Euthanasia in Belgium five years after legalisation

European Journal of Health Law

Volumn 16, Issue 2, 2009, Pages 125-138

  Lewis, Penney ^a  

^a KING'S COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Assisted; Belgium; Criminal law; Euthanasia; Legislation and jurisprudence; Suicide

Indexed keywords

BELGIUM; CLINICAL PRACTICE; CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR; EUTHANASIA; GOVERNMENT; HUMAN; HUMAN RIGHTS; LAW; MEDICOLEGAL ASPECT; REVIEW; SUICIDE; TERMINAL DISEASE;

BELGIUM; EUTHANASIA; HUMANS; NETHERLANDS; TERMINALLY ILL;

EID: 67650870124     PISSN: 09290273     EISSN: 15718093     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1163/157180909X430238-2     Document Type: Review

References (77)

1. Some parts of this section and the next are adapted from P. Lewis, Assisted Dying and Legal Change, (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007), pp. 153-157 with the kind permission of Oxford University Press. I am grateful to Robert Cliquet and Herman Nys for their comments on an earlier version of this section and the next. The responsibility for all errors of fact or interpretation of course remains my own.
2. Dutch Criminal Code, Art. 293(1). Retrieved 20 August 2008 www.wetboek-online.nl/wet/Sr/293.html (Dutch).
3. B. Broeckaert, "Belgium: Towards a Legal Recognition of Eudianasia", European Journal of Health Law, 8 (2001) 95.
4. H. Weyers, "Legal recognition of the right to die", in: A. Garwood-Gowers, J. Tingle, K. Wheat (eds.), Contemporary Issues in Healthcare Law and Ethics, (Edinburgh: Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann, 2005) pp. 253,256, n. xi.
5. Belgian Advisory Committee on Bioethics, Opinion concerning the advisability of a legal regulation on euthanasia, No. 1, 12 May 1997. Retrieved 20 August 2008 https://portal.health.fgov.be/pls/portal/url/ITEM/ 46BD9442BAAC3816E04400144F3EAABC.
6. Broeckaert, supra n. 3; M. Adams, "Euthanasia: the Process of Legal Change in Belgium", in: A. Klijn, M. Otlowski, M. Trappenburg (eds.), Regulating Physician-Negotiated Death, (Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2001), pp. 29, 33-4.
7. Law on Euthanasia of 28 May 2002. Retrieved 15 August 2008 www.ejustice.just.fgov.be//mopdf/2002/06/22-l.pdf#Page16 (Dutch/French). "The Belgian Act on Euthanasia of May, 28th 2002", European Journal of Health Law, 10 (2003) 329.
8. Court of Arbitrage, Judgement No. 4/2004, January 14,2004. Retrieved 20 August 2008 www.arbitrage.be/public/n/2004/2004-004n.pdf (Dutch), www.arbitrage.be/public/f72004/2004-004f.pdf (French).
9. L. Hennebel, "La dépέnalisation de l'euthanasie en Belgique [The decriminalisation of euthanasia in Belgium]", Journaldel'InstitutInternationaldesDroitsdel'Homme, 2(1) (2002) 1, 2.
10. Advice of the Council of State, Belgian Senate, 2000-2001 session, 2 July 2001, No. 2-244/21, [18]. Retrieved 20 August 2008 www.senate.be/www/webdriver? MItabObj=pdf&MIcolObj=pdf&MInamObj=pdnd&MItypeObj=application/ pdf&MIvalObj=33576864 (Dutch/French).
