to childbirth - a review of new and old data and the medical and legal implications. J Contemp Health Law Policy 2004;20:279-327.
50. Reardon DC, Ney PG. Abortion and subsequent substance abuse. Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse 2000;26:61-75.
51. Houston H, Jacobson L. Overdose and termination of pregnancy: an important association? Br J General Pract 1996;46:737-738
52. Schmiege S, Russo NF. Depression and unwanted first pregnancy: longitudinal cohort study. BMJ 2005;331:1303. (Pubitemid 41746459)
53. Russo NF, Schmiege SJ. Debates about our design are beside the point: the Reardon and Cougle findings are invalid and cannot be reproduced with properly coded data. BMJ 2005(18 Dec). http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/eletters/331/7528/ 1303
54. Russo NF, Schmiege SJ. Depression and unwanted first pregnancy: methodological issues, additional findings. BMJ 2006(10 Feb). http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/eletters/331/7528/1303
55. Wittchen HU, Zhao S, Kessler RC, Eaton WW. DSM-III-R generalized anxiety disorder in the National Comorbidity Survey. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1994;51:355-364 (Pubitemid 24176813)
56. Major B, Cozzarelli C, Cooper ML, et al. Psychological reponses of women after first-trimester abortion. Arch Gen Psychiat. 2000;57:777-784 (Pubitemid 30650113)
57. Gissler M, Kauppila R, Merilainen J, Toukomaa H, Hemminki E. Pregnancy-associated deaths in Finland 1987-1994 - definition problems and benefits of record linkage. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand 1997;76:651-657
58. Gissler M, Berg C, Bouvier-Colle MH, Buekens P. Methods for identifying pregnancy-associated deaths: population-based data from Finland 1987-2000. Pediatr Perinat Epidemiol 2004;18:448-455
59. Gissler M, Berg C, Bouvier-Colle MH, Buekens P. Injury deaths, suicides and homicides associated with pregnancy, Finland, 1987-2000. Eur J Public Health 2005;15:459-463
60. Taft A, Watson LF. Depression and termination of pregnancy (induced abortion) in a national cohort of young Australian women: the confounding effect of women's experience of violence. BMC Public Health 2008;8:75.
61. Harlow BL, Cohen LS, Otto MW, Spiegelman D, Cramer DW. Early life menstrual characteristics and pregnancy experiences among women with and without major depression: the Harvard study of moods and cycles. J Affect Disord 2004;79:167-176 (Pubitemid 38340540)
62. Broen AN, Moum T, Bodtker AS, Ekeberg O. Psychological impact on women of miscarriage versus induced abortion: a 2-year follow-up study. Psychosom Med 2004;66:265-271 (Pubitemid 38393237)
63. Broen AN, Moum T, Bodtker AS, Ekeberg O. Reasons for induced abortion and their relation to women's emotional distress: a prospective, two-year follow-up study. Gen Hosp Psychiatry 2005;27:36-43. (Pubitemid 40202896)
64. Broen A, Moum T, Bodtker AS, Ekeberg O. Predictors of anxiety and depression following pregnancy termination: a longitudinal five-year follow-up study. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand 2006;85:317-323 (Pubitemid 43879218)
65. Congleton GK, Calhoun LG. Post-abortion perceptions: a comparison of self-identified distressed and nondistressed populations. Int J Soc Psychiatry 1993;39:255-265
66. Lauzon P, Roger-Achim D, Achim A, Boyer R. Emotional distress among couples involved in first-trimester induced abortions. Can Fam Physician 2000;46:2033-2040
67. Major B, Cozzarelli C, Sciacchitano AM, Cooper ML, Testa M, Mueller PM. Perceived social support, self-efficacy and adjustment to abortion. J Pers Soc Psychol 1990;59:452-463
68. Major B, Cozzarelli C, Testa M, Mueller P. Male partners' appraisals of undesired pregnancy and abortion: implications for women's adjustment to abortion. J Appl Soc Psychol 1992;22:599-614.
69. Cozzarelli C. Personality and self-efficacy as predictors of coping with abortion. J Pers Soc Psychol 1993;65:1224-1236
70. Major B, Zubek JM, Cooper ML, Cozzarelli C, Richards C. Mixed messages: implications of social conflict and social support within close relationships for adjustment to a stressful life event. J Pers Soc Psychol 1997;72:1349-1363 (Pubitemid 127689009)
71. Major B, Richards MC, Cooper ML, Cozzarelli C, Zubek J. Personal resilience, cognitive appraisals and coping: an integrative model of adjustment to abortion. J Pers Soc Psychol 1998;74:735-752 (Pubitemid 128658102)
72. Cozzarelli C, Sumer N, Major B. Mental models of attachment and adjustment to abortion. J Pers Soc Psychol 1998;74:453-467
73. Quinton WJ, Major B, Richards C. Adolescents and adjustment to abortion: are minors at greater risk? Psychol Public Policy Law. 2001;7:491-514.
74. Sit D, Rothschild AJ, Creinin MD, Hanusa BH, Wisner KL. Psychiatric outcomes following medical and surgical abortion. Hum Reprod 2007;22:878-884
75. Williams GB. Short-term grief after an elective abortion. J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal Nurs 2001;30:174-183
76. Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. Termination of pregnancy: a resource for health professionals. East Melbourne, Australia: RANZCO, 2005.