11. Belgian Penal Code, Art. 422bis. Retrieved 31 August 2008 www.juridat.be/cgi-loi/loi-N.pl?cn=1867060801 (Dutch), www.juridat.be/cgi-loi/ loi-F.pl?cn=1867060801 (French). M. Adams, H. Nys, "Zet de Belgische Euthanasiewet de mensenrechten onder druk? De Belgische Euthanasiewet tussen zelf-beschikking en gewetensvrijheid [Does the Belgian Euthanasia Law put human rights under pressure? The Belgian Euthanasia Law between self-determination and freedom of conscience]", in: A. den Exter, (ed.), De Euthanasiewet: grondrechten onder druk? [The Euthanasia Law: human rights under pressure?], (Brussels: Kluwer/Bruylant, 2006), pp. 102, 105.
12. M. Adams, H. Nys, "Euthanasia in the Low Countries: Comparative Reflections on the Belgian and Dutch Euthanasia Act", in: P. Schotsmans, T. Meulenbergs (eds.), Euthanasia and Palliative Care in the Low Countries, (Leuven: Peeters, 2005). 5, 8-10.
13. H. Nys, "Physician assisted suicide in Belgian law", European Journal of Health Law, 12(1) (2005) 39.
14. FCEC, First Report to the Legislative Chambers (September 22, 2002-December 31, 2003). Belgian Senate and House of Representatives, 2003-2004 Session, No. 3-860/1 (Senate), DOC 51 1374/001 (House) September 16, 2004, 13-14. Retrieved 8 August 2008 www.lachambre.be/FLWB/pdf751/1374/51 K1374002.pdf (Dutch/French).
15. National Council of the Order of Physicians, Opinion on palliative care, euthanasia and other medical decisions at the end of life, 22 March 2003. Retrieved 13 August 2008 http://195.234.184.64/web-Ned/nl/a100/a100006n.htm (Dutch), http://195.234.184.64/web-Fr/fr/a10O/a100006f.htm (French).
16. Senate, Bill modifying the law on euthanasia of 28 May 2002 in relation to assisted self-euthanasia, No. 4-919, 16 September 2008. Retrieved 30 October 2008 www.senate.be/www/webdriver?MItabObj=pdf&MIcolObj=pdf&MInamObj= pdfid&MItypeObj=application/pdf&MIvalObj=67110271 (Dutch/French).
17. L. Kater, "The Dutch Model for Legalizing End-of-life Decisions", Medicine ér Law, 22 (2003) 543, 544.
18. Senate, Bill modifying the law on euthanasia of 28 May 2002, No. 3-804/1, 7 July 2004. Retrieved 20 August 2008 www.senate.be/www/webdriver?MItabObj= pdf&MIcolObj=pdf&MInamObj=pdfid&MItypeObj=application/ pdf&MIvalObj=50332915 (Dutch/French). Senate, Bill modifying article 4 of the law on euthanasia of 28 May 2002, No. 3-1485/1,14 December 2005. Retrieved 20 August 20,2008 www.senate.be/www/webdriver?MItabObj=pdf&MIcolObj= pdf&MInamObj=pdfid&MItypeObj=application/pdf&MIvalObj=50334399 (Dutch/French).
19. Senate, Bill modifying article 4 of the law on euthanasia of 28 May 2002, No. 4-676/1, 8 April 2008. Retrieved 20 August 2008 www.senate.be/www/ webdriver?MItabObj=pdf&MIcolObj=pdf&MInamObj=pdfid&MItypeObj= application/pdf&MIvalObj=67109732 (Dutch/French). Another attempt which seems unlikely to succeed appears to allow alternative triggering conditions: either suffering from a serious and incurable disorder caused by illness or accident, or being in a persistent vegetative state. Senate, Bill modifying article 4 of the law on euthanasia of 28 May 2002, concerning the advance request, No. 4-922, 16 September 2008. Retrieved 30 October 2008 www.senate.be/www/webdriver?MItabObj=pdf&MIcolObj=pdf&MInamObj= pdfid&:MItypeObj=application/pdf&MIvalObj=67110274 (Dutch/French).
20. Chamber of Representatives, Bill modifying the law on euthanasia of 28 May 2002, DOC 52 1050/001,10 April 2008. Retrieved 30 October 2008 www.lachambre.be/FLWB/PDF/52/1050/52K1050001.pdf (Dutch/French).
21. Royal Decree regulating the recording of advance requests for euthanasia and the notification of doctors involved through the National Register, 27 April 2007. Retrieved 13 August 2008 www.ejustice.just.fgov.be//mopdf/2007/06/07-l. pdf#Page78 (Dutch/French). Federal Health Department, Circular addressed to doctors, "Advance requests for euthanasia - electronic consultation by doctors", 4 September 2008. Retrieved 28 October 2008 https://portal. health.fgov.be/pls/portal/docs/l/9046008.PDF (Dutch), https://portal.health. fgov.be/pls/portal/docs/l/9046007.PDF (French).
22. Termination of Life on Request and Assisted Suicide (Review Procedures) Act 2001, s.2(l)(d). European Journal of Health Law, 8 (2001) 183.
23. J. Massion, "L'Exception euthanasique en droit Beige [The eudianasia exception in Belgian law]", Louυain Médical, 124 (2005) 238, 243.
24. J. Griffiths, H. Weyers, M. Adams, Euthanasia and Law in Europe, Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2008, pp. 91-93.
25. FCEC, Third Report to the Legislative Chambers (2006-2007), 61. Retrieved 8 August 2008 https://portal.health.fgov.be/pls/portal/url/lTEM/ 50F44477D08A63EBE04400144F3EAABC (Dutch), https://portal.health.fgov.be/pls/ portal/url/ITEM/50F44477D08A63EBE04400144F3EAABC (French). FCEC, First Report, supra n. 13, 12. H. Nys, "A Presentation of the Belgian Act on Euthanasia Against the Background of Dutch Euthanasia Law", European Journal of Health Law 10 (2003) 239, 247.
26. Lewis, supra n. 1,79-80.
27. Justice Committee, Report, Chamber of Representatives 2001-2002 Session, No. 50-1488/9, 217, 344,379. Retrieved 22 August 2008 www.lachambre.be/FLWB/PDF/ 50/1488/50K1488009.pdf (Dutch/French).
28. FCEC, First Report, supra n. 13, Table VII.
29. FCEC, Second Report to the Legislative Chambers (2004-2005), 22. Belgian Senate and House of Representatives, 2003-2004 Session, No. 3-1935/1 (Senate), DOC 51 2733/001 (House), 8 Nov 2006. Retrieved 8 August 2008 www.lachambre.be/FLWB/PDF/51/2733/51K2733001.pdf (Dutch/French). FCEC, Third Report, supra n. 22, 24.
30. J. Burgermeister, "Doctor reignites euthanasia row in Belgium after mercy killing", British Medical Journal, 332 (2006) 382. M. Cosyns, De HuisartslLe Généraliste (9 February 2006), 6-7.
31. Griffiths, Weyers & Adams, supra, n. 23, 315.
32. Brongersma, Supreme Court, December 24, 2002, Nederlandse Jurisprudentie 2003:167. Retrieved 20 August 2008 www.rechtspraak.nl/ljn.asp? ljn=AE8772 (Dutch).
33. Lewis, supra n. 1,99-101.
34. R. Schwitters, "Medical Competence as a restriction on physician-assisted suicide: the Brongersma case", NewsletterMBPSL 7 (2003), 2. Retrieved 12 August 2008 www.rug.nl/rechten/faculteit/vakgroepen/rth/ rechtssociologie/onderzoek/researchprogram/newsletters/newsletter7.pdf.
35. FCEC, Information Brochure for Doctors. 6 September 2005,7. Retrieved 28 October 2008 https://portal.health.fgov.be/pls/portal/url/ITEM/ 4F747916400A28E6E04400144F3EAABC (Dutch), https://portal.health.fgov.be/pls/ portal/url/ITEM/4F747916400A28E6E04400144F3EAABC (French).
36. P.J. Van der Maas, J.J. Van Delden, L. Pijnenborg et al., "Euthanasia and other medical decisions concerning the end of life", Lancet, 338 (1991), 669.
37. P.J Van der Maas, G. Van der Wal, I., Haverkate et al., "Euthanasia, physician-assisted suicide, and other medical practices involving the end of life in the Netherlands, 1990-1995", New England Journal of 'Medicine, 335 (1996) 1699.
38. B.D.Onwuteaka-Philipsen, A. Van der Heide, D. Koper et al., "Euthanasia and other end-of-life decisions in the Netherlands in 1990, 1995, and 2001", Lancet, 362 (2003) 395.
39. A. Van der Heide, B.D.Onwuteaka-Philipsen, M.L. Rurup et al., "End-of-LIfe Practices in the Netherlands under the Euthanasia Act", New England Journal of Medicine, 356 (2007) 1957.
40. L. Deliens, F. Mortier, J.Bilsen et al., "End-of-life decisions in medical practice in Flanders, Belgium: a nationwide survey", Lancet, 356 (2000) 1806, Table 1.
41. Lewis, supra n. 1, 169-87. M. Otlowski, "The Effectiveness of Legal Control of Euthanasia: Lessons from Comparative Law", in: A. Klijn, M. Otlowski, M. Trappenburg (eds.), RegulatingPhysician-Negotiated Death, (Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2001), pp. 137, 141-143, 152-155.
42. A. Van der Heide, L. Deliens, K. Faisst et al., "End-of-life decision-making in six European countries: descriptive study", Lancet, 362 (2003) 345, Table 2.
43. Griffiths, Weyers & Adams, supra n. 23, 332-3.
44. Ibid., 332, n. 4.
45. R.H. Vander Stichele, J.J.R. Bilsen, J.L. Bernheim et al., "Drugs used for euthanasia in Flanders, Belgium", Pharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety, 13 (2004) 89, 93.
46. Griffiths, Weyers & Adams, supra n. 23, 333.
47. Deliens, supra n. 34. Van der Heide, supra n. 38.
48. FCEC, First Report, supra n. 13, 9-10. M. Englert, B. Hanson, D. Lossignol, "Deux années d'eutha-nas¡e dépé nalisée en Belgique: comparaison avec les Pays-Bas [Two years of decriminalised euthanasia in Belgium: comparison with the Netherlands]", Revue Médicate de Bruxelles, 26 (2005) 145, 150-1.
49. M. Englert, "La pratique dépénalisée de l'euthanasie en Belgique: évolution de 2002 à 2005 et interpretation des différences entre le Nord et le Sud du pays [The decriminalised practice of euthanasia in Belgium: evolution from 2002 to 2005 and interpretation of the differences between the North and South]", Revue Médicate de Bruxelles, 28 (2007) 423,428-9.
50. Belgian Senate, Session 2006-7, Plenary session 30 November 2006, No. 3-191,25. Retrieved 22 August 2008 www.senate.be/www/webdriver?MItabObj= pdf&MIcolObj=pdf&MInamObj=pdfid&MItypeObj=application/ pdf&MIvalObj=50335615 (Dutch/French).
51. K. Jooken, G. Sermeus, "Acts at the end of life and euthanasia", Test SantélTest Gezondheid, 77 (2007) 26,26-9. G. Tegenbos, 2007. "Niet minder euthanasie in Franstalig België [No less euthanasia in French-speaking Belgium]." De Standaard, 29 January.
52. FCEC, Third Report, supra n. 24, 24. FCEC, Second Report, supra n. 28, 24. FCEC, Information Brochure, supra n. 34, 12.
53. Englert, Hanson & Lossignol, supra n. 44, 146-7.
54. Compassion in Dying v. Washington (1996) 79 F.3d 790, 824, n. 98 (US 9th Circuit en banc).
55. Dutch Regional Review Committees on Euthanasia, Annual Reports. Retrieved 22 August 2008 www.toetsingscommissieseuthanasie.nl/en/review-committees/ annualreport/.
56. Law on Palliative Care of 14 June 2002, Art. 7. Retrieved 15 August 2008 www.ejustice.just.fgov.be//mopdf/2002/10/26-l .pdf#Page 1 (Dutch/French).
57. B. Broekaert, R. Janssens, "Palliative care and euthanasia: Belgian and Dutch perspectives", in: P. Schotsmans, T. Meulenbergs (eds.), Euthanasia and Palliative Care in the Low Countries, (Leuven: Peeters, 2005) p. 35. Subsequently, proposals have been made to include a palliative filter in the law. For a recent example, see Chamber of Representatives, Bill introducing a mandatory palliative filter into the law on euthanasia of 28 May 2002, DOC 52 0774/001, 4 February 2008. Retrieved 30 October 2008 www.lachambre.be/FLWB/PDF/52/0774/52K0774001.pdf (Dutch/French).
58. J. Lemiengre, B Dierckx de Casterlé, G. Verbeke et al, "Ethics policies on euthanasia in hospitals - A survey in Flanders (Belgium)", Health Policy, 84 (2007) 170,180.
59. J. Lemiengre, B. Dierckx de Casterlé, Y. Denier et al, "How do hospitals deal with euthanasia requests in Flanders (Belgium)? A content analysis of policy documents", Patient Education and Counselling, 71 (2008) 293, 299-300.
60. C. Gastmans, J. Lemiengre, G. Van der Wal et al, "Prevalence and content of written ethics policies on euthanasia in Catholic healthcare institutions in Belgium (Flanders)", Health Policy, 76 (2006) 169, 176 (emphasis in original).
61. National Council of the Order of Physicians, supra n. 14.
62. Griffiths, Weyers & Adams, supra n. 23, 316.
63. FCEC, First Report, supra n. 13, 24. FCEC, Second Report, supra n. 28, 29. FCEC, Third Report, supra n. 24, 29.
64. FCEC, Information Brochure, supra n. 34, 6.
65. FCEC, First Report, supra n. 13, 21.
66. FCEC, Third Report, supra n. 24, 25.
67. B.D. Onwuteaka-Philipsen, A. Van der Heide, M.T. Muller et al, "Dutch experience of monitoring euthanasia", British Medical Journal, 331 (2005) 691-3. Griffiths, Weyers & Adams, supra n. 23, ch. 4.
68. FCEC, Second Report, supra n. 28, 22.
69. MELC (Monitoring quality of End-of-Life Care) study, Study of Medical End-of-life decisions. Retrieved 12 August 2008 www.endoflifecare.be/MELCstudy/ WorkPackages/ELD3/tabid/115/Default.aspx.
70. FCEC, Third Report, supra n. 24, 21.
71. FCEC, Third Report, supra n. 24, 22. Deliens, supra n. 36. Van der Heide, supra n. 38.
72. FCEC, Third Report, ibid.
73. FCEC, First Report, supra n. 13, 18.
74. L. Van den Block, V. Van Casteren, R. Deschepper et al, "Nationwide monitoring of end-of-life care via the Sentinel Network of General Practitioners in Belgium: the research protocol of the SENTI-MELC study", BMC Palliative Care, 6(6) (2007).
75. L. Van den Block, N.Bossuyt, V. Van Casteren et al, Het sterfbed in België. Resultaten van deSENTI-MELC studίe 2005-2006 (The deathbed in Belgium: Results of the SENTI-MELC study 2005-2006], Brussels: Academic and Scientific Publishers, 2007, p. 89.
76. FCEC, Third Report, supra n. 24, 22. FCEC, Second Report, supra n. 28, 21.
77. R., Löfmark, T. Nilstun, C. Cartwright et al., "Physicians' experiences with end-of-life decisionmaking: survey in 6 European countries and Australia", BMC Medicine, 6(4) (2008).